CourtListener 10265726•People v. Ball CA2/1
Full text
Filed 11/4/24 P. v. Ball CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
THE PEOPLE, B322908
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. SA102473)
v.
RAYMOND EDWARD BALL,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Lauren Weis Birnstein. Affirmed.
Jennifer A. Gambale, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Assistant
Attorney General, Steven D. Matthews and Analee J. Brodie,
Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
__________________________________
Raymond Edward Ball appeals from a judgment entered
after a jury found him guilty of one count of attempted criminal
threats (count 2) and one count of criminal threats (count 3),
made against the same victim on two separate occasions.1 The
trial court suspended imposition of sentence and placed Ball on
formal probation for two years.
Ball contends there was insufficient evidence presented at
trial to support the conviction on the criminal threats offense
charged in count 3. He also contends the trial court erred in
allowing the prosecution to refile count 3 after the magistrate
declined to hold him to answer for that charge at the preliminary
hearing. For the reasons explained below, we reject Ball’s
contentions and affirm the judgment.
BACKGROUND
A. The Charges
After the close of evidence at the preliminary hearing, the
magistrate held Ball to answer on charges of assault with a
firearm (Pen. Code,2 § 245, subd. (a)(2); count 1) and criminal
threats (§ 422, subd. (a); count 2), both alleged to have occurred
on February 8, 2020, and a charge of stalking (§ 646.9, subd. (a);
count 4), alleged to have occurred between February 8 and 22,
2020. The magistrate declined to hold Ball to answer on a second
charge of criminal threats, alleged to have occurred on February
22, 2020 (count 3). The district attorney filed an information
asserting the three charges (counts 1, 2 & 4), consistent with the
magistrate’s ruling.
1 The jury found Ball not guilty of the crime charged in
count 1, assault with a firearm against the same victim.
2 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2
Ball filed a motion under section 995 to set aside the
information as to the stalking count. After hearing from the
parties, the trial court granted the motion and dismissed the
stalking count. The court allowed the district attorney to amend
the information to refile count 3, the February 22, 2020 criminal
threats offense. Accordingly, the case proceeded to trial on an
amended information charging Ball with assault with a firearm
(count 1) and two counts of criminal threats (counts 2 & 3).
In addressing Ball’s contention of error regarding the
refiling of count 3 (infra, Discussion section B) we will set forth a
summary of the pertinent evidence presented at the preliminary
hearing and a more detailed account of the relevant proceedings
below.
B. Summary of Pertinent Evidence Presented at Trial
The victim of the offenses charged in this case, Kenneth
Solana, and his fiancé, Mychelle Reyna, worked at a Trader Joe’s
store in Los Angeles County (hereafter, the store). Appellant Ball
and his wife, Maria Rodriguez-Ball, lived near and shopped at
the store. Ball was a private investigator who carried a firearm
when he was working. The charged offenses arise from two
encounters between Ball and Solana that occurred at the store
(the first outside, and the second inside).
At trial, Solana and Reyna testified in the prosecution’s
case and Ball and Rodriguez-Ball testified in the defense case
(and each side called other witnesses).
1. February 8, 2020 incident
Ball does not challenge his conviction for attempted
criminal threats (count 2) arising from the February 8, 2020
encounter between him and Solana. We describe the February 8,
2020 incident here because the history between Ball and Solana
3
informs an evaluation of whether Ball committed a criminal
threats offense against Solana on February 22, 2020. (See People
v. Mosley (2007) 155 Cal.App.4th 313, 324 (Mosley) [the history
between the defendant and the victim is a relevant circumstance
to examine in determining whether the defendant’s statement
constitutes a criminal threat].)
a. Evidence presented by the prosecution
regarding the February 8, 2020 incident
In the evening on February 8, 2020, Solana was working at
the store. Reyna, who was not working at that time, drove to the
store to meet Solana during his meal break. She arrived at their
meeting spot, near the store’s loading dock, at around 7:00 p.m.
Another car was parked in the same area. She drove her car in
reverse toward the other car and parked in front of it. A man—
whom she identified at trial as Ball—honked his horn, exited the
car, and paced back and forth as he screamed profanities at her.
