Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-096

1986-096Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
July 7, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 96
Frank C. Beyerl
Greenwood County Attorney
223 N. Main
Eureka, Kansas 67045
Re: Taxation -- Collection and Cancellation of Taxes --
County Treasurer's Acceptance of Partial Payment of
Delinquent Property Taxes
Synopsis: K.S.A. 79-2004 and K.S.A. 79-2004a deal with the
time for payment of real estate and personal
property taxes. By expressly giving the taxpayer
the option to pay the full amount immediately or
one-half of the full amount assessed at a time,
the statutes exclude all other options available to
the taxpayer. Accordingly, a county treasurer may
not be compelled to accept partial payment on any
delinquent taxes, although he or she may do so in
his or her discretion, crediting it to the tax
assessed. Cited herein: K.S.A. 79-2002; 79-2004,
79-2004a; K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 79-2101; Comp. Laws
of 1879, §89, §91.
*
Dear Mr. Beyerl:
As Greenwood County Attorney, you request our opinion
regarding the partial payment of delinquent property taxes.
Specifically, you inform us that the Greenwood County
Treasurer has refused to accept partial payment on any
delinquent taxes, and inquire as to whether she may be
compelled to do so. In answering your question, we find it
initially helpful to refer to 84 C.J.S. §624 on Taxation. The
sub-heading on partial payment provides:
"Except where part payment is authorized
by statute, or where the taxes are
separable, acceptance of part payment
cannot be compelled, although an officer
may accept it in his discretion."
(Emphasis added.)
The section explains that the law ordinarily intends that
taxes shall be paid in full at one time and, unless part
payment is authorized by statute, a taxpayer cannot tender a
portion of the tax due and demand a receipt therefor.
However, it goes on to state that this does not mean the
officer may not legally accept a partial payment, and in fact
he may do so in his discretion, crediting it to the tax
assessed.
We are aware that your question is directed toward the
collection of delinquent, not current, property taxes. K.S.A.
1985 Supp. 79-2101, the statute which deals with the
collection of delinquent taxes, specifies:
"All the taxes on personal property that
remain due and unpaid on February 16 or
July 1 shall be collected in the following
manner:
"If such taxes remain unpaid for a period
of 30 days after mailing such notice, the
county treasurer shall forthwith issue a
warrant under the treasurer's hand
directed to the sheriff of the county,
commanding the sheriff to levy the amount
of such unpaid taxes and the interest
thereon, together with the sheriff's fees
for collecting the same, upon any personal
property, tangible or - intangible, of the
person, firm, unincorporated
association,company or corporation to whom
such taxes were assessed."
Thus, if personal property taxes are not paid to the county
treasurer by February 16 or July 1 of the year due, they
become delinquent and must be collected according to the
provisions of K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 79-2101, rather than pursuant
to K.S.A. 79-2004a. However, we find no differences in the
statutes which deal with the payment of current taxes (K.S.A.
79-2004 and 79-2004a), and the statute which deals with the
payment of delinquent taxes (K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 79-2101), which
would compel a county treasurer to accept partial payment on
delinquent taxes when the treasurer cannot be compelled to
accept the same on current taxes. Therefore, we find the
provisions of K.S.A.
79-2004 and 79-2004a, and the case law in Sheriff v.
Ainsworth, 27 Kan. 446 (1882), to be relevant in answering
your inquiry.
K.S.A. 79-2004 deals with the time for payment of real estate
taxes, and states at subsection (a):
"Any person charged with real estate taxes
on the tax books in the hands of the county
treasurer may pay, at such person's option,
the full amount thereof on or before
December 20 of each year, or 1/2 thereof on
or before December 20 and the remaining 1/2
on or before June 20 next ensuing."
Similarly, K.S.A. 79-2004a deals with the time for payment of
personal property taxes, and states:
"Any person, firm, unincorporated
association, company or corporation charged
with personal property taxes on the tax
books in the hands of the county treasurer
may at its option pay the full amount
thereof on or before December 20 of each
year, or 1/2 thereof on or before December
20 and the remaining 1/2 thereof on or
before June 20 next ensuing, . . . ."
