2025-01 City of Watertown Informal

New York Attorney General Opinion 2025-01Nyag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

The City Council and the City Manager can withhold privileged attorney-
client communications relating to legal action against a council member from
the Council member.
September 2, 2025
Kristen E. Smith 	Informal Opinion
City Attorney 	No. 2025-01
City of Watertown
Bond Schoeneck & King
One Lincoln Center
Syracuse, New York 13202-1355
Dear Ms. Smith:
You have requested an opinion regarding whether the attorney-client
privilege permits the City Council, acting through a majority of its members, and
the City Manager to withhold confidential city records from a sitting city council
member. The confidential records relate to legal action the City is taking against
the member. The member explained that he requested the confidential records
in his capacity as a member of the City’s governing body so that he can perform
his oversight duties as a member of the City Council. We conclude that the City
Council and the City Manager can withhold information relating to legal action
against one of the Council’s members when that information constitutes
privileged attorney-client communications.
In general, all members of a local government’s governing body are
entitled to the same access to information relevant to their governmental work.
This access allows them to perform their governmental duties and adequately
represent their constituents. But on occasion a member’s personal or unique
interests may affect his or her ability to impartially perform those governmental
duties. On those occasions, the appropriate remedy is for the member to recuse
him- or herself from all aspects of governing with respect to the matter. The
public must be assured that their officials are free to exercise their best
judgment without any hint of self-interest or partiality. Matter of Titan Concrete,
Inc. v. Town of Kent, 202 A.D.3d 972, 974 (2d Dep’t 2022). In Titan Concrete,
the town supervisor – who had a personal interest in closing the Titan concrete
plant – recused herself from voting on a local law that would prevent any
2
concrete plants from locating or remaining in Titan’s current zoning district. Id.
But the supervisor participated in other aspects of the concrete plant zoning
issue and that participation tainted the enactment of the local law. Id. at 975.
The appellate court upheld the trial court’s nullification of the local law because
the town supervisor had participated by presiding over public hearings, engaging
in discussions with a representative of the concrete plant and the public on the
matter, and voting on certain motions related to the local law. Id. at 974. To
avoid any appearance of influencing the governmental process with her personal
interest, the supervisor should have recused herself from performing her public
duties in all aspects relating to the concrete plant zoning issue. “Where a
substantial conflict is inevitable, the public official should not act.” Id. at 975.
In short, when faced with a personal interest that conflicts with, or appears
to conflict with, the impartial performance of public duties, the public officer
must refrain from engaging in the public duties.
Here, the council member’s interest as an individual involved in a legal
matter against the remaining members of City Council mandates recusal from
performing his public duties relating to the legal matter. This includes his
oversight duties as a member of City Council. Accordingly, the other members of
City Council and the City Manager can decline to provide confidential attorney-
client communications regarding the legal matter to the individual adversarial
council member.
The 	Attorney 	General 	issues 	formal 	opinions 	only 	to 	officers 	and
departments of state government. Thus, this is an informal opinion rendered to
assist you in advising the municipality you represent.
Very truly yours,
KATHRYN SHEINGOLD
Assistant Solicitor General
in Charge of Opinions

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.