In re Walker S. CA2/7

CourtListener 10270513CalctappNov 8, 2024

Full text

Filed 11/8/24 In re Walker S. CA2/7
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION SEVEN

In re WALKER S., a Person B333404
Coming Under the Juvenile Court
Law. (Los Angeles County Super. Ct.
No. 22CCJP04278C)

LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

SETH S.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Tamara Hall, Judge. Reversed with directions.
Linda J. Vogel, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and David Michael Miller, Senior
Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
____________________________________

INTRODUCTION

Seth S., father of two-year-old Walker S., appeals from the
juvenile court’s jurisdiction findings, disposition orders, and
subsequent orders terminating jurisdiction, awarding Walker’s
mother, Shannon L., sole legal and physical custody of Walker,
and requiring Seth’s visits with Walker to be monitored. Seth
argues substantial evidence did not support the jurisdiction
findings his history of domestic violence and violent outbursts
placed Walker at substantial risk of serious physical harm. Seth
also challenges the juvenile court’s custody and visitation orders.
We agree substantial evidence did not support the court’s
jurisdiction findings. Therefore, we reverse the jurisdiction
findings and direct the court to vacate the custody and visitation
order and dismiss the petition.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

A. Shannon Takes Sedatives and Loses Consciousness
While Caring for Walker; The Department Files a
Petition Under Section 300
Shannon has three children including Walker. Her ex-
husband Brian L. fathered two of them: Maisy (now an adult)
and Kingston (now 10 years old). Maisy lived with Shannon;

2
Kingston lived with both parents. Walker also lived with
Shannon, and Seth visited him regularly.
The Los Angeles County Department of Children and
Family Services became involved with the family in
October 2022, after family members could not reach Shannon by
phone. Maisy went home and found Shannon “‘out of it,’” “‘kind
of awake’ but . . . not completely all there,” and incoherent.
Walker, then two months old, was “fine and in his bed.” Maisy
called the 911 emergency operator, and paramedics took Shannon
to the emergency room. The toxicology report showed Shannon
had benzodiazepine in her system.1 Shannon told the case social
worker that she had taken “half an Oxycodone pill and Xanax
(1 mg)” the night before paramedics took her to the hospital.
Shannon also disclosed a prior voluntary case with the
Department based on prescription drug abuse, but she denied
current substance abuse. Shannon volunteered to drug test.
During the Department’s initial investigation, Shannon
told the case social worker that she and Seth were “high school
sweethearts” and that they reconnected after Shannon’s divorce.
Shannon said that her feelings toward Seth changed and that
they were no longer together, but that Seth wanted their
relationship to continue. Seth expressed frustration over the
relationship and said he felt “gaslighted” after they reconnected

1 “The benzodiazepine class of drugs is, like alcohol, a central
nervous system depressant, commonly used as a tranquilizer.
Alcohol and benzodiazepines have an additive effect when used
together. In addition to diazepam, another generic
benzodiazepine is clonazepam. Brand names for benzodiazepines
include Rivotril, Klonopin, Xanax and Valium.” (People v. Huynh
(2012) 212 Cal.App.4th 285, 292, fn. 2.)

3
and Shannon became pregnant.2 Maisy told the case social
worker she had “a ‘fine’ relationship” with Seth, but Kingston
said he did not speak with Seth because “Seth will often say rude
comments to him and his mom.” Kingston said he had seen Seth
and Shannon “get into ‘tiny verbal arguments’ but denied any
physical fighting.” Shannon denied domestic violence with either
Brian or Seth.
The Department filed a petition under Welfare and
Institutions Code section 300, subdivision (b)(1),3 alleging in
count b-1 that Shannon had a history of substance abuse and was
a current abuser of Oxycontin and Xanax and that her substance
abuse rendered her unable to provide regular care for her
children. The Department alleged in count b-2 Shannon had a
history of “mental and emotional problems” that rendered her
unable to provide regular care for the children. The Department
also alleged in both counts Brian and Seth failed to protect their

2 “Gaslighting is a term derived from the 1944 film Gaslight
and refers a kind of psychological abuse in which a person denies
another person’s reality and causes that person to question
himself or herself and his or her perceptions.” (Garrett v. Cape
Fox Facilities Servs. (E.D.Va., Jan. 17, 2020, No. 1:19-cv-579)
2020 WL 265869, p. 2, fn. 6; see Commonwealth v. Gardner
(Mass. App. Ct. 2023) 102 Mass.App.Ct. 299, 304, fn. 5
[“Gaslighting is defined as ‘psychological manipulation of a
person usually over an extended period of time that causes the
victim to question the validity of their own thoughts, perceptions
of reality, or memories and typically leads to confusion, loss of
confidence and self-esteem, uncertainty of one’s emotional or
mental stability, and a dependency on the perpetrator.’”].)