He returned to his car, revved the engine, drove around her car,
reversed toward her, and parked in front of her car. She
recognized Ball as a regular customer of the store.
Solana exited the store and entered Reyna’s car. She told
him about her encounter with Ball—whom she referred to as a
regular customer—and said she wanted to leave because the
customer was “acting crazy.” Solana, who was wearing his store
uniform, exited Reyna’s car and walked over to Ball’s car. He
wanted to know which customer it was. He looked through a
window of Ball’s car, which was rolled partway down, and
recognized Ball as a frequent customer at the store. He asked
Ball, “Is everything okay” and/or “Hey, bro, is there a problem?”
Ball responded, “You and your bitch need to get the fuck out of
here. You’re gonna get smoked.” He reiterated the statement
4
about Solana and Reyna getting “smoked” multiple times. Solana
replied, “I know who you are,” trying to convey that he recognized
Ball as a customer. He again asked Ball if everything was okay
and said, “What’s up?” According to Solana, Ball “blew up” at
him. Solana observed something shiny on Ball’s lap and believed
Ball was holding a gun.
Solana was confused by Ball’s reaction, and he started to
walk back to Reyna’s car. He was scared because he believed
Ball “wasn’t playing around” and was going to hurt or kill him
and Reyna. Ball exited his car and walked toward the back of it.
He repeated that Solana and Reyna need to leave before they “get
smoked.” Reyna heard Ball make a statement to this effect and
believed it meant Ball was going to shoot them. Solana testified
that when he was not yet to Reyna’s car, he looked at Ball and
observed that Ball was holding a shiny black handgun in his
right hand, close to his body, with the barrel pointing at Solana.
Solana entered Reyna’s car, told her that Ball had pulled a gun
on him, and indicated they should leave. Solana was shocked
and scared. Reyna had not observed a gun.
Reyna drove to the front of the store. She and Solana
approached two of the store’s managers in the parking lot. They
told the managers what happened, and the managers contacted
law enforcement. Solana waited inside the store. When an
officer arrived, Solana reported the incident.
b. Evidence presented by the defense regarding the
February 8, 2020 incident
During his trial testimony, Ball denied that he spoke to or
yelled at Reyna on February 8, 2020. He stated that he honked
his horn and moved his car after she pulled in front of him and
5
backed up very close to his car. He said he did not exit his car or
speak to her.
Ball further testified that he was talking to a friend on his
phone when Solana crouched next to his car and thumped on his
closed passenger window.3 Solana was wearing a sweatshirt with
the hood pulled over his head. Using profanity, Solana asked
why Ball was being disrespectful to his fiancé. Ball responded
that he did not know what Solana was talking about. Solana
continued to accuse Ball of being disrespectful and continued to
use profanity. Ball recognized Solana as a store employee, and
he exited his car to “investigate.” He tried to calm Solana down,
and when he was unsuccessful, he entered his car and drove
away.
Ball denied that he had his gun with him at the store on
February 8, 2020. He stated that he was licensed to openly carry
a firearm while he was working as a private investigator, and he
was not permitted to carry it when he was not working. Ball’s
wife, Rodriguez-Ball, testified at trial that she recalled Ball left
his firearm on a bedroom dresser when he went to the store on
February 8, 2020.
2. February 22, 2020 incident
Count 3, the criminal threats offense at issue in this
appeal, arises from a February 22, 2020 encounter between Ball
and Solana that took place inside the store at around 5:00 p.m.,
while Solana was working.
3 The friend testified at trial.
He stated that while he was
on the phone with Ball on February 8, 2020, he heard someone
knock on the car window and he heard Ball say, “Hey, what’s
going on?” He did not hear Ball raise his voice or say he was
going to “smoke” anyone.
6
a. Evidence presented by the prosecution regarding
the February 22, 2020 incident
The store was crowded with customers. Solana was
passing out cheese samples when Rodriguez-Ball (Ball’s wife)
approached and asked him about the cheese. After Solana
answered her questions, she stepped to the side, and Solana
noticed Ball, who had been standing behind her. Although Ball
appeared calm (at first), Solana was nervous because of their
previous encounter.
