Towell v. Move CA2/5

CourtListener 10013317CalctappJul 24, 2024

Full text

Filed 7/24/24 Towell v. Move CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

SELENA TOWELL, B324868 c/w B324885

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. Nos.
v. 22STCV13224,
22STCV13353)
MOVE, INC., et al.,

Defendants and Appellants.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Carolyn B. Kuhl and Gail Killefer, Judges. Affirmed.
Mitchell Silberberg & Knupp, Adam Levin and Corey G.
Singer for Defendant and Appellants.
Berenji Law Firm, Shadie L. Berenji and Kristopher N.
Tayyeb for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_________________
In consolidated appeals, defendants and appellants Move,
Inc., Move Sales, Inc., and News Corporate Services, Inc.,
(collectively Move) appeal from orders denying motions to compel
arbitration entered in favor of plaintiff and respondent Selena
Towell in two employment-related actions. On appeal, Move
contends that Towell impliedly consented to an arbitration
agreement in the employee handbook because after receiving an
email about revisions to the handbook, she remained employed
with the company. We conclude substantial evidence supports
the trial courts’ findings that Towell did not have notice of the
arbitration agreement, because the employer’s email did not
mention arbitration, and when Towell took medical leave before
the deadline to review the handbook, she no longer had access to
the email system or the handbook. Therefore, we affirm.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

Employment with Move

Move hired Towell as a sales consultant associate in
January 2021. Towell acknowledged reading a copy of the
employee handbook, which did not contain an arbitration
agreement.
On May 20, 2021, Move employee Kat Koutsantonis sent an
email to all employees with the subject line “Check Out Our
Updated Employee Handbook and Confirm You’ve Reviewed It[.]”
The email mentioned that the handbook contained new and
updated policies, including policies for paid holidays, paid time
off, and bereavement leave. The email contained a hyperlink to

2
the full handbook and noted that the handbook was available on
the company’s intranet. The email stated that employees would
receive another email later that day from the online training
platform with directions to acknowledge that they had received,
read, and understood the updated handbook. Employees were
required to complete the acknowledgement by May 27, 2021.
The email system shows that Koutsantonis’s May 20, 2021
email was delivered to Towell’s email account that same day and
marked “opened and read.” There is no evidence, however,
whether the email program automatically advanced messages,
such that if Towell deleted a message, the program would
automatically advance to the next message and mark it as read.
Towell declared that she did not see the message about the
revised handbook.
Move assigned a course on the training platform for
employees to review and acknowledge receipt of the handbook. A
notification to complete the course was posted within the training
platform, but no email with directions was sent to employees.
On May 26, 2021, one day before the company’s deadline to
provide written acknowledgement of the revised handbook,
Towell began a medical leave of absence. When Towell’s medical
leave began, Move revoked access to her employee email account
and the training platform. She was still on leave when Move
terminated her employment on December 14, 2021.

The Revised Handbook

A disclaimer at the beginning of the revised handbook
stated in pertinent part: “This Employee Handbook (the
‘Handbook’) is provided so that you may familiarize yourself with

3
. . . our employment-related practices and policies. . . . [¶] Except
for the Company’s At-Will Employment Policy applicable to its
US employees only, this Handbook is not, nor should it be
considered to be, an agreement or contract of employment,
express or implied, or a promise of treatment in any particular
manner in any given situation. This Handbook states only
general Company guidelines. Any guidelines particular to the
state in which you[r] work can be found on the Human Resources
Knowledge Nook. You are required to comply with the practices
and policies set out in this Handbook and on the Knowledge Nook
as a condition of your employment with the Company, and failure
to do so may lead to disciplinary action up to and including
termination of employment for cause.”
The revised handbook included an arbitration agreement.
One provision of the arbitration policy stated, “This Mutual
Agreement to Arbitrate policy is a condition of every employee’s
ongoing employment and shall be binding on every Employee
upon receipt, whether or not the Employee signs an
acknowledgement of receipt of the Handbook containing this
policy. By continuing your employment after receipt of this
policy, you are acknowledging your agreement to arbitrate all
Claims in accordance with this policy.”
The final page of the handbook had lines for an employee’s
signature to acknowledge receipt of the handbook and agreement
to be bound by the policies as a condition of employment. The
acknowledgement included the statement, “I agree to final and
binding arbitration of any and all disputes related to my
employment with the Company, as stated in the policy entitled
‘Mutual Agreement to Arbitrate.’ ”

