Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-003

1987-003Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
January 9, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 3
Judith K. Stringer
Consumer Credit Commissioner
217 S.E. 4th Street, 4th Floor
Topeka, Kansas 66603-3501
Re: Consumer Credit Code--Insurance; Insurance in
General; Consumer Credit Insurance; Property and
Liability Insurance
Synopsis: A creditor may not contract for or receive a
separate charge for insurance unless the credit
insurance provides a benefit which covers a loss to
property related to the credit transaction.
Household goods cannot be related to the
transaction unless a purchase money credit
arrangement is involved. Nor may the creditor be
named as a loss payee of a policy which covers all
of a consumer's household goods, even though that
creditor has a security interest in some of the
property covered under the policy. The amount of
insurance is limited to the lesser of either the
amount of debt or the value of the property
insured. If a separate charge is received for
credit insurance, before the insurance may be
written, the consumer must give,an informed,
affirmative, written request for the policy. In
addition, a creditor may not sell credit insurance
to a consumer if he has knowledge that an existing
policy gives full coverage of the property related
to the transaction, and the credit insurance would
therefore be pro-rated. Cited herein: K.S.A.
16a-3-301;
16a-4-106;
16a-4-301;
16a-1-101, 16a-1-102; 16a-2-501;
16a-3-302; 16a-4-104; 16a-4-105;
16a-4-109; 16a-4-112; 16a-4-202;
16a-4-302; 50-626(b)(3); K.A.R. 40-5-8; 40-5-103;
15 U.S.C. 5545, 1605(b); 12 C.F.R. 55227.1;
§227.13; §226.4; §226.18; 16 C.F.R. 5444.2(a)(4).
Dear Ms. Stringer:
As Commissioner of the Consumer Credit Commission, you have
requested our opinion concerning several aspects of the
Consumer Credit Code. Specifically, you inquire into matters
involving the sale of insurance against loss to property
related to a credit transaction. We address your questions in
the order in which they were asked.
(1) In a consumer credit transaction, may creditors insure
household goods in which they do not have a security
interest?
As you correctly point out, the Federal Trade Commission has
determined that a non-possessory security interest in
household goods, other than a purchase money security interest
(PMSI), is an unfair credit practice within the meaning of -
Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act, 15 U.S.C. §45.
See, 16 C.F.R. §444.1(a)(4). A regulation with nearly
identical language appears in 12 C.F.R. 5227.13(d), making a
security interest in household goods, other than a PMSI, a
prohibited act for state member banks. A state member bank is
defined as a bank which is chartered by a State and is a
member of the Federal Reserve System. 12 C.F.R. 5227.1(c).
Thus, the general rule is applicable to banks as defined
above, to lenders, and to retail installment sellers. (The
regulation speaks of non-possessory security interests
only. It would appear that a security interest in household
goods would be valid if perfected by possession. This
distinction might create uncertainty in other jurisdictions.
For discussion of possessory security interests in household
goods, see 49 Federal Register 7767 (March 1, 1984). However,
Kansas laws make the distinction largely irrelevant, as will
be discussed below.) Household goods are defined narrowly to
include "clothing, furniture, appliances, one radio and one
television, linens, china, crockery, kitchen ware, and
personal effects (including wedding rings) of the consumer and
his or her dependents. . . ." 16 C.F.R. §444 (1)(i). This
narrow definition allows the pledging of items which have
significant economic value. 49 Federal Register 7767, note
98.
16 C.F.R. §444.1(a)(4), limiting security interests in
household goods, was promulgated in recognition that such
security interests are used by creditors because of their
psychological or punitive effect on debtors' defaulting on
loans. 49 Federal Register 7763 (March 1, 1984). Based on
our understanding of the Kansas Consumer Credit Code and the
federal regulation, it is our opinion that a creditor may not
contract for insurance against loss to household goods [as
defined at 16 C.F.R. §444(1)(i)] unless the creditor's
interest in those goods is the result of a purchase money
transaction.
