Key legal question
Whether the alleged share transfer to A. was proved and effective before 14 February 2007
Extracted holding
The courts held that the transfer was not proven to have occurred before 10 April 2007; the February letters were treated only as confirmation of a transfer, not as the transfer itself.
Extracted reasoning
The parties' actual understanding showed no assignment agreement had been concluded in February 2007. The later written assignment document was the first proven transfer instrument.