Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-017

1986-017Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
February 12, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 17
The Honorable Fletcher Bell
Commissioner of Insurance
Insurance Department
420 SW 9th Street
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Insurance -- Firefighters Relief Act -- Payment
to State and Local Associations; Non-Receiving
Associations
Synopsis: Absent legislative authority, "nonreceiving"
associations may not be reclassified as "receiving"
association after their initial year of
participation in the distribution of funds under
the Firefighters Relief Act. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 40-1706(c).
*
Dear Commissioner Bell:
You have requested our opinion regarding the proper
interpretation to be given to K.S.A. 1985 Supp.
40-1706(c)(4). Specifically, you inquire whether a
"nonreceiving association" retains that status permanently
or should be classified as nonreceiving only for its initial
year of participation in the Firefighters Relief Tax Fund.
It is our opinion that the meaning of the statute is clear,
and that while the effect of the statutory language may
impose an administrative burden on the insurance department,
relief must come from the legislature in the form of an
amendment to the statute.
While the legislature has not provided a separate definition
of "nonreceiving association," the meaning of the term may
be implied from the statute, which states in relevant part [at
subsection (c), paragraph (4), subparagraph (A)]:
"(A) Whenever a firefighters relief
association is to receive a payment under
this paragraph (4) but did not receive a
payment from the taxes collected for
calendar year 1983, the commissioner of
insurance shall determine for the
nonreceiving association, from such
information as is made available to the
commissioner by the nonreceiving
association, the amount the nonreceivinq
association would most probably have
received if it had actually received such
a payment from the taxes collected for
calendar year 1983, with appropriate
adjustments based on payments to
firefighters relief associations of fire
departments providing fire protection
services within geographic areas having
similar populations and assessed tangible
property valuation as the geographic area
provided fire protection services by the
fire department of each such
nonreceiving association, and, upon
making such determination, the
commissioner of insurance shall include
the amount so determined within the
computations prescribed by this paragraph
(4) for payments hereunder
• • • • " (Emphasis added.)
In plain terms, a nonreceiving association is one which is
to now receive a payment, but which did not receive such
funding for calendar year 1983, which is established as the
base year for purposes of calculating such payments.
You indicate that such an interpretation may not be conducive
to the efficient administration of the relief fund. Your
concerns involve the burden placed on the insurance department
in the yearly reassessment of nonreceiving associations, and
the advantage such associations will have over "receiving"
associations in being able to prosper from increases in
population and property values. While these concerns are
valid, in our opinion no inherent absurdity results from our
interpretation of the statute.
It appears that a reassessment will be necessary only when
there are in fact changes in a nonreceiving association's
population or property values. It follows that if there are
no substantial changes, the previous year's formulation would
remain valid. However, it is apparent that the legislature
did intend for changes to result in adjustments in funding, as
evidenced by K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 40-1706(c)(B), which states in
relevant part:
"(B) one or more firefighters relief
associations may apply to the commissioner
of insurance for a redetermination of the
proportionate amounts payable to all
firefighters relief associations under
this paragraph . . . ." (Emphasis added.)
This section, which also addresses your concern regarding
disparities between receiving and nonreceiving associations,
indicates that the legislature contemplated changing
populations and property values. Accordingly, a mechanism is
available for redeterming the amounts to be given to all
association, both "receiving" and "nonreceiving."
The failure of the legislature to define a nonreceiving
association as retaining such status for only its initial year
cannot be said to be an obvious oversight or omission.
Further, in construing statutes there is a presumption against
.finding inadvertent omissions or oversights. See 82 C.J.S.
Statutes, §316, at 547-48. While it cannot be said with
certainty that these concerns were in fact considered by the
legislature, it is well settled that omissions resulting from
inadvertence or failure to contemplate an occurrence are not
grounds for a court to supply the words or phrases which may
have been omitted. State v. Wood, 231 Kan. 699, 701 (1982).
Since no inherent ambiguity appears in the statute, a
definition limiting the classification of associations as
nonreceiving to one year lies entirely within the province
of the legislature. It is well settled that "an
administrative body may interpret an uncertain statute, but it
cannot make new law." Lowden v. Garvie, 152 Kan. 388,
392 (1940). Accordingly, it remains up to the legislature to
to clarify the status of a "nonreceiving" association.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.Southard
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JSS:crw

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.