Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-075

1985-075Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
July 3, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 75
Keith Hoffman
Dickinson County Attorney
325 Broadway
Abilene, Kansas 67410
Re: Labor and Industries -- Minimum Wage and Maximum
Hours -- Fair Labor Standards Act; Applicability
to Sheriff's Department
Synopsis: As a result of the decision in Garcia v. San Antonio
Metropolitan Transit Authority, the Dickinson County
sheriff's department is subject to the federal Fair
Labor Standards Act. Department employees who meet
the qualifications of 29 C.F.R. §553.4 are entitled
to the exemption from overtime in 29 U.S.C.A. §207(k)
if the employer so elects. As the department has more
than four employees who are law enforcement officers,
it is therefore not eligible for the exemption in 29
U.S.C.A. §213(b)(20). Law enforcement employees who
are subject to §7(k) may work a maximum of 171 hours
in a 28 day pay period. Following April 15, 1985,
overtime is required to be paid to such employees
for any hours over this amount. Cited herein: 29
U.S.C.A. §§201, 203, 206, 207, 213, 216, 217; K.S.A.
19-803, 44-1203, 44-1204; 29 C.F.R. §§516, 531, 541,
553, 778, 785; U.S. Supreme Court Rule 51, 52.
Dear Mr. Hoffman:
As county attorney for Dickinson County, you have requested our
opinion concerning the applicability of the Fair Labor Standards
Act (FLSA), 29 U.S.C.A. §201 et seq., to the Dickinson County
sheriff's department. This office has received numerous
inquiries concerning the FLSA and its applicability to various
governmental departments at the state, county and city levels. A
majority of the questions concern law enforcement personnel; many
are similar to the questions you have raised. Therefore, we feel
it appropriate at this time to examine various aspects of the
FLSA. Once this is done, we can apply the standards of the Act
to your specific questions, along with those which have been
raised by others.
The Fair Labor Standards Act was adopted by the United States
Congress in 1938. Its purpose was to protect workers in
industry by providing both a minimum wage to be paid for each
hour worked and overtime to be paid at time and one-half for
every hour worked over forty (40) hours. The act was
subsequently amended numerous times, and in 1974 was amended to
specifically include public employees employed by state and local
governments. Following numerous challenges to the Act's
provisions in this regard, on June 24, 1976, the Supreme Court
handed down its decision in National League of Cities v. Usery,
426 U.S. 833, 96 S.Ct. 2465, 49 L.Ed.2d 245 (1976). This case
held that Congress had exceeded its authority under the
10th Amendment in imposing minimum wage and overtime requirements
on state and local governments, at least in those areas that
constituted "traditional functions" of state government.
In response to National League, the U.S. Department of Labor
defined various areas of government service so as to distinguish
between traditional and non-traditional functions of government.
For example, the department maintained that public mass transit
systems were not traditional government functions, and so were
subject to the Act. The San Antonio Metropolitan Transit
Authority challenged this interpretation and after several
appeals to and remands from the Supreme Court, on February 19,
1985 a decision was issued in Garcia v. San Antonio Metropolitan
Transit Authority, U.S. 105 S.Ct. 1005, 83 L.Ed.2d 1016.
Rather than expanding the category of non-traditional government
functions, the Supreme Court completely overruled National League,
declaring that the tests created in 1976 to determine traditional
versus non-traditional functions of government were unworkable
and inconsistent with the established rules of federalism.
Without going into detail relative to the Court's rationale,
suffice it to say that due to the overruling of National League,
the FLSA is now fully applicable to state and local public
employees. As a result, we must look to the Act to answer the
questions you raise.
Section 3 (29 U.S.C.A. §203) defines employer as "any person
acting directly or indirectly in the interest of an employer and
includes a public agency . . . ." (Emphasis added.) Employee
is defined at §203(e) as follows:
"(1) Except as provided in paragraphs (2)
and (3), the term 'employee' means any
individual employed by an employer.
"(2) In the case of an individual employed by
a public agency such term means--
"(C) any individual employed by a State,
political subdivision of a State, or an
interstate governmental agency, other than
such an individual--
"(i) who is not subject to the civil service
laws of the State, political subdivision, or
agency which employes him; and
"(ii) who--
"(I) holds a public elective office of that
State, political subdivision, or agency,
"(II) is selected by the holder of such an
office to be a member of his personal staff,
"(III) is appointed by such an officeholder to
serve on a policymaking level, or
"(IV) who is an immediate adviser to such an
officeholder with respect to the
constitutional or legal powers of his office."
(Emphasis added.)
Section 6 [29 U.S.C.A. §206] reads in pertinent part as follows:
"(a) Every employer shall pay to each of his
employees who in any workweek is engaged in
commerce . . . wages at the following
rates:
"(1) . . . not less than $3.35 an hour
after December 31, 1980 . . . ." (Emphasis
added.)
Overtime provisions are contained in Section 7 (29 U.S.C.A.
§207). Subsection (a) in essence provides that no employee can
work in excess of 40 hours per week unless the employee receives
time and one-half for hours in excess of 40 hours. However,
payment of overtime after fewer hours per week can be negotiated.
A workweek (or work period) is based on 168 hours (seven 24-hour
periods) and constitutes 40 hours worked in a seven-day period.
See 29 C.F.R. §778.105. [Note: there is no prohibition on the
total number of hours worked, only on the maximum hours worked
before overtime is paid. See 29 C.F.R. §778.100 et seq.]
Subsection (e) states that the "regular rate" of pay which an
employee is paid "shall be deemed to include all remuneration for
employment paid to, or on behalf of, the employee, but shall not
be deemed to include . . . ." and goes on to list seven
exceptions. See 29 C.F.R. §778.200 et seq. The regular rate of
pay is basically the weekly salary divided by the number of
hours worked in that period. See 29 C.F.R. §778.108 et seg.
Subsection (k) of 29 U.S.C.A. §207 reads as follows:
"No public agency shall be deemed to have
violated subsection (a) with respect to the
employment of any employee in fire protection
activities or any employee in law enforcement
activities . . . if--
"(1) in a work period of 28 consecutive days
the employee receives tours of duty which in
the aggregate exceed . . . the lesser of
(A) 216 hours or (B) the average number of
hours (as determined by the Secretary . . .)
in tours of duty of employees engaged in such
activities in work periods of 28 consecutive
days . . . or
"(2) in the case of such an employee to whom a
work period of at least 7 but less than 28
days applies, in his work period the employee
receives for tours of duty which in the
aggregate exceed a number of hours which bears
the same ratio to the number of consecutive
days in his work period as . . . 216 hours
[or if lower, the number of hours referred to
in clause (B) of paragraph (1)] bears to 28
days, compensation at a rate not less than
one and one-half times the regular rate at
which he is employed." (Emphasis added.)
On September 8, 1983, at 48 Fed. Reg. 40,518, the Secretary of
Labor determined that the average number of hours worked in a
28-day period was 212 hours by fire protection employees and 171
hours by law enforcement employees. [See Appendix A which
provides a schedule of hours to be worked per day in various work
periods.]
Section 13 (29 U.S.C.A. §213) states that:
"(a) The provisions of sections 6 . . . and
7 shall not apply with respect to--
"(1) any employee employed in a bona fide
executive, administrative, or professional
capacity . . . .
"(b) The provisions of section 7 shall not
apply with respect to . . .
"(20) any employee of a public agency who in
any workweek is employed in fire protection
activities or any employee of a public agency
who in any workweek is employed in law
enforcement activities . . ., if the public
agency employs during the workweek less than 5
employees in fire protection or law
enforcement activities, as the case may be
1 1	
. • • •
(Emphasis added.)
Having now cited the basic applicable provisions of the FLSA, we
may now address your issues. You advise that the Dickinson
County sheriff's department is composed of the sheriff,
undersheriff, three full-time road deputies, a criminal
investigator, a secretary and matron, four dispatchers, matrons
and part-time jailors, a full-time jailor and a jailor/dispatcher
assistant.
Initially, it is clear that the the sheriff, as an elected
official not subject to the state or county civil service laws,
would be statutorily exempt from overtime under 29 U.S.C.A.
§203(e)(2)(c). As such, the sheriff would be expected to put in
as many hours as needed in order to effectively and efficiently
run the department.
As indicated above, a person is also exempt from overtime if such
person serves at the pleasure of the elected official, is
unclassified, is part of the elected official's personal staff or
is a personal legal advisor. Such persons would include personal
secretaries, executive assistants, etc. One possible such
position in the sheriff's department would be that of
undersheriff. K.S.A. 19-803 states:
"The sheriff of each county shall . . .
appoint some proper person undersheriff of
said county, who shall also be a general
deputy, to hold office during the pleasure
of the sheriff . . . ." (Emphasis added.)
As such, the undersheriff serves at the pleasure of the sheriff
and is thus an unclassified position, but is also a deputy. If
the position of undersheriff is truly unclassified (in that a
removal from office as undersheriff does not place the individual
into the classified deputy position), he would be exempt from the
overtime provisions. However, it is our understanding that the
undersheriff, if removed from office, would retain the classified
position of deputy and is thus truly not an unclassified
employee. Hence, he would not be exempt pursuant to 29 U.S.C.A.
§203(e)(2)(C) and thus it is necessary to look at the provisions
set out in 29 U.S.C.A. §213(a)(1) to determine if the exemptions
for executive,or administrative or professional employees apply.
The regulations that address this latter exemption are contained
