Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-105

1988-105Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL July 19, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 105
The Honorable Bill Graves
Secretary of State
2nd Floor, State Capitol
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Elections -- Voting Machines -- Voting Machine
Requirements; "Write-in" Votes
Synopsis: A voting machine meets the requirement of providing
facilities for write-in votes if it provides a key
board on which a voter may "type" a write-in
candidate's name. Cited herein: K.S.A. 25-1307;
25-1308; 25-1310; 25-1330.
*
Dear Secretary Graves:
As Secretary of State for Kansas, you are the chief election
officer of the state. In this capacity, you request our
opinion on a question regarding voting machines.
The statutes concerning voting machines are located at K.S.A.
25-1307 et seq. K.S.A. 25-1308 states that "no kind or
make of voting machine shall be used at any election . . .
unless and until it shall have been approved by the secretary
of state. . . ." Voting machines must meet the requirements
listed in K.S.A. 25-1310, which includes the following:
"(8)[A kind or make of voting machine] must
provide facilities for 'write-in' votes. . . ."
You have been asked to certify a voting machine which provides
facilities for "write-in" votes by providing a key board on
which a "write-in" candidate's name may be typewritten if
desired. You ask our opinion whether a typewritten "write-in"
candidate's name would be a valid vote cast.
The term "write-in" is not defined. In Attorney General
Opinion No. 84-99 we were asked whether a label or sticker
containing the name of a candidate thereon attached to an
official ballot by a person wishing to vote for a "write-in"
candidate would constitute a valid vote. In concluding that
such votes would be valid, we stated:
"Although two Kansas statutes contained in
the chapter dealing with elections provide
that electors wishing to vote for a
write-in candidate shall 'write' the vote
in the provided space (K.S.A. 25-213,
25-2903), other statutes in the same
chapter allow electors to 'insert' (K.S.A.
25-612, 25-2021, 25-2116) or 'affix' such
votes. (K.S.A. 25-1330). No statute
specifically prohibits the use of prepared
stickers or labels which contain the name
of a candidate who is conducting a
write-in campaign. Where such a sticker
or label is attached to a ballot in such a
manner as to make the intent of the voter
clear, a valid vote has been case and the
expression of the voter's will should be
given effect." (Emphasis added).
Among the statutes concerning voting machines is K.S.A.
25-1330. One year after the above-cited Attorney General
opinion, this statute was amended by the legislature as
follows:
"Ballots voted for any person whose name
does not appear on the machine as a
nominated candidate for office are herein
referred to as write-in ballots. All
write-in ballots voted shall be deposited,
written or affixed in a single receptacle
or device and the elector may vote in or
by such receptacle or device for one or
more persons whose names doe not appear
upon the machine with or without the names
of one or more persons whose names do so
appear. A write-in ballot must be
east shall be handwritten and cast by
the voter or by a person authorized by
K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 25-2909, and
amendments thereto, in its appropriate
place on the machine or it shall be void
and not counted." L. 1985, ch. 119,
14.
The statute now requires write-in votes by voters using voting
machines to be "handwritten and cast by the voter." To
determine whether a voting machine meets the statutory
requirement of providing facilities for write-in votes by
providing a key board for the voter to "type" the person's
name, an examination of the legislature's intent in amending
K.S.A. 25-1330 is necessary.
K.S.A. 25-1330 was amended by 1985 Senate Bill No. 272 (L.
1985, ch. 119, § 14). This amendment, however, had its
genesis in 1985 House Bill No. 2536, § 3. Testimony regarding
H.B. 2536 was presented to the House elections committee on
March 7th. (Minutes, House Committee on Elections, March 7,
1985). The provisions of this bill were amended into 1985
Senate Bill No. 315 on March 26th after H.B. 2536 was
stricken from the House calendar. (1985 House Journal, p.
642). S.B. 315 also concerned "candidates' names on ballots
and write-in candidates." The last action on S.B. 315 was the
failure of the House to accept a conference committee report.
(1985 House Journal, p. 880). The proposed amendment to
K.S.A. 25-1330, however, did not die with S.B. 315. A third
bill, S.B. 272, concerning election matters was also before
the legislature. During a conference committee meeting on
S.B. 272, the language of H.B. 2536, § 3, amending K.S.A.
25-1330, was added to the bill in section 14. (1985 Senate
Journal, p. 691).
As noted earlier, testimony on H.B. 2536, § 3, was presented
to the House elections committee on March 7th. No other
legislative committee received testimony on the 1985 amendment
to K.S.A. 25-1330 because of the manner in which this item
became law via amendment to S.B. 272. The pertinent minutes
of the March 7th meeting provide as follows:
"HB 2536, An Act relating to elections;
concerning candidates' names on ballots,
was next up for hearing. The Chair
recognized Eric Rucker, Secretary of
State's office.
"Attention was drawn to Section 3 of HB
2536 which concerns a problem that
developed when individuals began to
utilize stickers to cast votes for
write-in candidates on voting machines.
There are numerous problems when stickers
are placed on voting machines, but the
largest problem of placing stickers on the
tape or roll which contain all write-in
candidates, can cause the machine to
malfunction.
At this time a letter from the Attorney
General's office was handed out to
committee members. This letter highly
suggests that legislation be passed
instead of trying to accomplish these
concerns by Rules and Regulations.
(Attachment 1).
Chairperson Harper now recognized
Charlotte Hargis, Johnson County Kansas,
who came before the committee regarding
the elimination of stickers on voting
machines. She passed samples of these
stickers that are used on the voting
machines in her area. She stated that she
thought the big question was whether or
not the committee believed in write ins."
(Minutes, House Elections Committee, March
7, 1985).
Attached is a copy of the letter referred to in the above
minutes written by the Attorney General's office. The letter
suggested that policies concerning casting write-in votes on
voting machines be by statute rather than by regulation.
In our opinion, the voting machine in question meets the
requirement of K.S.A. 25-1310(8). It appears that the intent
of amending this provision was to provide that write-in
ballots could not be "affixed" when voting machines are used.
This was in response to the problem that developed when labels
or stickers used to cast "write-in" ballots caused voting
machines to malfunction. The technology of the machine in
question, which provides a keyboard to "type" the write-in
candidates name, was not available when this statute was
written or amended. It is apparent that the "handwritten"
requirement is not intended for authenticating a write-in
vote. If that were the legislative intent, an alternate
conclusion would be necessary. However, authentication of a
vote is accomplished through other provisions in K.S.A.
25-1310 and various statutes concerning voting machines.
Therefore, our opinion that a write-in vote entered by a
keyboard mechanism is not in violation of K.S.A. 25-1330 is
not inconsistent with the legislative intent of L. 1985, Ch.
119, § 14.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:bas
Attachment
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL February 15, 1985
The Honorable Jack H. Brier
Secretary of State,
State Capitol, 2nd Floor
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Regulation 7-21-3
Dear Secretary Brier:
The Attorney General has approved regulation number 7-21-3
regarding casting write-in votes on voting machines which are
approved by your office. The regulation is authorized by K.S.A.
25-1312 which requires the Secretary of State to issue rules and
regulations pertaining to the use of voting machines.
Although we are able to approve the regulation, it is our opinion
that the issues and problems addressed therein may be more
adequately and appropriately addressed through legislation. We
would urge you to seek appropriate legislative changes to
accommodate these concerns.
Thank you for your cooperation.
Very truly yours,
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
ROBERT T. Stephan
Mary F. Carson
Assistant Attorney General
MFC:crw

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.