3 Statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions
Code.

4
respective children from Shannon. The Department did not ask
the juvenile court to detain the children. The court released
Walker to the homes of his parents under the supervision of the
Department, with primary custody to Shannon and unmonitored
visitation for Seth.

B. The Department Investigates
A Department investigator interviewed members of
Walker’s family. Shannon said she had taken Xanax the evening
paramedics took her to the emergency room, but denied taking
Xanax regularly and said she did not use Oxycodone. Shannon
said she consulted a neurologist because she was concerned about
her reaction to Xanax. Regarding count b-2, Shannon denied
“a history of mental and emotional problems,” but said she “has
had situational anxiety related to her job (as a nurse) and the
divorce but this has never negatively affected her parenting as
she has raised all the kids by herself.”
Shannon said Seth “has a temper and ‘he flips all of a
sudden’ and now his anger is directed at her and ‘he has gotten
worse since [she does not] want to be with him’ but there is a
reason she does not want him around her children.” Shannon
said that Seth was difficult at custody exchanges.
Seth told the Department investigator his relationship with
Shannon was “chaotic at times.” Seth said he never lived with
Shannon, but he spent some nights at her home when they were
together.
Maisy, who was a senior in high school, told the
investigator she had not seen her mother abuse prescription
drugs or alcohol. She said Shannon “‘has been going through a
lot with her divorce, the new baby, and Seth . . . , and she has had

5
her ups and downs but she has been able to function.’” Maisy
said Seth “‘has always had anger issues. He has screamed at my
face when I wanted to deescalate the situation when he was
arguing with Mom.’” Maisy also said she felt uncomfortable with
Seth “[w]hen he gets his anger issues.”
Kingston, who was in the third grade, said he had not seen
his mother take prescription drugs or abuse alcohol. Like Maisy,
Kingston was concerned about Seth. “When Seth . . . is here,
there is arguing (between the mother and [Seth]). I don’t know
what they argue over but Seth yells over and cusses out Mom and
sometimes me, a lot. Mom does not yell or cuss back. The
argument would end when he’d swing and slam the door and
leave. He has not thrown anything. Every time he’d come over,
little or big argument, he’d not leave without an argument.
A long time ago when I was 6 or 7, he used to be fine. They
argued mostly when Mom was pregnant. He has never been
physical. He has not done anything bad to the baby (Walker)
that I know of. I am feeling safe with Mom except when Seth is
over because he always makes up a fight and makes me scared.
Other than Seth, I am completely fine and safe with Mom and
[Brian].”
The investigator also interviewed Seth’s ex-girlfriend
Julia A., with whom Seth had an older child. Julia said that she
and Seth lived together for six months and that Seth was
sometimes abusive. “During one incident, when [Julia] woke up
at 2:00 am in the morning to change her baby’s diaper, [Seth] ‘did
not like my tone and he threw a diaper at me.’” Another time
Seth “came to visit his daughter where he ‘licked me all over my
face aggressively while I was holding the baby and I went to the
ground to protect my daughter. I called the cops but he left.’”

6
Julia also said Seth “has anger management issues and he could
‘snap’ anytime.” According to Julia, Seth recently left her house
in anger while holding their daughter and said, in the child’s
presence, “‘You are dead to me.’” Julia said she had full custody
of their daughter and a five-year restraining order against Seth.
The Department recommended Shannon participate in a
substance abuse program, “intensive mental health services, and
medication management (if needed) to stabilize her mental
health condition.” The Department said it did not find enough
evidence to support the “failure to protect” allegations regarding
Brian and Seth. But the Department said it “became concerned
about [Seth’s] aggressive and demeaning behavior and anger
towards the mother and the [two older] children. Additionally,
the Department was informed of [Seth’s] little knowledge of
parenting as evidenced by the way he was holding newborn
Walker and his inability to console the baby during [a] home
visit. To rule out drug abuse, [Seth] agreed to drug test for the
Department and he tested positive for low levels of Marijuana.”
The Department also said that it was currently investigating a
referral regarding Seth’s daughter and that Seth’s “anger might
be anxiety-driven due to the situation he is in now as far as his
relationship with the two mothers and issues related to custodial
and visitation time with his children.” The Department
recommended Seth participate in individual counseling to
address anger management and child safety, and take a
parenting class and a parental conflict workshop.

