Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-167

1985-167Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

December 12, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85 - 167
Ronald Heberling
Elk Township Trustee
Route 2
Overbrook, Kansas 66524
Re: Bonds and Warrants--Cash Basis Law--Lease or
Installment Purchase Agreement; When Allowed
Synopsis: The Cash Basis Law, K.S.A. 10-1101 et seq., forbids
a municipality to incur a contractual indebtedness
in excess of funds actually on hand in the
municipality's treasury and budgeted for such
indebtedness in any particular budget year. K.S.A.
10-1116b allows municipalities to enter into
lease-purchase agreements which provide for periodic
payments or monthly installments, but only if such
agreements specifically state that the municipality is
obligated only to pay such payments or installments as
have been provided in the budget of the municipality
for the current year, or which can be derived from a
lawfully operated revenue producing source.
Accordingly, an agreement which may obligate a
municipality for an amount in excess of the funds
provided in the budget for the current budget year
does not comply with the Cash Basis Law. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 10-1101; 10-1113; 10-1116b.
Dear Mr. Heberling:
As trustee for Elk Township, you request our opinion as to
whether the provisions of a "lease-purchase agreement," to be
entered into by the township to acquire road maintenance
equipment, are in compliance with the requirements of the
Cash Basis Law, K.S.A. 10-1101 et seq. The agreement purports
to lease the described equipment to the township, subject to the
terms and conditions stated in the agreement. Your concern is
that certain of these terms and conditions obligate the township
beyond what is allowed under the Cash Basis Law.
For example, the final paragraph of item 2 of the agreement
provides that the township "covenants that it will do all things
lawfully within its power to obtain, maintain and properly request
and pursue funds from which the Lease Payments may be made,
including making provisions for such payments to the extent
necessary in each budget submitted for the purpose of obtaining
funding, using its bona fide best efforts to have such portion of
the budget approved and exhausting all available and
administrative reviews and appeals in the event such portion of
the budget is not approved. . . ." Item 3 of the agreement
allows the township to terminate the agreement at the end of any
fiscal period during the payment schedule, but only if "(i) funds
for the succeeding fiscal period cannot be obtained, (ii) Lessee
has exhausted all legally available means for making the payment
called for under this Agreement, (iii) Lessee has invoked and
diligently pursued all legal procedures by which payment called
for under this Agreement may be made, (iv) such failure to obtain
funds has not resulted from any act or failure to act of Lessee,
(v) Lessee has not acquired and has no intent to acquire during
the subsequent fiscal period, items of property having functions
similar to those of the equipment or which provide similar
benefits to Lessee, and (vi) no funds have been appropriated for
the acquisition of such property. . . ." Finally, item 18
describes the events constituting default of the agreement and
includes failure to perform any other covenant or condition of
the agreement. Item 19 then provides that, upon default, the
balance of the amounts due under the lease shall become
immediately due and payable.
In our opinion, the agreement in question does not satisfy the
requirements of the Cash Basis Law. The Cash Basis Law forbids a
municipality to incur a contractual indebtedness in any amount
which exceeds those funds which are actually on hand and budgeted
for such indebtedness for that particular budget year. K.S.A.
10-1113. While K.S.A. 10-1116b allows a municipality to enter
into lease and installment-purchase agreements which provide for
periodic payments or monthly installments over a period in excess
of one year, this is only under the conditions provided; such
conditions being:
"Nothing in the provisions of K.S.A. 10-1101
et seq. shall prohibit a municipality from
entering into (1) an agreement to pay for
electric interconnection or transmission
facilities or services, (2) a lease agreement,
with or without an option to buy, or (3) an
installment-purchase agreement, if any of
such agreements specifically state that the
municipality is obligated only to pay periodic
payments or monthly installments under the
agreement as may lawfully be made from (a)
funds budgeted and appropriated for that
purpose during such municipality's current
budget year or (b) funds made available from
any lawfully operated revenue producing
source." K.S.A. 10-1116b (Emphasis added.)
Under this statute, a lease or installment-purchase agreement may
not obligate a municipality to make payments in any year
subsequent to its current budget year. In addition, it may not
obligate a municipality to pay more in the current year than is
budgeted for that particular purpose in the current year's budget.
The lease-purchase agreement in question does not contain the
specific statement limiting the township's obligation as required
by K.S.A. 10-1116b. This office has previously opined that the
inclusion of such a statement is mandatory. See Attorney General
Opinion Nos. 84-117, 82-46 and 80-141. Moreover, the agreement
obligates the township to do everything legally possible to
provide for payments from future budgets, and states that failure
to do so may result in the balance of the lease payments becoming
due and payable, regardless of whether there are funds on hand to
pay the balance. This language is a clear violation of the Cash
Basis Law, in that it obligates the township to make payments
other than the periodic payments or monthly installments.
The township's right to terminate (item 3 of the agreement) does
not compensate for this lack of compliance with the Cash Basis
Law. Attorney General Schneider concluded in his Opinion Number
77-279 that:
"The privilege of cancellation does not
immunize the agreement from the cash-basis
law. The agreement must be measured against
the cash-basis law on the basis of the
obligation which exists unless and until the
privilege of cancellation is exercised, for
unless and until that occurs, the agreement
constitutes a binding obligation on the city
for which sufficient funds must be on hand and
available for that purpose at the time the
obligation is incurred."
We affirmed that conclusion in Attorney General Opinion No.
80-141, and do so again here.
In conclusion, it is our opinion that the lease-purchase
agreement in question is in violation of the Cash Basis Law, in
that it obligates the township to pay more than periodic payments
or monthly installments as have been provided for in the budget
of the township for the current budget year, or which can be
derived from a lawfully operated revenue producing source.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JuleneL.Miller
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:JLM:jm

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.