Bonta v. Super. Ct.

CourtListener 10045023CalctappAug 13, 2024

Full text

Filed 8/13/24
CERTIFIED FOR PARTIAL PUBLICATION*

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Sacramento)
----

ROB BONTA, as Attorney General, etc.,
C101764
Petitioner,
(Super. Ct. No. 24WM000115)
v.

THE SUPERIOR COURT OF SACRAMENTO
COUNTY,

Respondent;

JON COUPAL et al.,

Real Parties in Interest.

ORIGINAL PROCEEDING in mandate. Stay issued. Petition granted.
Shelleyanne W.L. Chang, Judge.

Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Thomas S. Patterson, Assistant Attorney General,
Benjamin M. Glickman and Megan A.S. Richards, Deputy Attorneys General, for
Petitioner.

* Pursuant to California Rules of Court, rule 8.1110, this opinion is certified for
publication with the exception of part IV of the Factual and Procedural Background and
part I of the Discussion.

1
No Appearance for Respondent.

Bell, McAndrews & Hiltachk, Thomas W. Hiltachk, Paul Gough; and Laura
Dougherty for Real Parties in Interest Jon Coupal and Howard Jarvis Taxpayers
Association.

Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Thomas S. Patterson, Assistant Attorney General,
Benjamin M. Glickman and Megan A. S. Richards, Deputy Attorneys General, for Real
Parties in Interest Shirley N. Weber, as Secretary of State, and the Office of State
Printing.1

Petitioner the Attorney General of the State of California drafted language for the
ballot title and summary and ballot label for Proposition 5, a proposed amendment by the
Legislature to the California Constitution that would allow passage of certain local bonds
by 55 percent voter approval rather than the current two-thirds margin. Real parties in
interest Jon Coupal and Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association brought a petition for writ
of mandate in the superior court that did not challenge the ballot title and summary, but
instead challenged the ballot label, which states in pertinent part that Proposition 5
“[a]llows approval of local infrastructure and housing bonds for low- and middle-income
Californians with 55% vote.”2 Real parties claimed the ballot label is misleading and
prejudicial in that it does not accurately describe the character and purpose of the
amendment because it does not specify that current law requires approval by two-thirds
of voters. Respondent court agreed, expressing the opinion that the ballot label failes “to

1 The Office of State Printing (State Printer) is also referred to as the Office of State
Publishing. (See Gov. Code, § 14850.) This real party in interest was referred to as the
Office of the State Printer in the filed petition.
2 Other real parties in interest are the Secretary of State and State Printer, which
take no position on the merits here. Subsequent references to “real parties” are to Jon
Coupal and the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association, except where noted.

2
inform the voters of the chief purpose of Proposition 5.” Consequently, respondent court
granted relief in mandate and entered an order and judgment that directs the Attorney
General to revise the ballot label and include additional language. By way of mandate
filed in this court, the Attorney General challenges that decision.
We conclude that the language for the ballot label, which incorporates a
“condensed version of the ballot title and summary,” concisely and accurately describes
Proposition 5 in terms that are not misleading. (Elec. Code,3 § 9051, subd. (b)(1).)
Moreover, respondent court failed to accord the discretion due to the Attorney General in
drafting ballot materials, including the ballot label. Accordingly, we shall issue a
peremptory writ of mandate directing respondent court to deny real parties’ petition for
writ of mandate and thereby allow the Attorney General’s originally drafted language for
the ballot label to be used in ballot materials.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
I
Proposition 5
Since the adoption of Proposition 13 following its passage in 1978, local bonds
and taxes to support those bonds generally must be approved by a two-thirds vote of the
electorate. (Cal. Const., Art. XIII A, § 1, subd. (b)(2); Cumero v. Public Employment
Relations Bd. (1989) 49 Cal.3d 575, 592; Foothill-De Anza Community College Dist. v.
Emerich (2007) 158 Cal.App.4th 11, 16.) However, there are exceptions. Following the
passage of Proposition 39 in 2000, approval of school bonds requires only 55 percent
voter approval. (Prop. 39, § 4, as approved by voters, Gen. Elec. (Nov. 7, 2000); Cal.
Const., Art. XIII A, § 1, subd. (b)(3); Foothill-De Anza Community College Dist., at
p. 16.) Proposition 5 would similarly amend the Constitution to permit bonds for public