C. The Court Detains Walker from Seth
On February 2, 2023 the Department filed a request to
detain Walker from Seth without notice. The accompanying

7
attorney declaration stated: “[The case social worker] is
concerned about father’s angry outbursts, verbal abuse to mother,
and hostile and aggressive behavior toward mother. Father has
demonstrated that he is unable to control his behavior and
emotions when confronted with situations that he does not agree
with or when others are telling him information he does not want
to hear. Father has been seen handling his infant son, Walker, in
ways that could harm Walker due to father being upset and
angry. Father has driven his van with children (the infant
Walker and a 2-year-old paternal half-sibling) in the vehicle in a
very aggressive manner, skidding his tires out of the Sheriff[’s]
Department Station and driving at high rates of speed because he
is upset after picking up the children. Father has cursed and
used foul language at complete strangers who become involved at
the exchanges of the children between the mother of the child and
the father.” The court granted the Department’s request.
The following day, the Department filed an ex parte
application under section 385 to modify the court’s custody order.
The Department again said it received reports from third parties
that Seth argued with and displayed “aggressive” and “abusive”
behavior toward Shannon (and in Walker’s presence) during
custody exchanges at the sheriff’s station. The Department also
said Seth “displayed aggressive and abusive behavior toward the
child Walker by shaking the baby during exchange; this incident
was observed by the mother and mandated reporters who were
concerned enough to intervene.” The Department asked the court
to vacate the current custody order, detain Walker from Seth,
and order monitored visitation for Seth.
The Department’s detention report (filed with the ex parte
application) stated that on January 22, 2023 two mandated

8
reporters observed Seth, Shannon, and Walker in the parking lot
of the sheriff’s station. One witness said she saw the family in
the lobby when Shannon gave Walker to Seth and thought
Shannon appeared uncomfortable. A few minutes later, in the
parking lot, the witness saw Seth yelling at Shannon, who was in
her car. As Shannon began to back her car out of the parking
space, Seth began to shake Walker, yelling “‘Here take the baby!
Take him!’” The witness “noticed the baby was in distress and
his little head was moving like a bobble head.” The witness
asked Shannon if she wanted assistance. As the witness walked
toward the station, Seth cursed at her. The second witness (a
visitation monitor) also saw Seth hold Walker with two hands
and shake him. She said the “shaking was extreme.”
The Department described Seth’s recent behavior during
custody exchanges as “angry and aggressive” and “hostile” toward
Shannon, the case social worker, and third parties. Shannon said
Seth attempted to manipulate her. Shannon sent Seth text
messages (during a time when there was a nationwide shortage
of baby formula) to say she needed formula. Seth purchased all
the formula in a local discount department store (more than
$600 worth) and told Shannon that, “if she comes over to his
house and is nice to him, he will give her some of the baby
formula.”
The Department also reported on recent visitation. On
December 4, 2022 Shannon arrived with Walker at the sheriff’s
station for a custody exchange. Seth saw Shannon arrive, went
to her car, and got inside the car with Shannon and Walker. Seth
refused to leave the car and spoke with Shannon for two hours,
begging her to resume their relationship. Shannon told the social
worker that she was too scared of Seth to argue or fight with him.

