Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-131

1989-131Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL October 26, 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89 - 131
Doug Martin
Shawnee County Counselor
Courthouse, Room 203
200 E. 7th
Topeka, Kansas 66603-3922
Re: Counties and County Officers -- County Treasurer --
Deputy Treasurers; Budget; Limitation of Personnel
Action
Counties and County Officers -- County
Commissioners; Powers and Duties -- Powers of Board
of Commissioners; Authority Over Employment of
Assistants by County Treasurer
Synopsis: If the yearly budget established by the board of
county commissioners includes either a line item
for salaries for county treasurer personnel or
another fund that may be properly expended for
personnel salaries, and those funds have been
previously expended or committed, the county
treasurer is subject to that budget and may not
commit additional funds without the approval of the
board of county commissioners. K.S.A. 19-503
authorizes the county treasurer to employ deputies
and assistants but such action is subject to
budgetary restrictions and any existing county
employee policies that are applicable to all county
employees. Cited herein: K.S.A. 10-1113;
19-212; 19-229; 19-235; 19-241; 19-302; 19-503;
19-803; 19-805; 19-4301; 79-2934; 79-2935; 79-2936.
Dear Mr. Martin:
As Shawnee County Counselor you request our opinion regarding
employee appointments made by your county treasurer. The
issues you present concern whether the board of county
commissioners may require another elected county official to
comply with county employee policies and procedures and
whether the salaries paid to a county treasurer's unclassified
personnel are subject to budgetary constraints.
This office has previously addressed the interaction between
authority granted to the board of county commissioners and
other elected officials. See Attorney General Opinions No.
88-171, 87-37, 87-14, 86-166, 85-147, 84-53, 81-86, 80-69,
79-279, and 79-113. As discussed in these opinions, the
Kansas statutes vest county fiscal management and legislative
authority in the board of county commissioners. The various
required duties and authorities enjoyed by other elected
county officials are also statutorily established. Thus,
Kansas statutes delineate the degree and nature of authority
vested in each county officer.
Pursuant to K.S.A. 19-212, 19-229 and general budgetary
procedures, the board of county commissioners exercise
authority over county expenditures. See also State v.
Garnett, 180 Kan. 405, 407 (1956). K.S.A. 19-212,
19-235, and 19-241 permit the board of county commissioners
certain authority over payments to county employees hired by
other elected officials. Discretionary expenditures may be
authorized or eliminated by the board. Gonser v. Board of
County Commissioners, 1 Kan.App.2d 57 (1977). An
exception to the general rule permitting the board to
determine when and where to spend county moneys exists when
funds are included in the budget of another elected official
or the expenditure is required by another elected official in
order to carry out statutorily imposed duties. Absent funds
properly budgeted for a particular purpose or a law allowing
or requiring other county officials to create an indebtedness
against the county, other elected officials cannot incur
expenses against the county in the absence of approval by the
board of county commissioners. See Norton v. Simms,'
85 Kan. 822 (1911); Commissioners of Neosho County v.
Stoddart, 13 Kan. 207 (1874); Hackler v. Board of
County Commissioners, 189 Kan. 697 (1962); Mt. Carmel
Medical Center v. Board of County Commissioners, 1
Kan.App.2d 374 (1977). It therefore becomes necessary to
determine whether the Shawnee county treasurer is committing
moneys budgeted for such expenditures or whether a statute or
law requires or allows the county treasurer to take the
actions which result in expenses that cannot be paid from
funds previously budgeted.
K.S.A. 19-503 discusses the authority of a county treasurer to
hire deputies and assistants and states:
"(a) The county treasurer may appoint a
deputy, who, in the absence of the
treasurer or in case of a vacancy in the
office, due to any disability of the
treasurer to perform the duties of the
office, may perform all the duties of the
office of treasurer until the vacancy is
filled or the disability removed. In
addition to the deputy, the county
treasurer also may appoint, promote,
demote and dismiss additional deputies
and any assistants necessary to carry out
the duties of the office. The county
treasurer shall supervise all assistants
in the performance of their duties.
Within the limitations of the budget for
the financing of the operation of the
county treasurer's office as approved by
the board of county commissioners, the
county treasurer may attend and may
require the deputies and any assistants to
attend any meetings or seminars which the
treasurer determines will be beneficial to
the operation of the treasurer's office.
"(b) The county treasurer shall submit a
budget for the financing of the operation
of the treasurer's office to the board of
county commissioners for their approval.
"(c) Any personnel action taken by the
county treasurer under this section shall
be subject to the following: (1)
Personnel policies and procedures
established by the board of county
commissioners for all county employees
other than elected officials; (2) any
pay plan established by the board of
county commissioners for all county
employees other than elected officials;
(3) any applicable collective bargaining
agreements or civil service system; and
(4) the budget for the financing of the
operation of the treasurer's office as
approved by the board of county
commissioners." (Emphasis added).
Thus, Kansas law allows a county treasurer to hire deputies
and assistants. However, K.S.A. 19-503(c)(4) clearly states
that "any personnel action taken by the county treasurer under
this section shall be subject to . . . the budget for the
financing of the operation of the treasurer's office as
approved by the board of county commissioners." Thus, it
appears that K.S.A. 19-503(c)(4) limits the ability of the
county treasurer to pay personnel salaries that are not
provided for in the budget. If the county treasurer's budget
included funds for hiring deputies and assistants, any funds
so budgeted may be spent for that purpose. You inform us that
the portion of the Shawnee county treasurer's budget for
employee costs will not cover the salaries of any new
employees. However, you do not indicate whether another fund
allocated to the county treasurer's office may also be
properly spent for personnel salaries.