4
Litigation

On April 20, 2022, Towell filed a complaint against Move
for claims related to disability discrimination (the discrimination
action), which was ultimately assigned to the Honorable Gail
Killefer. The following day, Towell filed a separate action against
Move on behalf of herself and similarly situated employees for
wage and hour violations (the class action), which was assigned
to the Honorable Carolyn Kuhl.
Move filed substantially similar motions to compel
arbitration in both actions on the ground that Towell agreed to
arbitrate because after receiving and opening the email about the
revised handbook, she remained employed for several months.
Towell opposed each motion on the grounds that no
arbitration agreement was formed, the arbitration policy was
void due to fraud in the execution, and the arbitration policy was
unenforceable because it was unconscionable. Towell argued that
there was no arbitration agreement, because she had not seen the
email or the arbitration policy contained in the handbook before
Move filed motions to compel arbitration. The email about the
handbook did not mention arbitration and did not attach a copy
of the handbook or the arbitration policy. She never signed or
acknowledged the handbook or the arbitration policy.
Towell submitted her declaration in support of the
oppositions. She declared, “I have never seen the May 20, 2021
email . . . .” attached to Move’s motions to compel arbitration.
Move never notified her that she had to arbitrate employment
claims if she continued her employment. Towell never signed or
acknowledged the handbook or arbitration policy. She added, “I
have never clicked on a hyperlink that led me to Move’s

5
Handbook, and I did not log into Move’s online portal and read
the Handbook.”
Towell declared, “As of May 20, 2021, I was afflicted with a
serious mental health condition that prevented me from being
able to work. As a consequence of my mental condition, my
healthcare provider placed me off work as of May 26, 2021. I
remained on medical leave until Move wrongfully terminated my
employment on December 13, 2021. [¶] . . . At the time I
commenced my medical leave, I had never received the Email or
Handbook. After I commenced my medical leave, Move blocked
my access to my employee email account and the online employee
portal. Therefore, after May 26, 2021, I was unable to access any
of my work emails or any employee documents that were in the
employee portal.”
In replies, Move argued that Towell impliedly consented to
the arbitration agreement because she received the email with
the link to the revised handbook and continued working for Move.
Move argued that the email did not have to explicitly advise
Towell of the arbitration agreement, and Towell was not required
to have clicked on the hyperlink to have accepted the contents.
In fact, Towell was not even required to have seen the email
because an employee may not avoid an arbitration agreement
imposed as a condition of employment by remaining willfully or
negligently ignorant of the policy. By notifying an employee that
the employee will be subject to arbitration, continued
employment constitutes acceptance of implied-in-fact arbitration
agreement regardless of whether the employee retrieves the
agreement. In addition, there was no factual support for fraud,
and the agreement was not unconscionable. Move also filed
objections to Towell’s declaration.

6
In the discrimination action, Judge Killefer issued a
tentative ruling that would grant the motion to compel
arbitration, but after a hearing on October 20, 2022, took the
matter under submission.
In the class action, Judge Kuhl held a hearing on the
motion to compel arbitration on October 24, 2022. Later that
day, the Judge Kuhl ruled that there was no arbitration
agreement between the parties and denied the motion to compel
arbitration. The company’s email did not expressly mention
arbitration or suggest that the handbook contained any binding
contract language. Although the email stated that employees
would receive an email from the online training platform, there
was no evidence that a second email was sent. The court noted
the factual dispute between the parties about whether Towell
received the email that was sent, but it was undisputed that
Towell did not start the training or complete an
acknowledgement of receipt of the handbook. After Towell failed
to complete the course or complete the acknowledgement of
receipt of the handbook, there was no evidence that Move
informed her that continued employment constituted acceptance
of an arbitration agreement. Towell stated she was afflicted with
a serious mental health condition on May 20, 2021, and it was
undisputed that she took medical leave beginning on May 26,
2021, one day before the acknowledgement had been requested.
The court also noted that the first page of the handbook could be
read to state that it does not create a contract between the
employee and Move.
Given the facts, Judge Kuhl could not find that the parties
entered into an agreement to arbitrate. There was no evidence
that Towell signed an arbitration agreement or provided explicit