"In the event any one so charged with
personal property taxes shall fail to pay
the first half thereof on or before
December 20, then the full amount thereof
shall become immediately due and payable."
(Emphasis added.)
Thus, the Kansas statutes dealing with the collection and
cancellation of taxes authorize the payment of taxes in one of
two ways: either the full amount can be paid on or before
December 20 of each year, or one-half of the full amount can
be paid on or before December 20 and the remaining one-half
on or before June 20 next ensuing.
We rely on the Latin phrase expressio unius, exclusio
alterius in concluding that by expressly giving the taxpayer
the option to pay the full amount immediately or one-half of
the full amount assessed at a time, the statutes exclude all
other options on the part of the taxpayer. Therefore, as our
statutes do not authorize any other partial payment of real
estate taxes or personal property taxes, the taxpayer must
either pay the full amount on or before December 20, or pay
half and half pursuant to K.S.A. 79-2004 and K.S.A. 79-2004a.
This result is supported by an early decision of the Kansas
Supreme Court which addressed the question of whether a
taxpayer can at his option tender to the county treasurer a
part of the taxes assessed upon any specific property, and
compel him to receive and issue a receipt for such portion.
The court stated:
"A county treasurer cannot be compelled to
receive taxes by piecemeal, nor obliged to
give any receipt unless a full payment is
made. Any other rule would throw a great
burden on the officer, beside casting into
the county records great confusion."
Sheriff v. Ainsworth, 27 Kan. 446, 448
(1882).
This decision was based on §89 of the tax law (Comp. Laws of
1879, p. 957), which provided:
"When the treasurer shall receive any
tax, he shall give a receipt therefor.
If upon land or town lot, the receipt
shall describe the land as it is described
in the tax roll, and give the valuation
thereof; and if upon personal property, it
shall state the value thereof, and on the
reverse side it shall give the amount of
each kind of tax on each one hundred
dollars." (Emphasis added.)
Our present statute on tax receipts by the county treasurer,
K.S.A. 79-2002, provides:
"Receipts shall be given for all taxes
received by the county treasurer.
Payment of current ad valorem property
taxes shall be validated by a statement
indicating the date received and the
amount paid on all copies of such
receipts." (Emphasis added.)
Both statutes impose the requirement that receipts shall be
given for all taxes received by the county treasurer. Based
on this requirement, the 1882 Kansas Supreme Court found that
§89 implied that the treasurer was entitled to the entire tax
before being required to give a receipt, and that the taxpayer
could not tender any sum of money he saw fit, and have the
same credited on his taxes, or demand a receipt for the money
thus paid.
The Court found this implication was made stronger by §91 of
the tax law, which provided:
"[Amny person charged with taxes, on the
tax book in the hands of the county
treasurer, may, at his option, pay the
full amount thereof on or before the
20th day of December of each year, or
one-half on or before the 20th day of
December, and the remaining one-half on
or before the 20th day of June next
ensuing."
While K.S.A. 79-2004 and 79-2004a separate the payment of
taxes into real estate taxes and personal property taxes, both
statutes contain wording nearly identical to that which was
relied on by the Kansas Supreme Court in 1882. That Court
stated:
"Giving him by express statute the option
to pay one-half at a time, excludes all
other option on the part of the tax-
payer. This is the clear intendment of
the statute, and we need go no further than
rest upon its language."
We concur in this result, and conclude that a taxpayer does
not have the right to make partial payment on delinquent
property taxes.
In summary, K.S.A. 79-2004 and K.S.A. 79-2004a deal with the
time for payment of real estate and personal property taxes.
By expressly giving the taxpayer the option to pay the full
amount immediately or one-half of the full amount assessed
at a time, the statute excludes all other options available to
the taxpayer. Accordingly, a county treasurer may not be
compelled to accept partial payment on any delinquent taxes,
although he or she may do so in his or her discretion,
crediting it to the tax assessed.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Barbara P. Allen
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:BPA:crw

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.