According to Solana, Ball explained why he reacted the way
he did during the February 8, 2020 incident. He told Solana that
he was from the “streets” of Los Angeles; he was “from a gang”;
and “anybody that goes up to his car, they’re going to see smoke.”
Solana replied, “You know who I was [meaning a store employee],
and you still did what you did.” Solana did not want to say more
because he was working, and he did not want to make Ball angry.
So, he “brushed him off,” and Ball started raising his voice.
Store managers, who witnessed the interaction, told Solana
to go to the back of the store. Solana testified that Ball told him,
“Yeah, you better go to the back. You better go to the back. I’m
gonna wait for you. I know -- I know what time you get off.” Ball
also said, “I’m gonna come back when you get off.” Solana was
scared and believed Ball was going to hurt him.
As Solana walked to the back of the store, Ball’s voice
became louder. He shouted to Solana that he was “going to come
back and catch [him] after work.” He also repeated multiple
times that he was “gonna catch [Solana] slipping.” Solana
understood this to mean that Ball was going to hurt him. Solana
was more afraid than he was after the February 8, 2020
encounter because this was the second time Ball had confronted
7
him at his workplace, and he believed Ball was serious about
hurting him.
Juliana Gonzalez, a store manager who witnessed the
February 22, 2020 encounter between Ball and Solana, testified
at trial. She was working near Solana when she heard people
arguing. She turned around and observed that it was Solana and
a regular customer (whom she identified at trial as Ball). It
appeared to her that Solana “was in a little bit of distress,” so she
told him to go to the back of the store. She heard Ball say to
Solana, “You’re gonna get caught slipping.” Solana “look[ed] like
he was in shock.”
Gonzalez saw Ball exit the store, and she asked some
employees to contact law enforcement. She followed Ball because
she wanted to be able to tell officers which way he went. She
observed him “pacing back and forth in front of the store,”
appearing “antsy” and “heated.” He looked at her and said, “Tell
him [meaning Solana] to come back out here” and “I’m gonna
smoke him.”
Solana testified that he spoke to officers the same evening,
after the incident. The following day, he transferred to a
different Trader Joe’s store. He felt like he could not work
“knowing that [Ball] was gonna come back.” He was afraid that
Ball would hurt him and/or Reyna (who also transferred to a
different store). Solana remained in fear of Ball at the time of
trial.
Ball was arrested outside his home on March 18, 2020. At
the time, he was wearing a badge around his neck and had a
loaded 9-millimeter semiautomatic firearm in a holster on his left
hip.
8
b. Evidence presented by the defense regarding
the February 22, 2020 incident
Ball testified at trial that while he and his wife were
shopping at the store on February 22, 2020, his wife spoke with
Solana, who was handing out samples. Ball approached Solana
and asked, “Are you the guy who knocked on my window?”
Solana replied loudly, “Yes, but you didn’t have to pull a gun on
me.” Ball felt embarrassed. Solana walked away with another
employee. Ball finished shopping with his wife, paid for their
groceries at the register, and left. He denied that anyone asked
him to leave the store.4
C. Verdicts and Sentencing
The jury found Ball not guilty of assault with a firearm
(count 1) and the lesser related offense of brandishing a firearm.5
The jury also found him not guilty of the February 8, 2020
criminal threats offense charged in count 2, but found him guilty
of the lesser included offense of attempted criminal threats in
count 2. Finally, the jury found him guilty of the February 22,
2020 criminal threats offense (count 3).
At the sentencing hearing, the trial court suspended
imposition of sentence and placed Ball on formal probation for
two years with terms and conditions, including that he serve 40
4 Rodriguez-Ball’s testimony regarding the February 22,
2020 incident was consistent with Ball’s testimony. She
presented bank records showing a purchase made at Trader Joe’s
on February 22, 2020.
5 Because Ball was acquitted of these firearm offenses, we
do not consider Solana’s testimony regarding Ball’s possession of
a gun in our analysis of the sufficiency of the evidence supporting
the criminal threats conviction.
