Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-090

1989-090Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL July 18, 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89- 90
The Honorable Vernon L. Williams
State Representative, Ninety-First District
2402 Coolidge Avenue
Wichita, Kansas 67204
Re: Constitution of the State of Kansas--Legislative--
Subject and Title of Bills; 1989 House Bill No. 2454
Oil and Gas--Oil and Gas Wells; Regulatory
Provisions, Miscellaneous Regulatory Provisions--
Transportation of Gas; Pressure; Constitutionality
of 1989 House Bill No. 2454
Synopsis: 1989 House Bill No. 2454 pertaining to maintenance
of natural gas pipelines and establishment of the
Citizens' Utility Ratepayer Board (CURB) does not
violate Art. 2, S16 of the Kansas Constitution
which prohibits a bill from containing more than
one subject. Though arguably tenuous, we believe
the sections addressing gas pipeline maintenance
are germane to those creating a board concerned
with the cost of utilities in that both are
encompassed under the subject and title "relating
to public utilities." As such, since the question
of how the bill evolved is not relevant to the
bill's constitutionality, we believe the connection
sufficient to cause the courts to uphold the
legislation as constitutional. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 55-112, as amended by 1989 H.B. 2454; Kan.
Const., Art. 2, 516; 1989 H.B. 2454; 1989 S.B.
105; L. 1982, ch. 144; L. 1985, ch. 48; L. 1982,
ch. 282; L. 1978, ch. 323.
Dear Representative Williams:
As State Representative for the Ninety-First District, you
request our opinion regarding the constitutionality of 1989
House Bill No. 2454. Specifically you inquire whether the
bill contains more than one subject in contravention of
Article 2, §16 of the Kansas Constitution which provides:
"No bill shall contain more than one
subject, except appropriation bills and
bills for revision or codification of
statutes. The subject of each bill shall
be expressed in its title. No law shall
be revived or amended, unless the new act
contain the entire act revived or the
section or sections amended, and the
section or sections so amended shall be
repealed. The provisions of this section
shall be liberally construed to effectuate
the acts of the legislature."
You indicate that 1989 House Bill No. 2454 (H.B. 2454) deals
with first, the transportation or conduct of natural gas
through pipelines and the maintenance of certain pipelines and
second, the establishment of a new state board, the Citizens'
Utility Ratepayer Board (CURB), to represent residential and
small commercial customers before the Kansas Corporation
Commission. You further note that the provisions establishing
the CURB were originally found in 1989 Senate Bill No. 105 and
were amended into H.B. 2454.
The test to determine whether the one subject rule has been
violated involves a review of the legislation to determine
whether a plurality of subject exits. Generally, if an act
embraces two or more dissimilar and discordant subjects, that
by no fair intendment can be considered to have any legitimate
connection with or relation to each other, it violates the one
subject rule. In order to comply with the rule none of the
provisions of an act can be read as relating or germane to any
other subject than the one named in the title. 73 Am.Jur.2d
Statutes, §125; see State v. Reeves, 233 Kan. 972, 978
(1983), where the court applies these general principles as
stated in Am.Jur.2d.
Accordingly, we must review 1989 H.B. No. 2454. The first two
sections amend K.S.A. 55-112 that deals with the
transportation of natural gas by any person, persons, firm,
company or corporation engaged in drilling, piping,
transporting, using or selling natural gas. Section one
incorporates the minimum federal safety standards for the
transportation of natural gas by pipeline found at 49 C.F.R.
part 192 (10-1-88 Edition) by requiring the transportation of
the natural gas through materials listed therein and requiring
pressure testing of the pipe be done in accordance with the
criteria provided therein. Section two adopts the
definitional section found in part 192.3 of the federal code,
charges full responsibility for maintenance of all pipelines
to the public utility, municipal corporation, or
quasi-municipal corporation which renders gas utility service
to residential premises, and excepts cities of the third class
from certain pipeline maintenance responsibilities.
Sections three through six deal with the establishment of a
citizens' utility ratepayer board. Section three sets forth
the composition of the board as consisting of five members
appointed by the Governor with authority to recommend
legislation as well as employ an attorney to [section four]
represent residential and small commercial ratepayers before
the state corporation commission at hearings or in complaint
cases. In addition counsel can intervene in and initiate
cases before the state corporation commission, including rate
increase requests and formal complaint cases. Counsel can
also seek rehearings or judicial review from orders issued.
Section five removes from the Board any authority to take any
action that concerns electric or telephone cooperations with
membership of less than 15,000. Section six provides for the
expiration of sections three through six on July 1, 1991.
In applying the test stated above we must look at how the
Kansas Supreme Court has utilized the test in various
circumstances. The most recent opinion in which the Court
thoroughly examined Art. 2, §16 is State v. Reeves, 233
Kan. 972 (1973). In that case the court discussed the
constitutionality of 1982 Senate Bill No. 699 (L. 1982, ch.
144), entitled as follows:
"'An Act relating to certain alcohol and
drug-related traffic offenses; relating to
penalties for certain prohibited acts;
providing for the establishment of an
alcohol and drug safety action
program; amending'. . . ." 233 Kan. at
973.
The court reviewed each of the 23 sections of the bill to
determine whether it contained more than one subject. The
bill amended the procedures and grounds for suspending
drivers' licenses, established a motor vehicle operator's
implied consent to submit to a blood alcohol test, and set the
procedures for the test. Other provisions concerned the
admission of and weight to be given evidence of drivers' blood
alcohol content, defined "habitual violator", and revised the
penalties for driving under the influence. The bill also
amended several statutes regarding diversion agreements, such
as contents, admissibility into evidence, and violation of
municipal ordinances. A state alcohol and drug safety action
program and fees to fund the program were also established by
the legislation. In addition, 1982 S.B. 699 amended the
statutes governing appeals to the district court.
