Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-149

1989-149Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL December 18, 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89- 149
David Markham
Labette County Counselor
P.O. Box 611
Parsons, Kansas 67357
Re: State Departments; Public Officers and Employees --
Public Officers and Employees; Open Public Meetings
-- Chamber of Commerce
Synopsis: The Parsons Chamber of Commerce, Inc. is not
subject to the provisions of the Kansas Open
Meetings Act in administering the county motel bed
tax funds. While the Chamber expends public funds,
it is not a legislative or administrative agency of
the state or its political and taxing
subdivisions. Cited herein: K.S.A. 75-4317;
K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 75-4318.
*
Dear Mr. Markham:
As county counselor for Labette county, you request our
opinion concerning the Kansas Open Meetings Act (KOMA),
K.S.A. 75-4317 et seq. Specifically, you inquire whether
the KOMA is applicable to an advisory subcommittee of the
Parsons Chamber of Commerce, Inc., the executive board of the
Parsons Chamber of Commerce, Inc., and the board of directors
of the Parsons Chamber of Commerce, Inc.
We are informed that in 1987 the Labette County Commission
passed a motel bed tax to raise money to promote conventions
and tourism. Approximately $17,000 has been collected, but no
monies have been spent. All of the motels in the county
affected by the tax are located in Parsons. You state that
the Parsons Chamber of Commerce, Inc. (Chamber), a nonprofit
corporation, "proposed itself to the County Commission as an
entity to spend the money to promote conventions and tourism
in the county."
Apparently the county commission agreed to the Chamber's
proposal. You inform us that the Chamber submitted a proposed
budget to the county commission. In an open meeting the
commission reviewed and approved the budget, authorizing the
Chamber's board of directors to spend $8,800 over the next
year to promote conventions and tourism. At the end of the
year the Chamber is to submit an annual report to the
commission to account for the expenditures made.
We understand that, since the budget was approved, the Chamber
has appointed an advisory sub-committee to make
recommendations as to how the funds should be spent. These
recommendations are made to the executive board of the Chamber
and are non-binding. The executive board reviews the
proposals and then makes recommendations to the board of
directors. The Chamber's board of directors is the only body
authorized by the commission to expend the motel bed tax
funds. The expenditures are to be approved by a majority of
the board of directors in accordance with the budget approved
by the commission. Therefore, you ask whether meetings of the
Chamber's subcommittee, executive board, or board of directors
are subject to the provisions of the KOMA.
By its terms the KOMA applies to
"all meetings for the conduct of the
affairs of, and the transaction of
business by, all legislative and
administrative bodies and agencies of the
state and political and taxing
subdivisions thereof, including boards,
commissions, authorities, councils,
committees, subcommittees and other
subordinate groups thereof, receiving or
expending and supported in whole or in
part by public funds. . . ." K.S.A. 1988
Supp. 75-4318(a).
The above language sets forth a two-part test which must be
met for a body to be included within the act's provisions:
(1) the body is a legislative or administrative agency of the
state or one of its political or taxing subdivisions, or is
subordinate to such a body; and (2) the body receives,
expends, or is supported in whole or in part by public funds,
or, in the case of subordinate groups, the parent or
controlling body is so supported. It is clear that the second
prong of this text is met as the Chamber receives and expends
public funds. The question is whether the first part of the
test is met; whether the Chamber, by receiving public funds
which must be spent as approved by the commission, is a
legislative or administrative body or subordinate to a
legislative or administrative body.
A similar question was before the Kansas Supreme Court in
Memorial Hospital Ass'n, Inc. v. Knutson, 239 Kan. 663
(1986). In that case the court stated:
"Whenever a body or group has in any way
derived the authority for its existence
from a legislative or administrative
agency, that body or group so created is
also subject to the open meetings act.
Where courts have found that the agencies
or bodies were not subject to the various
act, they have looked at form and not
considered how the entity came into
existence or, in some instances, its
purpose.
"Courts have found two types of entities,
whatever form they may take, which are not
subject to the open meetings laws: (1)
those which are merely advisory and have
no decision-making authority, and (2)
those which are basically independent
entities which have some connection, by
contract or other tie to a government
entity, but are not actually created by
some form of government action.
"Where it can be shown that a public body
has intentionally, and for the purpose of
avoiding the light of public scrutiny,
appointed a board of non-elected citizens
to determine for the elected board what
course should be pursued, or where the
actions of the private citizens are in any
way binding upon the elected officials,
the meetings of such groups should be open
to public scrutiny. Public bodies cannot
be allowed to do indirectly what the
legislature has forbidden." 239 Kan. at
670-71.
In holding that the KOMA was not applicable to Memorial
Hospital Association, the court ruled that, when a county
hospital board leases the hospital property to another, the
lessee (association) is not subject to the KOMA if the lessee
"(1) has no governmental decision-making
authority to expend public funds, and (2)
is an independent entity which by contract
agrees to provide hospital services under
a lease of hospital property from a board
of trustees." Id. at 672.
The court also noted that the lessee/association was not
created as an "alter ego" to the governmental bodies involved
and was not created to evade the open meetings law. Id.
In Attorney General Opinion No. 81-253 we opined that Planned
Parenthood, Inc., a private, nonprofit corporation, was not
subject to the KOMA. Though it received public funds, we
concluded that the first part of the test was not met because
the entity was not "of" the state or a political or taxing
subdivision thereof.
"The mere fact that this corporation
[Planned Parenthood] contracts with the
county to provide services which the
county would otherwise provide, does not
extend the requirements of the Kansas Open
Meetings Act to an essentially private
entity." (Page 6).
The opinion relied in part on the following authority's
construction of the KOMA:
"A private corporation, by contracting to
perform services for the State of Kansas
or a political or taxing subdivision, does
not subject its board of directors to
public scrutiny under the Act." Smoot
and Clothier, Open Meetings Profile: The
Prosecutor's View, 20 Washburn L.J. 241,
252 (1981).
See Attorney General Opinion No. 80-239 ("cooperation
between an essentially private organization and a public
agency does not subject the former to the [KOMA].")
In the situation before us, neither the Chamber nor any of the
Chamber's boards or committees was created by the county
commission. We have no evidence to suggest that the
commission agreed to have the Chamber administer the motel bed
tax money to avoid the open meetings law. The Chamber is a
private entity which has agreed to provide services for the
county. As the court in Memorial Hospital noted, the courts
have found that basically independent agencies not created by
governmental action which are connected to a governmental
entity by contract are not subject to open meetings laws. The
Chamber is a basically independent entity whose connection
with the county commission is the agreement and approved
budget to promote conventions and tourism. Therefore, we
conclude that the Chamber, including the board of directors,
executive board, and advisory sub-committee, is not subject to
the KOMA in this instance.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:bas

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.