9
days in jail (which he had already served), perform 50 days of
community labor, and complete a 52-week anger management
class.6 The court also issued a three-year criminal protective
order, requiring Ball to stay at least 100 yards away from Solana,
Reyna, Gonzalez, and all Trader Joe’s stores in Los Angeles
County.
DISCUSSION
A. Sufficient Evidence Presented at Trial Supports the
Conviction for Criminal Threats (Count 3)
Under section 422, subdivision (a), “Any person who
willfully threatens to commit a crime which will result in death
or great bodily injury to another person, with the specific intent
that the statement . . . is to be taken as a threat, even if there is
no intent of actually carrying it out, which, on its face and under
the circumstances in which it is made, is so unequivocal,
unconditional, immediate, and specific as to convey to the person
threatened, a gravity of purpose and an immediate prospect of
execution of the threat, and thereby causes that person
reasonably to be in sustained fear for his or her own safety or for
his or her immediate family’s safety, shall be punished by
imprisonment in the county jail not to exceed one year, or by
imprisonment in the state prison.”
Ball contends the prosecution presented insufficient
evidence at trial to support a conviction on count 3, arguing (1)
the statement he made on February 22, 2020 was too ambiguous
to express a criminal threat, and (2) the statement did not convey
6 In explaining the decision to order Ball to complete a 52-
week anger management class, the trial court stated that Ball’s
attitude during his trial testimony indicated he was “a hothead”
and had “anger issues.”
10
to Solana a gravity of purpose and an immediate prospect of
execution of a threat to commit a crime that would result in
death or great bodily injury.
1. Standard of review
“In assessing a claim of insufficiency of evidence, the
reviewing court’s task is to review the whole record in the light
most favorable to the judgment to determine whether it discloses
substantial evidence—that is, evidence that is reasonable,
credible, and of solid value—such that a reasonable trier of fact
could find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.
[Citation.] The federal standard of review is to the same effect:
Under principles of federal due process, review for sufficiency of
evidence entails not the determination whether the reviewing
court itself believes the evidence at trial establishes guilt beyond
a reasonable doubt, but, instead, whether, after viewing the
evidence in the light most favorable to the prosecution, any
rational trier of fact could have found the essential elements of
the crime beyond a reasonable doubt. [Citation.] The standard of
review is the same in cases in which the prosecution relies
mainly on circumstantial evidence. [Citation.] . . . ‘ “ ‘ “If the
circumstances reasonably justify the trier of fact’s findings, the
opinion of the reviewing court that the circumstances might also
reasonably be reconciled with a contrary finding does not warrant
a reversal of the judgment.” ’ ” ’ ” (People v. Rodriguez (1999) 20
Cal.4th 1, 11.)
In determining whether substantial evidence supports the
conviction, “we do not reweigh the evidence, resolve conflicts in
the evidence, draw inferences contrary to the verdict, or
reevaluate the credibility of witnesses.” (People v. Little (2004)
115 Cal.App.4th 766, 771, citing People v. Jones (1990) 51 Cal.3d
11
294, 314.) “[I]t is the exclusive province of the trial judge or jury
to determine the credibility of a witness and the truth or falsity of
the facts on which that determination depends.” (Jones, at p.
314.) Moreover, “testimony of a single witness is sufficient to
support a conviction” unless the testimony “is physically
impossible or inherently improbable.” (People v. Young (2005) 34
Cal.4th 1149, 1181.)
2. Pertinent legal principles regarding criminal threats
“A threat is sufficiently specific where it threatens death or
great bodily injury.” (People v. Butler (2000) 85 Cal.App.4th 745,
752 (Butler).) “[T]here is no requirement that a specific crime or
Penal Code violation be threatened.” (Id. at p. 755.) “A threat is
not insufficient simply because it does ‘not communicate a time or
precise manner of execution, section 422 does not require those
details to be expressed.’ ” (Id. at p. 752.) Nor does section 422
“require an immediate ability to carry out the threat.” (People v.
Smith (2009) 178 Cal.App.4th 475, 480.)
In determining whether a defendant made a criminal
threat, we do not evaluate the defendant’s statements in a
vacuum. Rather, the statements “are judged in their context.”