7
assent to an arbitration policy, and more importantly, there was
no evidence she was sufficiently notified of any arbitration policy.
The email contained no mention of an arbitration policy, let alone
that Towell’s future employment was conditioned on an
agreement to arbitrate. The email did not state that receipt of
the email constituted acceptance of any agreement found in the
handbook. In addition, the email specifically stated that
employees would receive a separate email from the online
training platform with details about how to acknowledge receipt
and understanding of the handbook, with a deadline by May 27,
2021. The fact that Move required a course and sought a written
acknowledgement of the handbook terms showed that mere
receipt did not constitute acknowledgement of the handbook.
On November 8, 2022, in the discrimination action, Judge
Killefer denied the motion to compel arbitration in that case
based on the same reasoning as the class action court. The court
in the discrimination action sustained objections to the following
statements from Towell’s declaration on the basis that they were
inadmissible legal conclusions: Move never notified her that she
would waive her right to file a lawsuit by continuing her
employment; Move never provided her with the handbook or the
arbitration agreement; she was afflicted with a serious mental
health condition that prevented her from being able to work as of
May 20, 2021; and she remained on medical leave until Move
wrongfully terminated her employment on December 13, 2021.
Move timely appealed from the two orders denying the
motions to compel arbitration. The parties subsequently filed a
joint motion to consolidate the appeals, which this appellate court
granted on February 16, 2023.

8
DISCUSSION

Standard of Review

In ruling on a motion to compel arbitration, the trial court
determines the facts. (Fleming v. Oliphant Financial, LLC
(2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 13, 18 (Fleming).) Where the material
facts are undisputed, we review the order de novo. (Ibid; Diaz v.
Sohnen Enterprises (2019) 34 Cal.App.5th 126, 129 (Diaz).) If the
facts are in dispute, however, we review the record to evaluate
whether substantial evidence supports the trial court’s order.
(Fleming, supra, 88 Cal.App.5th at p.18.) “ ‘Under the deferential
substantial evidence standard of review, findings of fact are
liberally construed to support the judgment or order and we
consider the evidence in the light most favorable to the prevailing
party, drawing all reasonable inferences in support of the
findings. [Citation.] “A single witness’s testimony may
constitute substantial evidence to support a finding. [Citation.]
It is not our role as a reviewing court to reweigh the evidence or
to assess witness credibility. [Citation.] ‘A judgment or order of
a lower court is presumed to be correct on appeal, and all
intendments and presumptions are indulged in favor of its
correctness.’ ” [Citation.]’ [Citation.]” (Bruno v. Hopkins (2022)
79 Cal.App.5th 801, 823.)

No Implied Consent to Arbitration Agreement

Move concedes that Towell did not expressly agree to
arbitration. Instead, Move contends Towell impliedly consented
to arbitration by continuing to work for Move after receiving the

9
email message about the revised handbook, which contained an
arbitration agreement. We conclude the trial courts’ finding1
that Towell did not consent to the arbitration agreement is
supported by substantial evidence.
“There is a strong public policy favoring contractual
arbitration, but that policy does not extend to parties who have
not agreed to arbitrate.” (Esparza v. Sand & Sea, Inc. (2016) 2
Cal.App.5th 781, 787 (Esparza).) General contract law principles
determine whether the parties have agreed to arbitration, and
mutual assent is an essential element. (Id. at pp. 787–788.) A
party’s agreement to arbitrate may be express, such as by signing
the agreement, or implied-in-fact, such as when an employee’s
continued employment constitutes acceptance of the proposed
agreement. (Pinnacle Museum Tower Assn. v. Pinnacle Market
Development (US), LLC (2012) 55 Cal.4th 223, 236 (Pinnacle);
Craig v. Brown & Root, Inc. (2000) 84 Cal.App.4th 416, 420
(Craig).)
When an employer notifies an employee that an arbitration
agreement is a condition of employment and the employee
continues to work for the company, the employee has impliedly
consented to the arbitration agreement. (Diaz, supra, 34
Cal.App.5th at p. 130.) “An arbitration clause within a contract
may be binding on a party even if the party never actually read
the clause.” (Pinnacle, supra, 55 Cal.4th at p. 236.) “The fact
that defendant either chose not to read or take the time to

1 The rulings of the two trial court judges at issue in this
consolidated appeal are substantially similar on the issues we
discuss below. Accordingly, we refer to a single “finding” that
was made by each trial court.

