Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-004

1987-004Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL January 13, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 4
Gene Porter
Barton County Attorney
Barton County Courthouse
P.O. Box 881
Great Bend, Kansas 67530
Re: Laws, Journals and Public Information -- Records
Open to Public -- Records;
Fees
Synopsis: The Kansas Open RreasonabelRecords Act provides that public agencies may charge reasonable fees for photocopying public records. that public agencies may charge reasagenciesfees for photocopying public records. public
agencie
photocopying public records. Fees are rcostsreasonafeesFbes are reasonabeetly
if they do not exceed the actual cost, or
cent sostst directly incurred, in providing copies. The twenty
cepercents per page fee charged by Unified School
District NoisNo. 431 is not unreasonable as it reflects
the actual cos redcosts incurred in furnishing copies of
public records. Cit552.nCited herein: K.S.A. 45-215;
45-216; 45-219; 5 U.S.C. §55County
*
Dear Mr. Porter:
As county attorney for Barton C as, you request
our opinion whether fees cHoisingtoncharged by Unified School District
(U.S.D.) No. 431, Hoisingtth photocopying records are
"reasonable" under tKansas Open Records Act (KORA), K.S.A.
45-215 et ffaseq.Thismatterhasbeenalong-standingpoint
of controversy as a patron of the school district contends
that the assessment of twenty cents per page is excessive.
Under the KORA, records of public agencies must be open to the
public unless otherwise provided. K.S.A. 45-216. Any person
has the right not only to inspect, but to obtain copies of
public records. K.S.A. 45-219(a). Public agencies may,
however, charge "reasonable fees" for furnishing copies:
"In the case of fees for copies of
records, the fees shall not exceed the
actual cost of furnishing copies,
including the cost of staff time required
to make the information available."
K.S.A. 45-219(c)(1). (Emphasis added.)
may require advance payment of the fee before copies
K.S.A. 45-219(a); State ex rel. Stephan v.
U.S.D. No. 431 bases its photocopying fee on the following:
Total Yearly
Copier Cost 6,650. 1,330.00
Maintenance Agreement (5 yr. life 552.00
Toner Cost expected) 525.00
2,407.00
2407 ?; 80,000 average copies per year = .03 per copy
PAPER COST
Ream $3.38 7 500 =
LABOR COST FOR RUNNING COPIER
Clerical staff in central office average salary per
hour including salary, fringe, and social security =
128 :; 34 copies per minute (copier speed) =
OTHER LABOR COSTS:
Type mailing labels, make billings, make receipts, run
postage meter, provide change, assemble, staple, time off
other tasks (estimate 30 seconds per page) = .064
Summation of Costs: Per Page
Copying machine .03
Paper Cost .007
Labor to run copier .003
Other Labor Costs .064
9" x 12" mailing envelope .07
*
.174
*Does not include utility costs or copier maintenance not
covered by maintenance agreement. (Drums are guaranteed for
120,000 copies and cost $329. per drum.
Taking the above listed costs and costs unforeseen as noted by the * it is
recommended that that [sic] USD 431 charge for copying open record
information be set at .20 cents per copy.
Variables not considered:
- 8 1/2" x 14" paper is higher priced (4.16 per ream) than the 8 1/2" x 11"
that is quoted.
- 8 1/2" x 14" paper runs slower (28 copies/minute) than the 8 1/2" x 11"
that is quoted.
- calculated on central office machine.
An agency
are made.
Harder, 230 Kan. 573, Syl. ¶7 (1982).
.007 per copy
7.69 per hour
Or .128 per min.
.003 per copy
There is no case law in Kansas interpreting reasonableness of
copying fees. The federal counterpart to the KORA, the
Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), also provides that fees
may be charged for furnishing copies:
"Such fees shall be limited to reasonable
standard charges for document search and
duplication and provide for recovery of
only the direct costs of such research and
duplication." 5 U.S.C. §552(a)(4)(A).
The court in Long v. U.S. Internal Revenue Service, 596 F.2d
362 (1979), cert. denied 446 U.S. 917 (1980),
interpreted this provision as follows:
"The legislative history indicates that
the intent of the amendment [permitting
fees] was so that 'fees should not be used
for the purpose of discouraging requests
for information as or obstacles to
disclosure of requested information.' S.
Rep. No. 1200, 93rd Cong., 2d Sess.
(1974); [1974] U.S. Code Cong. & Ad.
News 6267, 6287."
According to K.S.A. 45-219(c)(1), fees are reasonable if they
do not exceed the actual cost of furnishing copies. It is not
clear what may be included in the calculation of "actual
cost." The League of Kansas Municipalities has taken the
position that "any fee charged up to and including the
actual costs incurred is reasonable." League of Kansas
Municipalities, Open Public Records: A Manual for Local
Governments on the 1983 Kansas Open Records Act, P.48 (1983)
(emphasis in original). The handbook provides that the
following may be included as actual costs: staff time,
including fringe benefits; equipment, including materials,
depreciation, and maintenance; that portion of overhead
attributed to providing facilities involved in producing
copies of records, including heating, cooling, maintenance and
insurance; and mailing handling and incidental costs. Id.
at 48-49.
One commentator on the KORA has researched the legislative
history of the "reasonable fees" provision and has concluded
that the legislature did not intend the calculation of actual
costs to include overhead costs. Frederickson, Letting the
Sunshine In: An Analysis of the 1984 Kansas Open Records
Act, 33 U.Kan.L. Rev. 205, 229 (1985). We agree that
"[flees must not be designed to produce revenue, but rather
to compensate the state for resources required to comply with
a request." Id.
In determining actual cost, we are of the opinion that only
those costs directly incurred in producing copies can be
recovered. Direct costs include, but are not necessarily
limited to, staff time, paper, and machine costs. General
building overhead expenses should not be included if such
costs would exist notwithstanding the requirement that public
agencies furnish copies of public records.
The costs estimated by U.S.D. No. 431 reflect costs directly
incurred in producing photocopies. It was determined that the
actual cost to furnish a copy is 17.4 cents per page. The
school district charged a fee of 20 cents per page.
Calculating photocopying fees is not an exact science but is
based on estimates. Therefore, it is our conclusion that,
based on the actual costs incurred, the fee of 20 cents per
page charged by U.S.D. No. 431 to furnish requested copies of
public records is not unreasonable.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:crw
cc: John Radke
Box 386
Hoisington, Kansas 67544
Randy Evans
Superintendent of Schools
106 North Main Street
Hoisington, Kansas 67554

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.