at 29 C.F.R. §541.0 et seq. Taking the regulations and reducing
them to their simplest terms, the test to determine whether a
person is employed in an executive capacity (and thus exempt)
requires the employee to: (1) be paid a salary of $250 or more per
week (about $1075 per month); (2) have as a primary duty the
management of the department; and (3) customarily or regularly
direct the work of two or more employees. Employees who are paid
less than $250 per week but not less than $155 per week are
exempt if the following tests are met: (1) their primary duty
consists of management of the department; (2) the employee
supervises two or more employees; (3) the employee has either the
authority to hire and fire subordinates or has his decisions in
this regard given weight by the executive; (4) the employee has
discretionary powers; and (5) the employee devotes no more than
20% of his or her activities to non-exempt work.
In regard to employees who make more than $250 a week, management
as a "primary duty" must be based on all the facts. 29 C.F.R.
§541.103 states that the executive must spend at least 50% of his
or her time in management functions. (This same rule applies to
administrative and professional employees as will be discussed
below.) Examples of such duties include, but are not limited to,
interviewing, selecting and training employees, setting and
adjusting pay rates and hours worked, directing work, evaluating
employee proficiency and efficiency, handling grievances,
handling discipline and providing for the safety of employees and
property. For employees in the $155-$250 pay range, non-exempt
duties would include the same kind of work as subordinate
employees, i.e. clerical duties, cleaning premises, etc. See 29
C.F.R. §§541.99 to .119.
To be exempt as an administrator, an employee must: (1) be paid a
salary of $250 or more per week; (2) have as his or her primary
duty the performance of office or non-manual work directly
related to management policies of his or her employer and
department; and (3) exercise judgment or discretion, as opposed
to following procedure and using skills. For those employees who
earn between $155 and $250 per week, the employee can be
considered exempt if the employee: (1) has a primary duty
consisting of office or non-manual work directly related to
management policies; (2) customarily and regularly exercises
discretion and independent judgment; (3) regularly assists an
executive or administrator; (4) performs work that is specific or
technical which requires special training, experience or knowledge
under general supervision or executes special assignments and
tasks under only general supervision; and (5) devotes no more
than 20% of his or her time to non-exempt activities.
Types of administrative employees would include (but are not
limited to) an executive or administrative assistant, executive
secretary, assistant to department head, or an advisory
management specialist. These duties are very diverse and the
duties, not the titles, of the position must be examined.
Non-exempt positions would include filing clerks, secretaries,
etc. See 29 C.F.R. §541.201 to .215.
The professional is the third exemption and will be discussed
herein below, in the context of the department's investigators.
In your letter, you do not indicate the job duties or rate of pay
of the undersheriff. The undersheriff, however, has provided our
office with a brief description of his job duties. He indicates
that he has administrative functions relative to the department
only in the absence of the sheriff and regulates and supervises
the operation of the jail. He also advises that he answers calls
and serves civil process papers. He further indicates that his
rate of pay would place him in the category of employees
receiving in excess of $250 a week. Finally, the undersheriff
estimates, based on a 40-plus hours per week, that his job duties
are 20% administration and 80% general.
Therefore, to determine whether he is exempt from overtime pay, a
two-step process must be used as set out in the regulations
quoted above. Should he receive a salary per week of $250 or
more and spend at least 50% of his time in administrative or
executive functions, he would be exempt. However, based on the
information provided, it does not appear as if the undersheriff
fits within the tests. Therefore he is not exempt from receiving
overtime compensation. However, we recommend that any final
determination be made by the county.
Based upon your representations concerning the remainder of the
sheriff's department employees, none of them, except possibly the
investigator, would appear to meet the administrative or
executive exemptions. As such, under FLSA, each of the
non-exempt employees is entitled to be paid straight time of at
least minimum wage and overtime at one and one-half time for any
hours in excess of 40 hours per week. However, as has been
indicated above, a special rule [29 U.S.C.A. §207(k)] can be
applied to law enforcement officers and firefighters to enable
them to work up to 171 and 212 hours per every 28 days,
respectively. You will note that this represents a substantial
deviation from K.S.A. 44-1201 et seq. K.S.A. 44-1203 sets the
minimum wage at $1.60 per hour, while K.S.A. 44-1204 states that
law enforcement and firefighters must be paid overtime only for
those hours worked in excess of 258 hours in a 28-day period. See