9
A few days later, Seth refused, until a sheriff’s deputy
intervened, to release Walker to the maternal grandmother. The
Department said Seth “then drove erratic[ally] by skidding his
vehicle at a high rate of speed out of the sheriff station parking
lot. (The maternal grandmother took [a] video of the father doing
this.)”
The case social worker spoke to Julia again in late
January 2023. Julia said that when she and Seth attended a
friend’s wedding, Seth punched Julia in the stomach, slapped
her, and jumped on top of her when she fell to the ground. Julia
said witnesses intervened and pulled Seth off her.
On February 8, 2023 the court held a hearing on the
section 385 petition. The Department asked the court to detain
Walker from Seth because Seth “has been reported to be very
inappropriate when he’s dealing with the mother with Walker
caught in the middle.” The Department argued Seth harassed
Shannon and did “not seem to respect boundaries” by, for
example, getting into Shannon’s car after a custody exchange and
talking to Shannon at length in Walker’s presence. The
Department also argued that Seth had “some anger management
blow-ups” and that “the last straw” occurred when witnesses
observed Seth shaking Walker on January 22, 2023. Counsel for
Shannon and Walker joined the Department’s request and agreed
the January 22, 2023 incident placed Walker in danger. Counsel
for Seth said Seth “strenuously denied that he shook or held his
child in an inappropriate manner during the January [22,] 2023
incident. Father will admit there was loud talking, but there was
no abuse to the child or inappropriate interaction above the loud
talking.” Counsel for Seth asked the court to deny the
Department’s request to detain Walker from Seth and suggested

10
third party assistance with custody exchanges would “alleviate
any conflict.”
The court stated: “What is concerning is, as indicated by
the facts as argued by counsel, [this is a] five-month old child and
father let his anger get the best of him.· He shook the baby in
such a manner where the baby’s head was wobbling back and
forth.· That is very dangerous for a child of this age.· He is still a
newborn infant baby. So the father’s anger and his
aggressiveness towards the mother, has and is placing this child
in harm’s way.” The court sustained the petition, detained
Walker from Seth, continued Walker’s placement with Shannon,
and ordered Seth to have three, 3-hour monitored visits weekly,
with custody exchanges to occur in the lobby of the sheriff’s
station. The court also ordered the Department to assess the
paternal grandmother as a monitor.

D. The Department Files an Amended Petition Adding
Allegations of Child Abuse and Domestic Violence by
Seth; The Department Continues To Investigate
On February 9, 2023 the Department filed an amended
petition with five counts, including counts b-1 and b-2 from the
original petition. In count b-3 the Department alleged under
section 300, subdivision (b)(1), that Seth had a history of
domestic violence and violent conduct, including verbal and
physical aggression directed toward Shannon in Walker’s
presence, and that Seth’s violent conduct placed Walker at a
substantial risk of serious physical harm. The Department also
alleged in counts b-4 and a-1 under section 300, subdivisions (a)
and (b), that Seth physically abused Walker on January 22, 2023

11
by shaking him aggressively and that such physical abuse placed
Walker at a substantial risk of serious physical harm.
The Department submitted a supplemental report
regarding the new allegations. Seth vehemently denied shaking
Walker as the Department claimed. Shannon said Seth was
holding Walker with his “‘arms spread out away from his body
and was saying “take him, take him.”’” Shannon said Seth
“appeared to be frustrated that they were back and forth in their
relationship and he was shaking child Walker in front of her.”
Shannon was “afraid” of Seth that day and “was scared enough to
ask for help.”
The Department obtained a police report of an incident of
domestic violence between Shannon and Seth in May 2022,
three months before Walker was born. Shannon said Seth asked
to meet her for dinner to discuss their relationship. Shannon
decided to leave and got into her car, but Seth prevented her from
closing the car door. They argued for a few minutes, and
Shannon began walking through the parking lot and away from
Seth. Seth grabbed Shannon’s arm, causing her to stop and turn
toward Seth. Shannon yelled at Seth and told him to leave her
alone. Shannon called the 911 emergency operator and began to
walk away again, but Seth grabbed her cell phone. Seth
eventually threw Shannon’s phone into her car. Seth generally
agreed with Shannon’s account of the incident but denied
grabbing her arm.
The Department said it was “gravely concerned” for
Walker’s safety in Seth’s custody because of the January 2023
shaking incident, Seth’s history of domestic violence with the
mothers of both his children, his history of violent outbursts, and
his apparent inability to control his anger. The Department

