Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-061

1988-061Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL	
May 4, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 61
Otis W. Morrow
City Attorney
P.O. Box 1146
Arkansas City, KS 67005
Re: Laws, Journals and Public Information -- Records
Open to Public -- Names and Salaries of Municipal
Hospital Employees
Synopsis: The Arkansas City Memorial Hospital is a "public
agency" under the Kansas Open Records Act as it is
an instrumentality of a political subdivision of
the state. The KORA requires that the names of
employees of public agencies and their salaries be
disclosed to the public upon request. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 14-601c; 14-602; 14-609; 45-215;
45-216; 45-217; 45-221.
Dear Mr. Morrow:
As the attorney for the city of Arkansas City, you request our
opinion concerning the Kansas open records act, K.S.A. 45-215
et s2a . You state that a local newspaper has requested
the Arkansas City Memorial Hospital to make available a list
of the twenty-five highest paid hospital employees. We assume
the request also asks for the salaries of these employees.
The Kansas open records act (KORA) declares it to be the
policy of this state that public records of public agencies
"shall be open for inspection by any person. . . ." K.S.A.
45-216(a). The KORA further provides that the act is to be
liberally construed and applied to promote the public policy
of openness. K.S.A. 45-216(a); Harris Enterprises, Inc. v.
Moore, 241 Kan. 59, 63 (1987). "Public agency" is defined
in the KORA as follows:
"'Public agency' means the state or any
political or taxing subdivision of the
state, or any office, officer, agency or
instrumentality thereof, or any other
entity receiving or expending and
supported in whole or in part by public
funds appropriated by the state or by
public funds of any political or taxing
subdivision of the state." K.S.A.
45-217(e)(1).
We understand that the Arkansas City Memorial Hospital was
established pursuant to K.S.A. 14-601c et seq. K.S.A.
14-602 provides that the governing body of any city of the
second class may levy a property tax to acquire a site and
build a hospital in the city. You inform us that Arkansas
City has never levied a tax for the city hospital. Therefore,
you ask whether the hospital must comply with the records
request "since all of the Hospital expenses are paid from
Hospital revenues and not from public tax dollars."
The definition of public agency in K.S.A. 45-217(e)(1) does
not require a body to receive, expend, or be supported by
public funds to be a public entity subject to the KORA.
Rather, the public funding language is in the alternative. A
body is a public agency if it meets one of two tests: (1) the
body is the state, a political or taxing subdivision of the
state, or an instrumentality of one of these entities, or
(2) the body receives or expends and is supported in whole or
in part by public funds. Since Arkansas City Memorial
Hospital is not supported by public funds, the question is
whether the hospital is an instrumentality of a political or
taxing subdivision. See Frederickson, Letting the
Sunshine In: An Analysis of the 1984 Kansas Open Records
Act, 33 U. Kan. L. Rev. 205, 206 (1985).
The Kansas legislature has not defined the term
"instrumentality" by statute, nor have the Kansas courts
judicially defined the term. In Attorney General Opinion No.
77-377 it was noted that the word is derived from "instrument"
which is defined in Webster's New Third International
Dictionary as "a means whereby something is achieved,
performed, or furthered. . . ."
A case which is analogous to the issue before us is Mallory
v. White, 8 F. Supp. 989 (1934). The question in that case
was whether the Boston City Hospital was an instrumentality of
the city of Boston. The issue was important for tax purposes,
as the federal government does not tax instrumentalities of a
state government. The court held that the city hospital was
an "instrumentality" since it was established and maintained
"for the reception of persons who by misfortune or poverty may
require relief during temporary sickness." 8 F. Supp. at
992. The court based its decision on application of the test
set out in Bolster v. City of Lawrence, 114 N.E. 722, 724
(1917):
"The underlying test is whether the act is
for the common good of all without the
element of special corporate benefit or
pecuniary profit."
See Gaither v. Fulton-DeKalb Hosp. Auth., 240 S.E.
2d 560, 562 (1977) (The court held that a local hospital
authority was an instrumentality of the state.)
In the present situation, the city hospital was established
pursuant to K.S.A. 14-601c et seq.:
"Every hospital established under this act
shall be for the benefit of all the
inhabitants of said city, and of any
person falling sick or being injured or
maimed within its limits, but every such
inhabitant or person who is not a pauper
shall pay to the board of hospital
trustees, or such officer as it shall
designate for such city hospital, a
reasonable compensation. . . ." K.S.A.
14-609.
City hospitals organized under these laws must be established
by a nonprofit corporation or a charitable or religious
organization. K.S.A. 14-601c. It appears that such hospitals
are for the "common good of all" and are "without the element
of special corporate benefit or pecuniary profit." Therefore,
under the Mallory analysis, it is our opinion that the
Arkansas City Memorial Hospital is an instrumentality of a
political subdivision of the state subject to the provisions
of the open records law.
The question now is whether a list of hospital employees and
their salaries is subject to disclosure. A "public record" is
"any recorded information, regardless of form or
characteristics, which is made, maintained or kept by or is in
the possession of any public agency." K.S.A. 45-217(f)(1).
Public records do not include
"records which are owned by a private
person or entity and are not related to
functions, activities, programs or
operations funded by public funds or
records which are made, maintained or kept
by an individual who is a member of the
legislature or of the governing body of
any political or taxing subdivision of the
state." K.S.A. 45-217(f)(2).
According to these definitions, a list of hospital employees
and their salaries is a public record.
Not all public records, however, are required to be open for
public inspection. K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a)(1) provides
that records, the disclosure of which is prohibited or
restricted by law, are not subject to disclosure under the
KORA. In addition, K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a)(2)-(36)
lists records which a public agency has discretion to keep
confidential. An exception applicable to the present
situation provides that a public agency is not required to
disclose
"[p]ersonnel records, performance
ratings or individually identifiable
records pertaining to employees or
applicants for employment, except that
this exemption shall not apply to the
names, position, salaries and lengths of
service of officers and employees of
public agencies once they are employed as
such." K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a)(4).
(Emphasis added).
The hospital is not required to release employee personnel
files, performance ratings, and other such documents.
However, the KORA clearly requires that the names of
employees of public agencies and their salaries must be
disclosed to the public upon request.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:bas

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.