Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-178

1987-178Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL December 8, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 178
Larry Montgomery
Executive Director
Kansas Lottery
128 North Kansas Avenue
Topeka, Kansas 66603
Re: State Boards, Commissions and Authorities--Kansas
Lottery Commission--Restrictions on Who May
Participate in the Lottery
Synopsis: Section 19(a)(2) of the Kansas lottery act
precludes only officers and certain employees of
those businesses providing supplies, services and
equipment used directly in the operation of a
lottery game from purchasing lottery tickets or
winning prizes. Persons only tangentially
connected to the Kansas lottery are not included
within this prohibition. Cited herein: L. 1987,
ch. 292, §§4, 11, 19.
* *
Dear Mr. Montgomery:
As Executive Director of the Kansas lottery, you request our
opinion regarding the eligibility of certain persons to
purchase lottery tickets and win prizes pursuant to L. 1987,
ch. 292, §19(a)(2) of the Kansas lottery act. Specifically,
you wish to know the types of businesses whose officers and
employees would be prohibited from participating in the state
lottery by this section of the act.
L. 1987, ch. 292, §19 provides as follows:
"(a) It is unlawful for any person to
purchase a lottery ticket or share, or for
another to pay a prize to such person,
knowing that such person is:
"(1) The executive director, a member of
the commission or an employee of the
Kansas lottery;
"(2) an officer or employee of a business
which is currently engaged in supplying
equipment, supplies or services being used
directly in the operation of any lottery
conducted pursuant to this act;
"(3) a spouse, child, stepchild, brother,
stepbrother, sister, stepsister, parent or
stepparent of a person described by
subsection (a)(1) or (2); or
"(4) a person who resides in the same
household as any person described by
subsection (a) (1) or (2).
"(b) Violation of this section is a class
A misdemeanor upon conviction of the first
offense and a class D felony upon
conviction of a second or subsequent
offense.
"(c) Notwithstanding subsection (a), the
executive director may authorize in
writing any employee of the Kansas lottery
and any employee of a lottery vendor to
purchase a lottery ticket for the purposes
of verifying the proper operation of the
state lottery with respect to security,
systems operation and lottery retailer
contract compliance. Any prize awarded as
a result of such ticket purchase shall
become the property of the Kansas lottery
and be added to the prize pools of
subsequent lottery games.
"(d) Nothing in this section shall
prohibit lottery retailers or their
employees from purchasing lottery tickets
and shares or from being paid a prize of a
winning ticket or share.
"(e) Each person who purchases a lottery
ticket or share thereby agrees to be bound
by rules and regulations adopted by the
commission and by the provisions of this
act."
We note first that this is a criminal statute. See §19(b).
Criminal statutes must be strictly construed in favor of
persons sought to be subject to them. Sutton v. State, 6
Kan. App. 2d 831 (1981); State v. Thompson, 3 Kan. App. 2d
426 (1979). In construing criminal statutes, courts are
required to place strict construction on the language used
therein. State v. Roudybush, 235 Kan. 834 (1984). A
criminal statute should not be extended to embrace conduct not
clearly included within its prohibitions, State v. Fowler,
238 Kan. 213 (1985), nor to embrace persons not within its
descriptive terms or the fair and clear import of the language
used. Schmokey v. U.S., 182 F.2d 937 (10th Cir. 1950).
Finally, where no definition of a term has been provided in a
statute proscribing crime, the nature and purpose of the
statute is of primary importance in construing that term.
State v. Deutscher, 225 Kan. 265 (1979).
The statutory provision in question expressly excludes from
its prohibition lottery retailers, §19(d), and any employee of
the Kansas lottery or of a lottery vendor who has been
authorized in writing to participate for purposes of checking
the system, §19(c). Conversely, the statute expressly
prohibits the executive director, members of the Kansas
lottery commission and employees of the Kansas lottery from
purchasing tickets and winning prizes, with the one exception
noted above. S19(a)(1). The provision in question is much
less clear as to its application.