12
believed Seth’s “conduct (shaking the baby) was a deliberate act,
done consciously and intentionally to show his frustration and
anger towards the mother.”
The Department filed a last minute information report on
March 17, 2023. The Department investigator had received and
reviewed video footage from the sheriff’s station taken on
January 22, 2023. The investigator stated: “The video shows the
father entering the parking lot and parking his car next to the
mother’s. He walks towards the entrance door of the Sheriff’s
Station that is not visible. Approximately 4 minutes later both
parents exit the Station and walk back towards their vehicles.
The [father] is seen holding child Walker with one arm (the other
arm is free). The [father] follows the mother to her car, stands by
the driver side door, and he is seen talking to the mother. The
mother enters her vehicle and shuts the door while the father
talks and this apparently angers the father; he is seen arguing
with the mother and moving his free arm up and down. The
mother exits her vehicle and engages in what appears to be an
argument with the father. The father continues to argue with
the mother and he is also seen talking to a bystander who walks
towards the entrance door of the Sheriff[’s] Station. Another
bystander pulls up by the mother’s vehicle and engages her into a
conversation. The father places the baby in his vehicle and
leaves the Station. In review of the video from that specific
angle, this [investigator] did not see the father shake the baby;
however, obviously the baby was present when both parents
engaged in what appeared to be a verbal argument that must
have been loud enough to draw the attention of bystanders.”
The investigator interviewed Seth, who denied any history
of domestic violence with Shannon or Julia and denied having an

13
anger management issue. Seth said that custody exchanges were
sometimes difficult because he would have exchanges with both
mothers at the same time. The investigator asked Seth whether
he shook Walker on January 22, 2023, as reported by witnesses,
and Seth strenuously denied ever shaking or hurting Walker.
Seth said that on that date he suspected Walker might not be his
son and confronted Shannon in the parking lot following a
custody exchange. Seth recalled saying that, “if this is not my
son, then stop torturing me, you can have Walker right now” and
holding Walker out in front of him to give him to Shannon. Seth
said he was attending anger management and parenting classes
and was participating in individual counseling.
The Department concluded there was no evidence to
support the physical abuse allegations in the amended petition.
The Department remained concerned, however, about father’s
inability to control his anger in front of Walker. The Department
asked the court to remove Walker from Seth and stated Seth
would benefit from mental health services, including anger
management and individual counseling, as well as parenting
classes.

E. The Juvenile Court Declares Walker a Dependent
Child of the Court and Removes Him from Seth
At the March 27, 2023 jurisdiction and disposition hearing,
the juvenile court dismissed the allegations regarding Shannon’s
substance abuse and “mental and emotional problems,” both
fathers’ failure to protect the children (counts b-1 and b-2), and
the allegations Seth physically abused Walker on January 22,
2023 (counts b-4 and a-1). As the Department had conceded in its

14
reports, the court found there was “no evidence to support these
counts.”
Regarding count b-3, the court found Seth’s “hostility
towards the mother, the arguments, the aggression towards the
mother while the child is present, places the child at risk.” The
court stated that Seth’s aggression and hostility, coupled with his
“antic” of buying all the available baby formula from the nearest
department store and then asking Shannon to come get the
formula from him, was “unreasonable” and “show[ed] control and
hostility and aggression towards the mother. So that is very
disturbing to the court. And that shows a level of domestic
violence. Domestic violence is not just physical. It is also
psychological and emotional.”
The court sustained count b-3, finding Seth had a “history
of domestic violence and engaging in violent altercations
including, but not limited to, verbal and physical aggression by
repeatedly demonstrating hostile and aggressive behavior toward
the mother, Shannon . . . . Further, on or about 01/22/2023, the
child was exposed to a violent episode in which the father . . .
shouted, berated, and cursed at the mother at the visit exchange.
Such violent conduct on the part of [Seth] against [Walker]
endangers the child’s physical and emotional health and safety
and places the child at risk of severe physical and emotional
harm, damage and danger.”
The court declared Walker a dependent child of the juvenile
court and placed him with Shannon under the supervision of the
Department. The court removed Walker from Seth and ordered
Seth to have monitored visitation in a neutral setting and, over
the Department’s objection, permitted the paternal grandmother
to monitor the visits. The court ordered Seth to take classes

15
(parental conflict workshop, anger management, developmentally
appropriate parenting) and participate in individual counseling.
The court ordered Shannon to join a parental conflict workshop,
participate in individual counseling, attend a full drug and
alcohol program, and submit to random or on-demand drug and
alcohol testing. Seth timely appealed from the court’s jurisdiction
findings and disposition orders.

