Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-169

1985-169Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

December 12, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 169
M. Leon Foster, President
Independence Community College
College Avenue & Brookside Drive
Independence, Kansas 67301
Re: State Departments; Public Officers and Employees --
Public Officers and Employees; Conflict of
Interests -- Prohibition on Certain Contracts;
Community College Board of Trustees
Synopsis: A determination whether a member of a community
college's board of trustees has a conflict of
interest because of his or her affiliation with a
business should be based on the general conflict of
interest statutes, K.S.A. 75-4301 et seq.
Where those statutes are inapplicable, the
determination of a conflict of interest should be
based on common law principles. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 75-4301; 75-4304.
Dear Mr. Foster:
In your capacity as President of Independence Community
College, you request legal guidelines that would assist
members of the college's board of trustees to determine
whether they may have a conflict of interest in certain
situations. You advise that two trustees own local business
firms that have ad business dealings with the college, that
one trustee is a medical doctor who may receive some student
athlete fees, and that yet another has a son on the college
teaching staff.
The general conflict of interest statutes for public officials
are found in K.S.A. 75-4301 et seq. K.S.A. 75-4304(a)
prohibits public officers (which term, as defined, would
include members of the board of trustees) from making or
"participating in the making of" contracts in which they have
a "substantial interest." This latter term is defined in
K.S.A. 75-4301 to include an individual's ownership of a legal
or equitable interest exceeding $5,000.00 or 5% of any
business.
K.S.A. 75-4304(a) provides that a public officer does not make
or participate in the making of a contract if he or she
abstains from any action in regard to the contract. A recent
advisory opinion from the Kansas Public Disclosure Commission
indicates that a "line-item abstention" would be appropriate
in such circumstances. (See Opinion 85-16, copy enclosed.)
Accordingly, the two trustees who own local business firms
should abstain from any and all board action concerning the
college's contracts with those businesses.
The general conflict of interest statutes do not include
within their scope the receipt of medical fees or the
existence of a familial relationship. Accordingly, it is
necessary to look to common law principles in resolving these
questions. The general common law rule states that a conflict
of interest exists if an administrative official votes on a
matter in which he has a personal, direct and pecuniary
interest. 63 Am.Jur.2d, Public Officers and Employees,
§322; Opinion of the Justices, 183 A.2d 909, 912 (N.H.
1962). The term "conflict of interest," when it is used to
suggest disqualification of a public official for performing
his sworn duty, refers to a clash between the public interest
and the private pecuniary interest of the individual
concerned. Gardner v. Nashville Housing Authority, 514 F.2d
38, 41 (6th Cir. 1975).
The Kansas Supreme Court has recognized the common law
principle that:
. . . a public officer owes an undivided
duty to the public whom he serves and is
not permitted to place himself in a
position that will subject him to
conflicting duties or cause him to act
other than for the best interests of the
public." Anderson v. City of Parsons,
209 Kan. 337, 341 (1972).
The court further stated that it adhered to the rule that
members of a public board are disqualified to vote as such on
proposals on which they have a "prime interest adverse to" the
public entity they represent. (209 Kan. at 345). However,
the court found that the rule should not apply to disqualify
any of the city commissioners or urban renewal commissioners
who owned property within the general urban renewal area but
not included in the specific urban renewal project under
consideration. The court noted that the common law does not
forbid the holding of an office and exercising powers
thereunder because of a possibility of a future conflict of
interest. (209 Kan. at 341-42.)
Similarly, in City of Topeka v. Huntoon, 46 Kan. 634
(1891), the court recognized the common law rule that members
of an administrative board are disqualified to vote on
propositions in which they have a "direct pecuniary interest
adverse" to the public body they represent (46 Kan. at 653).
However, the court found no such conflict of interest where a
city councilman voted on the establishment of a sewer district
which would include and exclude some of his property.
As was stated in Anderson:
"[t]he difficult problem which is often
presented in conflict of interest cases is
in determining whether or not the personal
interest of the commissioner or board
member is of a nature justifying
disqualification to act. Usually this is
a question to be determined under the
peculiar facts and circumstances of the
particular case presented to the court for
determination." 209 Kan. at 342.
In our judgment, a trustee who collects fees from student
athlete charges would have a direct pecuniary interest in any
proposal to increase or alter those medical fees.
Accordingly, he should abstain from participation in any board
action concerning such a proposal. However, a trustee whose
son teaches at the college would not, merely by virtue of that
relationship, appear to have a direct pecuniary interest in a
proposal concerning the terms and conditions of his son's
employment.
When the members of the board of trustees are placed in a
situation which may be viewed as a conflict of interest, those
members should first determine, perhaps with the advice of the
college's legal counsel, whether their decision falls within
the general conflict of interest statutes. If those statutes
are inapplicable, the board members should then, in reliance
upon common law principles, determine whether they have a
direct pecuniary interest which is not of a general or minor
character and which is adverse to that of the public they seek
to represent.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
Kathryn Gardner
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:KG:crw

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.