Budgetary laws and K.S.A. 19-503(c)(4) do not authorize the
board of county commissioners to unreasonably or capriciously
restrict the exercise of authority granted to the county
treasurer. Kansas law requires that county treasurers perform
certain duties. K.S.A. 19-241 requires the board of county
commissioners to levy sufficient amounts to defray all county
charges and expenses. In formulating a budget, the board must
therefore consider many factors, including the availability of
funds and the degree of need or demand for specific
governmental services. The necessity for a specific
expenditures is often a factual question which must be
determined on a case by case basis by the entity given the
authority or directed by law to take a particular action.
See Commissioners of Sumner County v. Simmons, 51 Kan.
304, 309 (1893); Vernon v. Edwards County Commissioners,
132 Kan. 119, 121 (1931). As discussed in Attorney General
Opinion No. 80-69, the board of county commissioners may not
use budgetary authority to prevent an elected official from
carrying out statutorily imposed duties. The yearly budgetary
procedures permit the board to work with each elected official
in formulating a reasonable compromise between county fiscal
status and each county office's needs or requirements. As
discussed in Attorney General Opinions No. 87-14 and 87-37,
the board of county commissioners may establish a line item
budget which restricts the transfer of funds from one line
item to another. County elected officials may exercise
authority over funds specifically allocated to their office in
a line item or budgeted for general use by the county official.
Once a yearly budget is set, Kansas law generally prohibits
moneys from one fund being diverted to another fund and
forbids the creation of indebtedness in excess of the budget.
K.S.A. 79-2934, 79-2935 and 10-1113. See also Attorney
General Opinion No. 86-104. If an expenditure of county funds
is authorized in violation of budgetary or cash basis laws,
there may be individual liability imposed upon the person
creating such indebtedness. See Superior Grade School
District No. 110 v. Rhodes, 147 Kan. 29, 30 (1938)
(school district treasurer and his bondsman held liable for
expenditure authorized by treasurer which was not provided for
in the budget). Moreover, K.S.A. 79-2936 provides that "any
member of the governing body, or any other public officer of
any taxing subdivision or municipality of the state, who
violates the provisions of this act, shall be subject to
removal from office." Thus, in order to justify expenditures
beyond those approved in the budget, an elected official must
demonstrate that the expenditure is necessary to fulfill
duties required by law. Unless a law specifically requires
that the treasurer hire additional employees or take other
actions, the county treasurer must refrain from actions that
incur indebtedness in excess of the established budget. It is
therefore our opinion that if the budget formulated by the
board of county commissioners includes a line item or general
funds for salaries to be paid to county treasurer personnel,
and those funds have been expended or previously committed, a
reasonable interpretation of the authority granted to a county
treasurer does not permit that official to exceed the
personnel budget unless such additional expenditure is
approved by the board.
You also inquire whether a county treasurer must follow county
employee policies and procedures with regard to hiring and
salaries. K.S.A. 19-503(c) contains language which
essentially mirrors that set forth at K.S.A. 19-302(1) and
19-805(d). L. 1983, ch. 91 enacted this new language and
essentially changed some of the conclusions reached in prior
Attorney General opinions issued before 1983 (e.g. Attorney
General Opinion No. 79-113). While the legislature did not
eliminate the authority of a county official to employ
assistants, the legislature clarified the areas of control
enjoyed by the board. Such areas include budget and personnel
policies.
In Attorney General Opinion No. 84-30 we examined K.S.A.
19-805(d) and opined that the county sheriff was subject to
those limitations stated in the statute "and, in particular,
to personnel and pay policies applicable to all county
employees." However, that opinion went on to note that "it
does not appear that the board may control or affect through
the enactment of county personnel policies, the appointment of
an undersheriff." This exception relied upon the language of
K.S.A. 19-803 which requires a sheriff to appoint an
undersheriff. Unlike K.S.A. 19-803, which states that "the
sheriff of each county shall . . . appoint some proper
person undersheriff. . . ." (emphasis added), K.S.A.
19-503(a) states that "the county treasurer may appoint a
deputy . . . and may appoint, promote, demote, and dismiss
additional deputies and assistants necessary to carry out the
duties of the office." (Emphasis added). Thus, the law does
not require a county treasurer to appoint a deputy or
assistant.
It is therefore our opinion that the authority of the county
treasurer to hire employees must be exercised within the
budgetary constraints and employee policies applicable to all
county employees. See also K.S.A. 19-4301. However, the
board of county commissioners may not prevent or direct the
exercise of mandatory duties performed by another elected
officer. If funds are available in the budget for the purpose
of hiring employees and if county employee policies do not
apply or exist, the board of county commissioners cannot
interfere with decisions properly made by another elected
official. The board has clearly been given the statutory
authority to adopt the county budget and to adopt employee
policies applicable to all county employees. Working within
such constraints, other county officers retain the authority
to make decisions within the scope of their authority and as
authorized by law.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Theresa Marcel Nuckolls
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TMN:bas

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.