Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-112

1989-112Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL September 6, 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89- 112
Pamela Scott
Chief Attorney
Kansas Insurance Department
420 SW 9th
Topeka, Kansas 66612-1678
Re: Insurance -- Prepaid Legal and Dental Service Plans
-- Definitions; Prepaid Service Plan
Synopsis: An organization which collects a periodic fee on a
prepaid basis in return for a promise to provide
selected dental services in the future at no charge
or at a discount must conform to the requirements
of the prepaid legal and dental service plans act,
unless exempted by statute. Cited herein: K.S.A.
1988 Supp. 40-4201; 40-4203; 40-4207; 40-4209;
40-4211, as amended by L. 1989, ch. 145, § 1;
1987 House Bill No. 2564.
Dear Ms. Scott:
On behalf of the State Insurance Commissioner you request our
opinion regarding prepaid dental service plans. Specifically,
you ask whether an organization which offers to arrange for
the provision of dental services on a prepaid basis is a
prepaid service plan regulated by K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 40-4201
et !2a .
A prepaid service plan is any legal entity which "collects
periodic fees on a prepaid basis . . in connection with
for-profit legal or dental coverage. . . ." K.S.A. 1988 Supp.
40-4201(a). Article 42 of Chapter 40 of the Kansas Statutes
Annotated places various statutory requirements on such
plans. For example, individuals who solicit members on behalf
of the plan must be registered with the insurance
commissioner. K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 40-4203. The plan holds the
membership fees in a fiduciary capacity, and must deposit the
fees in a bank account established for the plan. K.S.A. 1988
Supp. 40-4207. Any person acting as a prepaid service plan
must hold a certificate of registration issued by the
commissioner of insurance. K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 40-4209(a).
Additionally, securities or irrevocable letters of credit must
be deposited with the insurance commissioner by the plan.
K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 40-4211, as amended by L. 1989, ch. 145,
§ 1.
Prepaid service plans are generally not considered to be the
business of insurance. Fundamentally, such plans are similar
to insurance because the subscriber pays a fee in return for a
promise to deliver services under certain contingencies.
Annotation, Prepaid Legal Services Plans, 93 A.L.R. 3d 199
(1979). However, insurance is defined by our courts as a
contract to indemnify another against certain risks. The
business of the promisor must include as its principal purpose
and object an assumption of the risk. State, ex rel. v.
Anderson, 195 Kan. 649, 662-63 (1965). In short, there
must be a transfer of risk arising from a fortuitous event.
Prepaid plans generally do not involve an assumption or
transfer of such risk, because they generally allow the
subscriber to receive the benefit of the agreement at their
own choosing, at least in a limited sense. For example, many
prepaid legal services include "drafting of a will, a
separation agreement, the purchase of a house," and other
non-fortuitous events which precipitate the retention of a
lawyer. Feinstein v. Attorney General, 36 N.Y. 2d 199,
326 N.E. 2d 288, 293 (1975) (prepaid legal plans not
prohibited by New York insurance law, on their face not
insurance).
Because the prepaid legal and dental service plans are not
insurance, they escaped regulation prior to passage of 1987
House Bill No. 2564. The law was adopted by the 1987
legislature as a means of protecting consumers from poorly
operated prepaid plans. An example was cited involving a
legal plan which became insolvent closed its doors, leaving
the consumers without the bargained-for service. See
Minutes of the House Committee on Insurance, March 31, 1987;
Minutes of the Senate Committee on Financial Institutions and
Insurance, April 9, 1987, 1987 House Bill No. 2564. During
committee discussion, the conferee representing Blue
Cross/Blue Shield objected to the bill unless it could be
limited to prepaid legal plans because the dental plans should
be treated as insurance. Senate Committee Minutes, at page
2. The conferee for the Kansas Department of Insurance had
previously explained to the House Committee that if the law
were to be limited to legal plans only, the agency would have
a problem, because there were a number of dental plans. House
Committee Minutes, at page 1. The law was eventually passed
with legal and dental plans being included.
The prepaid service plans law is obviously an attempt by the
legislature to protect consumers from financially unsound or
unscrupulous organizations which bring together service
providers and service plan members, but which are not
regulated under the insurance statutes. The protections
granted by the statutes may not be avoided by calling the
organization something other than a prepaid plan.
Therefore it is our opinion that an organization which
collects a periodic fee on a prepaid basis, whether referred
to as a fee, premium, or monthly dues, and in return promises
selected dental services to be provided in the future at no
cost or at a discount must conform to the requirements of the
prepaid legal and dental service plans act unless exempted by
statute.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN-
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Mark W. Stafford
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:MWS:bas

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.