10
understand these provisions is legally irrelevant.” (Harris v. TAP
Worldwide, LLC (2016) 248 Cal.App.4th 373, 383 (Harris).)
In this case, substantial evidence supports the trial courts’
finding that Towell did not impliedly consent to Move’s
arbitration agreement. Move sent an email to all employees
about a revised handbook that described some of the changes in
the handbook, but did not mention a new arbitration policy. The
email itself did not provide any notification that employees were
agreeing to arbitrate employment disputes by continuing to work
for the company. The handbook was not provided as an
attachment to the email. Instead, a portion of the email
contained a hyperlink to the handbook or the employee could find
the document on the company’s internal website. The email
stated, however, that employees would receive a second email
with directions to complete a training course and a written
acknowledgement, which they were required to complete by
May 27, 2021. No second email was sent.
Before the company’s deadline to review the handbook,
Towell took medical leave. While she was on medical leave, Move
revoked her access to the email system and the training platform,
including her ability to review the handbook with the proposed
arbitration agreement. Although Move was aware from its
records that Towell had not reviewed the handbook prior to
taking medical leave and did not have access to the email system
or training platform, Move did not take any action to make the
handbook available to her or secure her acknowledgement of the
revised handbook. There is also no evidence that she was
required to work or capable of consenting while out of the office
on medical leave. The evidence supports the trial courts’ finding
that in this case, Towell did not have notice of the arbitration

11
policy such that remaining employed by the company while she
was out of the office on medical leave constituted consent to
arbitrate.
The cases relied on by Move are readily distinguishable. In
Diaz, for example, the plaintiff employee received notice at an in-
person meeting that her employer was adopting an arbitration
policy and that continuing employment would constitute
acceptance of the arbitration agreement. (Diaz, supra, 34
Cal.App.5th at p. 128.) The employee was expressly told twice
that by continuing her employment, she would be agreeing to
arbitration provisions. (Id. at p. 130.) In the present case,
Move’s email to employees did not mention arbitration and did
not explain that continuing employment would constitute consent
to whatever policies were in the handbook.
In Craig, in two separate years, the defendant employer
sent a memorandum to employee Craig at her home address
explaining that the company had adopted a dispute resolution
program and enclosing a brochure with details. (Craig, supra, 84
Cal.App.4th at pp. 419–420.) The mail was not returned to the
employer, but Craig declared that she did not receive either set of
documents. (Id. at p. 420.) After considering this conflicting
evidence, the trial court found that Craig received the documents.
On appeal, the appellate court concluded the trial court’s findings
were supported by substantial evidence. Permissible inferences
could be drawn from the employer’s act of mailing the documents
that Craig received the documents and, by continuing to work for
several years, agreed to be bound to the terms of the arbitration
agreement. (Id. at pp. 421–422.) In contrast, in the instant case,
the trial courts found Towell did not have notice of the employer’s

12
proposed arbitration agreement, a finding that is supported by
substantial evidence.
In Harris, employee Harris acknowledged in writing that
he received an employee handbook and the employer’s arbitration
agreement. (Harris, supra, 248 Cal.App.4th at p. 377.) The
arbitration agreement stated that if the employee voluntarily
continued employment after the effective date of the policy, the
employee would be deemed to have consented to the arbitration
agreement. (Id. at p. 381.) Based on the employee’s receipt of the
handbook and arbitration agreement, which stated that
continuing employment would be deemed to be agreement to the
policies, followed by the employee’s continued employment, the
appellate court found the employee impliedly assented to the
terms of the handbook. (Id. at p. 384.) In contrast, in this case,
Towell did not acknowledge receipt of the revised employee
handbook or have notice of the arbitration agreement, so her
continued employment by the company did not constitute consent
to arbitrate.

13
DISPOSITION

The orders denying the motions to compel arbitration are
affirmed. Respondent Selena Towell is awarded her costs on
appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

MOOR, J.

We concur:

BAKER, Acting, P. J.

KIM, J.

14

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.