In ruling that the legislation was constitutional, the court
in Reeves cited State, ex rel. v. Kansas Turnpike
Authority, 176 Kan. 683, 697 (1954), and stated:
"[A]rt. 2, §16, should not be construed
narrowly or technically to invalidate
proper and needful legislation, and that
where the subject of the legislation is
germane to other provisions, the act is
not objectionable as containing more than
the one named in the title." 233 Kan.
at 978.
The court in Reeves concluded as follows:
"These provisions are all germane to the
broad encompassing subject of alcohol and
drug-related traffic offenses. None of
the revisions to existing statutes or
newly enacted provisions contained in the
act can be said to be so diverse or
dissimilar as to have no legitimate
connection or relation to the subject of
alcohol or drug-related traffic
offenses." 233 Kan. at 980. (Emphasis
added.)
In State v. Larson, 12 Kan. App. 2d 198 (1987), 1985
Senate Bill No. 127 (L. 1985, ch. 48), a statute under which
Stanley Larson was convicted for driving with a blood or
breath alcohol concentration of .10 or above was challenged as
unconstitutional for containing more than one subject. In
upholding the legislation, the court without reviewing the
sections of the legislation quoted from State v. Reeves:
"All of the revisions to existing statutes and newly enacted
provisions contained in the act relate in some way to the
comprehensive subject of alcohol and drug-related traffic
offenses and prosecution thereof." 233 Kan. at 979. The
title of the bill read as follows:
"An Act relating to certain alcohol and
drug related offenses involving motor
vehicles; concerning certain tests related
thereto and providing penalties for
refusal to submit thereto; prohibiting
certain acts and providing penalties for
violations; concerning diversion of
certain prosecutions and conditions
thereof. . . ."
Clearly the court in this case found the provisions of this
act germane to one comprehensive subject.
In State ex rel. Stephan v. Board of Lyon County
Comm'rs, 234 Kan. 732 (1984), it was argued that L. 1982,
ch. 282 contained more than one subject because the bill dealt
with out-district tuition for community colleges and the
municipal university, and also contained a provision that such
institutions could enter into agreements with state agencies
to provide instruction for payment. The court found that the
act did "not offend article 2, section 16" because the
provision in question did concern out-district tuition when
the state pays for the instruction, rendering all the sections
of the bill as concerned with the single subject of the
financing of community colleges and municipal universities.
The defendant also argued that Art. 2, §16 was violated
because the legislature consolidated several bills into the
act at the close of the session. In rejecting this argument,
the court stated:
"There is absolutely no indication,
however, that a matter of legislative
merit was tied to an unworthy matter or
that matters have no relation to each
other were intermixed. No legislative
history or extrinsic evidence of how the
act evolved is necessary or relevant where
the act contains no unrelated or unworthy
matters and is clear on its face."
(Emphasis added.) 234 Kan. at 740.
Hence, a determination that more than one subject exists in
the legislation needs to be made from the legislation, without
considering how the act evolved.
However, once two subjects have been found, legislative
history may be used to support the violation. The Court found
two subjects in State ex rel. Stephan v. Thiessen, 228
Kan. 136 (1980), when asked whether 1978 House Bill No. 3129
(L. 1978, ch. 323) violated the one subject rule. The first
four sections of the bill enacted new statutes concerning
release on recognizance and supervised released programs. The
remaining two-thirds of the bill dealt with the Kansas law
enforcement training center and its funding. Focusing on the
original titles to the two bills in question the court noted
that one bill was defeated by the Senate, before the two bills
were merged. In Thiessen the title of the bill in
question read "An Act relating to crimes, authorizing certain
release on recognizance and supervised release programs and
procedures; amending and supplementing the Kansas law
enforcement training center and advisory commission act;
amending . . . ." 228 Kan. at 137. The court ruled that
the bill was unconstitutional:
"These are two separate subjects which
cannot lawfully be united under the broad
title 'crimes.' Significantly, no crimes
are defined in the act and no provision in
the act amends or alters the Kansas
Criminal Code which is located in Chapter
21 of the Kansas statutes." 228 Kan. at
143-144.
While these constitute only a few of the cases where
legislation has been challenged under the one subject rule,
they establish important principles: the legislation must be
considered on its face; it must relate or be germane to that
expressed in the title; if all the topics in the act relate or
are germane to each, there is no relevance given to how the
legislation evolved. (See also Attorney General Opinion
No. 88-74).
Applying the principles the courts have used to determine
whether a bill contains more that one subject, we find that
1989 H.B. 2454 meets the one-subject requirement of Art. 2,
§16. The test of compliance with the constitutional mandate
of singleness of subject is that "none of the provisions of an
act can be read as relating or germane to any other subject
than the one named in the title." State v. Reeves, 223
Kan. at 978. The title of H.B. 2454 reads as follows: "An
Act concerning public utilities; relating to natural gas;
establishing the citizens' utility ratepayer board; amending
K.S.A. 55-112 and repealing the existing section." The title
in question states that the bill contains subject matter that
concerns public utilities. Unlike Thiessen where the bill
erroneously stated the legislation concerned "crimes," both
the bills combined in the final version of 1989 H.B. 2454
concern public utilities. The connection, however tenuous,
between the maintenance of pipelines transporting natural gas
and a board concerned with the cost of utilities is that both
these topics relate to public utilities. Therefore, based on
recent court decisions we must conclude that 1989 House Bill
No. 2454 does not violate Art. 2, §16 of the Kansas
Constitution.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Guen Easley
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:GE:jm

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.