In re S.M. CA5

CourtListener 10276011CalctappNov 18, 2024

Full text

Filed 11/18/24 In re S.M. CA5

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

In re S.M. et al., Persons Coming Under the
Juvenile Court Law.

KERN COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF F088255
HUMAN SERVICES,
(Super. Ct. Nos. JD145354-00 &
Plaintiff and Respondent, JD145355-00)

v.
OPINION
C.M. et al.,

Defendants and Appellants.

THE COURT*
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Kern County. Christie Canales
Norris, Judge.
Elaine Forrester, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and
Appellant, C.M.
Gregory M. Chappel, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant
and Appellant, M.J.

* Before Franson, Acting P. J., Peña, J. and DeSantos, J.
Margo A. Raison, County Counsel, and Alexandria Ottoman, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
-ooOoo-
Appellants C.M. and M.J., parents of minor children C.M. and S.M., appeal from
the juvenile court’s order terminating their parental rights (Welf. & Inst. Code,1
§ 366.26). They argue the court erred under the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978
(25 U.S.C. § 1901 et seq.; ICWA) by failing to make findings as to whether inquiry was
adequate and additionally that the evidence was insufficient to make such a finding.
Respondent Kern County Department of Human Services (department) concedes error
and requests conditional reversal and remand.
We accept the department’s concession; we conditionally reverse the order
terminating parental rights and remand to ensure compliance with ICWA inquiry
provisions.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
The underlying dependency case was initiated in San Bernardino County. The San
Bernardino County Children and Family Services agency (SBCFS) filed a petition on
behalf of then eight-month-old S.M. in July 2022, alleging he came within the juvenile
court’s jurisdiction under section 300, subdivisions (b)(1) and (j). The department
reported that paternal grandmother and a maternal cousin both claimed no Native
American ancestry.
S.M. was ordered detained from the parents on July 28, 2022. The parents were
not present at the detention hearing.

1 All further undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions
Code.

2.
In December 2022, a petition was filed on behalf of S.M.’s sibling, newborn
C.M., alleging he came within the juvenile court’s jurisdiction under section 300,
subdivisions (b)(1) and (j).
Mother subsequently executed a “PARENTAL NOTIFICATION OF INDIAN
STATUS” (ICWA-020) form indicating she had lineal ancestors who were members of
the Navajo Nation out of Albuquerque, New Mexico. Father executed an ICWA-020
form indicating none of the indicia suggesting the children were Indian children applied.
Both parents additionally provided phone numbers of several relatives.
The detention hearing related to C.M.’s petition was conducted on December 21,
2022. At the hearing, the San Bernardino juvenile court heard testimony regarding
ICWA. Mother testified she had Native American ancestry through the Navajo Nation,
but to her knowledge, she was not eligible for membership. She further testified her
grandmother’s brother had lived on a reservation but to her knowledge neither she nor her
lineal ancestors had utilized Indian legal services or gone to Indian school. She provided
the maternal grandmother’s name—S.H.—and phone number on the record. Father and
paternal grandmother were also present and denied Native American ancestry. C.M. was
ordered detained from the parents.
SBCFS subsequently followed up on mother’s claim, and she clarified her
grandmother, the maternal great-grandmother—N.P.—was part of the Navajo Nation.
SBCFS also conducted inquiry of a maternal aunt and a paternal aunt, who both denied
Native American ancestry. SBCFS also reported attempting to contact several other
relatives for whom voice mails were left. They also attempted to contact the maternal
grandmother S.H., but the voice mailbox was full. SBCFS sent three inquiry letters to the
Colorado River tribe, Navajo Nation tribe, and Ramah Navajo tribe via e-mail dated
January 10, 2023. The letters listed the children and parents’ names and dates of birth
and indicated mother was claiming Navajo heritage through the maternal grandmother—
S.H.