Kansas has adopted the 1974 version of the Uniform Consumer
Credit Code (U3C), K.S.A. 16a-1-101 et !..ca . The U3C
contains provisions which are supplemented by the
above-mentioned federal rule. While conflicts between the
federal and state rules in this area are not common, we feel
that it is necessary to note that the Federal Trade Commission
Act, and regulations promulgated pursuant thereto, do not
prohibit state regulation. The FTCA regulates unfair and
deceptive acts or practices in or affecting interstate
commerce.
Section 4.301 of the U3C, K.S.A. 16a-4-301, prohibits a
creditor from contracting for credit insurance unless "the
insurance covers a substantial risk of loss or damage to
property related to the credit transaction." K.S.A.
16a-4-301(1)(a). Emphasis should be given the phrase,
"property related to the credit transaction." If certain
property is not related to the credit transaction, then the
statute prohibits a creditor from contracting for insurance on
that property. Unless the consumer credit transaction
involves a PMSI, the Federal Rules state that property which
is categorized as household goods may not be property "related
to the credit transaction". (A non-possessory security
interest in household goods may not be taken except in the
form of a PMSI). State law would therefore prohibit a
creditor from contracting for insurance on that property.
1986 Senate Bill No. 454 would have amended K.S.A.
16a-4-301(1) to read: "A creditor may not contract for or
receive a separate charge for insurance against loss of or
damage to property unless: (a) the insurance covers a
substantial risk of loss of or damage to property all or part
of which is related to the credit transaction. . . ."
(Proposed amended language underscored). Our office was
requested to issue an opinion regarding the proposed
amendment. In Attorney General Opinion No. 86-42, we noted
that the proposed amendment would conflict with other code
provisions. In particular, we expressed concern that, if a
creditor could contract for or receive a separate charge for
insurance covering property which is not related to the credit
transaction, then the consumer might be purchasing insurance
which does not confer a benefit of value to him; such practice
is in conflict with K.S.A. 16a-2-501. To illustrate, assume
that the consumer-debtor is the loss payee on insurance
purchased pursuant to a credit transaction. If the insurance
covers property which is not related to the transaction;
i.e. previously owned goods, and the debtor already has
insurance on those goods, such as homeowner's insurance, then
the added insurance might be of no value to the consumer.
(Part 6 of this opinion discusses the matter further).
Without the proposed additional language, the code does not
permit a creditor to contract or receive a separate charge for
insurance unless the insurance covers a substantial risk of
loss of, or damage to, property related to the credit
transaction. Two purposes for this prohibition come to
light. First, a debtor should not be led to believe that
other property, such as household goods as defined by the
federal rules, are subject to the creditor's rights of
possession upon default. Secondly, the debtor must receive
a benefit which is of value to him when purchasing insurance in
a consumer credit transaction. Unless household goods are
subject to a PMSI, they cannot be property related to the
credit transaction. In addition, the consumer might not
receive a benefit which is of value to him if he purchases
insurance to cover the non-related goods. It is therefore
our opinion that a creditor may not contract or receive a
separate charge for insurance to cover household goods in
which the creditor does not have a PSI. In any event, the
proposed bill died in the House Committee on Insurance, June
6, 1986. Senate and House Actions Report, Final Report,
June 6, 1986, at page 40.
Our opinion to this point is confined to the question you have
presented, and should not be read as allowing a security
interest in property other than household goods, as dealt with
by the F.T.C Rule. Subsection (1) of K.S.A. 16a-3-301, also
places some precise limitations on security interests when a
consumer transaction is involved. When the federal rule
regarding household goods, 16 C.F.R. §444(2)(a)(4), and K.S.A.
16a-3-301(1) are read together, the following rules apply in a
consumer credit sale.
(a) A PMSI is valid in all goods.
(b) If services are performed on goods, then a security
interest may attach to the goods on which the services were
performed if:
(1) the goods are maintained, repaired, or improved as
a result of the service,
(2) the debt secured is $300 or more, and
(3) the goods are
(A) not household goods, or
(B) are household goods which are subject to a
security interest which is perfected by
possession.
(c) If goods are sold and installed, annexed to or improve
personal property, then a security interest in the personal
property is valid if
(1) the personal property is maintained, repaired, or
improved as a result of the improvement, installation,
or annexation,
(2) the debt secured is $300 or more, and
(3) the personal property is
(A) not a household good, or
(B) is a household good which is subject to a
security interest which is perfected by
possession.