3 Undesignated statutory references are to the Elections Code.

3
infrastructure and affordable housing with 55 percent voter approval. (Assem. Const.
Amend. No. 10, Stats. 2024 (2023-2024 Reg. Sess.) res. ch. 134, amending Assem.
Const. Amend. No. 1, Stats. 2023 (2023-2024 Reg. Sess.) res. ch. 173.)
II
Title And Summary And Ballot Label
Pursuant to his statutory obligation, the Attorney General was tasked with
preparing and submitting to the Secretary of State a title and summary for the measure,
which included the Legislative Analyst’s statement of the fiscal impact of the measure.
(§§ 9050, 9051.) The title and summary “shall not exceed 100 words, not including the
fiscal impact statement.” (§ 9051, subd. (a)(1).) Excluding the fiscal impact statement,
the title and summary the Attorney General drafted for Proposition 5 states:
“ALLOWS LOCAL BONDS FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND
PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE WITH 55% VOTER APPROVAL. LEGISLATIVE
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT.
“Allows local bonds for affordable housing for low- and middle-income
Californians, or for public infrastructure including roads, water, and fire protection to be
approved by 55% of voters, rather than current two-thirds approval requirement.
“Bonds must include specified accountability requirements, including citizens
oversight committee and annual independent financial and performance audits.
“Allows local governments to assess property taxes above 1% to repay affordable
housing and infrastructure bonds if approved by 55% of voters instead of current two-
thirds approval requirement.” (Bullets omitted.)
The Attorney General was further tasked with preparing a ballot label not to
exceed 75 words, which must be “a condensed version of the ballot title and summary
including the financial impact summary.” (§ 9051, subd. (b)(1), italics added; see also
§ 303, subd. (b).) Here, the Attorney General presented evidence he received the
Legislative Analyst’s materials for Proposition 5 as well as other ballot measures on

4
July 5, 2024, the same day the Attorney General’s materials were due to the Secretary of
State to be provided for public comment. It was thus necessary to account for the
Legislative Analyst’s contribution to the ballot label. The complete ballot label
submitted by the Attorney General to the Secretary of State, including the Legislative
Analyst’s fiscal impact summary, contains the following language:
“ALLOWS LOCAL BONDS FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND
PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE WITH 55% VOTER APPROVAL. LEGISLATIVE
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT. Allows approval of local infrastructure and
housing bonds for low- and middle-income Californians with 55% vote. Accountability
requirements. Fiscal Impact: Increased local borrowing to fund affordable housing,
supportive housing, and public infrastructure. The amount would depend on decisions by
local governments and voters. Borrowing would be repaid with higher property taxes.”
Counting the words “fiscal impact” as part of the label and considering the phrase
“low- and middle-income” as four words, the ballot label amounts to some 68 words,
including 35 words in the portion drafted by the Attorney General. (Capitalization &
boldface omitted.) Real parties and respondent court described the label as originally
drafted as containing 65 words, which may reflect a different counting of this language.
III
Proceedings In Respondent Court
Real parties filed a petition for writ of mandate in the superior court on August 1,
2024, challenging the ballot label on the ground that it failed to accurately describe the
measure’s real purpose, to reduce the voter approval requirement from two-thirds to 55
percent, and that it thereby misled voters by withholding “ ‘vital information’ ” with no
“valid reason” for doing so “since the word limit for the ballot label is not an impediment
to providing such information.” Real parties reasoned that this was easily remedied by
changing the label to refer to the “current two-thirds approval requirement.” (Boldface &
underscoring omitted.)

5
Respondent court set the matter for hearing at 1:30 p.m. on August 9, 2024, and
provided its tentative decision the day before the hearing. The parties agreed to submit
the matter without a hearing to facilitate appellate review, and the Attorney General
drafted a proposed final order and judgment that was approved by both parties as to form
and signed by the court on August 9. Respondent court found “no fault” with the
Attorney General not modifying his own language upon receipt of the Legislative
Analyst’s language for the label given that the materials were due to the Secretary of
State. But the court reasoned the language “would mislead the voters absent use of
additional clarifying language, which additional language is available within the 75-word
limit.” Respondent court concluded that the original language “fails to inform the
electorate of the character and purpose of the measure.”4 Respondent court directed the
Attorney General to change the sentence stating Proposition 5 allows approval of the
bonds “with 55% vote” to instead read “with 55% voter approval, rather than current
two-thirds approval requirement.” (Underscoring omitted.)
Immediately following entry of respondent court’s written order and judgment on
August 9, the Attorney General filed the current petition for writ of mandate in this court.
The same day, this court issued a temporary stay and advised the parties that we were
considering issuing a peremptory writ in the first instance and that “[a]ny opposition or
further opposition [wa]s to be filed on or before 12:00 p.m. on August 12, 2024.” (See
Palma v. U.S. Industrial Fasteners, Inc. (1984) 36 Cal.3d 171.)

