Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-021

1987-021Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL February 5, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 21
Douglas F. Martin
Shawnee County Counselor
Shawnee County Courthouse, Room 203
200 E. 7th
Topeka, Kansas 66603-3922
Re: Taxation--Correction of Irregularities--Collection
of Judgments Subsequent to Taxpayer's Discharge in
Bankruptcy
Synopsis: Valid liens which are not otherwise avoidable
survive a discharge in bankruptcy and may be
executed as provided by law after the proceedings
in bankruptcy have come to an end. Judgments which
are not liens upon property of the estate may not
be enforced against the debtor subsequent to a
discharge in bankruptcy. Penalties and interest
owed on delinquent taxes are to be treated in the
same manner as the tax itself, unless punitive in
nature. Cited herein: K.S.A. 79-1703; 11 U.S.C.
§§101, 301, 302, 303, 362, 507, 523, 524, 944, 1328.
Dear Mr. Martin:
As County Counselor for Shawnee County, Kansas, you request
our opinion regarding the effect of certain bankruptcy
proceedings on property tax judgments and liens.
Specifically, you ask what steps, if any, should be taken by
Shawnee County officials upon a final discharge in
bankruptcy with respect to property taxes, interest, penalties
and court costs that have been reduced to judgments.
We note initially that certain property taxes of individual
debtors are not dischargeable in bankruptcy. 11 U.S.C.
55523(a)(1)(A) and 507(a)(7)(B). Additionally, under a
Chapter 9 bankruptcy, a debtor is not discharged from any debt
that is excepted from discharge by the plan or by the court
order confirming the plan, 11 U.S.C. 5944(c), and, generally
speaking, the debts discharged by the court in a Chapter 13
bankruptcy have already been paid according to the plan, 11
U.S.C. 51328(a). This opinion will speak only to property
taxes which are properly dischargeable. Tax claims which have
become statutory or judicial liens, as those terms are defined
in 11 U.S.C. §101(30) and (45), are secured interests to be
disposed of by the bankruptcy court according to the
Bankruptcy Code, 11 U.S.C. 55101 through 151326, and state
law. See 9A Am. Jur. 2d Bankruptcy 55716,717 (1980);
Palmer v. First National Bank of Kingman, 10 Kan. App.
2d 84, 88 (1984).
You question what, if any, actions should be taken by county
officials with respect to taxes which, for one reason or
another, have been discharged in bankruptcy. Section 524 of
the Bankruptcy Code, 11 U.S.C. §524, provides in part as
follows:
"(a) A discharge in a case under this
title--
"(1) voids any judgment at any time
obtained, to the extent that such judgment
is a determination of the personal
liability of the debtor with respect to
any debt discharged under section 727,
944, 1141, or 1328 of this title, whether
or not discharge of such debt is waived;
"(2) operates as an injunction against the
commencement or continuation of an action,
the employment of process, or an act, to
collect, recover or offset any such debt
as a personal liability of the debtor,
whether or not discharge of such debt is
waived. . . ."
This language is similar to that of the automatic stay of 11
U.S.C. §362(a) which prohibits any action to collect a debt
after a petition is filed under 55301, 302 or 303 of the
Bankruptcy Code. See 11 U.S.C. §362(c) for termination of
stay.
Sections 771 et seq. of 9A Am. Jur. 2d Bankruptcy
discuss the purpose and effect of a discharge in bankruptcy:
"The power of Congress to prescribe
regulations concerning discharge in
bankruptcy, so long as they were not so
grossly unreasonable as to be incompatible
with fundamental law, was established
early. In interpreting the statutes thus
enacted by Congress, it was uniformly held
that the right to discharge should be
liberally construed; that it was not to be
construed against the bankrupt; that it
must be liberally construed in favor of
the bankrupt at least where there was not
intent to violate former 11 USCS §32;
that, conversely, it must be construed
strictly against one objecting to
discharge; and that it must be liberally
applied to achieve its primary purpose of
giving debtors a new chance in life.
[page 505].
• • •
"According to the legislative history, 11
USCS §524(a) is intended to insure that
once a debt is discharged, the debtor will
not be pressured in any way to repay it.
In effect, the discharge extinguishes the
debt, and creditors may not attempt to
avoid that. [page 511].
"Case law under the 1898 Act indicated
that despite the discharge in bankruptcy,
the debt remained in existence after the
discharge, although it was divested of its
character as a personal obligation which
was legally enforceable by a creditor.