3.
The Navajo Nation responded in a letter dated February 1, 2023, that it was in the
process of verifying the children’s “enrollment or eligibility for enrollment with the
Navajo Nation” and that they should be treated as Indian children until it was determined
on the record that they did not meet the statutory definition of Indian child.
A combined jurisdictional/dispositional hearing was conducted as to both children
on February 15, 2023. At the hearing, the juvenile court noted the inquiries with the
Navajo tribes did not contain familial information. The court obtained names and dates
of birth of lineal ancestors from the parents on the record, including the name of mother’s
relative who lived on a reservation. The court ordered additional inquiry with the Navajo
tribe to include the additional relative and statistical information as well as any other
information SBCFS had obtained. The court found ICWA may apply and ordered the
department to provide a packet within 60 days regarding the additional inquiry that
needed to be conducted. The court found the children came within its jurisdiction under
section 300, subdivisions (b) and (j), adjudged them dependents, and removed them from
their parents’ custody. Father was ordered to participate in reunification services, and
mother was bypassed for services.
SBCFS subsequently made inquiry of several maternal relatives, including an
adult sibling, who reported she had heard her maternal grandparents talk about Native
American ancestry; a maternal great uncle, who denied Native American ancestry;
maternal grandmother, S.H., who reported her uncle may have received Indian services
but had passed away; maternal great-grandmother, N.P., who reported she did not know if
she had Native American ancestry and that she had Indian ancestry through Chihuahua,
Mexico.
SBCFS received another letter from the Navajo Nation dated April 6, 2023,
indicating the tribe was unable to verify the children’s eligibility for tribal membership
enrollment based on the additional ancestry provided and thus “the intake will be closed.”
Later that month, SBCFS sent out new letters to the Navajo tribes listing only the

4.
children’s and parents’ names, as well as several maternal half siblings names and dates
of birth. A hearing for an ICWA update was conducted on April 24, 2023, where this
information was provided to the court. It does not appear the court made any orders as to
whether ICWA applied at the hearing.
The six-month status review hearing was conducted on August 15, 2023. Father’s
reunification services were continued. It does not appear any ICWA orders were made at
the hearing.
The 12-month status review hearing was conducted on September 18, 2023.
Father had indicated he had been living in Kern County for over six months and would
like the case transferred to Kern County. County counsel indicated they would verify
father’s residence and determine whether it would file a motion to transfer out. Father’s
services were continued. It does not appear any ICWA orders were made at the hearing.
SBCFS filed a motion for transfer out on November 8, 2023. The court
subsequently issued transfer-out orders, including that the court had not yet determined
whether ICWA is applicable.
The Kern County juvenile court accepted the case at a transfer-in hearing on
December 8, 2023. At the hearing, county counsel stated, “[W]e recognize that there
hasn’t been a finding regarding ICWA yet. The prior court in San Bernardino—the
agency did send out notices to two Navajo tribes. I’ll have our ICWA paralegals follow
up and get responses from those tribes.”
The department’s 12-month (for C.M.)/18-month (for S.M.) status review report
included the ICWA information previously set forth in the SBCFS reports. It also stated
the department family finding social worker reviewed a previous dependency case where
mother reported Navajo Native American ancestry through the maternal great-
grandmother, N.P. The social worker subsequently attempted inquiry of several relatives,
including N.P. N.P. denied Native American ancestry and denied any familial association
with the Navajo Nation.

5.
The 12-month/18-month status review hearing was conducted on February 15,
2024. Father’s services were terminated, and a section 366.26 hearing was set.
The department’s section 366.26 report set forth the ICWA inquiries made by
SBCFS but not the subsequent inquiries made by the department that were previously
reported and additionally stated, “On December 8, 2023, the Court found there was no
ICWA finding made.” The report later stated ICWA “is still being determined in this
matter as the mother reported that her grandmother was part of the Navajo Nation.”
The section 366.26 hearing was conducted on June 13, 2024. The court ordered
parental rights terminated and selected adoption as the children’s permanent plan. No
ICWA findings were made at the hearing.
DISCUSSION
Under California’s statutory scheme to comply with ICWA, the court and county
child welfare department “have an affirmative and continuing duty to inquire whether a
child,” who is the subject of a juvenile dependency petition, “is or may be an Indian
child.”2 (§ 224.2, subd. (a); see In re Isaiah W. (2016) 1 Cal.5th 1, 9; Cal. Rules of Court,
rule 5.481(a).) The agency’s duty of inquiry includes “asking the child, parents, legal
guardian, Indian custodian, extended family members, others who have an interest in the
child, and the party reporting child abuse or neglect, whether the child is, or may be, an
Indian child and where the child, the parents, or Indian custodian is domiciled.” (§ 224.2,
subd. (b)(2).) When the court or social worker has “reason to believe” (but not sufficient
evidence to determine there is “reason to know” as defined in § 224.2, subd. (d)) that an
Indian child is involved in a proceeding, “further inquiry regarding the possible Indian
status of the child” is required. (§ 224.2, subd. (e).)