F. The Juvenile Court Conducts Further Proceedings
The Department filed an application under section 388
asking the court to modify its monitored visitation order to
require a professional monitor. The Department’s application
included declarations from the maternal grandmother and
Shannon, who said Seth appeared to be emotionally unstable.
The juvenile court ordered Seth to have a psychological
evaluation and suspended his visits with Walker pending review
of the evaluation and a further hearing.
The psychological expert reported that Seth’s Personality
Assessment Inventory profile was “within normal limits” and
that Seth showed an interest in treatment.4 She said she
“specifically looked at the scale of Aggression and its subscales of
Aggressive Attitude, Verbal Aggression, and Physical Aggression.
These were all low, i.e., right at the mean for the normal
population. The Violence Potential Index was also very low, with

4 A Personality Assessment Inventory is a test “designed to
reveal abnormal psychology or mental illness, and assesses a
person’s personality structure.” (People v. Saldana (2018)
19 Cal.App.5th 432, 450.) According to the expert, a Personality
Assessment Inventory “is very useful in evaluations of this type,
as it evaluates amenability to treatment and also violence
potential risk.”

16
a T-score of 43, which is below the mean for the average
population.” Regarding Seth’s diagnoses and treatment, the
expert concluded: “Clinical interviewing and testing . . . did not
result in mental health diagnosis, nor personality disorder
diagnosis. Personality has normal variation, and it seems to me
that he is man who is excitable and had poor control of emotion.”
The expert recommended Seth continue with individual
counseling.
At a June 7, 2023 hearing counsel for Seth argued that, in
light of the expert psychologist’s findings, there was no evidence
to suggest Seth posed a risk of harm to Walker. The juvenile
court, however, stated the expert report did “not convince the
court regarding the father’s mental status in light of the text
messages that he sent and his behavior toward the child.” The
court ordered Seth to have two, 3-hour monitored visits weekly in
a therapeutic setting or three, 3-hour visits weekly in the
Department’s office with a Department-approved monitor. On
June 26, 2023 the family court issued a one-year domestic
violence restraining order against Seth protecting Shannon, her
two older children, and the maternal grandmother.
During the next period of supervision, Seth complied fully
with his case plan and tested negative for drugs and alcohol. The
Department said, however, Seth would benefit from “additional
anger management services to better practice the coping skills
taught in the programs” and from additional child development
classes. Seth consistently visited Walker and always arrived
with food, toys, a playpen, and other supplies. The Department
said Seth “actively engage[d] with the child through play” and
provided “affection to the child by hugging, [carrying] him,
singing, and telling the child how much he loves him.” According

17
to the Department, Seth had “shown effort in being a present
father in the life of the child.”
The Department recommended the juvenile court terminate
jurisdiction and award Shannon sole legal and sole physical
custody of Walker. After a contested hearing in November 2023,
the court ruled the conditions justifying dependency jurisdiction
under section 300 no longer existed and were not likely to exist if
the court withdrew supervision. (§ 364, subd. (c).) The court
terminated jurisdiction, awarded Shannon sole legal and sole
physical custody of Walker, and ordered monitored visitation for
Seth. Seth appealed.

DISCUSSION

A. Applicable Law and Standard of Review
Section 300, subdivision (b)(1), “allows a child to be
adjudged a dependent of the juvenile court when ‘[t]he child has
suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer,
serious physical harm or illness, as a result of the failure or
inability of his or her parent or guardian to adequately supervise
or protect the child, or the willful or negligent failure of the
child’s parent or guardian to adequately supervise or protect the
child from the conduct of a custodian with whom the child has
been left.’ A jurisdiction finding under section 300,
subdivision (b)(1), requires the Department to prove three
elements: (1) the parent’s or guardian’s neglectful conduct or
failure or inability to protect the child; (2) causation; and
(3) serious physical harm or illness or a substantial risk of
serious physical harm or illness.” (In re Cole L. (2021)

