Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-046

1987-046Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTOR NEY G ENERAL March 12, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 46
The Honorable Nancy Parrish
State Senator, Nineteenth District
State Capitol, Room 403-N
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Schools -- Provisions Related to Common-School
Districts -- School Attendance
Synopsis: In Kansas, every child has a constitutional and
statutory right to attend the public schools,
subject to reasonable regulations adopted by the
board of education. Nutt v. Board of
Education, 128 Kan. 507 (1929); Kan. Const.,
Art. 6, 5 5, as amended in 1986. A regulation is
"reasonable" if it furthers the educational
mission. In our opinion, a regulation which denies
a minor child admission to a public school solely
because the child has obtained a G.E.D. is not
reasonable. However, depending on the facts and
circumstances of the particular case, a regulation
which delays enrollment for a Certain amount of
time or until certain requirements are met may be
appropriate. Cited herein: K.S.A. 72-1046;
72-1046a; 72-1107; 72-1111; 72-4530; 72-5209;
72-8201; K.A.R. 1986 Supp. 91-10-1; Kan.
Const., Art. 6, 55 1,5.
*
Dear Senator Parrish:
As State Senator for the Nineteenth District, you request our
opinion on two issues concerning school attendance:
1. Does a school district have authority to deny admittance
to a school age child who has received a G.E.D. but wishes
to return to high school and receive a diploma?
2. Does a school district have authority to delay or deny
enrollment to children who transfer to the district
without sufficient records for placement or who have for
one reason or another missed a significant part of a
semester and wish to enroll in school at mid-semester?
The Kansas compulsory school attendance law, K.S.A.
72-1111(a), provides that children who are at least seven
years old and under the age of sixteen must attend a public or
private school. Any child who will attain the age of six
years on or before September 1 of any school year is eligible
to attend the elementary grades. K.S.A. 72-1107. Any
eligible child may attend school in the district in which the
child lives if:
"(1) the child lives with a resident of
the district and the resident is the
parent, or a person acting as parent, of
the child; or (2) the child lives in the
district as a result of placement therein
by a district court or by the secretary of
social and rehabilitation services."
K.S.A. 72-1046(a)
In certain situations a child may attend school in a district
in which he is not a resident. K.S.A. 72-1046(b); 72-1046a.
Pursuant to K.S.A. 72-4530, the State Board of Education has
adopted regulations concerning the general educational
development (G.E.D.) credentials. To be eligible for G.E.D.
testing an applicant must be eighteen years old "and the class
of which he or she was a member shall have graduated." K.A.R.
1986 Supp. 91-10-1(a). Exceptions to these requirements are
provided for in K.A.R. 1986 Supp. 91-10-1(b):
"(b) Any person who does not meet the
requirements of subsection (a) may, upon
submitting the recommendations of two
persons other than members of the
immediate family, apply to take the G.E.D.
test if the person:
"(1) is 16 years of age or older;
"(2) if the person would benefit from
receipt of a Kansas state high school
equivalency diploma; or
"(3) if the person is:
"(A) a ward of the state or of the court;
"(B) self-supporting;
"(C) joining any branch of the armed
services; or
"(D) confronted with a set of
circumstances or conditions not usually
associated with youth of this age."
The Kansas statutes do not specify if or when a school
district may deny enrollment to a school-age child. The
authority of local school districts is derived from Article
Six of the Kansas Constitution, as amended by the voters in
November 1986:
"§1. Schools, educational institutions
and related activities. The legislature
shall provide for intellectual,
educational, vocational and scientific
improvement by establishing and
maintaining public schools, educational
institutions and related activities which
may be organized and changed in such
manner as may be provided by law.
• • •
"§5. Local public schools. Local public
schools shall be maintained, developed and
operated by locally elected boards . . . .
The state board of education shall
exercise such supervision over the
maintenance, development and operation of
local public schools as may prescribed
by law."
The Kansas legislature has established a system of local
public schools which are placed under the supervision of
locally elected boards of education. K.S.A. 72-8201 et
seq. Opportunity of education, where the state has
undertaken to provide it, must be made available to all on
equal terms. Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka, 347
U.S. 483, 74 S.Ct. 686, 98 L.Ed. 873 (1953). The Kansas
Supreme Court has stated that every child has a constitutional
and statutory right to attend the public schools. Nutt v.
Board of Education, 128 Kan. 507, 508 (1929); Creyhon v.
Board of Education, 99 Kan. 824, 826 (1917). However, the
court also recognizes the authority of local school boards to
set standards concerning school attendance and that the right
to attend public schools is subject to such regulations, if
they are reasonable. Blaine v. Board of Education, 210
Kan. 560, 570-71 (1972); Nutt v. Board of Education, 128
Kan. at 508; Creyhon v. Board of Education, 99 Kan. at
824, Syl. § 2. The authority of a board of education to
deny admittance to a student has been summarized as follows:
"School attendance is a privilege which
the state confers upon its youth; the only
right a child has to school attendance is
the right which the state confers upon all
other children similarly situated. Since
attendance at the state schools is
essentially a privilege and not a right,
the state may authorize its agents to
exclude all children who do not meet the
requirements established by the state.