(In re Ricky T. (2001) 87 Cal.App.4th 1132, 1137 (Ricky T.).) “The
surrounding circumstances must be examined to determine if the
threat is real and genuine, a true threat.” (Ibid.) Similarly, the
determination of “whether the words were sufficiently
unequivocal, unconditional, immediate and specific [that] they
conveyed to the victim an immediacy of purpose and immediate
prospect of execution of the threat can be based on all the
surrounding circumstances and not just on the words alone.”
(People v. Mendoza (1997) 59 Cal.App.4th 1333, 1340 (Mendoza).)
A history between the defendant and the victim may “ ‘ “be
12
considered as one of the relevant circumstances.” ’ ” (Mosley,
supra, 155 Cal.App.4th at p. 324.) Moreover, “circumstances
occurring after” the defendant made the statements may “further
a finding of a [criminal] threat.” (Ricky T., at p. 1139.) “[I]t is the
circumstances under which the threat is made that give meaning
to the actual words used. Even an ambiguous statement may be
a basis for a violation of section 422,” when considered in light of
the surrounding circumstances. (Butler, supra, 85 Cal.App.4th at
p. 753.)
For example, in Mendoza, supra, 59 Cal.App.4th 1333, the
Court of Appeal concluded substantial evidence supported the
defendant’s conviction for criminal threats where the defendant
told a former associate of his gang who had testified against his
brother at a preliminary hearing on a murder charge, “you fucked
up my brother’s testimony. I’m going to talk to some guys from
Happy Town [the criminal street gang].” (Id. at pp. 1337, 1340-
1342.) About a half hour after the defendant came to her home,
made the statements and left, the victim heard the honk of a car
horn and observed the defendant’s friend and fellow gang
member sitting in a car parked across the street. (Id. at pp. 1338,
1341.) The appellate court acknowledged that the defendant’s
“words themselves” were ambiguous and “did not articulate a
threat to commit a specific crime resulting in death or great
bodily injury.” (Id. at pp. 1340, 1342.) Considering all the
surrounding circumstances, including the history between the
defendant and the victim, however, the Court of Appeal
concluded that a “rational juror could reasonably find a threat to
bring a person to the attention of a criminal street gang as
someone who has ‘ratted’ on a fellow gang member presents a
serious danger of death or great bodily injury.” (Id. at p. 1341.)
13
The appellate court also pointed out that the defendant had
“apparently acted on his intention” to talk to “some guys from
Happy Town,” as a gang member was looking for the victim
within 30 minutes of the defendant making the threat. (Ibid.)
3. Analysis
Ball argues the statement “I’m gonna catch you slipping”
was too ambiguous to express a criminal threat and did not
convey to Solana a gravity of purpose and an immediate prospect
of execution of a threat to commit a crime that would result in
death or great bodily injury.7 Considering the other words Ball
uttered on February 22, 2020 and the circumstances surrounding
the statement, we disagree with Ball’s arguments.
Evidence presented at trial shows that two weeks before
Ball made the statement at issue, he threatened to “smoke”
Solana (and Reyna). Solana and Reyna understood this to mean
Ball would shoot or kill them. Ball has offered no alternative
meaning of “smoke,” as used here, and we are aware of none.
On February 22, 2020, prior to saying “I’m gonna catch you
slipping,” Ball became angry and started raising his voice. He
told Solana, “I’m gonna wait for you”; “I know what time you get
off [work]”; “I’m gonna come back when you get off”; and “I’m
going to come back and catch you after work.” When Ball
thereafter said, “I’m gonna catch you slipping,” Solana
understood that to mean that Ball was going to hurt him.
According to store manager Gonzalez, immediately after the
incident in the store, she observed Ball pacing back and forth
outside in front of the store in a “heated” manner. Ball said to
7 Ball does not challenge the sufficiency of the evidence
supporting the other elements of the crime of criminal threats.
14
her, “Tell him [Solana] to come back out here” and “I’m gonna
smoke him.”