(d) If goods are serviced or purchased and affixed to land
which is maintained, repaired, or improved by the service or
purchase, a security interest may attach to the land when the
debt secured is $1000 or more.
(e) If the consumer credit sale involves a valid
cross-collateral arrangement, a creditor may take a security
interest in goods previously purchased but which are still
subject to a previous debt, in order to secure the debt
arising from the latter purchase in transactions which involve
interstate commerce, but only to the extent that the prior
purchase does not involve household goods.
In applying the FTCA, security interests which arise out of
a consumer credit sale which do not fit into one of the above
categories are void. (There is a possible situation in which
the U3C would allow a security interest which the FTCA
would not, involving subsection (f) above. For our present
purposes, it is not necessary to discuss this situation.) If
property does fit into one of the above-listed categories,
then it is property which is related to the transaction, and a
creditor may contract for insurance on that property.
(2) May the amount of insurance contracted for in relation to
a consumer credit transaction be in an amount greater than the
value of the personal property in which the creditor has a
security interest? May the amount of insurance contracted for
in relation to a consumer credit transaction be greater than
the amount of the loan or greater than the amount necessary to
cover a substantial risk of loss or of damage to property
related to the credit transaction?
Limitations on the amount of consumer credit insurance and
benefits are provided in K.S.A. 16a-4-202. The statute
provides that (with limited exceptions):
"(a) in the case of consumer credit
insurance providing life coverage, the
amount of insurance may not initially
exceed the debt and, if the debt is
payable in installments, may not at any
time exceed the greater of the scheduled
or actual amount of the debt; or
"(b) in the case of any other consumer
credit insurance, the total amount of
periodic benefits payable may not exceed
the total. of scheduled unpaid installments
of the debt, and the amount of any
periodic benefit may not exceed the
original amount of debt divided by the
number of periodic installments in which
it is payable." K.S.A. 16a-4-20211).
In short, the statute requires that the coverage not initially
exceed the debt, and that coverage decline with the
installment schedule. See generally Fonseca, Handling
Consumer Credit Cases, Vol. 1, §12:9 (3d ed. 1986).
These provisions focus on the amount of the debt, not on the
value of property which is the subject of a security
interest. However, a further limitation appears in K.S.A.
16a-4-301(1)(6), which states that the amount of insurance
must be reasonable in relation to the value of the property
insured. The practical effect of these limitations become
clearer when they are applied to the three possible situations
which may arise, each assuming the security interest is valid
in light of other consumer oriented statutes. First, the
value of the property might equal the initial amount of the
debt. In that case, the amount of insurance coverage may
coincide with the value of the property. The second situation
is where the value of the property exceeds the amount of the
debt. In that case, the creditor is oversecured. For
example, if the debtor makes a down payment on a household
good, the creditor may have a PMSI in the item, the value of
which is greater than the actual debt. If the item is not a
household good, then the interest need not be a PMSI. In
either case, the amount of insurance is limited to the amount
of debt. In the event of property loss, the creditor will be
fully compensated. The third situation occurs when the
creditor is undersecured, where the value of property
subject to the security interest is less than the debt. In
this case, if the amount of insurance is equal to the amount
of debt, the insurance proceeds would exceed the value of the
property and a surplus would result. Public policy forbids
this result, as a creditor could benefit to a greater extent
than the security agreement provides by receiving a surplus,
or the debtor would benefit to the extent that he received the
surplus. In short, the debtor may have unknowingly contracted
for insurance which was not needed or desired. This last
situation is covered by the limitation which requires
reasonableness in relation to the value of the property
insured.
In summary, the U3C limits the amount of insurance in two
ways: by amount of, debt, and by value of property. It is our
opinion that the amount of insurance is limited to the lesser
of these two.
(3) May a creditor contract for insurance and be named loss
payee on a policy which insures all items of household
contents and personal property even though they have a
security interest in only a few of the items insured?
This question is very closely related to the first question,
in which we opined that a creditor may not insure household
goods in relation to a consumer credit transaction unless the
creditor has a purchase money security interest in the
item(s). Our opinion was premised in part on K.S.A.