2 An “Indian child” is defined in ICWA as an unmarried individual under 18 years
of age who is either (1) a member of a federally recognized Indian tribe, or (2) is eligible
for membership in a federally recognized tribe and is the biological child of a member of
a federally recognized tribe. (25 U.S.C. § 1903(4) & (8); see § 224.1, subd. (b).)

6.
The agency “must on an ongoing basis include in its filings a detailed description
of all inquiries, and further inquiries it has undertaken, and all information received
pertaining to the child’s Indian status, as well as evidence of how and when this
information was provided to the relevant tribes.” (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 5.481(a)(5).)
“ ‘ “ ‘The juvenile court must determine whether … ICWA applies to the
proceedings.’ ” ’ ” (In re J.C. (2022) 77 Cal.App.5th 70, 78.) Before finding ICWA
inapplicable, the juvenile court must make a finding that the agency conducted “proper
and adequate further inquiry” and exercised “due diligence” in doing so, and that “there
is no reason to know whether the child is an Indian child.” (§ 224.2, subd. (i)(2).)
The parents point out that while SBCFS sent out letters to the Navajo tribes, they
incorrectly identified the maternal grandmother, S.H., rather than N.P. as the relative
whom mother was claiming Navajo ancestry through. They also point out the department
never contacted the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) and State Department of Social
Services, as they must do when further inquiry is required. Finally, they contend the
court’s failure to make any determinative ICWA findings was reversible error. They
contend the matter must be remanded for corrected notice to be sent to the Navajo tribes
identifying the maternal great-grandmother’s name and notice to be sent to the BIA and
state agency before the juvenile court can make an informed decision regarding ICWA.
The department has responded simply by conceding “the juvenile court may have
erred in making a finding under [ICWA]” and requests that this court conditionally
reverse the order and remand the matter to ensure compliance with ICWA inquiry
provisions.
We accept the department’s concession in light of the fact that no court ever made
express ICWA findings. As this court stated in In re K.H. (2022) 84 Cal.App.5th 566,
ICWA determinations are best left “for the juvenile court in the first instance because it is
better positioned to evaluate the evidence provided by the Department. So long as the
court ensures the inquiry is reasonable and of sufficient reach to accomplish the

7.
legislative purpose underlying ICWA and related California law, the court will have an
adequate factual foundation upon which to make its ICWA finding.” (In re K.H., at
p. 621.)
Here, both child welfare agencies involved in this case made numerous inquiries
of several relatives and attempted to follow up on mother’s claim that the maternal great-
grandmother had Navajo ancestry though the maternal great-grandmother herself was
equivocal and later denied any Native American ancestry. Nonetheless, the children’s
potential relation with the Navajo Nation was never definitively discovered. Mother
claimed Navajo ancestry through the maternal great-grandmother, but in the initial
e-mails sent to the tribes, only the maternal grandmother’s name was given, and in the
follow up letters, only maternal half siblings were provided. It does not appear SBCFS
ever provided the additional familial information the San Bernardino court ordered it to
provide to the tribes nor did the department follow up with the tribes as county counsel
represented it would at the transfer-in hearing. Further, there is no evidence before us
that the juvenile court considered this evidence or any other evidence before it to make
informed ICWA findings. (See In re E.W. (2009) 170 Cal.App.4th 396, 405 [holding that
an implicit ICWA finding may suffice, “as long as the reviewing court can be confident
that the juvenile court considered the issue and there is no question but that an explicit
ruling would conform to the implicit one”].)
We therefore agree with the parties that conditional reversal and remand is
appropriate under the circumstances of this case. The juvenile court must evaluate in the
first instance the evidence, as well as any additional evidence the department presents to
it, to determine whether the inquiry was of sufficient reach to inform the juvenile court
and whether the information provided gives rise to a reason to know the children are
Indian children. We do not reach nor comment on the parents’ specific arguments
regarding whether the department’s inquiry was adequate. It would be premature to do
so, as those matters may be raised in, and considered by, the juvenile court on remand,

8.
though, as the department’s concession suggests they have conducted or plan to conduct
additional inquiry, there may be no need to do so.
DISPOSITION
The order terminating parental rights is conditionally reversed. The matter is
remanded for compliance with the inquiry and notice requirements of sections 224.2 and
224.3 and the documentation provisions of California Rules of Court, rule 5.481(a)(5). If
the juvenile court thereafter finds a proper and adequate further inquiry and due diligence
has been conducted and concludes ICWA does not apply, then the court shall reinstate the
order terminating parental rights. If the juvenile court concludes ICWA applies, then it
shall proceed in conformity with ICWA and California implementing provisions.

9.

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.