Viewing the evidence in a light most favorable to the
judgment of conviction, as we must, substantial evidence
demonstrates that Ball intended to convey to Solana that he
would wait for him after work, and when he found him in a more
vulnerable position than in a crowded grocery store, he would kill
him or inflict great bodily harm. The fact that Ball remained
outside the store, and told Gonzalez to go get Solana so he could
smoke him, demonstrates “a gravity of purpose and an immediate
prospect of execution of the threat” he had made to Solana. (See
§ 422, subd. (a).) Sufficient evidence supports the conviction.
Ball likens this case to Ricky T., supra, 87 Cal.App.4th
1132, but that case is readily distinguishable. There, the juvenile
court found that a 16-year-old student committed criminal
threats when he told his teacher, “I’m going to get you” and “I’m
going to kick your ass,” after the student pounded on a locked
classroom door and the teacher opened the door, hitting the
student with it. (Id. at pp. 1135-1136.) The Court of Appeal
concluded there were no surrounding “circumstances to
corroborate a true threat,” given there was no “prior history of
disagreements” between the student and teacher, and there was
no “evidence that a physical confrontation was actually
imminent.” (Id. at p. 1138.) Here, in contrast, Ball had
previously threatened to “smoke” Solana and his fiancé; and he
waited outside the store after the February 22, 2020
confrontation, indicating to the store manager that he wanted
Solana to come outside so he could “smoke” him.
15
B. The Trial Court Did Not Err in Allowing the
Prosecution to Refile the Criminal Threats Charge in
Count 3
Ball contends the trial court erred when it allowed the
district attorney to refile count 3 in an amended information,
arguing (1) the magistrate made factual findings that were “fatal”
to the criminal threats offense charged in count 3, and (2) even if
the magistrate did not make such factual findings, the
prosecution presented insufficient evidence at the preliminary
hearing to support the charge.
1. Proceedings below
As set forth above, the charges the magistrate considered
at the preliminary hearing were assault with a firearm (count 1),
the February 8, 2020 criminal threats offense (count 2), the
February 22, 2020 criminal threats offense (count 3), and
stalking (count 4).
Solana testified at the preliminary hearing. Regarding
count 3—the charge at issue here—Solana stated that Ball
approached him in the store on February 22, 2020 and explained
that he was “from the streets,” and “from a gang,” and he would
“smoke” anyone he did not know who came up to him (referring to
the manner in which Solana had approached him on February 8,
2020). As Solana walked to the back of the store after their brief
exchange, Ball said, “Yeah, you need to go to the back before I
kick your ass.” Ball also said, “I’m going to come back and catch
you slipping.” Solana interpreted the latter statement as a threat
that Ball would come back to the store and beat him up or shoot
him or harm him in some way.
The magistrate questioned Solana as follows: “And I know
[the prosecutor] asked you this. You took it as a threat. Did you
16
take it as a threat that it was going to happen to you right then,
or did you take it as something that would or might happen in
the future?” Solana responded, “In the future. I didn’t think he
was going to do it there with a hundred people watching him.”
After the close of evidence at the preliminary hearing,
Ball’s counsel argued there was insufficient evidence to hold Ball
to answer on the charge of assault with a firearm. As defense
counsel then began to discuss the alleged criminal threats, the
magistrate stated, “You might have a more sympathetic ear from
me as to . . . the 422 on count 3” (the February 22, 2020 criminal
threats offense). The prosecutor responded, “The People submit.”
The magistrate stated, “I’m not going to hold to answer on count
3.” During a subsequent discussion regarding whether the
magistrate should hold Ball to answer on the stalking count, the
magistrate stated: “And, for the record, it [the crime of stalking]
doesn’t have the immediacy element that 422 [the crime of
criminal threats] has. And the Court doesn’t intend to hold to
answer on the 422, but the stalking charge doesn’t have the same
element of immediacy of the threat.” The magistrate held Ball to
answer on charges of assault with a firearm, the February 8,
2020 criminal threats offense, and stalking; and the district
attorney filed an information asserting these charges.