K.S.A. 44-1203(b) and K.S.A. 44-1204(c)(1).
As the Kansas act is not applicable to those employees covered by
the FLSA, we must again look to federal law for the definition of
law enforcement officers and firefighters. In addition, it
should be noted that 29 C.F.R. §553.1(b) requires that an
employer elect to claim the §7(k) exemption before the 171 or 212
hour rule can be applied. However this election need not be
formal. 29 C.F.R. §553.4 reads in pertinent part as follows:
"(a) As used in sections 7(k) and 13(b)(20) of
the Act, the term 'any employee in law
enforcement activities' refers to any employee
(1) who is a uniformed or plainclothed member
of a body of officers and subordinates who are
empowered by statute or local ordinance to
enforce laws designed to maintain public peace
and order and to protect both life and
property from accidental or willful injury,
and to prevent and detect crimes, (2) who has
the power of arrest, and (3) who is presently
undergoing or has undergone or will undergo
on-the-job training and/or a course of
instruction and study which typically includes
physical training, self-defense, firearm
proficiency, criminal and civil law
principles, investigative and law enforcement
techniques, community relations, medical aid
and ethics.
"Employees who meet these tests are considered
to be engaged in law enforcement activities
regardless of their rank, or of their status as
'trainee,' probationary' or 'permanent'
employee, and regardless of their assignment
to duties incidental to the performance of
their law enforcement activities . . ."
Although you have not specifically inquired about firefighters,
29 C.F.R. §553.3 reads in pertinent part:
"(a) As used in section 7(k) and 13(b)(20) of
the Act, the term 'any employee in fire
protection activities' refers to any employee
(1) who is employed by an organized
fire department or fire protection district
and who, pursuant to the extent required by
State statute or local ordinance, has been
trained and has the legal authority and
responsibility to engage in the prevention,
control or extinguishment of a fire or any
type and (2) who performs activities which are
required for, and directly concerned with the
prevention, control or extinguishment of
fires, including such incidental
non-firefighting functions as housekeeping,
equipment maintenance, lecturing, attending
community fire drills and inspecting homes and
schools for fire hazards. The term would
include all employees, regardless of their
status as 'trainee,' probationary,' or
'permanent' employee, or of their particular
specialty or job title (e.g., firefighter,
engineer, hose or ladder operator, fire
specialist, fire inspector, lieutenant,
captain, inspector, fire marshal, battalion
chief, deputy chief, or chief), and regardless
of their assignment to support activities . . .
"(c) Not included in the term 'employee in
fire protection activities' are the so-called
'civilian' employees of a fire department,
fire district, or forestry service who engage
in such support activities as those performed
by dispatchers, alarm operators, apparatus and
equipment repair and maintenance workers, camp
cooks, clerks, stenographers, etc."
See 29 C.F.R. §553.3 and 553.8 for provisions relating to
ambulance and other emergency medical technicians. Additionally,
it should be noted that §7(k) employees are subject to the 20%
limitation on the performance of non-exempt work. 29 C.F.R.
§553.5.
We have been advised that the investigator, jailors and
dispatchers have been deputized. If these employees in fact meet
the above criteria, they would be treated as law enforcement
officers regardless of their actual duties. We are advised also
that the matrons are deputized but we are unable to determine if
they have met the third element of the §553.4(a) test (i.e.
specialized course of training.) In any event, using the
definition of law enforcement employee as set out above, and
based upon the information provided by the sheriff's department,
we have no hesitancy in concluding that the undersheriff,
deputies, investigator, dispatchers and jailors are law
enforcement officers and thus are eligible for the limited
exemption under §7(k). All other employees of the department
are subject to the 40-hour rule.
As noted earlier, 29 C.F.R. §553.1 states that criminal
investigative agents may be §13(a)(1) administrative employees.
However, depending upon the requirements imposed upon the deputy
necessary to enable him to become an investigator, the employee
may also be exempt from overtime as a §13(a)(1) professional
employee. To be exempt under this classification, the
professional must: (1) be paid a salary of $250 or more per
week; (2) have as a primary duty work requiring knowledge of an
advance type in a field of science or learning customarily
acquired by a prolonged course of specialized intellectual
instruction and study; and (3) perform work requiring consistent
exercise of discretion and judgment, or work requiring invention,
imagination or talent in a recognized field of artistic endeavor.
Employees earning less than $250 but more than $170 per week must
do: (1)work requiring advanced knowledge; (2) work that is
original or creative in character in a recognized field by
artistic endeavor; (3) work which requires consistent exercise of
discretion and judgment; (4) work which is predominantly
intellectual and varied in character; and (5) no more than 20%
