Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-052

1987-052Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL March 19, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 52
Dale L. Pohl
Eureka City Attorney
P.O. Box 528
Eureka, Kansas 67045
Re: Constitution of the State of Kansas--
Corporations--Cities' Powers of Home Rule
Synopsis: It is our opinion that the city of Eureka may
make a grant in the amount $100,000 to the
Greenwood County Fair Association, Inc., a
non-profit corporation, for the purpose of
assisting in the development of facilities for
pari-mutuel horse and dog races in the city of
Eureka, as long as economic benefits are expected
to return to the city. Cited herein: Kan.
Const., Art. 12, §5.
Dear Mr. Pohl:
You request our opinion as to whether the city of Eureka may
grant public funds to the Greenwood County Fair Association,
Inc., a nonprofit corporation, for the purpose of assisting
the association in development of facilities for pari-mutuel
horse and dog races in the city of Eureka. You indicate
that the governing body of the city of Eureka believes that
the development of these facilities would be beneficial to the
economic development of the community and, therefore, is
favorably considering a grant in the amount of $100,000. We
will assume that any tax levy funds included in such a grant
could properly be expended by the city for the purpose of
promoting economic development.
Initially, it should be noted that we are unaware of any
statute which would authorize the city of Eureka to grant
funds to a non-profit corporation for the purpose described
above. However, under article 12, section 5 of the Kansas
Constitution, cities have power to determine their local
affairs and government, and do not need legislative
authorization to pass a particular ordinance. City of
Junction City v. Griffin, 227 Kan. 332, 334 (1980). As
promotion of economic development in a community is clearly a
local affair, the city of Eureka may exercise its home rule
power to make a grant to a non-profit corporation under the
circumstances described above, provided such action does not
run afoul of any constitutional limitations. In this regard,
two recent Kansas cases provide guidance as to the
constitutionality of making such a grant.
In Ulrich v. Board of Thomas County Commissioners, 234
Kan. 782 (1984), the Kansas Supreme Court considered the
constitutionality of a law which authorized the board of
trustees of a county hospital to transfer certain hospital
assets, including "unencumbered monies," to a private,
non-profit corporation which would operate a private
hospital. The court stated that grants of public funds to a
private corporation are valid where a public purpose is shown,
and ruled that the operation of a hospital by a private,
non-profit corporation promoted the public health and was
for a public purpose. (Id. at 789-790.) Therefore, the
court held that the statute authorizing the transfer of
hospital assets to a non-profit corporation was
constitutional.
In State ex rel. Tomasic v. City of Kansas City, 237
Kan. 572 (1985), , the court considered the authority of p
city to convey a plant site consisting of 568 acres in the
heart of the Kansas City industrial district to General Motors
for the nominal sum of $250,000. The court rejected the
contention that the conveyance was an unauthorized donation by
the city, stating that "not only will the city receive the
cash payment of $250,000, it will receive the real and
valuable consideration of the economic benefits which are
expected to flow from GM's presence in the city." Id. at
595. The court cited the Ulrich case in noting that it
had "previously held that the entire transaction is to be
taken as a whole and that the consideration for a transfer of
property by the state to a private entity may consist, at
least in part, of the public benefit which flows from the
transfer." Id.
The Ulrich case and the Kansas City case, supra,
indicate that economic benefits which are expected to flow to
a city may serve as consideration for a grant made to a
private corporation. Our research into the legislative
history of the pari-mutuel amendment which was approved by
voters last November reveals that one of the primary reasons
for submission of the amendment to voters was the claim of
proponents that pari-mutuel racing would stimulate and enhance
the Kansas economy. Accordingly, in our judgment the economic
benefits which are expected to flow to the city of Eureka
from the development of facilities for pari-mutuel horse and
dog races may serve as consideration for a grant from the city
to a private corporation to aid such development. However, in
order to assure that there is adequate consideration for the
grant, the city should include a contractual provision
mandating return, of the grant monies in the event the fair
association is unsuccessful in initiating pari-mutuel races.
In summary, it is our opinion that the city of Eureka may
make a grant in the amount $100,000 to the Greenwood County
Fair Association, Inc., a non-profit corporation, for the"
purpose of assisting in the development of facilities for
pari-mutuel horse and dog races in the city of Eureka, as
long as economic benefits are expected to return to the city.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TRH:jm

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.