16a-4-301(1)(a), which requires that the insurance cover a
substantial risk of loss to property related to the
transaction. The insurance contract must relate to the goods
which are subject to the credit transaction. Based on our
previous analysis, it is our opinion that a creditor may not
be named loss payee on an insurance policy for which he
contracts unless the creditor has a security interest in all
the household and personal property items insured.
In addition to K.S.A. 16a-4-301(1)(a), we find support for our
conclusion both in the U3C and in the common law. First,
K.S.A. 16a-4-302 involves creditors' single interest insurance
against loss or damage to property. The statute provides that
the risk of loss "is on the consumer only to the extent of any
deficiency in the effective coverage of the insurance, even
though the insurance covers only the interest of the
creditor." K.S.A. 16a-4-302. The 1973 Kansas Comment states
that this section prohibits a creditor from receiving a
separate charge from the debtor for insurance which covers a
creditor's interest in the property unless the debtor also
receives the benefit of the insurance. Professor Fonseca
explains the practical effect of the section:
"If a creditor obtains a separate charge
for insurance covering property worth more
than $300, and the property is destroyed
by accident so that the insured pays the
proceeds to the creditor, the creditor
must first apply the proceeds to the debt,
turn over any surplus to the debtor, and
proceed against the debtor only if there
is a deficiency, even though the insurance
covers only the interest of the
creditor." (Emphasis added). J.
Fonseca, Handling Consumer Credit
Case, Vol. 1, §12:11, at 500, (3d ed.
1986).
Both K.S.A. 16a-4-301(1)(a) and 16a-4-302 speak in terms of a
creditor contracting for or receiving a separate charge for
insurance. While we do not suggest that this language is
ambiguous, we do acknowledge that the general purpose of the
act is to regulate transactions between creditors and
consumers. An argument might be made that a creditor could
therefore contract with an insurer, as opposed to a consumer,
for insurance on the consumer's personal property, naming the
creditor as loss payee on the policy. C.F., K.S.A.
16a-4-102(b). In short, a scheme could be cleverly devised
whereby the consumer did not become a party to the insurance
contract, but indirectly pays for the creditor's protection
through higher prices. In such a circumstance, the common law
provides authority to prohibit the creditor from devising such
a scheme, as the creditor would not have an insurable interest
in the property. An insurable interest exists when a person
"would profit or gain some advantage by [the property's]
continued existence and suffer some loss or disadvantage by
its destruction [independent of the insurance benefit]."
Price v. Trinity Universal Insurance Co., 8 Kan.App.2d
223, 224 (1983). While the insurable-interest doctrine was
not intended to, and indeed would not, be a means of
regulating retail prices, its application discourages an
attempt by the creditor to obtain the insurance and pass the
cost to the consumer, thereby accomplishing indirectly what
the statute forbids.
In summary, it is our opinion that a creditor may not be named
as loss payee on an insurance policy which insures all items
of household contents and personal property belonging to the
consumer, when the creditor has a security interest in only
some of the items insured, regardless of whether the insurance
contract is in connection with or collateral to the actual
consumer transaction, and regardless of whether the charge for
the insurance is paid by the consumer directly or indirectly.
In addition, you inquire as to whether the policy should
specifically name those items insured or the items in which a
creditor has a security interest. This area is not
specifically dealt with by the code. However, under authority
of K.S.A. 16a-4-112, the Commissioner of Insurance has
promulgated K.A.R. 40-5-103. Subsection (c) of the rule
regulates evidence of coverage. Part (2)(B) states in part
that, in addition to other requirements,
"all policies of insurance issued in
connection with a credit transaction or
loan shall set forth the kind or kinds' of
insurance included, the coverages, and all
the terms, exceptions, limitationt,
restrictions, and conditions of the
contract or contracts of insurance.
Certificates shall contain all provisions
of the master policy applicable to the
debtor."
We have previously stated that the items insured must coincide
with the security interest, so listing the property both as
covered property and as collateral on a debt would result in a
redundancy. We believe that K.A.R. 40-5-103(c)(2)(B) requires
the listing of insured items in the policy.
(4) What disclosures must be given to the consumer before the
insurance is written?
