Key legal question
Whether the appeal met the written reasoning requirement under Art. 321(1) CPC
Extracted holding
No. The filing did not contain any recognizable legal grievance against the challenged order, so it did not permit the appellate court to understand what was being contested.
Extracted reasoning
An appeal must be reasoned sufficiently to show what the appellant seeks and to allow the court to identify the objections without searching for them itself. Mere description of personal circumstances is insufficient; the lack of reasoning is an irremediable defect and cannot be cured under Art. 132 CPC.