non-exempt work.
Examples of professionals would be accountants, engineers,
chemists, etc. In essence, the test is whether the activity
engaged in requires a special degree and the work must be
intellectual and varied as opposed to routine, manual, physical
or mechanical. See 29 C.F.R. §§541.301-.315. Also, please note
the primary duty test of 50% and the non-exempt work test would
be the same as above. Therefore, to determine whether the
investigator, or any of the other employees in that department,
fit into the §13(a)(1) exemptions, it will be necessary to match
the duties against the test.
As indicated earlier, an employee can be a law enforcement
officer or firefighter and still be able to claim a §7(k),
§13(a)(1) or §13(b)(20) exemption. See 29 C.F.R. §553.1. This
regulation, however, goes on to state that:
"In no event, however, will the election [by
the employer] to take the section 13(a)(1)
exemption for an employee who qualifies for
it, result in excluding that employee from the
count that must be made under §553.1(d) in
determining whether the employer may claim for
its other employees the section 13(b)(20)
exemption." (Emphasis added.)
In other words, the criminal investigator and undersheriff who
otherwise are law enforcement officers and could be 513(a)(1)
exempted employees for purposes of overtime, will still be
included as employees for purposes of the 513(b)(20) exemption
(which exempts those departments which have four or less
employees with fire protection or law enforcement duties.) The
sheriff would not be included because he is not defined as an
employee at all under 53(e)(2). Therefore, based upon your
representations of the composition of the sheriff's department,
we have little hesitancy in concluding that the 513(b)(20)
exemption is not applicable.
Having addressed your main inquiries concerning the status of the
department's various employees, we feel it appropriate to briefly
discuss several additional FLSA provisions.
One of the most frequently-asked questions to this office has
been the issue of standby or "on call" employees. As a general
rule, the determination of whether an employee is "waiting to be
engaged" or "engaged to wait" depends upon the restrictions
placed on the employee's movement by the employer. If the
employee is told to stay by a telephone and wait, he is "engaged
to wait" and is entitled to be paid. If, on the other hand, the
employee is simply told to leave a number where he or she can be
reached or to carry a pager or portable radio and told to stay
within a certain radius of the office (and thus is otherwise able
to make use of his time as he pleases), the employee is "waiting
to be engaged" and is thus not subject to be paid until such time
as he or she is called back on duty. See 29 C.F.R. 55785.14 to
785.17. In addition, if the employer requires employees to come
in prior to the working shift to be briefed or allows the
employee to work (so called "suffered to work") prior to the
working shift, 29 C.F.R. §785.11 requires that the employee be
paid. See also 29 C.F.R. §553.14 and §553.17.
Pursuant to federal law, 29 C.F.R. §785.18 and §553.15 require that
employees must be paid for sleep time and meal time. If the
employee can be completely relieved of job duties for a period of
30 minutes or more for lunch, then the employer does not have to
pay for lunch time. If, however, this period is interruptible or
is less than 30 minutes in length, this is compensable time.
Also, for those employees who are required to work a 24-hour (or
less) shift and are given rest periods, these rest periods are
compensable time as well.
One of the biggest effects of the FLSA on sheriff's duties, as
well as other public employees, is the prohibition of
comprehensive or "comp" time. 29 C.F.R. §553.19 precludes the use
of comp time except on a limited basis. Those employees who are
not subject to the §7(k) exemption must be paid overtime if the
employee works in excess of 40 hours per week. As each work week
stands alone, the hours cannot be averaged together. 29 C.F.R.
§778.104. However, such is not the case with employees on the
§7(k) schedule. If the work period is 28 days, the number of
hours worked each day or week can exceed the scheduled maximum
hours as long as the permissible total is not exceeded.
Employees who must work in excess of the stated hours can be
subject to a forced lay-off or comp time to stay within the
permissible limits. However, the time can only be given in hours
off if the time is taken during the work week in which the
overtime occurred at an hour for hour comp rate. Comp time can
be given at time and one-half if taken within the pay period in
which the overtime occurred. If the comp time is not taken
within that specified time, the employee must be paid in cash by
the next pay period. See 29 C.F.R. §531.27 et seq.
Another common area of interest concerns the use of volunteers or
reserve officers. As set out at 29 C.F.R. §553.11, volunteers are
not considered employees until such time as they are paid more
than a nominal fee. Under the regulations, payments of $2.50 per
call are considered nominal. (Note: In that these regulations
were drafted in 1975, a higher amount may be considered nominal
by 1985 standards.) Any amount paid in excess of the $2.50 may
still be nominal if the money paid is actually reimbursement for