L. 1987, ch. 292, §19(a)(2) states that "it is unlawful for
any person to purchase a lottery ticket or share . . .
knowing that such person is: . . . an officer or employee of
a business which is currently engaged in supplying equipment,
supplies or services being used directly in the operation of
any lottery conducted pursuant to this act. . . ." (Emphasis
added.) Subsections 19(a)(3) and (4) prohibit certain
relatives and persons residing in the same household as any
person described by subsection (a)(1) or (2) from lottery
participation. A strict construction of the above-quoted
language in favor of persons sought to be subject thereto
would indicate that only officers and employees (their
relatives and persons residing in their households) of
businesses providing equipment, supplies or services used
directly in the operation of a lottery game would be
covered by the prohibition. Thus, officers and employees of
businesses which supply equipment, supplies or services to
vendors who in turn do business with the Kansas lottery would
not be covered by the prohibition because such equipment,
supplies or services are not used directly in the operation of
a lottery; the connection with the lottery is indirect or
tangential. Further, officers and employees of businesses
which supply equipment, supplies or services other than for
the operation of any lottery game are not covered by the
prohibition. An indication of what the legislature
contemplated as necessary for a lottery's operation may be
found at L. 1987, ch. 292, §§4(c) and 11(c)(1). The latter of
these lists "goods and services needed for operation of the
lottery, including but not limited to . . . tickets,
independent studies and surveys, data transmission,
advertising, printing, promotion, incentives, public
relations, communications, and distribution of tickets and
shares." These are goods and services necessary to the
operation of a lottery game. Other goods and services which
are commonly required by any state agency or private business
concern and not used directly in the operation of a lottery
game would include the services of utilities (electricity,
gas, water), office space and most office supplies. Officers
and employees of businesses supplying equipment, services and
supplies not used directly in the operation of any lottery
game are not covered by the prohibition.
This interpretation would appear to coincide with legislative
intent and the nature and purpose of the statute. In
establishing a state owned and operated lottery, the
legislature hoped to generate revenues for the state.
Prohibiting numerous persons only tangentially connected with
the Kansas lottery from purchasing tickets would seem to
defeat this purpose. The apparent purpose of L. 1986, ch.
292, §19 is to ensure the integrity of the lottery games.
Prohibiting persons only tangentially connected with the
Kansas lottery would not further this purpose.
With this legislative intent in mind, application of the rule
of statutory construction which provides that the nature and
purpose of the criminal statute is of primary importance in
construing its undefined terms further leads us to conclude
that the prohibition may not extend to every employee of a
business which supplies equipment, supplies or services to be
used directly in the operation of a lottery game. A
determination whether a particular employee is precluded from
participation in lottery games will require a balancing of the
legislative purposes involved, and a close evaluation of all
the particular circumstances. For example, a person employed
by a subsidiary of a large conglomerate corporation which has
a separate company involved in supplying services for the
operation of a lottery game probably was not intended as the
subject of §19(a)(2) restriction. Such an individual probably
has absolutely no ability to tamper with a lottery game, and
the purchase of a ticket by that person would not even create
the appearance of impropriety. Thus, the integrity of the
lottery would not be compromised by such person's
participation, and the Kansas lottery would produce revenues
otherwise not available. We believe that including such
persons only tangentially connected with the Kansas lottery
within the scope of this criminal statute would be embracing
persons and conduct not clearly within the statute's
prohibitions, and thus would be contrary to the rules of
statutory construction.
In conclusion, L. 1987, section 19(a)(2) of the Kansas lottery
act precludes only officers and certain employees of those
businesses providing supplies, services and equipment used
directly in the operation of a lottery game from purchasing
lottery tickets or winning prizes. Persons only tangentially
connected to the Kansas lottery are not included within this
prohibition.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Julene L. Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.