Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-058

1988-058Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL April 25, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 58
The Honorable Theo Cribbs
State Representative, Eighty-Ninth District
1551 N. Minnesota
Wichita, Kansas 67214
Re: Cities and Municipalities--Ordinances of
Cities--Subject and Title of Ordinance
Synopsis: K.S.A. 12-3004 prescribes that the subject of an
ordinance shall be clearly expressed in its title.
Pursuant to this requirement, the title of an
ordinance is sufficient if it is broad enough to
indicate in general terms the provisions of the
ordinance, and it need not include all the details
of the ordinance. Under this standard, the subject
of charter ordinance no. 93 of the city of Wichita
is clearly expressed in its title, and the
proposition to adopt said charter ordinance (which
referred to the ordinance both by number and title)
was properly presented to voters pursuant to
Article 12, Section 5 of the Kansas Constitution.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 12-3004; Kan. Const.,
Art. 12, §5.
Dear Representative Cribbs:
You request our opinion as to whether there is a conflict
between the title to charter ordinance no. 93 of the city of
Wichita and the text of the ordinance. Additionally, you ask
whether those who voted on the adoption of the ordinance were
properly and fairly informed of its effect by the title of the
ordinance.
Charter ordinance no. 93 of the city of Wichita bears the
following title:
"A CHARTER ORDINANCE CHANGING THE METHOD
OF SELECTION OF CITY COMMISSIONERS FROM AT
LARGE TO DISTRICTS; EXEMPTING THE CITY OF
WICHITA, KANSAS, FROM K.S.A. 25-2110,
K.S.A. 25-2110(a) AND K.S.A. 12-1003 AND
REPEALING CHARTER ORDINANCE NO. 38."
Your question is whether the portion of the title which
indicates it is an ordinance "changing the method of selection
of city commissioners from at large to districts," is legally
sufficient. In this regard, it should be noted that under the
ordinance members of the city commission are nominated from
districts and elected at large. Additionally, commission
members must be residents of their respective districts at the
time of filing for election and thereafter for the duration of
their terms.
K.S.A. 12-3004 prescribes, in part, that "no ordinance shall
contain more than one subject, which shall be clearly
expressed in its title." The requirement that the subject of
an ordinance be clearly expressed in its title has been
construed as follows by the Kansas Supreme Court:
"The purposes of the constitutional section
which is the exemplar for 12-3004 have been
stated many times. They include the
prevention of a matter of legislative merit
from being tied to an unworthy matter, the
prevention of hodge podge or log rolling
legislation, the prevention of surreptitious
legislation, and the lessening of improper
influences which may result from intermixing
objects of legislation in the same act which
have no relation to each other. This court
has held these purposes are fulfilled even
though a city ordinance does not include in
its title all the details of the provisions
of the ordinance. It is sufficient if the
title is broad enough to indicate in general
terms the provisions of the ordinance. . .
Garten Enterprises Inc. v. The City
of Kansas City, 219 Kan. 620, 622 (1976).
Applying the principles laid down in the Garten
Enterprises case, it is necessary to consider whether the
description in the title relating to the new method of
selecting city commissioners, i.e. "districts," is legally
sufficient. As noted above, charter ordinance no. 93
establishes five commission districts and provides that each
commission district shall be represented by one district
commission member. Additionally, the ordinance provides that
commission members shall be residents of their respective
districts at the time of filing for election and thereafter
for the duration of the their terms, and that the commission
members are to be nominated from districts but elected at
large.
In our judgment, the description of the new system as
"districts" indicates in general terms the provisions of the
ordinance. The ordinance establishes districts, requires
nomination from districts, and provides that candidates for
each district seat on the commission be residents of the their
districts (both during the primary and the general election,
and thereafter). While the title does not indicate that
district commission members are elected at large in the
general election, the Garten Enterprises case indicates
that an ordinance need not include in its title all the
details of the provisions of the ordinance. In our judgment,
the at large election of district commission members is one
such detail.
In response to your second question, i.e. the adoption of
charter ordinance no. 93 by voters, article 12, section 5 of
the Kansas Constitution specifically provides for the method
of adoption of a charter ordinance:
"The proposition shall be: 'Shall charter
ordinance no. , entitled (title of
ordinance) take effect?'"
As the proposition regarding the adoption of charter ordinance
no. 93 complied with the above-quoted form, it is our opinion
that it was properly presented to voters.
In summary, it is our opinion that K.S.A. 12-3004 prescribes
that the subject of an ordinance shall be clearly expressed in
its title. Pursuant to this requirement, the title of an
ordinance is sufficient if it is broad enough to indicate in
general terms the provisions of the ordinance and it need not
include all the details of the ordinance. Under this
standard, the subject of charter ordinance no. 93 of the city
of Wichita is clearly expressed in its title, and the
proposition to adopt said charter ordinance (which referred to
the ordinance both by number and title) was properly presented
to voters pursuant to article 12, section 5 of the Kansas
Constitution.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearsham
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TRH:jm

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.