Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-105

1989-105Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL August 15, 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89- 105
Mr. Delton M. Gilliland
Osage County Counselor
112 E. 7th, P.O. Box K
Lyndon, Kansas 66451
Re: Fees and Salaries -- Fees in All Counties and
Salaries in Certain Counties -- Disposition of Fees
and Compensation Not Authorized to be Retained by
Officers and Employees; Diversion Fees
Criminal Procedure -- Kansas Code of Criminal
Procedure; Procedure After Arrest -- Provisions of
Diversion Agreement; Disposition of Diversion Fees
Counties and County Officers -- County Attorney --
Fees, When; Diversion Fees
Synopsis: The county attorney should not retain control of
fees received pursuant to a diversion agreement
except as authorized by the board of county
commissioners in accordance with proper budgetary
procedures. Such fees should initially be paid
over to the county treasurer pursuant to K.S.A.
28-175. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 8-1567,
as amended by L. 1989, ch. 38, §42 and L. 1989, ch.
92, §16; K.S.A. 19-705; 22-2906; 22-2907; 22-2909,
as amended by L. 1989, ch. 95, §6 and L. 1989, ch.
38, §47; K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 28-170; 28-170a;
28-170b; 28-172b; K.S.A. 28-175.
Dear Mr. Gilliland:
As Osage County Counselor you request our opinion concerning
funds received from criminal defendants pursuant to diversion
agreements. You specifically ask that we address the
following:
"1. Who is the proper custodian of fees
so collected, the County Attorney, or the
County Treasurer?
2. Is it proper for a County Attorney to
retain custody of funds collected pursuant
to diversionary agreements exclusive of
the County Treasurer?
3. Is it proper for the County Attorney
to directly make expenditures of such
funds without the approval or order of the
County Commissioners?
4. Is the receipt and expenditure of such
funds by the County Attorney in excess of
receipts and expenditures authorized by
the budget adopted for the current year in
violation of the State's budget law?
5. For what purposes is it proper for the
County Attorney to spend funds comprised
of fees collected from criminal defendants
entering into diversionary agreements?"
K.S.A. 22-2907 permits prosecutors to offer diversion to
certain criminal defendants. K.S.A. 22-2906 defines diversion
and diversion agreement:
"(3) 'Diversion' means referral of a
defendant in a criminal case to a
supervised performance program prior to
adjudication.
(4) 'Diversion agreement' means the
specification of formal terms and
conditions which a defendant must fulfill
in order to have the charges against him
or her dismissed."
K.S.A. 22-2909(a) discusses certain provisions which may be
contained in the diversion agreement:
"The diversion agreement may include, but
is not limited to, provisions concerning
payment of restitution, including court
costs and diversion costs, residence in a
specified facility, maintenance of
gainful employment, and participation in
programs offering medical, educational,
vocational, social and psychological
services, corrective and preventive
guidance and other rehabilitative
services." (Emphasis added).
If the diversion agreement is in lieu of further criminal
proceedings under K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 8-1567, as amended, K.S.A.
22-2909(c) discusses fines under that statute. The statutes
clearly authorize the payment of fees by a criminal defendant
who enters into a diversion agreement. Thus, when entering
into a diversion agreement, a prosecutor may include
requirements concerning the payment of fees by the criminal
defendant. The issue becomes how to properly characterize and
handle the fees thus received.
The statutes do not define or characterize these fees as
compensation to the prosecutor. Rather, they are assessed as
payment for fines, restitution, court costs, or diversion
costs. Many statutes discuss the disposition of fees
collected pursuant to criminal proceedings. See
K.S.A. 28-170 (the clerk of the court shall remit a portion of
court costs payments to the state treasurer); K.S.A. 1988
Supp. 28-170a (the clerk of the court shall pay a portion of
docket fees to the county treasurer for the prosecuting
attorney's fund); and K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 28-172b (the clerk of
the court shall pay a portion of the docket fee to the state
treasurer for the indigent defense services fund).
The statutes do not specifically discuss the proper
disposition of all fees and moneys received pursuant to a
diversion agreement. However, K.S.A. 28-175 provides:
"County officers and employees shall
receive no compensation, tips, fees,
mileage or salaries, which compensation,
tips, fees, mileage or salaries are or
shall be paid to such officer or employee
directly or indirectly by reason of his or
her performance of the duties or
obligations of such county office or
employment, unless such compensation,
tips, fees, mileage or salaries are
specifically allowed to them by law.
All such compensation, tips, fees,
mileage or salaries received, directly or
indirectly by them or from their
respective offices from any source
whatsoever, which compensation, tips,
fees, mileage or salaries would not have
been received except for such officer's or
employee's performance of the duties or
obligations of such county office or
employment, including all notary fees
collected by any officer, deputy or clerk
in any proceeding pending or to become
pending, filed or to be filed in said
office, not specifically authorized to be
retained by them, shall be paid over on
the first and fifteenth days of each
month, or if either of said dates be a
Sunday or legal holiday, then on the next
secular day, to the county treasurer
accompanied by a sworn statement in such
form as the board of county commissioners
may prescribe, to the effect that all
compensation, tips, fees, mileage and
salaries collected are correctly set forth
therein. All such compensation, tips,
fees, mileage and salaries shall be
placed by said treasurer to the credit of
the county general fund." (Emphasis
added).
All funds which come into the hands of a public officer in
Kansas by virtue of their office belong to the state or some
political subdivision of the state and are "public funds".
Mermis v. Jackson, 93 F.2d 579 (10th Cir. 1937).
K.S.A. 19-705 gives further direction to county attorneys
concerning fees from individuals:
"No county attorney shall receive any fee
or reward from or on behalf of any
prosecutor or other individuals, except
such as are allowed by law for services in
attend. . . ." See also Attorney
General Opinion No. 88-50.
Thus, unless specifically allowed to them by law, fees
received by county attorneys as a result of performance of
their official duties should be considered public funds and
thus, pursuant to general county procedures regarding the
proper procedures for handling public funds, should be paid
over to the county treasurer. We find no specific statutory
or common law exempting diversion fees from the provisions of
K.S.A. 28-175 or K.S.A. 19-705. It is therefore our opinion
that the county treasurer is the proper custodian of diversion
fees. Such fees are not controlled by the county attorney
unless such control is authorized by the board of county
commissioners. Diversion fees should be paid over as directed
under K.S.A. 28-175, credited to the general fund, and
thenceforth handled in accordance with budgetary procedures
applicable to all moneys deposited in the county general
fund.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Theresa Marcel Nuckolls
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TMN:bas

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.