expenses, as opposed to renumeration.
You should also be aware of 29 C.F.R. §553.7 and 29 C.F.R. §785.27
et seq. These regulations state that whenever an employee is
required to attend training classes as part of a job requirement,
such time is compensable. Travel time may also be included. See
29 C.F.R. §785.33 et seq. 29 C.F.R. §553.18 allows employees to
trade time, with these provisions similar to those set out in
K.S.A. 44-1204.
It should be pointed out that the FLSA requires the maintenance
of records for a period of at least three years. See 29 C.F.R.
§516.1 et seq. While departments may currently be maintaining
hourly records, these should be checked against the requirements
set out in 29 C.F.R. §516.1 et seg. 29 C.F.R. §516.2 sets out
the basic reporting requirements and includes such items as name,
address, sex, date of birth, date and time of start of workweek,
regular rate of pay, hours worked each day and each pay period,
total straight and overtime hours and deductions for each
employee, whether exempt or not. See 29.C.F.R. §516.11. 29
C.F.R. §516.4 requires the posting of notices to employees of
the applicability of the FLSA. Furthermore, it is important to
remember 29 C.F.R. §553.9 mandates that whenever an employee is
engaged in joint employment or moonlighting, the compensable time
is "tacked" together if the employee worked for the same employer
in two capacities or performs the same type of work for two
governmental agencies. For example, if a police officer works
for the city as an officer and as a clerk, the hours would be
cumulative; they would not be if he worked as an independent
private security guard or for a different employer, so long as
the employers are truly independent of each other.
Section 16 [16 U.S.C.A. §216] contains the penalty provisions
for non-compliance. Subsection (b) provides an employee private
enforcement rights, and states that for violations of §§6 or 7,
the employee is entitled to the amount of unpaid wages and/or
overtime, and an additional equal amount as liquidated damages
plus attorneys fees. Subsection (c) contains the actions
available to the U.S. Department of Labor. These include
supervision of the payback of wages which would include a waiver
of the employee's subsection (b) rights, plus liquidated damages.
Any private remedies under (b) are suspended whenever the
Department of Labor intervenes, unless the department determines
that said intervention should be dismissed. Subsection (e)
contains criminal sanctions. Section 17 [29 U.S.C.A. §217]
sets forth the injunctive relief available to the department.
Finally, there have been many questions raised concerning the
enforceability date of Garcia. As stated above, Garcia was
decided on February 19, 1985. However, subsequent to the
decision, a motion for reconsideration was filed. The Supreme
Court denied that motion on April 15, 1985. Under Rule 51, a
party has 25 days in which to file a petition for rehearing.
Under Rule 52, a mandate will not lie until a motion for a
rehearing is ruled upon. Accordingly, we are of the opinion that
the effective date of enforceability runs from the date that the
litigation is final, or April 15, 1985, and not from the date the
decision was announced. See United States of America v. Ohio
Power Company, 353 U.S. 98, 1 L.Ed.2d 683, 77 S.Ct. 652 (1957).
Therefore, until such time as the state, county or city
department comes into compliance with federal law, those
employees who have not been paid overtime beyond 40 hours (and
were not otherwise compensated) are entitled to be paid time and
one-half for those hours. As noted, the number of hours which
may be worked prior to payment of overtime is increased if the
employer has elected the §7(k) exemption.
There are many more provisions of the federal law that have not
been mentioned. We have attempted to provide a concise outline
of the major sections. It may may be necessary for you to
consult the regulations for further clarification. Please note
also that since the statutes and regulations on public employees
were drafted in 1974 and 1975 and then stayed by National League,
it is extremely likely that they will be revised in the near
future.
In conclusion, as a result of the decision in Garcia v. San
Antonio Metropolitan Transit Authority, the Dickinson County
sheriff's department is subject to the federal Fair Labor
Standards Act. Department employees who meet the qualifications
of 29 C.F.R. §553.4 are entitled to the exemption from overtime
in 29 U.S.C.A. §207(k) if the employer so elects. As the
department has more than four employees who are law enforcement
officers, it is therefore not eligible for the exemption in 29
U.S.C.A. §213(b)(20). Law enforcement employees who are
subject to §7(k) may work a maximum of 171 hours in a 28 day pay
period. Following April 15, 1985, overtime is required to be
paid to such employees for any hours over this amount.
Very truly Boddington
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF 11ANSAAttachment
Matthew W. Boddingtmnr
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:MKANSAS
Appendix A
Work period (days) Maximum hours standards
Fire protection Law enforcement
28 212 171
27 204 165
26 197 159
25 189 153
24 182 147
23 174 141
22 167 134
21 159 128
20 151 122
19 144 116
18 136 110
17 129 104
16 121 98
15 114 92
14 106 86
13 98 79
12 91 73
11 83 67
10 76 61
9 68 55
8 61 49
7 53 43

