Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-020

1987-020Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GEN ER AL February 5, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 20
John J. Gillett
Wilson County Attorney
Wilson County Courthouse, Room 201
P.O. Box 556
Fredonia, Kansas 66736
Re: Taxation--Property Valuation, Equalizing
Assessments, Appraisers and Assessment of
Property--Taxation of Royalty Interest on Oil and
Gas Lease
Synopsis: If a person sells his personal property after it
has been assessed and before the tax has been paid,
an in rem tax lien follows the property into the
hands of the purchaser. K.S.A. 79-2110. However,
if three or more years pass from the time the tax
becomes due and payable to the time the county
attempts to enforce the lien, the property owner
(purchaser) is no longer liable for the tax. In
light of this limitation, even though a lien
followed the royalty interest in question upon its
sale in 1981, Wilson County is prohibited from
collecting any 1981 personal property taxes owing
on the royalty interest, as more than three years
have passed since the unpaid taxes became due.
Wilson County may collect the personal property
taxes on the royalty interest owed to the county
for the years 1982 to the present. K.S.A. 1986
Supp. 79-1475. Furthermore, penalties may be
assessed by the county for the years 1983 to the
present. K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 79-1427a. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 79-306; 79-329; K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
79-1427a; 79-1475; K.S.A. 79-2110.
Dear Mr. Gillett:
As Wilson County Attorney, you request our opinion on whether
the county can collect several years' worth of delinquent
personal property taxes for a royalty interest on an oil and
gas lease, now that the true owner of the royalty interest in
question has come to light.
The facts, as stated in you request letter, are as follows.
The royalty interest of an oil and gas lease on a piece of
land in Wilson County was sold in 1981. For unknown reasons,
the company which was the owner of the working interest and
the operator of the lease neglected to update the 1982 listing
of the lease to reflect the change in interest owners.
Because the conveyance was not noted on the 1982 listing, the
appraiser's office continued to send delinquent tax statements
to the previous owner of the royalty interest, and later to
his estate after he became deceased.
In October, 1986, the Wilson County Appraiser was made aware
of the 1981 conveyance of the royalty interest. You now
inquire as to whether Wilson County can collect the delinquent
personal property taxes owed to the county on the royalty
interest from the past several years.
An oil and gas lease is by law declared to be personal
property for ad valorem tax purposes. K.S.A. 79-329. Thus,
in determining whether Wilson County can collect any or all of
the back taxes from the current royalty interest owners, it is
necessary to apply the Kansas personal property tax statutes
to the aforementioned facts.
Initially, we note that the listing for an oil and gas lease
owned by a corporation is due in the appraiser's office by
April 1 of each tax year. K.S.A. 79-306. It is the
responsibility of the operator of each lease to list this
property. The listing usually includes well information, any
changes made in the lease, and a listing of the names and
addresses of the current interest owners, both working and
royalty.
It is unclear from the facts we received whether the 1981
personal property taxes on the royalty interest are
delinquent. If the previous owner of the royalty interest did
not pay his 1981 taxes, it is our opinion that Wilson County
cannot collect these taxes from the current owners.
K.S.A. 79-2110 provides in part:
"If any person in this state, after his
or her personal property is assessed and
before the tax thereon is paid, shall sell
all of the same to any one person, and
not retain sufficient to pay the taxes
thereon, the tax for that year shall be
a lien upon the property so sold, and
shall at once become due and payable, and
the county treasurer shall at once issue a
tax warrant for the collection thereof,
and the sheriff shall forthwith collect it
as in other cases. The one owing such tax
shall be civilly liable to any purchaser
of such property for any taxes he or she
owes thereon, but the property so
purchased shall be liable in the hands of
the purchaser or purchasers for such
tax." (Emphasis added.)
Thus, under the provisions of this statute, an in rem tax lien
follows the property into the hands of the purchaser or
purchasers. Accordingly, it would initially appear that the
current owners would be liable for the unpaid taxes of the
previous owner.
However, K.S.A. 79-2110 goes on to provide:
” . . . no personal property which has been
transferred in any manner after it has
been assessed shall be liable for the tax
in the hands of the transferee after the
expiration of 3 years from the time such
tax became originally due and payable."
