Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-107

1989-107Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL August 23, 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89- 107
Steve Kraushaar
Marshall County Attorney
Courthouse
Marysville, Kansas 66508
Re: Counties and County Officers -- County
Commissioners; Powers and Duties -- Access to
Personnel Files
Counties and County Officers -- Sheriff -- Deputies
and Undersheriffs; Personnel Files
Laws, Journals and Public Information -- Records
Open to Public -- Certain Records Not Required to
be Open; Personnel Records, Sheriff's Office
Synopsis: The county sheriff may discretionarily choose to
disclose personnel records maintained and kept by
the sheriff, subject to the exceptions contained in
K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 45-221(a)(4), as amended. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 19-212 Sixth; 19-805; 19-4301;
19-4403; 25-101; 45-215; 45-217; K.S.A. 1988 Supp.
45-221, as amended by L. 1989, ch. 154, § 1.
*
Dear Mr.Kraushaar:
As Marshall County Attorney you request our opinion concerning
whether the board of county commissioners can obtain and
review personnel files of the county sheriff, undersheriff and
deputies. We assume that these personnel files contain the
types of information ordinarily found in personnel files;
applications, references, background information, employee
evaluations, and employer's comments.
K.S.A. 45-215 et seq. contain the Kansas open records act
(KORA). The records of public entities are subject to
KORA, with certain exceptions, unless otherwise provided by
law. K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 45-221(a)(4), as amended by L. 1989,
ch. 154, § 1, discusses personnel files pertaining to public
employees:
"(a) Except to the extent disclosure is
otherwise required by law, a public agency
shall not be required to disclose:
• • •
(4) Personnel records, performance
ratings or individually identifiable
records pertaining to employees or
applicants for employment, except that
this exemption shall not apply to the
names, positions, salaries and lengths of
service of officers and employees of
public agencies once they are employed as
such." (Emphasis added).
As discussed in Attorney General Opinion No. 87-109, although
personnel records are public records, not all public records
are required to be open for public inspection. K.S.A. 1988
Supp. 45-221, as amended, permits personnel records to remain
confidential. The official custodian of personnel records
possesses discretionary authority to allow or prohibit public
access to personnel files. "Official custodian" is defined by
K.S.A. 45-217(d) as "any officer or employee of a public
agency who is responsible for the maintenance of public
records, regardless of whether such records are in the
officer's or employee's actual personal custody or control."
Both the sheriff and the board of county commissioners are
officers of a public agency, the county. However, the sheriff
is responsible for the maintenance of these personnel records
and, thus, may be considered the official custodian of these
personnel files. If the custodian of the records decides to
close these files from public inspection, the issue becomes
whether the board of county commissioners is entitled to
examine these records in their official capacity.
K.S.A. 19-212 Sixth gives the board of county commissioners
the authority to manage the business and concerns of the
county "in all cases where no other provision is made by
law." Kansas law vests general control over county matters in
the board of county commissioners. "The county commissioners
are the general agents of the county. . . ." State v. City
of Garnett, 180 Kan. 405, 407 (1956). However, authority
to manage county affairs may be limited. "The means by which
the county commissioners may discharge the many and varied
duties imposed on them are supplied by statutes, although
occasionally the courts have had to concede that there is a
narrow field in which the doctrine of implied powers must be
permitted to operate. . . . The only implied powers possessed
by such officer or board are those which are necessary for the
effective exercise and discharge of the powers and duties
expressly conferred and imposed." Womer v. Aldridge,
155 Kan. 446, 449 (1942). See also Attorney General
Opinion No. 62-94, Vol. III, p. 243. We are unaware of
any specific statutory or case law granting authority or
dictating that the board of county commissioners keep the
sheriff's personnel files or be given access to these files.
Thus, in order to find that such authority exists, it becomes
necessary to imply such authority from the powers and duties
granted to the board of county commissioners.
K.S.A. 19-4301 et seq. and 19-4403 et seq. discuss the
establishment of certain county employment systems or law
enforcement agencies in counties of a certain population.
Although Marshall county has not adopted such systems, we are
informed that this county has adopted an employee policy
manual. Apparently, this manual does not specifically discuss
access to the sheriff's personnel files by the board of county
commissioners, nor are we convinced that the board could
dictate such a policy if such authority does not otherwise
exist.
County sheriffs are not hired or appointed by the board of
county commissioners. "The sheriff is the state's chief
executive and administrative officer in his county." State
v. McCarty, 104 Kan. 301, 305 (1919). Sheriffs are
selected for their offices by the voters pursuant to a general
election under K.S.A. 25-101 et seq. Personnel in the
office of the sheriff are selected pursuant to K.S.A. 19-805
which vests the authority to hire in the county sheriff. The
sheriff, not the board of county commissioners, is empowered
to hire and fire employees of the county sheriff. Sedgwick
County Commissioners v. Toland, 121 Kan. 190 (1926).
The board of county commissioners may adopt a personnel policy
or agreement affecting policy and pay plans. Attorney General
Opinion No. 84-30. Additionally, any payment of staff by the
sheriff is subject to the budget approved by the board of
county commissioners. Attorney General Opinions No. 87-14 and
87-37. Thus, the board of county commissioners possesses a
limited degree of authority regarding employees of a county
sheriff. However, the authority of the board of county
commissioners to establish employee policies, pay plans and
budgets affecting salaries does not imply an all encompassing
power over the employees of the sheriff. Under Kansas law,
county sheriff's personnel are subject to the control of the
county sheriff. The authority of the sheriff to appoint,
hire, or fire an individual employee may not be altered by the
board of county commissioners. See Attorney General Opinion
No. 80-36. Thus, while the board may implement pay plans or
general employee policies, the county sheriff has the final
decision concerning individual employee matters.
Information contained in the sheriff's personnel files
generally relates to matters over which the sheriff has
control. It appears that the specific personnel files do not
contain information related to matters over which the board of
county commissioners has authority. Thus, in making decisions
within the scope of their authority, the board of county
commissioners does not rely on nor require information
contained in the sheriff's personnel files.
Therefore, pursuant to K.S.A. 45-221(a)(4), as amended, and
subject to the exceptions contained therein, the county
sheriff may discretionarily choose to decline a request by
the board of county commissioners to review sheriff's
personnel files. We do not find any express authority
permitting the board of county commissioners to obtain and
review personnel files of the county sheriff nor can such
authority be implied from the powers and duties vested in the
board. Absent specific facts not present in this situation,
the sheriff may discretionarily deny the board of county
commissioners access to sheriff's employee files.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Theresa Marcel Nuckolls
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TMN:bas

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.