Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-173

1987-173Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
December 1, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87-173
Philip E. Winter
Lyon County Counselor
Lyon County Courthouse
Emporia, Kansas 66801
Re: Counties and County Officers--General Provisions--
Powers Generally; Home Rule
Automobiles and Other Vehicles--Uniform Act
Regulating Traffic; Size, Weight and Load of
Vehicles--Restricting Use of Highways
Synopsis: Pursuant to Kansas law, counties may impose
limitations as to the size and weight of vehicles
on certain roads. Constitutional restrictions
apply to such regulations and require that every
classification be reasonable and rest upon a
rational basis which serves a valid governmental
purpose. The proposed regulation restricting
weight on county roads should apply equally to all
vehicles under the same circumstances and
conditions. Cited herein: K.S.A. 19-101 Fifth;
K.S.A.1986Supp.19-101a;K.S.Amend.K.S.A.
8-2002(f); U.S. Const. Fourteenth Amerequest
*
Dear Mr. Winter:
As Lyon County Counselor you reqiiest our opinion on a
proposed county resolution restricting vehicle weight on
certain Lyon county roads. You specifically inquire as to
the legalities of the resolution in accordance with the laws
of Kansas and the Constitution.
K.S.A. 19-101 Fifth enables each county "to exercise the
powers of home rule to determine their local affairs and
government authorized under the provisions of K.S.A.
19-101a." K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 19-101a grants counties the
authority to "transact all county business and perform all
powers of local legislation and administration it deems
appropriate," subject to certain enumerated limitations.
K.S.A. 8-2002(7) permits local authorities to restrict the use
of highways as authorized in K.S.A. 8-1912. Under subsection
(f) of K.S.A. 8-1912 local authorities "may prohibit the
operation of trucks or other commercial vehicles, or may
impose limitations as to the weight or size thereof, on
designated highways". Prohibitions and limitations must be
designated by appropriate road signs and there must be a
satisfactory alternate route provided when the restrictions
apply to a street connecting with the state highway system.
Thus, provided procedural dictates are followed, the proposed
regulation by Lyon County appears to be authorized by state
law. However, state or local legislation cannot abuse federal
constitutional rights. Harris v. Anderson, 194 Kan. 302,
cert. denied, 382 U.S. 894 (1965). U.S. Const.,
amend. XIV.
The proposed resolution states in pertinent part:
"F.A.S. Route 151, commonly known as the
Olpe/Hartford Road; shall have the
following weight restrictions; No vehicle
or combination of vehicles shall be moved
or operated upon any of the
beforementioned roads when the gross
weight is in excess of 40,000 pounds.
"EXCEPT THAT a vehicle or combination of
vehicles may be moved or operated on the
above-mentioned roads when the gross
weight does not exceed 85,000 pounds.
"So long as no such vehicle so loaded or
operated as authorized by this subsection
shall travel more distance than 25 miles
from the City limits of the City of
Emporia, County seat of Lyon County,
Kansas."
The resolution makes a distinction between vehicles having
Emporia as their termini and those that do not. The
distinction results in a different classification and
treatment for vehicles with the same weight. Dual treatment
of vehicles based solely on the distance traveled from a city
raises an equal protection question.
"The prohibition against denial of equal
protection does not preclude a state or
municipality from resorting to
classification for purposes of legislation
or regulation, and confining such
provisions to a certain class or classes.
Moreover, the classifications may validly
prescribe different sets of rules for
different classes, or discriminate in
favor of, or against, a certain class.
The general rule is, however, subject to
the qualification that the classification
or discrimination be reasonable, rather
than arbitrary, and rest on a real and
substantial difference or distinction
which bears a just, reasonable, or
substantial relation to the legislation or
the subject or object thereof.
Furthermore, in order for a classification
to satisfy the dictates of equal
protection, the legislation must operate
equally, uniformly, and impartially on all
persons or property within the same
class. As viewed from a different
perspective, only those classifications
which are invidious, arbitrary, or
irrational offend the equal protection
clause." 16B C.J.S. Constitutional Law
§780 (1985).
Vehicles weighing in excess of 40,000 pounds belong to the
same class. The classification made by the proposed
regulation rests upon the distance traveled from Emporia.
Classifications are valid when rationally related to a
legitimate governmental interest or purpose. Manhattan
Buildings, Inc., v. Hurley, 231 Kan. 20, 30 (1982).
Several courts have declared laws unconstitutional when the
maximum weight limits did not apply to every vehicle. See
Lossinq v. Hughes, 244 S.W. 556 (C.A. Tex 1922); State
ex rel. Parker v. Frick, 7 So.2d 152 (Fla. 1942);
Richter Concrete Corp. v. City of Reading, 136 N.E.2d 422
(Ohio 1956); see also 16C C.J.S. Constitutional Law 006
(1985).
Lyon county officials must have a rationale basis for why
this regulation serves a valid governmental purpose. The
Richter court objected to distinctions based on a
vehicle's local origins because "the mere fact of traffic
having its termini outside of the municipality is not a valid
basis of classification." Richter at 425. In pursuance
of valid governmental purposes communities may protect the
safety and welfare of their area. This includes protection of
the roads contained therein. Brown v. City of Abilene, 93
Kan. 737 (1915). However, regulations concerning weight of
vehicles must not be unreasonable, arbitrary, or
discriminatory. 7A Am.Jur.2d Automobiles and Highways
§197 (1980).
If the purpose of the regulation is to protect roads from
excessive weight, the distinction made between vehicles
traveling no further from Emporia than twenty-five miles and
all other vehicles has no apparent rationale basis. The roads
will still be subjected to a weight deemed excessive. If
there is another valid governmental purpose that can be
accomplished through this distinction, the classification
might survive a constitutional challenge. However, it is our
opinion that the proposed regulation would not be able to
withstand judicial scrutiny as to its constitutionality and
therefore weight restrictions should apply equally to all
vehicles under the same circumstances and conditions.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Theresa Marcel Nuckolls
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TMN:jm

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.