4 Respondent court found real party Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association lacked
standing to appear as a petitioner pursuant to section 13314 but found the issue not
dispositive given real party Coupal had standing.

6
IV
State Printer
In the current petition to this court, petitioner explains that real parties, the
Secretary of State and State Printer, requested a ruling by 5:00 p.m. on August 12, 2024.
This is consistent with Assistant State Printer Norma Kreider’s declaration, which was
provided to the superior court, that the final text for the voter information guide must be
delivered by that time to allow adequate time for preparation and mailing. Kreider
declared: “[State Printer] will require 55 working days to complete the printing of the
current state voter information guide and mailing by both the [State Printer] and a private
vendor under contract with the Secretary of State. This 55-day schedule assumes
operation of the printing plant 24 hours per day, 6 days per week between August 12,
2024, and October 26, 2024, reserving the seventh day each week to address mechanical
problems as necessary and to make up for any time lost in the printing processes as a
result of such problems.” The majority of voter information guides must be mailed by
October 15, 2024, which is 21 days before the November 5 election. (§ 9094, subd. (a).)
DISCUSSION
I
Timeliness And Remedy
Remedy by appeal is inadequate considering the very short timeframe that remains
available to revise the ballot materials. (See Lungren v. Superior Court (1996)
48 Cal.App.4th 435, 438; Andal v. Miller (1994) 28 Cal.App.4th 358, 360-361.)
However, we conclude there is sufficient time to act on the current petition, considering
the issues raised and procedural context. The petition was filed immediately following
respondent court’s ruling and within the public examination period, which in this case
commenced exactly 20 days before the Secretary of State planned to send the ballot
materials to the State Printer. (See Elec. Code, § 9092; Gov. Code, § 88006.)

7
By statute, a peremptory writ of mandate may issue only if “issuance of the writ
will not substantially interfere with the printing and distribution of the state voter
information guide” or “ballot pamphlet” as required by law.” (Elec. Code, § 9092 [state
voter information guide]; Gov. Code, § 88006 [ballot pamphlet].) Considering the
assistant state printer’s declaration, and the fact that this court’s temporary stay was only
with respect to the ballot label for Proposition 5, the minimal delay of one day past
August 12, 2024, occasioned by the temporary stay will not substantially interfere with
the timely printing and distribution of ballot materials.
II
Merits
The Elections Code requires the Attorney General to prepare a ballot title and
summary that “give[s] a true and impartial statement of the purpose of the measure in
such language that the ballot title and summary shall neither be an argument, nor be
likely to create prejudice, for or against the proposed measure.” (§ 9051, subd. (e); see
§ 9050.) These materials “must reasonably inform the voters of the character and
purpose of the proposed measure” while avoiding “ ‘misleading the public with
inaccurate information.’ ” (Yes on 25, Citizens for an On-Time Budget v. Superior Court
(2010) 189 Cal.App.4th 1445, 1452.) “In preparing the ballot title and summary and the
ballot label, the Attorney General is afforded considerable latitude.” (Ibid.) The
Attorney General must exercise “judgment and discretion in discerning the chief
purposes and points of an initiative measure” and must present this information “in clear
and understandable language.” (Ibid.) A reviewing court must indulge all legitimate
presumptions favoring the propriety of the Attorney General’s actions when reviewing
ballot materials he is tasked with drafting. (Id. at pp. 1452-1453.) Further, while the
Elections Code expressly allows a challenge to be made concerning ballot materials, “[a]
peremptory writ of mandate shall issue only upon clear and convincing proof that the