1 printed pages contain little extracted OCR body text; searchable legal-body completeness has not been established for those pages.

OCR transcription for search; preserved printed pages are authoritative

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL

oy

STATE OF KANSAS
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
2ND FLOOR, KANSAS JUDICIAL CENTER, TOPEKA 66612

MAIN PHONE: (913) 296-2215
CONSUMER PROTECTION: 296-3751

July 3, 1985

ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 75

s

Keith Hoffman

Dickinson County Attorney
325 Broadway

Abilene, Kansas 67410

Res

Synopsis:

Labor and Industries -- Minimum Wage and Maximum
Hours -- Fair Labor Standards Act; Applicability
to Sheriff's Department

As a result of the decision in Garcia v. San Antonio
Metropolitan Transit Authority, the Dickinson County
sheriff's department is subject to the federal Fair
Labor Standards Act. Department employees who meet
the qualifications of 29 C.F.R. §553.4 are entitled
to the exemption from overtime in 29 U.S.C.A. §207 (k)
if the employer so elects. As the department has more
than four employees who are law enforcement officers,
it is therefore not eligible for the exemption in 29
U.S.C.A. §213(b) (20). Law enforcement employees who
are subject to §7(k) may work a maximum of 171 hours
in a 28 day pay period. Following April 15, 1985,
overtime is required to be paid to such employees

for any hours over this amount. Cited herein: 29
U.S.C.A. §§201, 203, 206, 207, 213, 216, 217; K.S.A.
19-803, 44-1203, 44-1204; 29 C.F.R. §§516, 531, 541,
553, 778, 785; U.S. Supreme Court Rule 51, 52.

* * *

Dear Mr. Hoffman:
As county attorney for Dickinson County, you have requested our
opinion concerning the applicability of the Fair Labor Standards
Act (FLSA), 29 U.S.C.A. §201 et seq., to the Dickinson County
sheriff's department. This office has received numerous
inquiries concerning the FLSA and its applicability to various
governmental departments at the state, county and city levels. A
majority of the questions concern law enforcement personnel; many
are similar to the questions you have raised. Therefore, we feel
it appropriate at this time to examine various aspects of the
FLSA. Once this is done, we can apply the standards of the Act
to your specific questions, along with those which have been
raised by others.
The Fair Labor Standards Act was adopted by the United States
Congress in 1938. Its purpose was to protect workers in
industry by providing both a minimum wage to be paid for each
hour worked and overtime to be paid at time and one-half for
every hour worked over forty (40) hours. The act was
subsequently amended numerous times, and in 1974 was amended to
specifically include public employees employed by state and local
governments. Following numerous challenges to the Act's
provisions in this regard, on June 24, 1976, the Supreme Court
handed down its decision in National League of Cities v. Usery,
426 U.S. 833, 96 S.Ct. 2465, 49 L.Ed.2d 245 (1976). This case
held that Congress had exceeded its authority under the
10th Amendment in imposing minimum wage and overtime requirements
on state and local governments, at least in those areas that
constituted "traditional functions" of state government.
In response to National League, the U.S. Department of Labor
defined various areas of government service so as to distinguish
between traditional and non-traditional functions of government.
For example, the department maintained that public mass transit
systems were not traditional government functions, and so were
subject to the Act. The San Antonio Metropolitan Transit
Authority challenged this interpretation and after several
appeals to and remands from the Supreme Court, on February 19,
1985 a decision was issued in Garcia v. San Antonio Metropolitan
Transit Authority, U.S. 105 S.Ct. 1005, 83 L.Ed.2d 1016.
Rather than expanding the category of non-traditional government
functions, the Supreme Court completely overruled National League,
declaring that the tests created in 1976 to determine traditional
versus non-traditional functions of government were unworkable
and inconsistent with the established rules of federalism.
Without going into detail relative to the Court's rationale,

suffice it to say that due to the overruling of National League,
the FLSA is now fully applicable to state and local public
employees. As a result, we must look to the Act to answer the
questions you raise.
Section 3 (29 U.S.C.A. §203) defines employer as "any person
acting directly or indirectly in the interest of an employer and
includes a public agency . . . ." (Emphasis added.) Employee
is defined at §203(e) as follows:
"(1) Except as provided in paragraphs (2)
and (3), the term 'employee' means any
individual employed by an employer.
"(2) In the case of an individual employed by
a public agency such term means--
"(C) any individual employed by a State,
political subdivision of a State, or an
interstate governmental agency, other than
such an individual--
"(i) who is not subject to the civil service
laws of the State, political subdivision, or
agency which employes him; and
"(ii) who--
"(I) holds a public elective office of that
State, political subdivision, or agency,
"(II) is selected by the holder of such an
office to be a member of his personal staff,
"(III) is appointed by such an officeholder to
serve on a policymaking level, or
"(IV) who is an immediate adviser to such an
officeholder with respect to the
constitutional or legal powers of his office."
(Emphasis added.)

