Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-137

1986-137Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL September 26, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 137
Anne Reyes, Registrar
Pottawatomie County Register of Deeds
Pottawatomie County Courthouse
Westmoreland, Kansas 66549
Re: Taxation -- Mortgage Registration and Intangibles;
Mortgage Registration -- Instruments Subject Thereto
Synopsis: An instrument which purports to assign a debtor's
right to receive payment under a contract for the
sale of real estate represents a security interest
in personality and must be filed accordingly in
order to perfect the creditor's security interest.
The instrument may also be recorded in the office
of the register of deeds in the county in which the
real estate is located, as the instrument is such
that "real estate may be affected thereby." K.S.A.
58-2221. Further, since the instrument is not a
mortgage of real estate as defined in K.S.A.
79-3101, no mortgage registration fee may be
assessed for such recording. If, however, the
instrument incorporates by reference an executory
contract for the sale of the real estate which has
never been recorded, and thus upon which no
mortgage registration fee has been paid, then a
mortgage registration fee must be collected based
on the amount of the indebtedness involved in the
executory contract. This is so because one cannot
do indirectly (record an executory contract without
paying mortgage registration fees) that which one
could not do directly. Cited herein: K.S.A.
58-2221; 79-3101; K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 79-3102; K.S.A.
84-9-102; K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 84-9-401.
Dear Ms. Reyes:
As Register of Deeds for Pottawatomie County, you request
our opinion regarding a certain instrument presented for
recording in your office. The instrument is an assignment of
the assignor's "right, title, interest and equity in and to a
contract for the sale of certain real estate" as consideration
for a $20,000.00 loan. We refer to this instrument
hereinafter as "the assignment," or "the instrument in
question." The contract pledged as security in the instrument
in question is an executory contract under which the assignor
sold real estate to a third party on credit. That executory
contract was never recorded, and thus no registration fee was
paid thereon, but it is, of necessity, referenced in the
instrument now sought to be recorded.
You indicate in your request letter that the assignee in the
instrument in question, Citizens State Bank and Trust Company
(the bank), understands that the instrument represents a
security interest in personalty, i.e. the executory
contract (K.S.A. 84-9-102(3) and official comment 4) and thus
should be filed centrally with the Secretary of State's
office. K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 84-9-401(1)(c). However, the bank
further requests that you file the Form UCC-1 Financing
Statement in your UCC files and index and record the
assignment in your real estate files. The bank cites In re
Southworth 34 U.C.C. Rep. 1372 (D.Kan. 1982) and
Barkley Clark, The Law of Secured Transactions Under
the Uniform Commercial Code, S1-36 (Supp. 1984) as authority
for the proposition that a creditor which holds an assignment
of the debtor's right to receive payment under a contract for
deed to real estate should file a financing statement pursuant
to Article 9 of the Code, and "should also perfect an interest
represented by an assignment of the contract seller's
reversionary interest in the land itself by a local real
estate recording." Clark, supra.
The Bank has agreed to pay a mortgage registration fee for the
recording of the assignment based on the $20,000.00 debt
secured by the assignment. You question whether the
underlying executory contract must be presented for collection
of the mortgage registration fee pursuant to K.S.A. 79-3102,
and if it is appropriate to collect the fee on the assignment
as well.
In Attorney General Opinion No. 77-202, this office was
presented with a situation very similar to that currently
before us. An executory contract for the sale of real estate
between X (the seller/assignor) and Y (the purchaser) was
assigned by X to Z Savings Association (the assignee) as
security for a debt. Opinion No. 77-202 discussed the
situation and concluded as follows:
"K.S.A. 79-3101 makes the recording of [an]
executory contract for the sale of real
estate, the complete performance of which
is deferred for a longer period than
ninety days, subject to the mortgage
registration fee. The assignment [in
question] incorporates by reference all
the necessary details of the original
contract. The recording of the assignment
would in effect be the recording of the
original contract of sale.
"Your letter indicates Z is insisting that
all he has is an assignment of the right
to receive payments on the contract, not
the contract itself. This is
questionable. If all that Z has is an
assignment of accounts receivable, then Z
should file a financing statement listing
as collateral an [instrument and file
accordingly].
"But Z does not do this. Z wants the
assignment of record in the land records
to show against the real estate described
in the purchase contract. Why? It is
because Z wants to protect rights under
that contract to repossess the land in
case of default, just as X might have
done. Z wants to put this on record as a
lien against that land, so it will be
prior to any subsequent claimant or
intervening lien holder. Whatever the
reason, Z is undertaking to place a lien
on real estate in Wallace County by
recording an assignment of a purchase
contract which says that Z succeeds to the
rights of X the seller. Had X offered the
contract for recording, the tax would have
been assessed. Z, as successor to X,
cannot do indirectly what X could not do
directly. If this executory contract is
to be made a matter of record, the
recorder, whomever he may be, must pay the
registration tax." See also Attorney
General Opinions No. 81-180; 82-107.
Thus, it was concluded that an executory contract used as
security for a subsequent mortgage must have mortgage
registration fees paid on it before the subsequent mortgage
could be recorded.
