Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-096

1988-096Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL. July 8, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 96
David E. Retter, City Attorney
City of Concordia
213 W. Sixth, P.O. Box 676
Concordia, Kansas 66901
Re: Public Health--Emergency Medical Services--
Counties
Synopsis: A county is not required to provide ambulance
services. If the county does provide services, it
may not do so in any part of the county in which a
taxing district already provides ambulance
services, but must reimburse the taxing district a
proportionate share of funds determined pursuant to
statute. Cited herein: K.S.A. 19-261; L. 1988,
ch. 261, §§12, 13 (to be codified at K.S.A. 65-6112
and K.S.A. 65-6113).
Dear Mr. Retter:
As City Attorney for the City of Concordia, you have requested
our opinion concerning L. 1988, ch. 261 (1988 Subs. for H.B.
2639, to be codified at K.S.A. 65-6112 and K.S.A. 65-6113).
That act allows municipalities, as defined by section 12(p) of
the act, to establish, operate and maintain an emergency
medical or ambulance service. Specifically, you inquire
whether a county may defeat the duty to reimburse a taxing
district within the county for expenses incurred by such
taxing district operating an emergency medical or ambulance
service by not budgeting either general fund or special levy
moneys for ambulance services within the county.
Your question arises from the language of section 13 of the
act. Subsection (a) authorizes a municipality to establish,
operate and maintain an emergency medical or ambulance
service. A municipality is defined by section 12(p) as a
"city, county, township, fire district or ambulance service
district." Funding for the service may be provided using
money from the general fund or from a special fund for which a
maximum three mill tax is levied pursuant to section 13(b).
L. 1988, ch. 261, §13(a). Subsection (d) states in part:
"In the case of a county, the board of
county commissioners shall not provide
ambulance service under the provisions of
this act in any part of the county which
receives ambulance service, but the county
shall reimburse any taxing district which
on the effective date of this act provides
ambulance services to such district with
its proportionate share of the county
general fund or special tax levy fund
budgeted for ambulance services within the
county. . . ." L. 1988, ch. 261, §13(d).
You ask whether the county could circumvent this section by
not budgeting moneys for ambulance services from the general
fund or special tax levy fund, even though the reimbursement
provisions are preceded by mandatory language.
In Reeves v. Board of Johnson County Comm'rs, 226 Kan.
397 (1979), the Court applied the rule of statutory
construction in holding that a duly noticed public hearing is
a prerequisite to a township's zoning board's recommendation,
stating,
"[w]here a statute is susceptible to more
than one construction, it must be given
that construction which, when considered
in its entirety, gives expression to its
intent and purpose, even though such
construction is not within the strict
literal interpretation of the statute."
226 Kan. at 402.
We believe that, in considering the act in its entirety, the
apparent mandatory language can be placed in proper context.
The act does not place a duty on counties to provide ambulance
services. The language of section 13(a) is nearly parallel to
the repealed language of K.S.A. 19-261 (Ensley, 1981). We
opined in Kansas Attorney General Opinion No. 82-163 that
providing ambulance services was discretionary. We find no
language in the new act which requires an alternate outcome.
The reimbursement provisions apply only when the county
actually provides such a service. Subsection 13(d) therefore
requires reimbursement to the taxing district supplying the
service that the county would be providing but for the other
municipality's efforts. This avoids a duplication of effort
on the part of various units of government. If, on the other
hand, the county elects not to budget general fund money or
special fund money derived from the authorized mill levy, then
such determination would be based on the decision not to
provide the service in the county, and subsection 13(d) would
not apply.
In conclusion, it is our opinion that a county is not required
to provide ambulance services. If the county does provide the
services, it may not do so in any part of the county in which
a taxing district already provides ambulance services, but
must reimburse the taxing district a proportionate share of
funds determined pursuant to statute.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Mark W. Stafford
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:MWS:bas

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.