At a pretrial hearing on May 11, 2022, the trial court noted
Solana stated Ball made statements to him on both February 8
and 22, 2020. Addressing defense counsel, the court stated:
“[Y]ou should understand that, if both of these dates come out,
you know, the People can ask to file according to proof and, you
know, I’ll just give a unanimity instruction that they’re going to
have to agree on whichever date or both. So that is something we
should consider now.” Turning to the prosecutor, the court
17
stated: “If you want to file an amended information and allege
both of the dates, you need to do that. If not, it’ll be according to
proof at trial if you make that motion.” The prosecutor stated she
would review the preliminary hearing transcript and file an
amended information if the testimony was consistent with the
statements given to the police officers. The court responded, “All
right. So defense is on notice of that. It can be filed on the next
appearance.” Defense counsel did not comment on the potential
refiling of count 3.
At the following pretrial hearing on May 17, 2022, the trial
court heard argument on Ball’s motion under section 995 to set
aside the information as to the stalking count. During that
discussion, the court noted the magistrate did not hold Ball to
answer on count 3, the February 22, 2020 criminal threats
offense. The court commented, “I don’t know the thinking of the
magistrate, really.” The prosecutor posited that the magistrate
believed the February 22, 2020 “threat lacked the immediacy
element.” The court responded, “Well, the case law says it
probably was immediate enough.” After further discussion, the
court stated its inclination was to grant the 995 motion as to the
stalking charge and allow the prosecution to refile count 3 in an
amended information. Defense counsel requested time to review
“the case law regarding the immediacy of the threat” and “the
language of the [February 22, 2020] threat on its face.” The court
took a recess.
After the recess, defense counsel stated, “Based off of the
nature of the threat, if it is the court’s opinion that that threat is
imminent enough and rises to the level of meeting the elements
of a 422 for the purposes of prelim, I would ask that the court
consider reducing that pursuant to 17(b) from a felony to a
18
misdemeanor . . . .” Defense counsel did not present any
additional argument regarding the immediacy of the threat. The
trial court explained that it could not reduce the charge at that
juncture. Defense counsel responded, “Perfect. I will submit.”
The court granted the 995 motion as to the stalking count and
ruled that the prosecution could refile count 3, concluding the
charge “fits all of the elements for purposes of the preliminary
hearing.”
The following day, on May 18, 2022, the district attorney
filed an amended information charging Ball with assault with a
firearm and two counts of criminal threats. Ball did not move to
set aside the amended information.
2. Analysis
Ball contends the magistrate made factual findings that
were “fatal” to the criminal threats offense charged in count 3,
and therefore, the trial court erred in allowing the district
attorney to refile count 3. While we agree with Ball that “the
trial court and this court would be bound by any express factual
findings made by the magistrate” based on evidence presented at
the preliminary hearing (People v. Barba (2012) 211 Cal.App.4th
214, 228), here, the magistrate made no such factual findings. As
Ball states in his opening appellate brief, the magistrate made “a
legal conclusion” when it indicated that Ball’s statement to
Solana on February 22, 2020, did not satisfy “the immediacy
element of section 422.” The trial court was not bound by the
magistrate’s legal conclusion. (See Barba, at pp. 227-228.)
Ball next contends the trial court erred in allowing the
district attorney to refile count 3 because the prosecution
presented insufficient evidence at the preliminary hearing to
support the charge. Assuming Ball preserved this claim for
19
appellate review, his challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence
at the preliminary hearing is not well taken. “Where the
evidence produced at trial amply supports the jury’s finding, any
question whether the evidence produced at the preliminary
hearing supported the finding of probable cause is rendered moot.
Even ‘ “ ‘[i]f there is insufficient evidence to support the
commitment, the defendant cannot be said to be prejudiced where
sufficient evidence has been introduced at . . . trial’ ” ’ to support
the jury’s finding as to the charge or as to the truth of the
allegation.” (People v. Crittenden (1994) 9 Cal.4th 83, 137; People
v. Letner and Tobin (2010) 50 Cal.4th 99, 140.) As we concluded
above, Ball’s conviction for the February 22, 2020 criminal
threats offense is supported by sufficient evidence presented at
trial.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
KLINE, J.*
We concur:
ROTHSCHILD, P. J. WEINGART, J.
* Retired Presiding Justice of the Court of Appeal, First
Appellate District, Division Two, assigned by the Chief Justice
pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
20
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.