Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-161

1988-161Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL November 16, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88-161
Earl E. Gatz, Secretary
Board of Veterinary Examiners
R.R. 1
Pratt, Kansas 67124
Re: Livestock and Domestic Animals -- Registration of
Veterinarians -- Practice of Veterinary Medicine;
Pregnancy Diagnosis; Embryo Transfers
Synopsis: Manual pregnancy testing and embryo transfer in
cattle constitute the practice of veterinary
medicine. A person must be a licensed veterinarian
to perform these procedures unless the person is
exempt from licensure pursuant to K.S.A. 47-817.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 47-814; 47-816; 47-817;
47-834.
Dear Dr. Gatz:
As Secretary for the Board of Veterinary Examiners (Board),
you have requested our opinion whether certain procedures
performed by non-licensed persons violate the Kansas
veterinary practice act, K.S.A. 47-814 et seq.
The practice of veterinary medicine is defined in K.S.A.
47-816(g) as meaning any of the following:
"(1) To diagnose, treat, correct, change,
relieve, or prevent disease, deformity,
defect, injury or other physical or mental
condition of any animal.
(2) To prescribe or administer any drug,
medicine, biologic, apparatus,
application, anesthetic or other
therapeutic or diagnostic substance or
technique on any animal.
(3) To use any manual or mechanical
procedure for testing for pregnancy, for
correcting or testing for sterility or
infertility or to render advice or
recommendation with regard to any of the
same on any animal.
(4) To represent, directly or indirectly,
publicly or privately, an ability and
willingness to do any act described in
paragraph (1), (2) or (3) of this
subsection.
(5) To use any title, words, abbreviation
or letters in a manner or under
circumstances which represent or imply
that the person using them is qualified
and licensed to do any act described in
paragraph (1), (2) or (3) of this
subsection."
Only persons who are licensed veterinarians or hold a
temporary permit issued by the Board may practice veterinary
medicine. K.S.A. 47-817; K.S.A. 47-834. The act, however,
creates several exemptions from the licensure requirement.
For example, the owner of an animal or employee of the owner
is exempted from licensure in the care and treatment of the
owner's animal. K.S.A. 47-817(f). Persons employed by and
under the direct supervision of a veterinarian are also exempt
from licensure. K.S.A. 47-817(j). Another exception, K.S.A.
47-817(b), provides that a non-licensed person may in effect
practice veterinary medicine if the "person [is] advising with
respect to or [is] performing acts which are accepted
livestock management practices."
Your first question is whether the practice or art of manually
diagnosing pregnancy in cattle constitutes the practice of
veterinary medicine or whether it is an accepted livestock
management practice. We believe it is clear under K.S.A.
47-816(g)(3) that manual pregnancy testing is the practice of
veterinary medicine. It is argued, however, that this
activity is an accepted livestock management practice and
therefore non-licensed persons may perform such testing.
This same question was presented to us in Attorney General
Opinion No. 76-213. We agree with the legal analysis in that
opinion and adopt its conclusion:
"We understand that in the generic sense
pregnancy diagnosis is in fact a widely
'accepted livestock management practice,'
and that it is based upon detection of the
physiological changes of the genital
organs associated with pregnancy through
the employment of either manual or
mechanical testing procedures. To contend
that this scientific examination of cattle
should be considered within the exception
granted per K.S.A. 47-817(b) carries the
resultant, logical corollary that since
the diagnosis and treatment of injuries to
cattle is also an accepted livestock
management practice, the unlicensed lay
person should be permitted to perform this
function as well. In other words by using
the broad exception under K.S.A. 47-817(b)
the provisions of the Kansas Veterinary
Practice Act may be circumvented in the
name of 'accepted livestock management
practices.' Such an interpretation is
untenable.
"The term 'livestock management practice'
as used in the act encompasses a broad
spectrum of activities employed in the
control of livestock. However, to go so
far as to construe this term to encompass
in toto the practice of veterinary
medicine would destroy the purpose of the
act. In my judgment the legislature has
clearly identified what is not to be
included in the term 'livestock
management' by delineating specifically
the activities to be controlled under the
act. . . .
"[T]he purpose and intent of the act is
clearly identified for the purpose of the
instant inquiry by the definition provided
in K.S.A. 47-816(g)(3): only a licensed
veterinarian is permitted in this state to
test for and diagnose animal pregnancy.
"Accordingly, it is the opinion of this
office that the Kansas Veterinary Practice
Act specifically prohibits non-licensed
individuals from testing for and
diagnosing the state of pregnancy in
animals which they do not own."
You also ask whether embryo transfer is part of veterinary
medicine. Embryo transfer is the art of removing a fertilized
ova or ovum from the reproductive tract of a genetically
superior animal (donor) and the transfer of the ovum to the
reproductive tract of an animal of the same species and of
lesser genetic quality (surrogate) for gestation and birth."
At this time embryo transfers are performed primarily on
cattle. Embryo transfers may be done surgically or
nonsurgically. It is beyond question that the surgical
procedure constitutes the practice of veterinary medicine.
We understand that nonsurgical embryo transfers generally
involve the following steps: (1) administering drugs to the
donor animal to induce superovulation (production of more
than one egg in the ovary at one time); (2) administering
hormones to induce oestrus synchronization between the donor
and surrogate animals (to ensure the animals are in heat at
the appropriate times); (3) artificial or natural insemination
of the donor with genetically superior semen; (4)
administering an anesthetic to the animals prior to the
collection procedure; (5) sterilizing various instruments; (6)
using a cervical dilation rod to dilate the cervixes of the
donor and surrogate animals; (7) palpation of the donor cow's
ovaries (also done at the time of breeding); (8) inserting the
collection apparatus through the cervix of the donor into the
uterine horn; (9) infusion of a media (liquid solution) to aid
in collection; (10) loading the embryo into a straw in the
collection apparatus by positioning the apparatus and
palpation; (11) evaluating the embryo; (12) transferring the
embryo to the surrogate animal; (13) administering antibiotics
to the animals.
Embryo transfer in bovines may be an accepted practice in
livestock production to produce superior offspring. However,
we believe such procedures must be performed by a licensed
veterinarian as such procedures are defined by statute as the
practice of veterinary medicine. K.S.A. 47-816(g)(2) clearly
provides that administering drugs and medicines is the
practice of veterinary medicine. Many of the drugs involved
in preforming an embryo transfer can only be used by licensed
veterinarians. In addition, the procedures as summarized
above fall under K.S.A. 47-816(g)(1) as the physical condition
of the animal is changed. The fact that a procedure, such as
embryo transfer or manual pregnancy testing, is an accepted
practice in the industry does not negate the licensure
requirement for the person performing the procedure if such
has been defined as the practice of veterinary medicine.
In summary, manual pregnancy testing and embryo transfer in
cattle constitute the practice of veterinary medicine. A
person must be a licensed veterinarian to perform these
procedures unless the person is exempt from the licensure
requirement by K.S.A. 47-817.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:bas

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.