Thus, discharge neither destroyed the debt
nor supplanted the moral obligation of the
debtor to pay it. Rather, discharge
merely served as a bar to the enforcement
of a discharged debt by a legal
proceeding. This included supplementary
proceedings against the income of the
debtor. On the other hand, recent 1898
Act case authority is to the contrary, and
this recent view seems more consistent
with the 1978 Act's legislative history,
discussed above. [pages 511, 512]."
(Footnotes omitted.)
However, it is also stated in this publication that:
"Whatever else may happen to liens in a
bankruptcy case, it was established under
the 1898 Act that a lien is not affected
by a discharge. It was held that a lien
should be given effect after a bankrupt
was discharged so as to give a judgment
creditor a lien upon the proceeds from the
sale of real estate to which the lien
attached. (sic) and it was held that
where tax liabilities secured by a tax
lien were nondischargeable and,
therefore, enforceable against the debtor
individually and against his
after-acquired assets despite his
discharge, the Internal Revenue Service
was entitled to retain its tax lien." 9A
Am. Jur. 2d Bankruptcy §779 (1980).
In support of this proposition, the United States District
Court, W.D. Wisconsin, has stated:
"It would be rather odd to bestow upon a
docketed judgment the quality of a lien
against real estate, but then to strip it
of this quality whenever the judgment
debtor petitions in bankruptcy, whether
more or less than four months subsequent
to the docketing of the judgment. Because
bankrupts are frequently discharged in the
bankruptcy proceedings at a time prior to
the trustee's sale of the real estate and
prior to the distribution of the proceeds
of the sale, this oddity would arise with
equal frequency unless the lien is given
effect in the bankruptcy proceeding
following the entry of the order
discharging the bankrupt. This persuades
me that the more reasonable course is to
give the lien effect after the discharge
if the Wisconsin statutes permit it." In
re Tillman Produce Co., Inc., 396 Fed.
Supp. 500, 502 (W.D. Wis. 1975),
aff'd, 538 F.2d 763 (7th Cir.
1976).
Also, the comment to 5524 of the Bankruptcy Code states that
"[s]ection 524(a)(2) clarifies that valid liens survive the
discharge." 11 U.S.C. 5524, comment.
In bankruptcy, existence and effect of liens on real estate
are to be determined by state law. Kansas taxation statutes
prohibit county officials from releasing, discharging,
remitting or commuting any portion of taxes assessed or levied
within their respective jurisdictions. K.S.A. 79-1703(a).
Though this statute states in subsection (b) the procedure to
be followed in cases involving a railroad in bankruptcy, it is
silent as to the procedure to be followed when any other
taxpayer files a bankruptcy petition. Attorney General
Opinion No. 85-100 sheds some light on what can be done to
collect taxes from a company that is in bankruptcy, though it
is not dispositive of the issue currently before us, i.e.
what is the effect of a discharge. Also of assistance is the
Court of Appeals decision in Palmer v. First National Bank of
Kingman, 10 Kan. App. 2d 84 (1984), though the case
speaks primarily to taxes which were not discharged in the
bankruptcy proceedings.
To bring these seemingly contradictory authorities into
unison, it is our opinion that valid liens, which are not
otherwise avoidable, survive a discharge in bankruptcy and may
be executed as provided by law after the proceedings in
bankruptcy have come to an end. Conversely, mere judgments
which are not liens upon property of the estate may not be
enforced subsequent to a discharge in bankruptcy. Other
states have provisions by which a person discharged in
bankruptcy may obtain a satisfaction of such a judgment from
the court which entered it, thereby extinguishing the
judgment. See Wis. Stat. 5270.79 (1975). Kansas does not
have such a provision. Thus, there appears to be no way in
which to remove judgments from the records even though they
cannot be legally enforced. Finally, the discharge of a debt
of the debtor does not affect the liability of any other
entity for such debt, except with regard to certain community
claims. 9A Am. Jur. 2d Bankruptcy 5782 (1980).
In conclusion, valid liens which are not otherwise avoidable
survive a discharge in bankruptcy and may be executed as
to an end. Judgments which are not liens upon property of the
estate may not be enforced against the debtor subsequent to a
discharge in bankruptcy. Penalties and interest owed on
delinquent taxes are to be treated in the same manner as the
tax itself, unless punitive in nature.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JuleneL.Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.