An historical analysis of credit insurance indicates a pattern
of abuse by creditors and insurance companies. Fonseca,
§12:1 at 484. As we noted in Attorney General Opinion No.
86-42, the FTCA and accompanying regulation Z, as well as
the U3C, were established to prevent abusive credit
insurance tactics by insuring that consumers have a real
choice in the decision to purchase credit insurance. The
problem is well summarized by John M. Sheffey:
"It would be naive to assume that most or
even many customers make a conscious
decision concerning the desirability and
price of insurance, and on the basis of
their conclusions, inform the creditor to
include or exclude the insurance from the
transaction. This possibility is even
more remote when the consumers must make
their decisions quickly and in the
presence of lenders." John M. Scheffey,
8 Fl. St. Univ. L. Rev., 463, 490
(1980).
More generally, Sheffey notes that consumers are likely to
have made a decision concerning the purchase itself, and it is
unlikely that they will forego the credit merely because the
terms of the credit insurance are not favorable. See
Sheffey, at 489.
Both the Federal Rule and the U3C have, in some areas,
prescribed disclosure statement forms, for example, those
relating to door-to-door sales. Both authorities have
failed to do so regarding consumer credit insurance, however.
The disclosures which are required by both bodies of law are
summarized below. We do not intimate that a form disclosure
is required, however, it is desirable. What is necessary is
that the following information be related to the consumer in
such a fashion so as to insure . a meaningful choice in the
purchase of credit insurance.
(a) If the premiums for credit life, accident, health, or
loss-of-income insurance are not included in the finance
charge, and a separate charge is made, the following must be
disclosed:
(i) whether the insurance is required by the creditor; and
(ii) the amount of the initial premium, and if the term
of the premium is less than the term of the
transaction, the term of the insurance; 12 C.F.R.
§226.18(n), 12 C.F.R. §226.4(d)(1).
(b) If the premiums for insurance against loss or damage to
property are not included in the finance charge, and a
separate charge is made, the disclosure must indicate
(i) the consumer may choose the insurer, or substitute
an existing policy owned by the consumer, and
(ii) if the coverage is obtained from or through the
creditor, the amount of the premium, and if the
term of the premium is less than the term of the
insurance, then the term of the insurance;
12 C.F.R. §226.18(n), 12 C.F.R. §226.4(d)(1),
K.A.R. 40-5-103.
If the premium for insurance is included in the finance
charge, the amount of the charge for insurance need not be
disclosed, however this does not exempt the creditor from
restrictions under any other law, (such as a law pertaining to
usury); 1983 Kansas Comment to K.S.A. 16a-4-104.
(c) If vendor's single interest insurance is included in the
insurance policy, it must be disclosed that the premium for
the coverage has been charged to the mortgagee; K.A.R. 40-5-8.
(d) If more than ore insurance plan is offered by the
creditor, then the consumer must be informed of all available
plans. K.A.R. 40-5-103(a).
In addition, if the creditor agrees to provide insurance, an
individual policy or certificate of insurance, or copy
thereof, must be delivered to the consumer within 30 days
after the term of the insurance commences. K.S.A. 16a-4-105.
While this list is not exhaustive, it covers those
requirements relating to disclosures regarding insurance. For
other disclosure requirements in consumer contracts, see
generally, Regulation Z, 12 C.F.R. 226 and Part 226
Supplement I.
(5) What authorization must be given by the consumer to the
lender before insurance is written and what options does the
consumer have to deny the purchase of insurance?
Regulation Z, 12 C.F.R. §226.4(d)(iii), states that premiums
for credit insurance may be excluded from the finance charge
if, among other requirements, the "consumer signs or initials
an affirmative written request for the insurance after
receiving" the required disclosure. See also, 15 U.S.C.
§1605(b). The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve
System has issued two relevant Official Staff Interpretations
regarding this rule. In FC-0043, the Board noted that,
where the purchase of insurance is strictly voluntary and such
is conspicuously disclosed in writing, the intent of the
regulation is best served by a separate disclosure statement
of the various types of insurance. A separately signed
affirmative written authorization for each type of insurance
is not required. What is contemplated is that the "signature
authorizing insurance coverage be separate from that on the
contract document evidencing the credit transaction." 42
Fed.Reg. 9384-85. In FC-0119, the Board noted that no
statement is required, such as "'I desire credit life
insurance' or 'by signing below, I indicate my desire for
credit life insurance'." 42 Fed.Reg. 55881.