8
copy in question is false, misleading, or inconsistent with the requirements of this code or
Chapter 8.” (Elec. Code, § 9092; see also Gov. Code, § 88006.)
Real parties do not dispute that the title and summary describe the purpose of the
measure in an accurate and nonprejudicial fashion. In fact, they emphasize the ballot
summary includes express reference to changing the existing two-thirds voting
requirement for passage of the local bonds affected by the measure. But real parties
argue, and respondent court agreed, that similar language must be included in the ballot
label to avoid misleading voters. That is despite the fact that the ballot label clearly states
that Proposition 5 will allow local bonds with 55 percent voter approval, which is what it
in fact proposes.
Not only is the language in the ballot label factually accurate, but we fail to
perceive how a voter would not correctly construe the purpose or the proposition even if
only reading the ballot label in isolation. As drafted, the ballot language unequivocally
states that Proposition 5 “allows” approval of local bonds for infrastructure and housing
with 55 percent of votes and that there are “[a]ccountability requirements.” And
immediately following this is the Legislative Analyst’s language indicating Proposition 5
would increase “local borrowing” that would be “repaid with higher property taxes.” We
do not agree that voters only reading this language would believe they were doing
anything other than relaxing the rules for authorizing such bonds. Real parties dismiss
these points as a “trail of breadcrumbs” that does not inform the electorate of the chief
purpose and point of Proposition 5. We disagree. What Proposition 5 would itself
effectuate is couched in concise language that is easy to understand.
The fact that real parties challenged the ballot label in isolation from the title and
summary points to an even more fundamental weakness in their argument. In
considering a challenge to the title and summary, this court has emphasized that they
should be read together as a whole and, in so doing, found a title was not likely to create
confusion because of language found in the summary. (Becerra v. Superior Court (2017)

9
19 Cal.App.5th 967, 977-978.) While the ballot label is undoubtedly prominent in the
voter information materials, the fact the title and summary here contain the information
that real parties want included in the label substantially diminishes the force of their
argument that there is a danger voters will be misled. Real parties presented no evidence
establishing voters will be misled by the ballot materials at issue or that these materials
are inconsistent with the Elections Code, much less evidence necessary to support a clear
and convincing evidence finding by the trial court. (See § 9092; Conservatorship of O.B.
(2020) 9 Cal.5th 989, 1011-1012 [appellate review of a clear and convincing evidence
finding requires “substantial evidence from which a reasonable fact finder could
[conclude] it is highly probable that” a fact is true].) The “ ‘chief purpose and points’ ”
requirement for the title and summary provision requires no more than substantial
compliance by the Attorney General, with a presumption the documents the Attorney
General prepared are accurate. (Becerra, at p. 975, quoting Amador Valley Joint Union
High Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Equalization (1978) 22 Cal.3d 208, 243.) If anything,
there must be more latitude accorded the Attorney General when exercising discretion to
draft the “condensed version” contained in the ballot label. (§§ 303, 9051, subd. (b)(1).)
Moreover, the Attorney General was operating under the additional constraint that, unlike
the 100-word maximum for the title and summary, the 75-word maximum for the ballot
label must account for the Legislative Analyst’s fiscal impact summary. (Compare
§ 9051, subds. (a)(1) & (b)(1).)
Real parties nevertheless argue this court should accept respondent court’s
decision because the revised ballot label language adopted by respondent court includes
the “exact same words found in the title and summary prepared by the Attorney General.”
Real parties also emphasize the fact that the Attorney General prepared the proposed
order and judgment effectuating respondent court’s tentative decision, suggesting that is
somehow significant to our analysis. It is not. Likewise, the fact that the ballot label
originally drafted did not ultimately contain more of the 75 available words is of no

10
consequence. The fact that the Attorney General included language in the title and
summary that is omitted in the ballot label is entirely consistent with his discretion and
the statutory requirement that the label be a “condensed version of the ballot title and
summary.” (§§ 303, subd. (b); 9051, subd. (b)(1).)

11
DISPOSITION
Having complied with the procedural requirements for issuance of a peremptory
writ in the first instance, we are authorized to issue the writ forthwith and without oral
argument. (See Brown, Winfield & Canzoneri, Inc. v. Superior Court (2010) 47 Cal.4th
1233, 1243-1244; Palma v. U.S. Industrial Fasteners, Inc., supra, 36 Cal.3d 171.) Let a
peremptory writ of mandate issue vacating respondent court’s August 9, 2024 order and
judgment for peremptory writ of mandate and entering a new and different decision
denying real parties’ mandate petition.
This decision is final forthwith as to this court. (See Cal. Rules of Court, rule
8.490(b)(2)(A).) The temporary stay order issued by this court on August 9, 2024, which
in part directed the State Printer not to use or begin preparation of ballot materials
concerning the ballot label for Proposition 5, is vacated. Respondent court’s order and
judgment of August 9, 2024, directing the Attorney General to make changes to the ballot
label for Proposition 5 is stayed pending finality of this decision for purposes of review.
The parties shall bear their own costs. (See Cal. Rules of Court, rule
8.493(a)(1)(B).)

/s/
ROBIE, Acting P. J.

We concur:

/s/
DUARTE, J.

/s/
RENNER, J.

12

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.