Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-034

1987-034Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL February 24, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 34
Robert A. Walsh
Cloud County Attorney
Cloud County Courthouse
Concordia, Kansas 66901
Re: State Departments; Public Officers and
Employees--Kansas Tort Claims Act--Employee's
Defense; Costs
Synopsis: Service of process is a condition precedent to an
employee's request for the provision of defense
counsel by a governmental entity, unless such
condition is waived. If, after the employee has
been served, the entity lawfully refuses to provide
for such defense, and if the request was made in
accordance with the statute, then the entity must
reimburse the employee for attorney expenses
incurred as a result of the retention of private
counsel. Absent service of process, timely request
for, and proper refusal of providing legal defense
counsel, no right is conferred on the employee to
retain private counsel at the expense of the
governmental entity. Cited herein: K.S.A.
75-6103, 75-6108, 75-6109.
Dear Mr. Walsh:
As attorney for Cloud County, Kansas, you request our opinion
regarding the Kansas tort claims act, K.S.A. 75-6101 et
seq. Specifically, you inquire whether a governmental
entity must reimburse an employee for attorney's fees and
other costs which that employee has incurred prior to the
commencement of suit against the person in his or her capacity
as a governmental employee. You indicate that, prior to the
filing of the lawsuit, the person may find himself in a
situation which is at odds with the position of the employer,
creating a conflict of interest which justifies separate legal
counsel.
We believe that the sections providing for legal defense of
governmental employees clearly enunciate the procedure by
which persons who are defendants in their official or
individual capacity are to be paid for legal expenses they
incur. First, we note that governmental entities are liable
for negligent or wrongful acts or omissions of their employees
who cause injury while acting within the scope of their
employment. K.S.A. 75-6103(a). The entity must indemnify its
employees against damages, with the exception of punitive or
exemplary damages, or costs which are paid through an
applicable contract or insurance policy. If the
trier-of-fact finds that the employee acted with actual
fraud or actual malice, or if the employee fails to cooperate
in good faith in the defense, the entity may recover payments
for judgments, costs and fees it has incurred on the
employee's behalf. K.S.A. 75-6109. In addition to the
governmental entity's liability for judgments, it is also
responsible for providing the defense for the employee in any
civil action or proceeding in which the employee is a
defendant in his or her individual or official capacity when
the suit arises out of an act or omission of the employee
while acting within the scope of his employment. This defense
is available to the employee upon proper request. K.S.A.
75-6108(a). The defense provided may be either by the
entity's own attorney, by outside counsel employed by the
entity, or counsel provided by an insurance carrier. K.S.A.
75-6108(b).
The request for defense must be made in accordance with K.S.A.
75-6108(e), which states in part,
"[the request] shall be made in writing
within fifteen (15) days after service of
process upon the employee in the action."
The timeliness of a request may be waived by the governmental
entity in its discretion. It is our opinion that service of
process on the employee is made a condition precedent to a
request for the provision of defense counsel by the
above-quoted subsection.
A governmental entity may refuse to provide for the employee's
defense if it determines that
"(1) The act or omission was not within
the scope of such employee's employment;
(2) such employee acted or failed to act
because of actual fraud or actual malice;
(3) the defense of the action or
proceeding by the governmental entity
would create a conflict of interest
between the governmental entity and the
employee; or (4) the request was not made
in accordance with subsection (e) [of
K.S.A. 75-6108]." K.S.A. 75-6108(c).
If the request is timely made, and the governmental entity
refuses to provide for the defense, then such entity must
reimburse the employee for reasonable attorney's fees, costs,
and expenses which the employee incurs as a result of
retaining his or her own defense counsel. K.S.A.
75-6108(d). We perceive two relevant points in subsection
(d). First, it is the prerogative of the governmental entity
to determine whether any of the enumerated conditions exist
for which it may refuse to provide defense counsel. As we
opined in Attorney General Opinion No. 85-140, the decision
must be made by the governing body. A determination by the
entity's attorney or by the employee would be without effect.
The second relevant point is that the request must be in
accordance with subsection (e), as cited above. In short, the
governmental entity is not required to reimburse employees for
legal defense expenses if the request for counsel was not made
in a timely fashion, i.e., within fifteen days after service
of process on the employee. Otherwise, governmental entities
might find themselves in the position of paying for what they
may consider as needless expenses if the request is made too
early, or ,at a disadvantage if the request is made too late.
In conclusion, service of process on the employee is a
condition precedent to the requirement that the governmental
entity provide for the legal defense of an employee when such
employee is named as a party defendant to a lawsuit in an
action arising out of the employment relationship, unless, in
its discretion, the governmental entity waives the condition.
The governmental entity may refuse to provide such defense
under specified circumstances, but if the request was made in
a timely fashion, then the entity must reimburse the employee
for reasonable costs incurred as a result of retaining outside
counsel. It is therefore our opinion that the entity is not
required to reimburse the employee for those expenses when the
employee's request for counsel was not made in the time period
and manner prescribed by statute. The statute confers no
right on the employee to retain outside counsel at the expense
of the governmental entity prior to the happening of the
events outlined above.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Julene L. Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.