Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-189

1987-189Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL December 31, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 189
Mr. Robert Christensen
Chapin & Penny, Attorneys
P.O. Box 148
Medicine Lodge, Kansas 67104
Re: Schools -- Organization, Powers and Finances of
Boards of Education -- Changing Use of Schools;
Disposition of Senior Class Funds
Synopsis: The senior class funds of a high school class which
is merged with another school within the same
district should be distributed in accordance with
the nature of the property interest claimed by the
students. If the students have a legitimate
expectation of receiving benefits from the fund,
then the moneys should be distributed to the
schools actually attended. Otherwise, the moneys
should be distributed to the district's senior
class as designated by the board. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 72-8205; 72-8213; 72-8233.
*
Dear Mr. Christensen:
As attorney for Unified School District No. 254, you have
requested our opinion concerning the disposition of funds held
by the local school board when an attendance facility's use is
changed. Specifically, you inquire how senior class funds
should be distributed when some of the high school students of
the "closed" facility choose to attend a school other than the
one with which the "closed" facility is merged.
The facts you have presented are as follows:
"In the spring of 1987 decision was made
by the Board of Education of U.S.D. #254
to close down the high school attendance
facility in Sharon, Kansas, and merge
those classes with Medicine Lodge High
School, Barber County North. As a result
of dissatisfaction with this board
decision, a majority of the Sharon High
School students elected not to attend
Medicine Lodge High School and transferred
to high schools out of the district.
Primarily, the majority of the senior
class of 1988 transferred to Attica High
School."
Those transferring seniors have requested that the board of
education distribute a pro rata share of the senior class fund
to the Attica senior class fund.
We find little guidance in the statutes for determining the
proper disposition of the funds. School closings are
generally regulated by K.S.A. 72-8213, however, subsection (g)
of that statute states that the section is not to be construed
to limit the authority of a board to change the use of a
school building if it continues to be used for pupil
attendance. It is our understanding that the Sharon facility
is being used for primary grades education.
In the absence of statutory guidance, we believe that common
law principles apply to the extent that the funds in question
are property of the senior class, not of the board. Whether
the legal relationship between the class and the board be
framed in terms of a trust or a debt, it is clear that the
beneficial interest in the fund belongs to the senior class.
The Kansas Department of Education has promulgated Guidelines
For School Activity Funds (May, 1987), and classified the type
of funds in question as a Group 4 account. While the moneys
are reported as agency funds on the district's main financial
statements, it is acknowledged that, by definition, the moneys
belong to the class, organization or club. Guidelines, at
page 24. We need not define with precision the relationship
as either a trust or a debt, as the result of either theory is
the same.
In determining the rights of the students, whether they be
beneficiaries of a trust or creditors, the controversy should
be resolved by looking to the interests of the claimants as
either members of a group or as individuals. If claiming as a
group, we believe that the students who are attending Attica
High School have no enforceable interest in the fund.- The
board has determined that the group previously attending
Sharon High School has been merged with Medicine Lodge High
School. As governing body of the district, we believe that
the board, and not the students, is authorized to designate
the district's official high school class. K.S.A.
72-8205(c). Students who enroll in an out-of-district school
are deemed to have graduated from the school district
attended, unless they attended school out-of-district pursuant
to an interdistrict agreement authorized by K.S.A. 72-8233.
We believe, therefore, that the students who attend Attica
High School instead of Medicine Lodge High School have
voluntarily disassociated themselves from the group previously
known as Sharon High School class of 1988, and have
accordingly surrendered their rights to the class fund as a
group.
As individuals, the students may have property interests in
the fund which are protected by the Fourteenth Amendment. The
final determination calls for an examination of facts to which
we have insufficient information. However, we believe that
guidelines are available to assist in the factual
determination. The nature of the interest relies on the
benefit the students hope to receive from the fund. As stated
in Board of Regents v. Roth, 408 U.S. 564, 92 S.Ct. 2701,
33 L.Ed.2d 548 (1972),
"[t]o have a property interest in a
benefit, a person clearly must have more
than an abstract need or desire for it.
He must have more than a unilateral
expectation of it. He must, instead, have
a legitimate claim of entitlement to it."
408 U.S. at 577, 33 L.Ed.2d at 561.
While this does not establish a clear test for resolving your
question, it does serve as a basis for the following factors
which should be considered. First, it should be determined
whether moneys in the fund are sufficiently severable to be
apportioned in light of individuals' input. Second, the
intent of the student as depositor, and of the school as
holder, should be considered to establish the legitimacy of
any expectation or promise of benefit. Third, a windfall
should not be gained by those who took no part in raising the
money. Finally, the intent of third parties who indirectly
contributed to the fund through purchases or donations is
important for deciding whether the intended benefit was for
particular students or for whomever graduated from the school
at a given time.
After considering the above factors, if the students as
individuals have a legitimate expectation of receiving the
benefits of the funds, then the funds should be distributed to
those individuals' school. To do otherwise would violate the
due process clause of the 14th Amendment. If, on the other
hand, the individuals merely have a unilateral expectancy, the
funds should benefit what is now the senior class of Sharon
High as established by the board, which is now merged with the
senior class of Medicine Lodge.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Mark W. Stafford
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:MWS:br

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.