52.1999.4•Appeals struck as moot after revocation annulled
52.1999.4Other CourtMar 1, 1999Other
Extracted by Omnilex
The appellant filed two administrative appeals on 7 January 1999 against State Council decisions of 22 December 1998 revoking operating authorizations for certain clinics. Before the tribunal decided the case, the State Council itself annulled those revocation decisions on 4 February 1999 and again authorized the clinics to operate. The appellant therefore requested that both appeals be declared moot and waived any claim for party compensation. The Administrative Court removed the appeals from the docket, ordered that no fees or expenses be collected, and awarded no indemnity for costs.
Mootness in administrative appeal proceedings; where the challenged administrative act is withdrawn or annulled by the deciding authority and the dispute thus loses its subject matter, the appeal is struck from the docket for lack of current legal interest. In such a constellation, the court may waive court fees and expenses and deny party compensation, especially where the appellant expressly renounces an award (consid. 1-2).
AIUTO RICERCA
Anteprima di stampa
Numero d'incarto: 52.1999.4
Data decisione, Autorità: 01.03.1999, TRAM
Incarto n. 52.99.00004-5
Lugano 1° marzo 1999
In nome della Repubblica e Cantone del Ticino
Il Tribunale cantonale amministrativo
composto dei giudici:
Lorenzo Anastasi, presidente, Raffaello Balerna, Stefano Bernasconi
segretario:
Leopoldo Crivelli
statuendo suoi ricorsi 7 gennaio 1999 della
patrocinata da: avv. __________
contro
le decisioni 22 dicembre 1998, no. 5946 e 5947, del Consiglio di Stato che revocano le autorizzazioni 2 agosto 1982 e 17 maggio 1994 del Dipartimento delle opere sociali per l'esercizio delle __________, __________ e __________, __________, di proprietà della __________
ritenuto che il Consiglio di Stato con risoluzioni 4 febbraio 1999, no. 545 e 546, ha annullato le succitate decisioni autorizzando l'esercizio delle cliniche __________ e __________;
preso atto che la ricorrente ha pertanto chiesto di dichiarare privi d'oggetto le due impugnative rinunciando all'assegnazione dell'indennità per ripetibili;
decreta:
I ricorsi sono stralciati dai ruoli poiché divenuti privi d'oggetto.
Non si prelevano né tasse, né spese.
Non si assegnano ripetibili.
Per il Tribunale cantonale amministrativo
Il presidente Il segretario
Ultimo aggiornamento: 02.07.2026
| Informazioni legali | Requisiti minimi | Contatta il webmaster
Extracted by Omnilex
Whether the appeals against the revocation of operating authorizations had become moot after the State Council annulled its own revocation decisions.
The appeals were removed from the docket because the challenged decisions had lost their subject matter.
Since the State Council subsequently annulled the revocation decisions and authorized the operation of the clinics again, there was no longer a live dispute to adjudicate.
Whether court fees, expenses, or party compensation should be awarded.
No court fees, expenses, or party compensation were imposed or awarded.
The appellant expressly waived any request for compensation, and the court ordered that no fees or costs be charged.
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.