Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-110

1986-110Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL July 24, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 110
Dennis W. Moore
District Attorney
Johnson County Courthouse
P.O. Box 728, 6th Floor Tower
Olathe, Kansas 66061
Re: State Departments; Public Officers and Employees --
Public Officers and Employees -- Open Public
Meetings; Bodies Subject Thereto; "Membership of a
Body"; Mayor-Council Form of Government
Synopsis: The intent of the Kansas statutes authorizing the
mayor-council form of municipal government is
that the office of mayor is separate and distinct
from the members of the council. Under the Kansas
Open Meetings Act a meeting is defined as a
prearranged gathering of a majority of a quorum for
the purpose of discussing the business of the
governing body. A "majority of a quorum" is the
smallest number of members of the governing body
that can take official action. In accordance with
the intent of the Kansas statutes and the purpose
of the KOMA, we conclude that the "membership of
the body" in a mayor-council form of municipal
government does not include the mayor for purposes
of determining the minimum number of persons that
can constitute a meeting. Cited herein: K.S.A.
15-106; 15-201; K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 15-204; K.S.A.
15-301; 15-310; 75-4317; 75-4317a.
Dear Mr. Moore:
As district attorney for Johnson County, Kansas, you request
our opinion on the interpretation of a provision of the Kansas
Open Meetings Act (KOMA), K.S.A. 75-4317 et seq. We are
informed that the City of Westwood Hills is a third-class
city in Johnson County with a mayor-council form of
government. You ask whether the mayor is included with the
members of the city council to determine the "membership of a
body" for purposes of the KOMA.
The Kansas Open Meetings Act provides that it is "the policy
of this state that meetings for the conduct of governmental
affairs and the transaction of governmental business be open
to the public." K.S.A. 75-4317. A "meeting" is defined as
follows:
"As used in this act, 'meeting' means any
prearranged gathering or assembly by a
majority of a quorum of the membership of
a body or agency subject to this act for
the purpose of discussing the business or
affairs of the body or agency." K.S.A.
75-4317a.
The open meetings law is violated if "a majority of a quorum
of the membership of a body" hold a private, prearranged
meeting to discuss governmental business. You ask if the
mayor is a member of the body because you are concerned
whether the KOMA is violated if the mayor meets with city
council members to discuss city business.
The statutes governing third-class cities with the
mayor-council form of government are found at K.S.A. 15-101
et seq. K.S.A. 15-106 states that a majority of
councilmen must be present to constitute a quorum to do
business. In Attorney General Opinion No. 83-6, we stated
that a "'[m]ajority' . . . means the number one greater than
half the number of members of the governing body . . . ."
See also Attorney General Opinion No. 83-174. It was also
noted in the opinion that since particular quorum requirements
are not uniformly applicable to all cities, a city may through
its home rule powers change the quorum requirements of its
governing body by charter ordinance. We are informed that the
city of Westwood Hills has not changed the number required
to constitute a quorum specified in K.S.A. 15-106. It should
be noted, however, that an ordinance cannot be enacted unless
a majority of the entire membership of the city council voted
for it. K.S.A. 12-3002.
A third-class city with a mayor-council form of government
must elect a mayor and five councilmembers. K.S.A. 15-201.
If the mayor is to be counted with the council members for
purposes of the KOMA, four persons would constitute a quorum
(one-half the total number plus one), and three persons
would be a majority of the quorum. If the mayor is not a
"member of the body," however, three persons (a majority of
five) would constitute a quorum, and a majority of the quorum
would be two.
In determining whether a mayor should be considered a member
of the governing body of a city to ascertain quorum, the
statutes authorizing the mayor-council form of government
and the purpose of the KOMA must be examined. K.S.A. 15-201
provides for the election of "a mayor, and five
councilmembers." (Emphasis added.) With the consent of the
council, the mayor is empowered to appoint city officials and
to fill vacancies on the council. If the office of mayor is
vacant, the president of the council becomes the mayor until
the next regular election. K.S.A. 15-201; K.S.A. 1985 Supp.