18
70 Cal.App.5th 591, 601; see In re Gilberto G. (2024)
105 Cal.App.5th 52, 61-62.)
Section 300 requires proof a child is subject to the defined
risk of harm at the time of the jurisdiction hearing. (In re
Gilberto G., supra, 105 Cal.App.5th at p. 62; In re M.D. (2023)
93 Cal.App.5th 836, 848-849; In re Cole L., supra, 70 Cal.App.5th
at pp. 601-602.) But the “court ‘need not wait until a child is
seriously abused or injured to assume jurisdiction and take steps
necessary to protect the child.’ [Citation.] And a parent’s ‘“‘[p]ast
conduct may be probative of current conditions’ if there is reason
to believe that the conduct will continue.”’ [Citation.] However,
‘“[t]o establish a defined risk of harm at the time of the hearing,
there ‘must be some reason beyond mere speculation to believe
the alleged conduct will recur.’”’” (In re S.F. (2023)
91 Cal.App.5th 696, 712-713; see Gilberto G., at p. 62.)
“‘We review the jurisdictional findings for substantial
evidence. [Citation.] We consider the entire record, drawing all
reasonable inferences in support of the juvenile court’s findings
and affirming the order even if other evidence supports a
different finding.’” (In re L.B. (2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 402,
411-412; see In re Gilberto G., supra, 105 Cal.App.5th at p. 62.)
Substantial evidence, however, is not synonymous with any
evidence. (Gilberto G., p. 62; In re B.D. (2024) 103 Cal.App.5th
315, 323.) “A decision supported by a mere scintilla of evidence
need not be affirmed on appeal. [Citation.] Furthermore, [w]hile
substantial evidence may consist of inferences, such inferences
must be a product of logic and reason and must rest on the
evidence [citation]; inferences that are the result of mere
speculation or conjecture cannot support a finding [citations].
[Citation.] The ultimate test is whether it is reasonable for a

19
trier of fact to make the ruling in question in light of the whole
record.” (B.D., at pp. 323-324, internal quotation marks omitted;
see Gilberto G., at p. 62.) “‘We do not consider the credibility of
witnesses or reweigh the evidence.’” (L.B., at p. 412; see
Gilberto G., at p. 62.)

B. Substantial Evidence Did Not Support the
Jurisdiction Findings Based on Domestic Violence
Seth contends substantial evidence did not support the
allegation Seth had a history of domestic violence and violent
outbursts that created a substantial risk of serious physical harm
to Walker. Seth concedes he engaged in verbal arguments with
Shannon, but argues the Department offered no evidence he ever
engaged in physical violence. He’s mostly correct.
“Exposure to domestic violence may serve as the basis for
dependency jurisdiction.” (In re Cole L., supra, 70 Cal.App.5th at
p. 602; see In re R.C. (2012) 210 Cal.App.4th 930, 941.) But
“[c]ases have made it abundantly clear that evidence of prior
domestic violence between a mother and father, in and of itself,
will not support jurisdiction under section 300,
subdivision (b)(1).” (In re S.F., supra, 91 Cal.App.5th at p. 714;
see In re B.H. (2024) 103 Cal.App.5th 469, 482 [“Past incidents of
domestic violence alone . . . cannot support a jurisdiction finding
based on domestic violence.”].) It is a child’s presence in the
vicinity of the parents’ violent conduct that creates the
substantial risk of serious physical harm to the child required for
jurisdiction under section 300, subdivision (b)(1). (See Cole L., at
p. 603 [children may be injured if present during parents’
physically violent fights]; In re Daisy H. (2011) 192 Cal.App.4th
713, 717 [physical violence between parents may support

20
dependency jurisdiction, but only if the violence has “directly
harmed the child physically or placed the child at risk of physical
harm”], disapproved on another ground in In re D.P. (2023)
14 Cal.5th 266, 278.) Moreover, dependency jurisdiction is
unwarranted unless domestic violence is “ongoing or likely to
continue.” (Daisy H., at p. 717; see B.H., at p. 482.)
Seth argues “the evidence shows no violence against
[Shannon]. Period.” Not quite. Before Walker was born, Seth
grabbed Shannon’s arm during an argument to prevent her from
walking away from him. Shannon was not injured. This single
incident of physical contact, however, did not support dependency
jurisdiction because it was remote in time and did not create a
risk of harm to Walker. (See In re Cole L., supra, 70 Cal.App.5th
at pp. 604-605 [substantial evidence did not support dependency
jurisdiction where an incident of pushing and shoving occurred
outside the presence of children]; In re Daisy H., supra,
192 Cal.App.4th at p. 717 [substantial evidence did not “support
a finding that past or present domestic violence between the
parents placed the children at a current substantial risk of
physical harm” because the “physical violence between the
parents happened . . . years before the [filing of] the petition,”
and there was no evidence the children were present when the
violence occurred].) And aside from that single (and relatively
minor) incident, there was no evidence (let alone substantial
evidence) to support the Department’s allegation Seth “engag[ed]
in violent altercations” and exposed Walker to “violent conduct.”
Indeed, Shannon and her two older children consistently denied
Seth was ever physically violent. (See In re M.W. (2015)
238 Cal.App.4th 1444, 1454 [substantial evidence did not support
dependency jurisdiction where a single incident of domestic

