Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-072

1988-072Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL May 20, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 72
The Honorable Joe Knopp
State Representative, Sixty-Seventh District
1201 Houston
Manhattan, Kansas 66502
Re: Courts -- Supreme Court -- Supreme Court Nominating
Commission; Appointment of Non-Lawyer Members
Synopsis: An appointed non-lawyer member may not continue
membership on the judicial nominating committee
once that member has been granted a temporary
permit to practice law. Cited herein: K.S.A.
20-119; 20-120, 20-123; 20-124; 20-125; 20-127;
Supreme Court Rule 705.
Dear Representative Knopp:
As Representative for the Sixty-Seventh District you ask our
opinion on a matter concerning the Kansas supreme court
nominating commission. You wish to know the definition of
"non-lawyer" for purposes of serving on that commission.
K.S.A. 20-124 provides for the appointment of non-lawyer
members to the supreme court nominating commission.
Conversely, K.S.A. 20-120 through 20-123 provide for the
election of lawyer members to the Commission. Based on the
information you have provided, the issue at hand concerns an
appointed non-lawyer member who, subsequent to appointment,
graduated from law school and obtained a temporary license
pending the bar examination and receipt of the results of that
exam.
Supreme Court Rule 705, 1987 Supp., Article 20, Chapter 30,
allows the issuance of a temporary permit to practice law. If
the Supreme Court issues such a permit, the permittee may
legally engage in all activities normally connected with the
practice of law: i.e. preparing legal documents, appearing
on behalf of clients in court giving legal advice, etc.
The practice of law has been generally defined as "the
rendition of services requiring the knowledge and the
application of legal principles and technique to serve the
interest of another with his consent." Blacks Law Dictionary
1054 (5th ed. 1979). Kansas case law discusses what
activities represent the practice of law:
"As the term is generally understood, the
practice of law is the doing or performing
of services in a court of justice, in any
matter depending therein, throughout its
various stages, and in conformity to the
adopted rules of procedure. But in a
larger sense it includes legal advice and
counsel, and the preparation of legal
instruments and contracts by which legal
rights are secured, although such matter
may or may not be depending in a court."
State v. Schumacher, 214 Kan. 1 (1974).
See also Depew v. Wichita
Association of Credit Men, 142 Kan.
403, 412 (1935); State v. Hill, 223
Kan. 425, 436 (1978).
"One who confers with clients, advises
them as to their legal rights, and then
takes the business to an attorney and
arranges with him to look after it in
court is engaged in the practice of law."
State ex rel. v. Perkins, 138 Kan.
899, 907 (1934). See also State v.
Schmidt, 174 Kan. 581, 588 (1953).
A person holding a temporary permit issued by the Kansas
Supreme Court authorizing the practice of law until the next
bar examination is not irregularly admitted to practice law,
but rather is "a regularly qualified practicing attorney."
Moore v. Wesley, 125 Kan. 22 (1928). See also 7
C.J.S. Attorney & Client, § 25 (1980). A person who
performs legal services without a temporary permit or a
license could be found guilty of practicing law without a
license.
Thus, it is our opinion that a person is a regularly qualified
attorney when they have been granted a temporary permit to
practice law pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 705. Because such
a person is a regularly qualified attorney that person can be
considered a lawyer, albeit for a temporary period of time.
Thus they would not qualify for appointment as a non-lawyer
member of the supreme court nominating commission.
This conclusion, however, does not necessarily resolve the
question of whether K.S.A. 20-119 et seq. thereby requires
such a person to resign his or her appointment to the
nominating committee. In order to qualify for appointment,
pursuant to K.S.A. 20-124, an individual must be a
non-lawyer. A person practicing law does not qualify for such
appointment. However, qualification requirements are not
necessarily continuous in nature.
All statutes must be interpreted and applied according to
plain meaning of language used and intent of the legislature.
Earth Scientists Ltd. v. U.S. Fidelity & Guar. Co., 619 F.
Supp. 1465 (Kan. 1985). It is not clear from the plain
language contained in the act what results when there is a
change in status from non-lawyer to lawyer. In the absence of
plain language, statutory construction rules dictate that
when intent can be ascertained from the statute the purpose
and intent of the legislature governs. Harris Enterprises,
Inc. v. Moore, 241 Kan. 59 (1987).
K.S.A. 20-119 et seq. clearly contemplates a nominating
committee made up of a proportionate distribution of lawyers
and non-lawyers. K.S.A. 20-125 sets forth the term held by
all members of the nominating committee:
"Except for those appointed to fill
vacancies all terms of office for members
of the commission subsequently elected or
appointed shall be for as many years as
there are, at the time of their election
or appointment, congressional districts in
the state."
K.S.A. 20-127 allows this term to be cut short and addresses
the effect of a change of a member's status after the
appointment or selection. The statute discusses three status
changes which divest committee membership: (1) when a lawyer
member ceases to be a member of the bar;(2) when any member
changes residence to a district other than the one he was
elected or appointed to represent;or (3) if the chairman moves
out of the state. The act does not specifically address the
status change from non-lawyer to lawyer. However, logic
dictates that if a lawyer who ceases to be a lawyer cannot be
a member, the opposite is also true. A hypothetical situation
could arise where all appointed non-lawyer members
subsequently change their status to lawyers. If this status
change would not affect membership on the committee it could
result in a committee made up of all lawyers. The act
obviously does not intend such a situation.
Therefore, it is our opinion that the legislative intent
evidenced in K.S.A. 20-119 et seq. does not permit an
appointed non-lawyer member to continue membership on the
judicial nominating committee once that member becomes a
lawyer. As Kansas case law recognizes that the holder of a
temporary permit is a regularly admitted attorney, such a
permittee no longer qualifies for non-lawyer membership on the
judicial nominating committee.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Theresa Marcel Nuckolls
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TMN:bas

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.