CourtListener 10007963•People v. Broadway CA3
Full text
Filed 7/19/24 P. v. Broadway CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Butte)
----
THE PEOPLE, C098290
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. Nos. 22CF05054,
22CF04132)
v.
DONNIE RAY BROADWAY,
Defendant and Appellant.
In a global plea agreement resolving two criminal cases, defendant Donnie Ray
Broadway pleaded no contest to three drug offenses in exchange for dismissal of all other
charges. On appeal, he argues that he was denied the benefit of his plea bargain after the
trial court failed to dismiss allegations of a prior strike. We conclude that the trial court’s
judgment failed to reflect the parties’ bargain. We therefore modify the judgment to
conform to the parties’ agreement.
BACKGROUND
In June 2022, law enforcement officers executed a search warrant at Broadway’s
home. The search of his bedroom uncovered various amounts of methamphetamine,
1
heroin, cocaine, cocaine and fentanyl mixed, and hydrocodone-acetaminophen pills as
well as drug paraphernalia, packaging, scales, and pay-owe sheets. Officers also found
methamphetamine and a scale under the couch cushions in the living room.
In August 2022, the People charged Broadway in Butte County case
No. 22CF04132 with four drug-related charges: count 1 for maintaining a place for
selling or using a controlled substance (Health & Saf. Code, § 11366); count 2 for
possession of methamphetamine for sale (§ 11378); count 3 for possession and purchase
of cocaine and fentanyl for sale (§ 11351); and count 4 for possession and purchase of
heroin for sale (§ 11351).1 For each count, the complaint alleged that he had suffered a
prior strike for a 1994 first degree burglary conviction and was therefore subject to
sentencing under California’s Three Strikes law. (Pen. Code, §§ 667, subds. (b)-(i),
1170.12.) Broadway was released on bail.
In October 2022, law enforcement officers searched a hotel room that Broadway
had rented. They discovered methamphetamine, “fake” heroin, acetaminophen and
hydrocodone bitartrate pills, oxycodone hydrochloride pills, Xanax bars of suspected
fentanyl/mannitol, and a used glass smoking device.
Later that month, the People filed a second criminal action against Broadway,
docketed as Butte County case No. 22CF05054. The complaint alleged two new drug-
related charges: count 1 for possession of methamphetamine for sale (§ 11378) and
count 2 for possession and purchase of oxycodone for sale (§ 11351). For each count, the
People alleged that, at the time of the offenses, Broadway was on bail in case
No. 22CF04132 (Pen. Code, § 12022.1) and that he had suffered a prior strike for a 1994
first degree burglary conviction (Pen. Code, §§ 667, subds. (b)-(i), 1170.12).
1 Further undesignated statutory references are to the Health and Safety Code.
2
The parties resolved both cases by plea. Under the terms of the global plea
agreement, Broadway pleaded no contest to counts 1 and 2 in case No. 22CF04132. In
case No. 22CF05054, he pleaded no contest to count 2 and admitted the on-bail
enhancement. In exchange, the agreement provided that “[a]ll other charges are
dismissed.”
The plea arrangement left sentencing to the trial court’s discretion. Broadway
agreed that the court could sentence him to the lower, middle, or upper term and that the
court could find aggravating factors based on the probable cause declaration, police
reports, and the probation report. He also agreed to a waiver under People v. Harvey
(1979) 25 Cal.3d 754, which allowed the sentencing judge to consider his prior criminal
history, including “any unfiled, dismissed or stricken charges or allegations or cases[,]
when granting probation, ordering restitution or imposing sentence.”
At a December 2022 hearing, the trial court accepted Broadway’s plea. It also
found Broadway in violation of probation in a misdemeanor matter (case
No. 20CM04390) and revoked probation in that case.
At sentencing in March 2023, the trial court designated count 2 in case
No. 22CF05054 as the principal term and sentenced Broadway to the upper term of four
years in state prison. The court imposed consecutive terms of eight months (one-third the
midterm) for each of counts 1 and 2 in case No. 22CF04132. It declined to strike the on-
bail enhancement in case No. 22CF05054 and added two years to Broadway’s sentence
for that enhancement. The court also imposed a concurrent six-month term for the
misdemeanor in case No. 20CM04390. Broadway’s aggregate sentence totaled seven
years four months in prison.
