Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-117

1986-117Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
August 18, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 117
Mr. Thomas L. Toepfer
111 W. 11th Street
P.O. Box 417
Hays, Kansas 67601
Re: Drainage and Levees--Watershed Districts--Powers
and Duties; Retention of Counsel for Tax Planning
Matters
Synopsis: When acquiring easements by donation from
landowners, the board of directors may employ the
services of an attorney or attorneys to perform
duties relevant to the drafting of the easements.
However, the district may not expend public monies
to reimburse a landowner for reasonable costs
associated in defending claimed deductions for
donated easements. Cited herein: K.S.A. 7-125;
24-1209.
* *
Dear Mr. Toepfer:
As attorney for Wet Walnut Creek Watershed District No. 58,
you request our opinion concerning the compensation of
attorneys by the district with respect to the acquisition of
easements. Specifically, you ask whether the district may
expend public monies to reimburse a landowner for reasonable
costs associated in defending claimed tax deductions for
donated easements. You inform us that, if the Internal
Revenue Service (IRS) does not allow the landowner to claim
a charitable tax deduction, he is not likely to donate the
easement to the district. The district would then be placed
in the position of having to pay for the easement.
K.S.A. 24-1209 (Sixth) provides that a watershed district may
employ such professional services and other assistance as is,
by its board of directors, deemed essential. It is clear,
therefore, that the board of directors may employ the services
of one or more attorneys to assist in conducting district
business. As the acquisition of easements by gift, purchase,
or otherwise, is district business [see K.S.A. 24-1209
(Eighth)] the district may hire one or more attorneys to
assist in expediting the acquisition of the easements. These
attorneys may prepare all necessary documents and conduct all
incidental searches. Attorney General Opinion No. 83-36.
They may also compile all relevant information about the
transaction for the landowner to use in claiming his
charitable tax deduction. Id.
As you note, the district greatly benefits by not having to
purchase the easements. Likewise, the landowner benefits from
the donation if he can claim a charitable tax deduction.
Since it is unlikely that the landowner will continue to
donate his easement if no benefit is forthcoming, it is clear
that the district's employment of one or more attorneys to
perform the above-mentioned services is beneficial to the
district. Accordingly, such an expenditure is a permissible
use of public money.
However, in Attorney General Opinion No. 83-36 we opined that
it would be improper for the district's counsel to provide
advice as to tax considerations or to represent landowners
directly in proceedings before the IRS. We did not intend
to limit the scope of this opinion to only those situations
involving the district's own attorney. Instead, it was our
opinion then, and it remains our opinion, that its reasoning
extends to the compensation of all attorneys, either directly
or indirectly, by the district.
It is a fundamental rule of law that a lawyer cannot permit a
person who pays him to render legal services for another to
direct or regulate his professional judgment in rendering such
legal services. K.S.A. 7-125, DR 5-107(B). Thus, even if the
district pays an attorney to represent a landowner before the
IRS, that attorney owes no duty to the district. Since
the interests of the individual landowner and those of the
district may not always be the same, and since any
appropriation of public money must be for a public purpose,
such an expenditure would be impermissible. See In re
Page, 60 Kan. 842 (1899).
Therefore, it is our opinion that a watershed district may
employ the services of one or more attorneys to perform duties
relevant to the drafting of the easements. However, the
district may not expend public monies to reimburse a landowner
for reasonable costs associated in defending claimed
deductions for donated easements.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Julene L. Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.