Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-136

1985-136Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

October 9, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85 - 136
Frederick J. Works
Immel & Immel
P.O. Box 766
Iola, Kansas 66749
Re: Waters and Watercourses -- Water Districts -- Rural
Water Districts -- Definitions; Participating Member
Synopsis: A person is eligible to serve on the board of
directors of a rural water district if he or she is
a "participating member" in the district, with this
term including persons who own land within the
district and who have subscribed to one or more
benefit units. While a person purchasing land on
contract holds an equitable interest in that land,
he or she does not have fee simple title. Due to
the nature of the right involved (i.e. the right
to vote), and the silence of the statutes as to
whether this right may be shared, the right to vote
in district matters should be exercised by the
holder of fee simple title. Cited herein: K.S.A.
60-1102; 82a-612; 82a-614; 82a-618; 82a-622;
82a-626; 82a-1021; E. 1978, ch. 230.
Dear Mr. Works:
As an associate in the law firm of Immel and Immel, which
represents the City of Elsmore, you request our opinion on a
question involving the board of directors of a rural water
district. Specifically, you inquire whether a person who is
purchasing land on contract (which land is located within the
district) and who has subscribed to a benefit unit of the
district is eligible to serve on the board of directors. The
district in question is Rural Water District No. 2, and is
located in Neosho and Allen counties.
The controlling statutes in this area are found at K.S.A.
82a-612 et seq., which is a 1957 act providing for the
establishment and operation of rural water districts. The
governing body of such a district is the board of directors,
who are selected pursuant to K.S.A. 82a-618 from among the
participating members of the district at the annual meeting.
K.S.A. 82a-626. The term "participating member" is defined at
K.S.A. 82a-612 to mean "an individual, firm, partnership,
association or corporation which owns land located within a
district and which has subscribed to one or more benefit units
of such district." In your case, there is no question that
the individual has subscribed to a benefit unit and is current
in his payments. This last requirement regarding payments is
found in the district's section of the by-laws which defines
"participating member," and is not at issue here.
Rather, the sole question presented for our opinion is whether
an individual who meets all of the other requirements for a
participating member may be denied a seat on the board of
directors because he is purchasing land on contract, instead
of being a holder of fee simple title. We initially note that
K.S.A. 82a-612 et seq. does not contain the language found
in another, related act which answers this question. K.S.A.
82a-1021(e), which is contained in the Groundwater Management
District Act, expressly states that "eligible voter" refers to
the fee owner, although a buyer on contract may, upon
agreement of the parties, be designated as the party entitled
to vote. However, as this act was not enacted at the same
time as the rural water district act and relates to a
different subject matter, K.S.A. 82a-1021 is not in pari
materia with K.S.A. 82a-612, and therefore is not
controlling, although it does indicate how the legislature has
addressed this question in a similar set of statutes.
Our research has indicated that in at least one area of Kansas
law the courts have construed the term "owner" to include
purchasers on contract. Prior to its amendment in 1978 by L.
1978, ch. 230, §3, the mechanics' lien law, K.S.A. 60-1102,
provided that notice of the filing of a lien statement must be
given to the "owner" of the property subject to the lien, with
the statute silent as whether owners of equitable interests
were included in the category of owners. In holding that they
were so included, the court in a number of cases declined to
give a "narrow construction" to the word "owner" so as to
limit it to the holder of the fee title. Toler v.
Satterwhaite, 200 Kan. 103 (1967), Schwaller Lumber Co.
Inc. v. Watson, 211 Kan. 141 (1973), Sutherland Lumber Co.
v. Due, 212 Kan. 658 (1973). Essentially, the court in these
decisions found that since the equitable owners could be
subject to and liable for any lien created, they had a right
to notice. While there could only be one debt, payment could
be sought for a variety of parties.
However, two factors lead us to conclude that this line of
cases should not be applied here. First, the act indicates
that, for purposes of both formation of the district (K.S.A.
82a-614) and attachment of adjoining land (82a-622), the tax
rolls of the county "shall be prima facie evidence of title
and of the name and address of the owners of land." While
purchasers on a contract for deed may be obligated by the
terms of that contract to pay into escrow the real property
taxes which are due, they are not normally listed on the tax
rolls, and so would not be owners of land under these statutes.
Second, in the present situation the "thing" at issue is the
right to vote, rather than potential liability for a debt.
While a buyer on contract may contribute all or part of the
cost of the benefit unit or units which have been subscribed
by a particular parcel of land, he or she cannot share in the
one vote to which the landowner is entitled. The right to
cast a vote in the district's affairs cannot be split, nor
should it be multiplied. If the latter were the case, a fee
owner who sold a number of small parcels on contract could be
joined in casting his or her vote by each of the contract
purchasers who had subscribed to a benefit unit. If the
former were allowed, would the vote be shared equally, or on
the basis of the degree to which the contract for deed had
been performed? Clearly, this is an area which needs to be
addressed by the legislature, perhaps on the basis of the
procedure already in place for groundwater management
districts as noted above.
In conclusion, a person is eligible to serve on the board of
directors of a rural water district if he or she is a
"participating member" in the district, with this term
including persons who own land within the district and who
have subscribed to one or more benefit units. While a person
purchasing land on contract holds an equitable interest in
that land, he or she does not have fee simple title. Due to
the nature of the right involved (i.e. the right to vote),
and the silence of the statutes as to whether this right may
be shared, the right to vote in district matters should be
exercised by the holder of fee simple title.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.	Southard
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JSS:crw

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.