21
violence occurred several years before the hearing and there was
no other evidence of altercations between the parents].)
True, Seth and Shannon argued, including during the
dependency proceedings. The evidence was that Seth (and
sometimes Shannon) engaged in yelling, name-calling, cursing,
and verbal harassment in Walker’s presence during custody
exchanges. There was no evidence, however, linking Seth’s
verbal aggression to any physical aggression or other conduct
that placed Walker at a substantial risk of serious physical harm.
(See In re B.H., supra, 103 Cal.App.5th at p. 483 [evidence of
mother’s “verbally aggressive,” “rude or profane” behavior toward
father did not show a substantial risk of physical harm to the
children]; In re S.F., supra, 91 Cal.App.5th at p. 715 [father’s
threatening text messages to mother were “not evidence of an
‘“identified, specific hazard in the child’s environment” that poses
a substantial risk of serious physical harm to him’”].)
The Department relies on claims by Seth’s ex-girlfriend
Julia of domestic violence in her relationship with Seth and
argues “past violence in a relationship is a good predictor of
similar behavior in the future.” The latter statement is true as a
general proposition. (See, e.g., In re B.H., supra, 103 Cal.App.5th
at p. 482 [past incidents of domestic violence may be “a predictor
of future violence”]; In re T.V. (2013) 217 Cal.App.4th 126, 133
[“A parent’s past conduct is a good predictor of future
behavior.”].) But it is speculative to conclude from that evidence
that Seth will likely engage in domestic violence with Shannon in
Walker’s presence, and create a substantial risk of serious
physical harm to him, in the future because he has engaged in
domestic violence with Julia outside the presence of their child,
particularly where the Department provided no evidence Seth

22
has ever been physically violent in Walker’s presence. (See B.H.,
at pp. 482-483 [substantial evidence did not support jurisdiction
findings where “there is simply no evidence of any ongoing
domestic violence between father . . . and mother, nor is there
evidence showing a likelihood past violence will recur”]; see also
Patricia W. v. Superior Court (2016) 244 Cal.App.4th 397, 420
[“‘Speculation or conjecture alone is not substantial evidence.’”].)
Finally, the juvenile court found that the January 22, 2023
incident was a “violent episode” that endangered Walker’s
“emotional health and safety” and placed him at risk of severe
“emotional harm, damage and danger.” This or similar conduct
may have supported dependency jurisdiction under section 300,
subdivision (c), had the Department alleged and proved Walker
was “suffering serious emotional damage, or [was] at substantial
risk of suffering serious emotional damage.” (See In re B.H.,
supra, 103 Cal.App.5th at p. 483, fn. 6.) But the Department did
not allege, and the juvenile court did not make findings for,
jurisdiction under that subdivision of section 300. And as
discussed, the juvenile court dismissed the count under
section 300, subdivision (a), for lack of evidence.
Seth obviously has some anger issues. Hopefully, he is
continuing with individual counseling, working on controlling his
emotions, and learning that yelling at everyone won’t make the
situation any better. But, with one exception years ago, he has
not used force with Shannon, and he has never engaged in
physical violence in Walker’s presence. Seth’s behavior around
Shannon was unacceptable, but it did not create a substantial
risk of serious physical harm to Walker.

23
DISPOSITION

The juvenile court’s jurisdiction findings under section 300,
subdivision (b), are reversed. The court is directed to vacate the
jurisdiction findings and the custody and visitation order and to
dismiss the petition.

SEGAL, J.

We concur:

MARTINEZ, P. J.

FEUER, J.

24

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.