15-204. "The city council shall elect one of their own body
as 'president of the council'" to serve in the mayor's
absence. (Emphasis added.) K.S.A. 15-310. It is the mayor's
duty to preside at council meetings, break a tie vote, and
enforce the laws and city ordinances. K.S.A. 15-301. The
powers of the city council are listed in chapter fifteen,
article four, which is entitled "General Powers of Governing
Body." The intent of these statutes appears to be that the
council is the governing body of the city and that the office
of mayor is separate and distinct from the city council. The
statutes authorizing the mayor-council form of government
for first-class cities, K.S.A. 13-101 et seq., and second-
class cities, K.S.A. 14-101 et !DE ., are very similar in
substance to the above statutes. We note that the number of
councilmembers of a first or second class city varies
according to the number of wards established in the city.
See K.S.A. 12-304; K.S.A. 14-301.
Kansas has no case law as to whether a mayor is a member of
the governing body of the city. In general, the law has been
stated as follows:
"Whether or not the mayor or chief officer
of a municipal corporation is regarded as
a member of the municipal legislative body
depends on the terms of the charter or
statute under which the corporation is
organized. It has been held that he is
not a member of the governing body, or a
branch thereof, unless expressly made such
by law." 62 C.J.S. Municipal Corporations
§388.
See Clark v. Mahan, 594 S.W.2d 7 (Ark. 1980) (Statute
provided that the mayor was part of the council.); 4
McQuillin, Municipal Corporation, §13.19, pp. 498-500
(1968). In 56 Am.Jur.2d Municipal Corporations §§163, 165,
176, it is stated that, even if the mayor is authorized to
preside at meetings and vote to break a tie, the mayor is not
part of the council and cannot be counted in determining the
presence of a quorum unless otherwise specified by statute.
See Savage v. City of Atlanta, 251 S.E.2d 248 (Ga.
1978) (Power to veto ordinances did not make mayor part of
council.)
The intent of the Kansas statutes and the general rule that a
mayor is not part of the governing body unless specified by
statute must be considered with the purpose of the KOMA. The
open meetings law was designed to prevent public meetings from
being a "rubber-stamp" of agreements made beforehand in
private by members of the public body. Thus, the term
"majority of a quorum" was chosen to define the number of
persons that could constitute a meeting as it is the "smallest
group of the particular governmental body that can take
official action." Tacha, "The Kansas Open Meetings Act:
Sunshine on the Sunflower State?", 25 U.Kan.L.Rev. 169, 182
(1977).
The business of the City of Westwood Hills is to be carried
out by the council. K.S.A. 15-106. The only situation in
which the mayor is involved in binding action is when breaking
a tie vote. If the mayor is included as a member of the
council, a majority of the quorum is three. In that case the
mayor could meet privately with only one council member to
discuss city business without violating the KOMA. Also, there
would be no violation of the open meetings laws if two council
members met to discuss city business behind closed doors. On
the other hand, if the mayor is not counted as a member of the
body, a majority of the quorum is two. The mayor could meet
behind closed doors with one council member to discuss city
business without violating the open meetings law because the
mayor would not be considered in figuring a majority of a
quorum. Two councilmen, however, could not meet in private to
discuss city business as a majority of a quorum would be
present. (We recognize that the result in this scenerio may
be different in the case of a first or second class city with
a different number of councilmembers than five.)
When a tie vote is broken, three persons, the mayor and two
councilmembers, are needed to take binding action. Even if
the mayor is not counted as a member of the body in that
instance, the purpose of the KOMA is served as the smallest
number needed to take binding action is prevented from meeting
privately. In addition, two members of the council would be
prohibited from discussing city business in private. In the
case of a meeting held with a bare quorum (three council-
members), the vote of two would constitute binding action. If
the mayor was included as a member of the council, these two
persons could meet privately and, in effect, make the
decisions of the city behind closed doors. In our opinion,
this latter situation would violate the intent and purpose of
the KOMA.
In summary, the intent of the Kansas statutes authorizing the
mayor-council form of municipal government is that the
office of mayor is separate and distinct from the members of
the council. Under the Kansas Open Meetings Act, a meeting is
defined as a prearranged gathering of a majority of a quorum
for the purpose of discussing the business of the governing
body. A "majority of a quorum" is the smallest number of
members of the governing body that can take official action.
In accordance with the intent of the Kansas statutes and the
purpose of the KOMA, we conclude that the "membership of the
body" in a mayor-council form of municipal government does
not include the mayor for purposes of determining the minimum
number of persons that can constitute a meeting.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:crw

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.