Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-076

1987-076Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL May 1, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 76
The Honorable Harold Guldner
State Representative, 122nd District
State Capitol, Room 174-W
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Counties and County Officers -- County Attorney --
Vacancy in Office
Elections -- Filling Vacancies in Offices and
Candidacies -- Vacancy in Office of County Attorney
Synopsis: Kansas law provides that a vacancy occurring in the
office of county attorney shall be filled by
appointment by the governor of a person elected by
a district convention held as provided in K.S.A.
25-3902. Although the applicable statutes do not
establish a time limit for filling such a vacancy,
nor penalties or other provisions for failure to
fill a vacancy, such vacancies in public office are
to be filled as soon as is reasonable and
practicable to avoid leaving the office unoccupied
for any extended period.
Authority and responsibility for calling a district
convention is vested entirely in the county
chairman, or alternatively in the county
vice-chairman. Consequently, other members of
the central committee, as well as registered
electors of the county, have no power to force the
calling of a convention. Cited herein: K.S.A.
19-715; 25-3901; 25-3902.
Dear Representative Guldner:
As state representative for the 122nd district, you request
our opinion on several questions regarding the occurrence of a
vacancy in the office of county attorney. You inform us that
the Kearny County Attorney resigned on February 1, 1987, and
that the District Judges of the 25th Judicial District,
pursuant to K.S.A. 19-715(b), appointed a temporary county
attorney on February 6, 1987. To this date, no convention has
been called of the Republican Central Committee of Kearny
County to make a nomination to the Governor of a permanent
county attorney.
In order to answer your inquiry, it is necessary to examine
relevant statutes which deal with vacancies in office. K.S.A.
19-715(a) provides in part:
"When a vacancy occurs in the office of
county attorney, the vacancy shall be
filled by appointment by the governor of a
person elected by a district convention,
in accordance with K.S.A. 25-3902 and
amendments thereto."
Under the terms of K.S.A. 25-3901(a), a "district office" is
defined to include the office of county attorney. K.S.A.
25-3902(a) provides in part:
. . . whenever a district convention is
provided by law to be held to elect a
person to be appointed to fill a vacancy
in a district office, the county chairman
. . . shall call a convention of all
committeemen and committeewomen of the
party of the precincts in such district
for the purpose of electing a person to be
appointed by the governor to fill the
vacancy. If such county chairman is
absent or for any reason is unable to
call, or refuses to call such convention,
then the county vice-chairman shall call
the convention . . . ." (Emphasis added).
After the convention is organized, the statute directs that
"it shall" elect a person to be appointed by the governor to
fill the vacancy.
In light of these statutory provisions, you inquire when such
a district convention should be called. Specifically, you ask
whether there is a recommended time frame for calling said
convention, or alternatively, whether the calling of a
convention is left entirely to the discretion of the county
chairman.
Attorney General Opinion No. 84-33 addressed the issue of when
a district convention must be called to fill a district
office. In considering this issue, we noted several things.
First, K.S.A. 25-3902 does not specify a time limitation in
which a convention to elect a person to fill a vacancy in
office must be held. Second, K.S.A. 25-3902 uses the term
"shall" in specifying the county chairman's responsibility to
call the convention for that purpose. Third, the statute
contemplates the inability or refusal of the chairman to call
a convention and, in such case, transfers the responsibilities
for calling the convention to the county vice-chairman,
again using the term "shall" in specifying the
vice-chairman's responsibilities. Finally, K.S.A. 25-3902
does not provide a consequence for failure to comply with its
terms, and thus may be read as a directory, rather than a
mandatory, statute. See e.g., In re Flournoy, 5
Kan. App. 2d 220 (1980).
In light of these statutory considerations, Opinion No. 84-33
concluded that "although the applicable statutes do not
establish a time limit for filling such a vacancy nor
penalties or other provisions for failure to fill a vacancy,
such vacancies in public office are to be filled as soon as is
reasonable and practicable to avoid leaving the office
unoccupied for any extended period."
We concur with this conclusion. We recognize that the power
provided to the members of a district convention by the terms
of K.S.A. 25-3902 is not forfeited by failure to act within a
certain time period, nor do we believe any consequences will
result from a failure to fill a vacancy in a district office.
However, in our opinion, public policy considerations require
that when the legislature provides that vacancies in certain
public offices shall be filled and provides a method for so
doing, such provisions should be utilized to fill the vacancy
as soon as practicable after the vacancy occurs. See
Attorney General Opinion No. 84-33.
A general rule stated at 67 C.J.S. Officers, § 74 provides:
"The law abhors vacancies in public
offices, and courts generally indulge in a
strong presumption against a legislative
intent to create, by statute, a condition
which may result in an executive or
administrative office becoming for any
period of time, wholly vacant and
unoccupied by one lawfully authorized to
exercise its functions."
See also, Board of Trustees v. Kercheval, 45 S.W.2d
846 (Ky. 1931).
The courts have held that vacancies in public offices should
be filled as soon as is reasonable and practicable to avoid
leaving the office unoccupied for long periods of time. As
the Indiana Court of Appeals noted in Roberts v. State, ex
rel., Jackson Co. Board of Comm'rs, 278 N.E.2d 285, 293
(Ind. 1972):
"The vacancy [in a public office] should
be filled as quickly as possible by a
competent and qualified person and the
office should not be permitted to go
begging for proper authority while others
. . . engage in political feuding, or
deliberations at the expense,
inconvenience and dismay of the taxpayers."
See also, Roher v. Dinkins, 298 N.E.2d 42 (N.Y. 1973);
67 C.J.S. Officers, § 76.
Of course, the amount of time which may be considered
reasonable and practicable to fill a vacancy in a public
office depends upon the individual circumstances of each
case. We believe this determination must be made by the
county chairman, or alternatively by the county
vice-chairman, who has been given the statutory authority
and responsibility to call a district convention. K.S.A.
25-3902(a).
In light of our answer to your first question, we need not
address your second and third questions at length. Under
K.S.A. 25-3902(a), the county chairman, or the county
vice-chairman, has sole discretion to decide when a district
convention should be called. Since the statute establishes no
time limit for filling a vacancy, nor penalties for failure to
fill a vacancy, it does not appear there can be a refusal to
call a district convention under the statute. Further, K.S.A.
25-3902(a) gives only the county chairman, or the county
vice-chairman, the authority to call said convention.
Accordingly, in our opinion, other members of the central
committee, as well as registered electors of the county, have
no power to force the calling of a convention.
In summary, Kansas law provides that a vacancy occurring in
the office of county attorney shall be filled by appointment
by the governor of a person elected by a district convention
held as provided in K.S.A. 25-3902. Although the applicable
statutes do not establish a time limit for filling such a
vacancy, nor penalties or other provisions for failure to fill
a vacancy, such vacancies in public office are to be filled as
soon as is reasonable and practicable to avoid leaving the
office unoccupied for any extended period.
Authority and responsibility for calling a district convention
is vested entirely in the county chairman, or alternatively in
the county vice-chairman. Consequently, other members of
the central committee, as well as registered electors of the
county, have no power to force the calling of a convention.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Barbara P. Allen
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:BPA:bas

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.