Section 6 [29 U.S.C.A. §206] reads in pertinent part as follows:
"(a) Every employer shall pay to each of his
employees who in any workweek is engaged in
commerce . . . wages at the following
rates:
"(1) . . . not less than $3.35 an hour
after December 31, 1980 . . . ." (Emphasis
added.)
Overtime provisions are contained in Section 7 (29 U.S.C.A.
§207). Subsection (a) in essence provides that no employee can
work in excess of 40 hours per week unless the employee receives
time and one-half for hours in excess of 40 hours. However,
payment of overtime after fewer hours per week can be negotiated.
A workweek (or work period) is based on 168 hours (seven 24-hour
periods) and constitutes 40 hours worked in a seven-day period.
See 29 C.F.R. §778.105. [Note: there is no prohibition on the
total number of hours worked, only on the maximum hours worked
before overtime is paid. See 29 C.F.R. §778.100 et seq.]
Subsection (e) states that the "regular rate" of pay which an
employee is paid "shall be deemed to include all remuneration for
employment paid to, or on behalf of, the employee, but shall not
be deemed to include . . . ." and goes on to list seven
exceptions. See 29 C.F.R. §778.200 et seq. The regular rate of
pay is basically the weekly salary divided by the number of
hours worked in that period. See 29 C.F.R. §778.108 et seg.
Subsection (k) of 29 U.S.C.A. §207 reads as follows:
"No public agency shall be deemed to have
violated subsection (a) with respect to the
employment of any employee in fire protection
activities or any employee in law enforcement
activities . . . if--
"(1) in a work period of 28 consecutive days
the employee receives tours of duty which in
the aggregate exceed . . . the lesser of
(A) 216 hours or (B) the average number of
hours (as determined by the Secretary . . .)
in tours of duty of employees engaged in such
activities in work periods of 28 consecutive
days . . . or

"(2) in the case of such an employee to whom a
work period of at least 7 but less than 28
days applies, in his work period the employee
receives for tours of duty which in the
aggregate exceed a number of hours which bears
the same ratio to the number of consecutive
days in his work period as . . . 216 hours
[or if lower, the number of hours referred to
in clause (B) of paragraph (1)] bears to 28
days, compensation at a rate not less than
one and one-half times the regular rate at
which he is employed." (Emphasis added.)
On September 8, 1983, at 48 Fed. Reg. 40,518, the Secretary of
Labor determined that the average number of hours worked in a
28-day period was 212 hours by fire protection employees and 171
hours by law enforcement employees. [See Appendix A which
provides a schedule of hours to be worked per day in various work
periods.]
Section 13 (29 U.S.C.A. §213) states that:
"(a) The provisions of sections 6 . . . and
7 shall not apply with respect to--
"(1) any employee employed in a bona fide
executive, administrative, or professional
capacity . . . .
"(b) The provisions of section 7 shall not
apply with respect to . . .
"(20) any employee of a public agency who in
any workweek is employed in fire protection
activities or any employee of a public agency
who in any workweek is employed in law
enforcement activities . . ., if the public
agency employs during the workweek less than 5
employees in fire protection or law
enforcement activities, as the case may be
1 1	
. • • •
(Emphasis added.)

Having now cited the basic applicable provisions of the FLSA, we
may now address your issues. You advise that the Dickinson
County sheriff's department is composed of the sheriff,
undersheriff, three full-time road deputies, a criminal
investigator, a secretary and matron, four dispatchers, matrons
and part-time jailors, a full-time jailor and a jailor/dispatcher
assistant.
Initially, it is clear that the the sheriff, as an elected
official not subject to the state or county civil service laws,
would be statutorily exempt from overtime under 29 U.S.C.A.
§203(e)(2)(c). As such, the sheriff would be expected to put in
as many hours as needed in order to effectively and efficiently
run the department.
As indicated above, a person is also exempt from overtime if such
person serves at the pleasure of the elected official, is
unclassified, is part of the elected official's personal staff or
is a personal legal advisor. