In re T.G. CA1/5

CourtListener 10045056CalctappAug 16, 2024

Full text

Filed 8/16/24 In re T.G. CA1/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not
certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been
certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

In re T.G., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.

MARIN COUNTY HEALTH AND
HUMAN SERVICES, A167431

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Marin County Super. Ct.
v. No. JV27156A)
L.G.,
Defendant and Appellant.

In this juvenile dependency proceeding, defendant L.G. (Father)
appeals from an order issued after the 12-month status review hearing (Welf.
& Inst. Code, § 366.21, subd. (f)), which terminated family reunification
services regarding his son, T.G. (the minor).1 Father contends the juvenile
court erred because he did not receive reasonable services and because there
was a substantial probability the minor would be returned to his care if
services were provided. We will affirm the order.

1 Except where otherwise indicated, all statutory references are to the

Welfare and Institutions Code.

1
I. FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
The minor was born in November 2010. At the time plaintiff and
respondent Marin County Health and Human Services (Department) became
involved in 2021, the minor lived with his mother, N.S. (Mother). The
Department filed a section 300 petition that alleged severe neglect by Mother
and a failure to protect by Father because he “failed to seek legal custody or
take other actions to ensure [the minor’s] basic needs were met.”
A. Initial Proceedings and Appeals
The parties submitted to jurisdiction in January 2022, based on an
amended petition alleging that Father negligently failed to adequately
protect the minor from Mother. The juvenile court placed the minor in a
Short-Term Residential Therapeutic Placement (STRTP).
In its February 2022 disposition order, the juvenile court declined to
place the minor in Father’s care on the ground it would have been to the
minor’s detriment. (§ 361.2.) The court approved a case plan by which
Father would show he had safe and sustainable housing for the minor,
identify a support network of at least three people who could help him care
for the minor, demonstrate that his home was free from drugs and alcohol,
submit to drug testing, and participate in a substance abuse assessment.
The plan also required Father to take parenting classes and participate in
family therapy when deemed appropriate. (Individual therapy was added to
the plan in September 2022.)
Father appealed from the disposition order, claiming there was no
substantial evidence to support the conclusion that it would be detrimental to
the minor if placed in Father’s care (Case No. A164680). We affirmed the
order.

2
At the six-month status review hearing (§ 366.21, subd. (e)), the
juvenile court again ruled that it would be detrimental to place the minor in
Father’s care. Father appealed (Case No. A166192). While the appeal was
pending, the court re-authorized the minor’s placement in a STRTP. Father
appealed this order as well (Case No. A166524).
We consolidated those two appeals and affirmed. We found that
substantial evidence supported the ruling that placing the minor in Father’s
care would still be detrimental to the minor because “Father did not comply
with aspects of his case plan,” “did not make progress in eliminating the
issues that led to the detriment finding at disposition,” and “had not shown
an ability to handle [the minor’s] needs or addressed concerns about his [own]
substance use.” We also affirmed the placement of the minor in the STRTP.
B. 12-Month Status Review
1. Department Report
In November 2022, the Department filed a report for the 12-month
status review, recommending that reunification services be terminated.
According to the report, the minor enjoyed his placement at the STRTP, made
progress on his behavioral goals, and was meeting with a school counselor
and individual therapist.
The report summarized the services that the Department had offered to
Father, including: monthly meetings to discuss case planning and the
minor’s health, safety, and well-being; monthly communications with Father
to monitor and discuss reunification services and review case plan activities;
transportation assistance; assistance in using ACCESS (the mental health
evaluation provider) and therapy referrals through Marin County Behavioral
and Recovery Services; monthly Child and Family Team (CFT) meetings;
referrals to substance testing and a substance use assessment; referrals to a

3
Positive Parenting Program and contact with the facilitator to verify
attendance and participation; contact with the Marin County eligibility office
regarding Father’s Medi-Cal application; coordinating and offering
Department-paid individual therapy for Father; offering to help Father build
a support network; and coordinating and funding visitation for Father with
professional supervision and parent coaching.
Father, however, had not cooperated with the Department. He refused
to provide information that would allow the Department to assess his ability
to provide for the minor if returned to his care. He refused to answer
questions regarding housing, employment, and his support network. He
consistently disputed the need for supportive services that had been put in
place to help address the minor’s significant needs in school and at home.
Nor had Father met the requirements of his case plan. As to safe and
sustainable housing, he claimed he lived on a boat but resisted the efforts of
the new child welfare social worker (Peasley) to confirm the details of his
residency. He did not allow Peasley to visit the boat until November 8, 2022.
He claimed the boat belonged to a friend who let him live there, but he did
not put Peasley in contact with the friend by the end of the review period.
The social worker was unable to confirm with the boat’s owner or the
harbormaster that Father was living on the boat or that the minor would be
allowed to live there with him.
As for his support network, when asked to identify at least three people
who could keep the minor safe and assist with meeting the minor’s needs,
Father said there were “ ‘doctors and lawyers’ ” but he did not want to involve
them because they were busy and he did not want people knowing his
business. Despite Father’s refusal to provide information about his relatives,
the social worker tracked down a paternal aunt who was willing to support

4
Father and the minor and attended two CFTs, but Father had no other
support network. Furthermore, Father was upset that the minor had
developed his own support network, including his CASA and his former
resource parent, saying it was “ ‘disgusting’ ” that the minor spent time with
them. He saw no need to ask the minor if he enjoyed the visits because he
knew his son.
The case plan also required Father to participate in a substance abuse
assessment and submit to substance tests. During the review period, Father
continued to refuse an assessment and denied that he had issues with alcohol
or substance abuse. He continued to dismiss the Department’s concerns
about his history of DUI’s — including his five DUI convictions in a 10-year-
period (the most recent in 2018) — insisting that “ ‘they have nothing to do
with anything.’ ” He missed the first substance test after the six-month
review hearing, tested from September 9, 2022, through October 12, 2022,
and missed a test on October 20, 2022. He consistently tested positive for
marijuana. Initially, he claimed to use marijuana for medical reasons but
failed to provide proof of a prescription. Later, he said he did not need a
prescription because recreational use of marijuana was legal.
Mental health services had been added to Father’s case plan after it
became apparent that he would benefit from therapeutic support. Peasley
confirmed that Father still displayed behaviors indicating he could use that
support. Father remained upset with the Department and the previous social
worker. He was quick to anger, raised his voice, claimed that providers were
lying and that the court’s involvement was based on lies and hearsay, and
believed that difficulties in coordinating therapy were the result of a
conspiracy against him.

5
Individual therapy for Father was ordered on September 1, 2022.
Later that month, Marin County Eligibility confirmed that Father was in the
process of applying for Medi-Cal and spoke with Father on September 16,
2022, but Father never went to the office to fill out the required paperwork.
He was given the documents to sign on September 20 and 27, 2022, but he
did not turn them in until September 30, 2022. His Medi-Cal application was
eventually approved.
Father participated in a mental health evaluation around October 10,
2022, but refused to sign a release for the Department to review the
evaluation and discuss it with the evaluators. The Department learned that
Father’s mental health needs were deemed not high enough for a referral to
services through the county, but without the release, the Department was
unable to review the assessment to see if Father accurately reported his
mental health.
After learning about the denial of county services, the Department
offered to pay for Father’s private therapy to expedite his access to mental
health services rather than waiting for a release to learn why he was denied
county services. The Department’s mental health practitioner explained to
Father the options for therapy on October 31, 2022, but he never followed up.
On November 10, 2022, Father told the social worker that he was
willing to engage in therapy and sign the release for the Department to
obtain information from the mental health evaluation provider. But when
Father was given the release to sign, he said he wanted to review it further
before signing. At the social worker’s request, Father called the
Department’s mental health practitioner and met with the therapist (Dr.
Russell) on November 25, 2022.

6
As for family therapy, the case plan provided that the minor and
Father would engage in family therapy when deemed appropriate. During
the review period, the minor’s therapist (Mr. Jacobs) tried to incorporate
Father into the minor’s session to include therapeutic family work. He
reached out to Father in late September 2022, but Father did not respond.
Eventually, Father was incorporated into one of the minor’s therapy sessions
by phone, but Mr. Jacobs found Father to be “ ‘minimally inappropriate’ ”
when he complained about the support provided to the family and the initial
involvement of external agencies.
As for visitation and parenting, the Department still had concerns
about Father’s behavior in the minor’s presence, which had led the juvenile
court at the six-month review hearing to change Father’s visits from
minimally-supervised to fully-supervised. As a result of this change, visits
were paused from September 1, 2022, to September 13, 2022, while the
Department arranged for supervision, but supervised phone contact
continued. On September 13, 2022, Father was offered supervised visits on
Mondays and Wednesdays, but he declined the Wednesday visits without
explanation. At the first fully supervised visit, the social worker noted that
Father was frustrated, continuously lectured the minor, and needed to be
redirected several times. The STRTP was later able to supervise only one
visit a week; Father attended all of those visits, and they went well.
Father consistently opposed the return to supervised visits and claimed
it was due to hearsay. The social worker advised Father that one way to
work toward reduced supervision was to attend parenting classes and
demonstrate new parenting skills as indicated in the case plan. But Father
continued to oppose parenting classes because he believed they were “ ‘not
normal,’ ” parenting was something “ ‘you are born with or not,’ ” and he had

7
been equipped to parent the minor since birth. In addition, Father had
already attended three parenting sessions and believed he should not have to
take more.
The Department contracted with a private parenting coach and visit
supervisor, Dr. Wanamaker, to work with Father. Father initially balked at
the idea because he thought he had done nothing wrong and was already a
safe and competent parent. He did not begin meeting with Dr. Wanamaker
until October 31, 2022, as part of his weekly supervised visit with the minor,
and had three sessions. Dr. Wanamaker described a very loving relationship
between the minor and Father, and Father was attentive, appropriate, and
engaged during visits.
In recommending the termination of services, the Department asserted
that Father had made only minimal progress on his case plan objectives, was
extremely resistant to services and supports, pushed back on individual
therapy, denied any need for concern about his substance abuse history,
refused to undergo a substance abuse assessment, continued to test positive
for marijuana, had nearly no support network and resented the minor having
one, disputed the need for services that had helped the minor stabilize and
progress, denied any responsibility for the past neglect of the minor, and
displayed a very volatile temper with Department workers and other
providers. The Department therefore believed that Father was unable to
make the progress needed for the minor to be returned to his care even with
an additional six months of services. His efforts to visit the minor
appropriately did not remedy the concerns about his ability to parent,
because Father had been visiting regularly with the minor before his removal
too. The Department explained: “The concern was, and continues to be, that

8
[Father] is unable to identify and address issues that directly impact his son’s
wellbeing.”
2. Department Addendum Report
At the 12-month review hearing in December 2022, the matter was set
for a contested hearing on January 27, 2023. On January 20, 2023, the
Department submitted an addendum report covering developments since its
November 2022 report.
According to the report, Father provided the Department with an email
from the owner of the boat where he was staying on December 7, 2022. The
boatowner asserted that Father had lived on the boat for over a year, paid the
slip fee, and maintained the boat. She also said Father could live there with
the minor. The social worker confirmed this with the boatowner on
December 12, 2022. On January 12, 2023, however, the harbormaster
informed the social worker that “liveaboards” were not permitted and that
Father specifically was not supposed to be aboard the boat more than three
days a week. Father had told the harbormaster that he lived somewhere else
the rest of the week.
Because Father had finally signed a release, the Department was able
to obtain information from Marin County Behavioral Health and Recovery
Services about the mental health assessment Father completed in October
2022. Father had “ ‘declined any mental health concerns at the time of
screening and state[d] that he is only seeking therapy to comply with [the]
court order.’ ” (Italics added.)
Father had also signed a release for the Department to speak with his
individual therapist, Ms. Russell. On December 16, 2022, the therapist
confirmed that Father had attended weekly sessions since November 25,
2022. She noted that Father claimed he had nothing to do with what

9
happened to the minor when the minor lived with Mother, and Father had
issues with the previous social worker, the CASA, and the former caregiver.
The therapist believed a psychological evaluation might be warranted. At a
session with Father that day, however, Father became upset when she
broached the topics of a substance abuse evaluation and possible
psychological evaluation, claiming he was going to hire a civil rights attorney.
On December 9, 2022, Father again refused to undergo a substance
abuse evaluation or include his friends in his support network. In the nine
times he was called for drug testing since the Department’s last report, he
had two “NO SHOWS” and one test was rejected due to damage to the
collection device. Of the six tests that were analyzed, all were positive for
marijuana and one was positive for alcohol. When confronted with the one
positive alcohol result, Father denied drinking alcohol, and a toxicologist
could not confirm that the result was due to alcohol consumption rather than
incidental exposure. As for the two missed tests, Father offered no
explanation. He provided one additional test on January 13, 2023, which was
positive for marijuana.
Since the last report, Father continued visiting the minor, and there
were no safety concerns. He also continued weekly parenting sessions with
the parenting coach, Dr. Wanamaker, to whom he expressed his frustration
with the Department. After the Department recommended termination of
reunification services, Father talked about “ ‘moving on’ ” if he could not
“ ‘have his son.’ ” Dr. Wanamaker invited Father to think about how the
minor might feel and react if Father walked away from him. In the following
session on January 2, 2023, Father continued to talk about his son being
taken from him “ ‘for no reason’ ” and reiterated that he would “ ‘just move
on’ ” if the minor was not going to live with him.

10
The Department continued to recommend that reunification services be
terminated for both parents.
3. 12-Month Contested Hearing
Peasley was the only witness at the contested hearing on January 27,
2023. He testified that the case plan required family therapy to be explored
when deemed appropriate by the minor’s therapist, and before the current
review period, neither the Department nor the minor’s clinician thought it
was appropriate to begin. Peasley added that the minor’s previous therapist
had concerns about Father’s presentation and his ability to control what he
said and be appropriate in a family session. The previous therapist believed
that Father needed individual work. Individual therapy was therefore added
to Father’s case plan at the six-month review and was discussed as a
“prerequisite” to family therapy. As Peasley summarized, Father was not
assessed to have a high enough need to be served by Marin County, so the
Department offered to pay for a private therapist to facilitate therapy
occurring sooner than if he had enrolled in another program. Private therapy
was further delayed by Father’s inaction, his insistence that therapy was
unnecessary, and the difficulty Peasley had in contacting him.2
As for parenting classes, Peasley referred Father to Marin County
Positive Parenting, a weekly virtual class. But Father refused to participate
in the class for a number of reasons until he started to work with Dr.
Wanamaker.
Peasley replaced the previous social worker assigned to the case in
August of 2022. It was uncommon for a social worker to be replaced, but the

2 On cross-examination, Father’s counsel asked if Peasley would agree

it takes time to get Medi-Cal approved, and Peasley responded: “[The
process] goes quicker [when] someone is responsive to requests for forms and
documents and follows through on the dates and times they say they will.”

11
relationship between Father and the previous social worker had become so
tense that the Department believed that changing the social worker might
help move things forward. Father continued to blame the previous worker for
most of the Department’s involvement and spoke of her in very derogatory
terms. He also became upset with Peasley when he asked about engaging in
services. Father was very quick to become angry, yell, and curse, which can
be signs of substance use or intoxication. Although those behaviors could
also be explained by a mental health condition, this possibility could not be
explored due to Father’s lack of cooperation with providers.
After Peasley’s testimony, counsel for Father and counsel for Mother
argued that reasonable services were not provided, services should be
extended to the 18-month date, and there was a substantial probability the
minor could be returned to parental custody with additional services. The
minor’s counsel argued that family therapy was a critical component of the
case plan and, because it did not occur, the services provided to Father were
not reasonable.
4. Juvenile Court’s Order
The juvenile court ruled orally on February 7, 2023, that the minor
could not be returned to either parent, services were reasonable, and services
could not be extended to the 18-month date based on a substantial probability
of return. As to whether services were unreasonable due to the absence of
family therapy, the court stated: “This court can’t find that family therapy
was critical when . . . [F]ather resisted signing up for therapy, even though he
had one-on-one help in doing so, was evasive in his agreement to engage, and,
essentially, delayed the process unnecessarily.”
The juvenile court commended Father for visiting the minor but stated:
“[A]t this point, [F]ather has not demonstrated the skills that can keep [the

12
minor] safe and protected, physically and emotionally. He has been secretive,
aggressive, noncooperative and has not addressed concerns about substance
abuse.” The court therefore terminated reunification services and adopted
the Department’s proposed findings. Father filed a timely appeal.3
II. DISCUSSION
At the 12-month review, the juvenile court shall return a child to the
parent unless it finds that doing so would create a substantial risk of
detriment to the child’s safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-
being. (§ 366.21, subd. (f).) If (as here) the child is not returned, the court
has a few options. One option is to continue the case with additional services,
but only if the court finds “[1] that there is a substantial probability that the
child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian
and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or
[2] that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or
guardian.” Id., subd. (g)(1).)
Father contends the juvenile court erred by denying his request to
continue reunification services because reasonable services were not provided
and there was a substantial probability that the minor could be returned to
his custody with additional services. We disagree.
A. Reasonable Services
The Department is not required to provide perfect reunification
services. (In re Alvin R. (2003) 108 Cal.App.4th 962, 972 (Alvin R.).) It need

3 Mother appealed as well. In her opening brief, she joined in Father’s
arguments “for the purpose of acquiring a reversal of the order terminating
reunification services and finding reasonable services had been provided to
[F]ather.” (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.200(a)(5).) She has not asserted error
as to any findings pertaining to the reasonableness of services she received or
the likelihood of the minor’s return to her care.

13
only make a reasonable effort to provide services that identify the problems
leading to loss of custody and to help remedy those problems. (In re Riva M.
(1991) 235 Cal.App.3d 403, 414.) We review the juvenile court’s ruling for
substantial evidence. (In re Misako R. (1991) 2 Cal.App.4th 538, 545.)4
Here, the problems leading to removal — and the reasons for not
placing the minor with Father initially — centered around inadequate
housing, lack of a support network, and issues regarding substance abuse.
To address these problems, the Department created a court-approved case
plan requiring Father to have safe and appropriate housing for the minor,
maintain a support network that could help him care for the minor, and show
that his home was free from substance abuse by submitting to drug testing
and undergoing a substance abuse assessment. The case plan also required
Father to take parenting classes, engage in individual counseling, and
participate in family therapy when deemed appropriate.
To help Father remedy the problems leading to removal and comply
with his case plan, the Department asked Father about his housing and
whether the minor could live there (efforts Father largely rebuffed), offered to
help him build a support network, reached out to a paternal aunt despite
Father’s refusal to provide information about his relatives, referred Father
for a substance abuse assessment, referred Father for substance testing,
referred Father to a parenting program and contacted the facilitator to verify
his participation, provided Father with a parenting coach, provided Father
with access to the mental health evaluation provider, made therapy referrals,
contacted the Marin County eligibility office regarding Father’s Medi-Cal

4 Father contends we should disregard the Department’s arguments

because its factual assertions are not supported by citation to the record. The
record citations for the facts on which we rely are contained in the
Department’s statement of facts.

14
application, and offered Department-paid individual therapy when county
services were unavailable. The Department also held monthly CFT
meetings, provided transportation assistance, coordinated and funded
professional supervision for visits, and communicated with Father to monitor
and discuss reunification services and review case plan activities,
notwithstanding difficulties in reaching Father and Father’s volatile
behavior. Substantial evidence supports the conclusion that the Department
provided reasonable services.
Father’s arguments to the contrary are unavailing. He contends the
Department delayed his access to individual therapy and a parenting coach,
noting that individual therapy was not ordered until September 1, 2022, and
did not begin until November 25, 2023. But there is substantial evidence
that Father contributed to the delays by not timely submitting paperwork for
Medi-Cal and for therapy, claiming to the mental health evaluator that he
had no mental health issues (which precluded county services), delaying
signing a release for the Department to discuss with the evaluator why
county services were denied, and initially resisting a parenting coach. It is
not our role to reweigh the evidence.
Father’s reliance on Alvin R., supra, 108 Cal.App.4th 962 is misplaced.
In Alvin R., the Department was entirely responsible for a delay in arranging
therapy for the minor as a precursor to joint counseling and failed to obey a
court order to arrange for family therapy. Here, by contrast, the Department
arranged for the minor’s therapy, and Father substantially contributed to the
delay in obtaining individual therapy and a parenting coach.
Father also argues that reasonable services were not provided because
the Department did not provide family therapy. However, the case plan
specified that family therapy would occur only when deemed appropriate, and

15
there was no evidence the minor’s therapist had reached this conclusion. The
minor’s therapist allowed Father to participate in one phone session with the
minor but noted that Father’s conduct was minimally inappropriate.
Father next complains that there was a delay in providing
unsupervised visitation. He relies primarily on Tracy J. v. Superior Court
(2012) 202 Cal.App.4th 1415, 1427 (Tracy J.), which stated: “When the
Agency limits visitation in the absence of evidence showing the parents’
behavior has jeopardized or will jeopardize the child’s safety, it unreasonably
forecloses family reunification on the basis of the parents’ labeled diagnoses
and does not constitute reasonable services.” In Tracy J., the agency had
restricted visitation for the parents, notwithstanding their demonstrated
ability to care for the child, merely because they had developmental
disabilities. Here, by contrast, Father’s visitation remained supervised
because Father had not addressed the safety concerns that had led the
juvenile court to increase supervision for visits at the six-month hearing.
Among other things, concerns remained over how Father spoke to the minor
about the first social worker and resource parent.
Lastly, Father argues that the Department did not provide housing
assistance. There is ample evidence, however, that Father did not seek
housing assistance, represented that his current housing was adequate, and
refused to provide details in response to the Department’s efforts to better
understand his living situation. It turned out that, contrary to his
representations, Father was not permitted to live on the boat full time with
the minor, but the Department did not discover this until shortly before the
end of the review period, due at least in part to Father’s misinformation.
In sum, while Father points to evidence that he believes supports his
position, he does not show that there was a lack of substantial evidence

16
supporting the juvenile court’s finding of reasonable services.
B. Substantial Probability of Return
Father contends that services should have been extended because
“there [was] a substantial probability that the child [would] be returned to
the physical custody of the parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in
the home within the extended period of time . . . .” (§ 366.21, subd (g).) We
disagree.
To find a “substantial probability” of return, the juvenile court must
find three elements: “(A) That the parent or legal guardian has consistently
and regularly contacted and visited with the child. [¶] (B) That the parent or
legal guardian has made significant progress in resolving problems that led
to the child’s removal from the home. [¶] [And] (C) [that] [t]he parent or
legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity and ability both to complete
the objectives of their treatment plan and to provide for the child’s safety,
protection, physical and emotional well-being, and special needs.” (§ 366.21,
subd. (g).)
There is no dispute that Father satisfactorily visited the minor. The
question, therefore, is whether substantial evidence supports the juvenile
court’s conclusion that the other two elements were not established. It does.
1. Progress in Resolving Problems Leading to Removal
Substantial evidence supports the conclusion that Father made little or
no progress in resolving the problems that led to removal. He never obtained
adequate housing, since the harbormaster stated he was not permitted to
stay all week on the boat, let alone with the minor. While he claims his
housing is still sufficient because he has stayed on the boat for a while
without the rules being enforced against him, the fact is that he has no
authorized housing and risks eviction. Father also did not disclose any

17
information regarding a support network. More notably, he never completed
a substance abuse assessment. The results of his drug tests were
consistently positive for marijuana and at least one test detected alcohol.
Although the marijuana levels were not high and Father denied consuming
alcohol, it was reasonable to conclude that he had made little progress given
his unexplained missed tests, his history of DUIs, his refusal to see why the
Department would be concerned about those DUIs, and his continuing refusal
to complete a substance abuse assessment. Father did begin individual
counseling and parenting classes during the most recent review period, but it
did not appear to result in significant behavioral change.
Father argues that the minor’s mental health has substantially
improved since the start of the case. But this is the minor’s progress, not
Father’s, and it supports the conclusion that the minor should stay at the
STRTP (or other appropriate facility) rather than be returned to Father. At
the STRTP, the minor receives services and treatment needed to address his
mental health struggles. Father does not point to evidence that his actions
helped the minor improve. He never even acknowledged that the minor has
significant mental health issues, claiming instead that the minor’s only
problem was being separated from Father.
2. Capacity and Ability to Complete the Plan
Given Father’s lack of progress over the past 12 months, and his
continuing resistance to the Department’s offers of services and refusal to
acknowledge that the minor has significant mental health issues, it was
reasonable to conclude that Father had not demonstrated the capacity and
ability to complete the objectives of the case plan and provide for the minor’s
safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being, and needs. To put it
another way, there was substantial evidence that, even with additional

18
services, there would remain a substantial risk of detriment to the minor if
returned to Father’s physical custody at the 18-month review.
The juvenile court’s findings and order were supported by substantial
evidence.
III. DISPOSITION
The order is affirmed.

CHOU, J.

We concur.

SIMONS, Acting P. J.

BURNS, J.

19

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.