Consequently, a school board usually has
the implied power to reject applicants for
admission who do not conform to the
reasonable and necessary requirements
established by the board." N. Edwards,
The Courts and the Public Schools, p.
540 (1971).
See also 68 Am. Jur. 2d Schools § 224.
The question becomes, what constitutes a "reasonable
regulation" by which a public school may deny enrollment to a
student? This question has been addressed in several Kansas
cases. T -1 Creyhon v. Board of Education, supra,
graduates of parochial grade schools were required to pass an
examination for admission to public high schools while
graduates of public grade schools were admitted without this
requirement. The court recognized the authority of the school
board to require an examination to determine whether a student
had sufficient preparatory training to warrant acceptance. 99
Kan. at 829. In this case, however, the court found that
the parochial students had studied the same textbooks and been
given the same tests as the public school graduates. Since
the background of the parochial and public students was the
same, the court held that the examination requirement for the
parochial students was not justified. 99 Kan. at 830.
In Nutt v. Board of Education, supra, the court stated:
"The public schools are for the benefit of
children within school age, and efficiency
ought to be the sole object of those
charged with the power and privilege of
managing and conducting the same, and
while great care should be taken to
preserve order and proper discipline, it
is proper also to see that no one within
school age should be denied the privilege
of attending school unless it is clear
that the public interest demands the
expulsion of such pupil or a denial of his
right to attend." Id. at 509.
In this case the court ruled that the fact that a minor had
conceived a child out of wedlock was an insufficient reason to
exclude the minor student from school.
More recently, the issue as to whether a school regulation is
reasonable was discussed in Blaine v. Board of Education,
supra:
"A school regulation must not be
oppressive or unreasonable. A regulation
to be reasonable must be a proper one to
further the educational processes in the
school and the means adopted to accomplish
a purpose must be appropriate to
accomplish the educational mission." 210
Kan. at 567
"In measuring the appropriateness and
reasonableness of school regulations
against the personal rights of the
individual student, courts should give
full credence to the role and purposes of
the schools as well as the nature of the
problems inherent in the public education
of our youth." 210 Kan. at 570.
"The responsibility for maintaining proper
standards for learning and discipline, and
for creating a wholesome academic
environment in our public schools is
vested in the local boards of education,
consistent with fundamental constitutional
safeguards . . . ." 210 Kan. at 571.
The court held that a board of education regulation "limiting
extreme hair styles of male students" had a rational purpose
and was not unduly oppressive or unreasonable.
As noted earlier, Kansas recognizes the constitutional and
statutory right of every child to attend the public schools,
subject to reasonable regulations. A school regulation which
denies a minor child admission to a public school solely
because the child has obtained a G.E.D., however, does not
appear to be reasonable. While a G.E.D is recognition that an
individual has achieved a certain level of education, it
cannot be said that a G.E.D. is the same as a high school
diploma. For example, the fact that an individual has a
G.E.D. is a red flag on a resume that he or she did not finish
high school. This is not to say that a high school graduate
is better educated than a person who has passed a G.E.D.
examination. Nevertheless, the fact remains that persons who
did not graduate from high school are placed at a disadvantage
in seeking employment. Such a regulation is not reasonable as
it does not appear to "further the educational processes in
the school." Therefore, a minor child should not be denied
the right to attend public school solely because the child has
attained a G.E.D.
The second question is whether a public school may delay or
deny enrollment to children who transfer without sufficient
records or who have missed a significant part of a semester
and wish to enroll at mid-semester. Depending on the
circumstances of the particular case, it may be reasonable for
a public school to delay enrollment for a certain amount of
time or until certain requirements are met. For example,
K.S.A. 72-5209 provides that every pupil enrolling in any
school for the first time must, before admission to and
attendance in school, present a certificate that the pupil has
received, or will receive within 90 days, the required tests
and inoculations. If a child transfers from another school
district or state without school records at the time of
enrollment, it would seem that the child's privilege to attend
school outweighs the concerns of administrative paperwork
caused by the delay in sending records. However, in some
situations it may be prudent or reasonable to delay enrollment
until the beginning of a semester. This may be the case, for
instance, where the student wishes to enroll late in the
semester, has not been attending school regularly, and has not
presented sufficient records for placement. We must emphasize
that the circumstances of the situation dictate
"reasonableness."
In summary, a school-age child has a constitutional and
statutory right to attend the public schools, subject to
reasonable regulations. To be reasonable a regulation must be
designed to "accomplish the educational mission." Such a
determination depends on the facts of the particular case.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:bas

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.