In the situation quoted above, Z Savings Association was
virtually stepping into the shoes of X, the seller under the
executory contract. In the present situation, the bank has
been assigned all of the seller's right, title, interest and
equity in and to a contract for the sale of real estate, as
set out in the ccntract between the seller and a third-party
purchaser and evidenced by the instrument in question. The
instrument names the third-party purchaser, states the date of
that executory contract, and describes the real property which
was sold under that contract. Thus, all relevant terms of the
executory contract are referenced by the assignment now
offered for recording.
The consideration for the sale of the real estate under the
executory contract is not stated in the assignment, but the
absence of this term does not alter our conclusion. The
executory contract has been effectively incorporated by
reference into the assignment, making it a matter of record as
a lien on real estate and thus must be treated the same as if
the original contract is offered. Since the bank has stepped
into the shoes of the seller/mortgagee, it must pay the
mortgage registration fee upon the executory contract. We
note that in Attorney General Opinion No. 75-440 it was found
that the register of deeds "has the right to inspect such
additional instruments as may be necessary to establish to his
or her satisfaction the full amount of consideration secured
by a mortgage (in this case the executory contract) in order
to assess the proper fee." Thus, the register of deeds may
inspect the executory contract to determine the amount of the
debt upon which the mortgage registration fee is to be based.
While we feel that mortgage registration fees must be assessed
on the underlying executory contract, we do not believe that
they must also be charged on the instrument which represents
the assignment. As indicated previously, the assignment
itself creates a security interest in personalty. The
executory contract, an instrument, is the security given under
the assignment. The Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) applies
to any transaction intended to create a security interest in
an instrument. K.S.A. 84-9-102(1)(a).
"[A] UCC financing statement, which
lists as security for repayment of a debt
'the proceeds' of an executory contract
for the sale of real property, does not
transfer an interest in, or create a lien
upon real property. Such a statement
merely shows that the secured party has a
security interest in an instrument,
i.e., the executory contract for the
sale of real property. See note #4 of the
Official UCC Comment to K.S.A. 1979
Supp. 84-9-102.
"K.S.A. 1979 Supp. 84-9-102(3)
specifically provides that Article 9 of
the Uniform Commercial Code applies to a
security interest in an instrument, even
though the instrument itself is secured by
a real estate mortgage. In the case of a
UCC financing statement listing as
security the proceeds from an executory
contract for the sale of real property,
the debtor is merely pledging as
collateral for a loan an interest owned by
it in an instrument. The UCC specifically
covers such a pledge of security. K.S.A.
1979 Supp. 84-9-102(3)." Attorney General
Opinion No. 80-196. See also Attorney
General Opinions No. 80-29; 81-107.
Thus, an instrument which assigns the right to receive payment
under a contract for the sale of real estate should be treated
as a security interest in personalty for filing purposes.
However, "[the] instrument is such that 'real estate may be
affected' thereby, and thus, under K.S.A. 58-2221, if the
instrument is proved or acknowledged, and certified in
accordance with the provisions of K.S.A. 58-2211 to 58-2219,
inclusive, the instrument also may be filed in the real estate
records [and], since the instrument is not a mortgage of real
property, . . . no mortgage registration fee is due
[thereon]." Attorney General Opinion No. 82-127.
In your request letter, you indicate your feeling that
mortgage registration fees should be collected for recording
the assignment. You base your conclusion on Attorney General
Opinion No. 83-119. The facts upon which that opinion was
based, however, were materially different than those presented
for consideration in this instance. In Opinion No. 83-119,
the instrument sought to be recorded was one in which the
purchaser of real estate under an executory contract was
granting a lien on his equitable interest in the property.
It was concluded in that opinion that if the instrument gave
notice of the existence of the executory contract through
which the purchaser obtained his interest in the real
property, a mortgage registration fee would be assessed on the
loan then being made to the purchaser as well as on the
principal amount of the executory contract.
In the situation currently before us, however, the instrument
to be recorded is one in which the seller of real estate
under an executory contract is conveying his interest in the
contract, which involves the receipt of payments under the
contract and the power to enforce the contract. No additional
lien is placed on the property by virtue of this assignment,
therefore no mortgage registration fee need be paid on the
assignment.
In conclusion, an instrument which purports to assign a
debtor's right to receive payment under a contract for the
sale of real estate represents a security interest in
personality and must be filed accordingly in order to perfect
the creditor's security interest. The instrument may also be
recorded in the office of the register of deeds in the county
in which the real estate is located, as the instrument is such
that "real estate may be affected thereby." K.S.A. 58-2221.
Further, since the instrument is not a mortgage of real estate
as defined in K.S.A. 79-3101, no mortgage registration fee may
be assessed for such recording. If, however, the instrument
incorporates by reference an executory contract for the sale
of real estate which has never been recorded, and thus upon
which no mortgage registration fee has been paid, then a
mortgage registration fee must be collected based on the
amount of the indebtedness involved in the executory
contract. This is so because one cannot do indirectly (record
an executory contract without paying mortgage registration
fees) that which one could not do directly. Very
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Julene L. Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:crw

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.