Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-173

1988-173Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL December 28, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 173
Mr. Ronald S. Reuter
Roeland Park City Attorney
P.O. Box 7933
Overland Park, Kansas 66207
Re: Cities of the Second Class--Elections--Elective and
Appointive Officers; Terms; Compensation
Synopsis: Pursuant to ordinances of the city of Roeland
Park, the duties of the city attorney must be
prescribed by ordinance passed by the governing
body. Accordingly, where no ordinance prescribes
that the city attorney shall represent city
officers who are sued in an individual capacity
(for actions they have taken in their official
capacities), the city attorney may refuse to
represent such city officials, and such refusal is
not a cause for removal from office. If, at the
direction of the governing body, and in the absence
of any fee agreement with an individual official,
the Roeland Park City Attorney voluntarily
undertakes the defense of a city officer who has
been sued in an individual capacity, it is our
opinion that he is to be compensated at the hourly
rate established for services provided for the
city. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 75-6108.
Dear Mr. Reuter:
As city attorney of Roeland Park, you request our opinion
concerning your obligation to represent city officials who are
sued in an individual capacity. Specifically, your questions
are as follows:
"1. Is a City Attorney obligated under the law to represent
city officials that are sued in an individual capacity for
actions they have taken in their official capacities if such
defense is directed by the City Council?
"2. In the absence of an apparent conflict of interest, is a
City Attorney who refuses to represent a city official subject
to removal from office for cause?
"3. Is a City Attorney, who is not an employee of the city,
who at the direction of the City Council undertakes the
defense of a city officials who have been sued in an
individual capacity for actions taken in an official capacity,
obligated to provide that defense at the hourly rate
established for the City Attorney for services provided for
the City."
In regard to the first and second questions quoted above,
Charter Ordinance No. 5 of the city of Roeland Park
prescribes that the city council "shall by ordinary ordinance
specify the duties and compensation" of the city attorney, and
section 1-312 of the city code sets forth the duties of the
city attorney as follows:
"CITY ATTORNEY. The city attorney shall:
"(a) Attend meetings of the city council
when so directed to attend by the city
council;
"(b) Advise the city council and all
officers of the city upon such legal
questions affecting the city and its
offices as may be submitted to him or her;
"(c) When requested by the city council
give opinions in writing upon any such
questions;
"(d) Draft such ordinances, contracts,
leases, easements, conveyances and other
instruments in writing as may be submitted
to him or her in the regular transaction
of affairs of the city;
"(e) Approve all ordinances of the city as
to form and legality;
"(f) Attend planning commission and board
of zoning appeals meetings when so
directed by the boards;
"(g) Prosecute municipal violations and
all other matters before the municipal
court, except when such violations or
matters are prosecuted by the assistant
city attorney.
"(h) Perform such other duties as may be
prescribed by the governing body and the
Kansas statutes."
Additionally, another ordinance provides that the Roeland
Park City Attorney shall be compensated "$60.00 per hour for
services provided the city."
In construing an ordinance which prescribes the duties of a
city attorney, the courts will not "strain words to exclude
anything a city attorney ought ordinarily to do." Johnson v.
Winfield, 75 Kan. 832, 833 (1907). However, we are
unaware of any Kansas case which states that a city attorney
should, as an inherent duty of his office, defend officers who
are sued in their individual capacity. In this regard,
subsection (b) of K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 75-6108 prescribes that a
city may provide for the defense of city officers by the city
attorney, by employing other counsel, or by purchasing
insurance which requires that the insurer provide the defense.
In regard to defense of city officials in Roeland Park, it
is our opinion that charter ordinance no. 5 of the city of
Roeland Park and section 1-312 of the city code are
ordinances which are in pari materia and therefore must be
read to together and harmonized. See Capital Services,
Inc. v. Dahlinger Pontiac-Cadillac, 232 Kan. 419, 422
(1982); Phillips v. Vieux, 210 Kan. 612, 617 (1972).
Accordingly, in light of the requirement of charter ordinance
no. 5 that duties of the city attorney shall be specified by
ordinary ordinance, subsection (h) of section 1-312 of the
city code must be read as authorizing the governing body to
prescribe "other duties" of the city attorney by ordinance.
Where no ordinance prescribes that the city attorney shall
represent city officers who are sued in an individual
capacity, it is our opinion that the city attorney may refuse
to represent such city officials, and such refusal is not a
cause for removal from office.
In response to your third question, it is our opinion that if,
at the direction of the governing body (such direction being
other than by ordinance), and in the absence of any fee
agreement with an individual officer, the Roeland Park City
Attorney undertakes the defense of a city official who has
been sued in an individual capacity, he is to be compensated
at the hourly rate established for service provided for the
city.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TRH:jm

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.