No magical words are necessary. What is important is that the
consumer must make an informed decision regarding the
insurance. If the consumer elects to purchase the insurance,
he must do so in a manner which indicates that the choice was
informed. This is accomplished by the consumer signing an
affirmative request for credit insurance.
The applicable laws do not prohibit a creditor from requiring
insurance against loss of or damage to property in order to
protect his interest. What is prohibited is an unscrupulous
creditor's requiring insurance for a separate charge, whereby
the creditor will receive a benefit over and above the benefit
received from the credit transaction itself. This is avoided
by requiring that the consumer be given certain options when
the cost of insurance is separate from the finance charge and
by other laws, such as those relating to usury, which protect
the debtor. 15 U.S.C. §1605, K.S.A. 16a-4-104.
The option given the consumer when the charge for insurance is
separate from the finance charge is to procure insurance from
another source, or instead, to offer a policy already in
existence. K.S.A. 16a-4-109. If the cost of insurance is
included in the finance charge, we find no authority which
allows the consumer to refuse the purchase of the insurance.
(6) May a creditor sell insurance to a consumer knowing that
the consumer has full coverage on the property and any loss
will be pro-rated by the two companies?
The uniform code and the federal Truth-in-Lending act were
responses to abuses by creditors which surfaced when the
post-World War II years experienced a boom in the insurance
and credit industries. Fonseca, §12 at 484. While the
federal act deals with issues of disclosure, the U3C deals
with other issues, one of which is unconscionability. Section
4.106 of the code, K.S.A. 16a-4-106, lists factors which are
to be considered when determining conscionability.
Subsection (a) includes the potential benefits to the
consumer. This factor is a reflection of the general
requirement that the insurance must cover a substantial risk
of loss to property related to the credit transaction.
16a-4-301(1)(a).
If the consumer has insurance already in existence which would
cover a loss to property related to the credit transaction,
the additional credit insurance might not provide a benefit.
(See Part 1 of this opinion). A clause in the credit
insurance contract stating that coverage will be pro-rated
in the event of other insurance coverage would deny the
consumer a material benefit from the credit insurance. If
this is done knowingly, the practice may be unconscionable.
In addition, we believe that the consumer's option of
providing insurance through an existing policy, as stated in
K.S.A. 16a-4-109, becomes relevant. This section is in
substance the equivalent of Regulation Z, 12 C.F.R.
§226.4(d)(2)(i). Footnote 6 of the federal regulation states
that a creditor may, for reasonable cause, reserve the right
to refuse acceptance of the policy offered by the consumer.
If the consumer offers existing insurance to cover the loss of
property, and the creditor does not accept the policy, to sell
credit insurance which will not benefit the consumer would be
deceptive. That being the case, the refusal itself may be a
deceptive act under the Kansas Consumer Protection Act, K.S.A.
50-626(b)(3), if the creditor knows of the existence of the
pro-rata liability clause.
In summary a creditor must give the consumer the option of
providing an existing insurance policy. That policy may be
refused for reasonable cause. If the refusal is made with the
knowledge that the additional credit insurance contains a
pro-rata liability clause, then the practice is deceptive.
In conclusion, it is our opinion that a creditor may not
contract for or receive a separate charge for insurance unless
the credit insurance provides a benefit which covers a loss to
property related to the credit transaction. Household goods
cannot be related to the transaction unless a purchase money
credit arrangement is involved. The amount of insurance which
a creditor may contract for is limited to the lesser of the
amount of the debt or the value of the property. If a
separate charge is received for credit insurance, a consumer
must give an informed, affirmative, written request for
insurance before the policy may be written. In addition, a
creditor may not sell insurance to a consumer knowing that
consumer will not receive a material benefit of the policy
because an existing policy covers the property, and the
benefits of the credit insurance will be pro-rated.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JuleneL.Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:MWS:jm

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.