DISCUSSION
On appeal, Broadway asks this court to modify the judgment to dismiss the strike
allegations in both cases brought against him. In his view, the trial court failed to comply
with the plea agreement’s provision to dismiss “[a]ll other charges” when the court
3
dismissed counts 3 and 4 in case No. 22CF04132 and count 1 in case No. 22CF05054 but
not the strike allegations. The People argue that modification is not required under the
terms of the plea agreement and, in any event, is unnecessary because the strike
allegations were dismissed by operation of law after the prosecution did not attempt to
prove, and Broadway did not admit, the allegations.
Having reviewed the record, we conclude that modification of the judgment is
warranted. It is well established that “when a plea rests in any significant degree on a
promise or agreement of the prosecutor, so that it can be said to be part of the inducement
or consideration, such promise must be fulfilled.” (Santobello v. New York (1971)
404 U.S. 257, 262.) In this case, there is no dispute between the parties that the plea
agreement required dismissal of the substantive counts to which Broadway did not
plead—namely, counts 3 and 4 in case No. 22CF04132 and count 1 in case
No. 22CF05054. Indeed, both parties’ briefs before this court assume that the trial court
has already dismissed those counts.
While it is true that the court minutes reflect the dismissal of those counts, the
court’s oral judgment does not. But “ ‘[r]endition of judgment is an oral
pronouncement.’ ” (People v. Mesa (1975) 14 Cal.3d 466, 471.) And “[w]here there is a
discrepancy between the oral pronouncement of judgment and the minute order or the
abstract of judgment, the oral pronouncement controls.” (People v. Zackery (2007)
147 Cal.App.4th 380, 385.) Here, the trial court orally sentenced Broadway on the
counts and allegation to which he expressly pleaded, but it did not address the remaining
charges at either the change-of-plea or sentencing hearings. Accordingly, to conform to
the plea agreement and the parties’ understandings, the judgment must be modified to
dismiss the substantive counts to which Broadway did not plead. (People v. Macheno
(1982) 32 Cal.3d 855, 861 [“Specific enforcement [of a plea bargain] is appropriate when
it will implement the reasonable expectations of the parties without binding the trial
judge to a disposition that he or she considers unsuitable under all the circumstances”].)
4
That leaves the question of whether the plea agreement also entitles Broadway to
dismissal of the strike allegations. Our state high court has explained that a negotiated
plea agreement is a form of contract that is interpreted according to general contract
principles. (People v. Shelton (2006) 37 Cal.4th 759, 767.) When interpreting a plea
agreement on appeal, we must give effect to the mutual intention of the parties. (Ibid.)
Where the contract language is clear and explicit, it governs. (Ibid.) But where
contractual terms are ambiguous or uncertain, we must interpret the language “ ‘ “in the
sense in which the promisor believed, at the time of making it, that the promisee
understood it.” ’ ” (Ibid.) “ ‘The mutual intention to which the courts give effect is
determined by objective manifestations of the parties’ intent, including the words used in
the agreement, as well as extrinsic evidence of such objective matters as the surrounding
circumstances under which the parties negotiated or entered into the contract; the object,
nature and subject matter of the contract; and the subsequent conduct of the parties.’ ”
(Ibid.)
While we agree with the People that a strike allegation is not a “charge” of a
crime, the parties’ conduct in this case establishes that the parties intended for the People
to seek dismissal of both the substantive counts and the strike allegations when they
agreed that “[a]ll other charges” would be dismissed. As the People acknowledge, the
prosecution never attempted to prove, and Broadway never admitted, the strike
allegations. In addition—and without objection from either party—the trial court did not
sentence Broadway under the Three Strikes law. These facts demonstrate that the parties
intended for all counts and allegations other than those to which Broadway expressly
pleaded to be dismissed.
The People argue that the terms of the plea agreement did not call for dismissal of
the strike allegations, but they represent on appeal that the allegations were dismissed by
operation of law when they were neither proven nor admitted; that the allegations cannot
be used against Broadway in the future; and indeed, that they “no longer exist.” The
5
modification we order is thus consistent with both parties’ expectations regarding the
status of the strike allegations in question.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is modified to dismiss counts 3 and 4 and the prior strike conviction
allegations in Butte County case No. 22CF04132 and count 1 and the prior strike
conviction allegations in Butte County case No. 22CF05054. The clerk of the superior
court is directed to correct the respective sentencing minute orders accordingly. As so
modified, the judgment is affirmed.
/s/
Feinberg, J.
We concur:
/s/
Mauro, Acting P. J.
/s/
Mesiwala, J.
6
Wondering how this text applies to your situation?
Free consultation, no commitment
Describe your situation. Our team will contact you by email about your consultation.
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.