(Emphasis added: .)
In light of this statutory limitation, even though a lien
followed the royalty interest in question upon its sale in
1981, it is our opinion that Wilson County cannot collect any
owing 1981 personal property tax from the current royalty
interest owners, as more than three years have passed since
the unpaid taxes became due.
In our judgment, however, Wilson County may collect from the
current owners all back taxes owing for the years 1982 to the
present. K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 79-1475 provides:
"Whenever the county appraiser discovers
that any property subject to taxation has
been omitted from the tax rolls, such
property shall immediately be listed and
valued by the appraiser, and returned to
the county clerk. The county clerk,
upon receipt of the valuation for such
property, shall compute the amount of tax
due based upon the mill levy for the year
in which such tax should have been
levied, and shall certify such amount to
the county treasurer as an added or
escaped appraisal. The county treasurer
shall proceed to collect and distribute
such tax in the same manner as prescribed
by law for the collection and distribution
of other taxes levied on property."
(Emphasis added.)
Thus, a county is not barred from collecting delinquent
personal property taxes simply because of the passage of
time. Rather, as long as the property has not been
transferred to another owner subsequent to assessment, a
county may collect personal property taxes due to the county
at any time.
In our judgment, Wilson County may additionally impose a
penalty for the current royalty interest owners' failure to
pay their personal property taxes. K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 79-1427a
provides:
"(a) If, after one year from the date
prescribed by K.S.A. 79-306, and
amendments thereto, for the listing of
tangible personal property, the county
appraiser discovers that any tangible
personal property which was subject to
taxation in any year or years within four
years next preceding has not been listed
or has been underreported for whatever
reason, such property shall be deemed to
have escaped taxation. In the case of
property which has not been listed, it
shall be the duty of the county appraiser
to list and appraise such property and add
100% thereto as a penalty for escaping
taxation for each such year during which
such property was not listed, and it shall
be designated on the appraisal roll as
'escaped appraisal' for each such
preceding year or years.
"(c) The provisions of this section shall
apply to any tangible personal property
discovered during the calendar years 1982,
1983, 1984 and any year thereafter to have
escaped appraisal and taxation during any
such year or any year within four years
next preceding any such year." (Emphasis
added.)
Taking into consideration the provisions of K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
79-1427a, it is our opinion that Wilson County may penalize
the current royalty interest owners for escaped taxes during
the last four years. Thus, Wilson County may impose a penalty
back through the 1983 tax year. Since the 1982 tax year falls
outside of the statutorily-imposed "4 year period," a
penalty may not be imposed for this year.
We note that, in most circumstances, the party responsible for
paying the tax is also the party responsible for listing the
property within the appraiser's office. Thus, the party who
lists the property knows that he or she must pay the tax. In
this situation, however, the party responsible for listing the
property and the party responsible for paying the tax are
different people. It is conceivable, therefore, that the
current property interest owners were not aware that property
taxes were due on their royalty interest. Since the party
responsible for listing the property neglected to inform the
appraiser's office of the change in the royalty interest
ownership, the county was never able to inform the current
owners that their taxes were delinquent. The recourse
available to the current owners, should they contest the
assessment, is to appeal the imposition of a penalty to the
state board of tax appeals, as provided for by K.S.A. 1986
Supp. 79-1427a(b).
In conclusion, if a person sells his personal property after
it has been assessed and before the tax has been paid, an in
rem tax lien follows the property into the hands of the
purchaser. K.S.A. 79-2110. However, if three or more years
pass from the time the tax becomes due and payable to the time
the county attempts to enforce the lien, the property owner
(purchaser) is no longer liable for the tax. In light of this
limitation, even though a lien followed the royalty interest
in question upon its sale in 1981, Wilson County is prohibited
from collecting any 1981 personal property taxes owing on the
royalty interest, as more than three years have passed since
the unpaid taxes became due.
Wilson County may collect the personal property taxes on the
royalty interest owed to the county for the years 1982 to the
present. K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 79-1475. Furthermore, penalties
may be assessed by the county for the years 1983 to the
present.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Barbara P. Allen
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:BPA:jm

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.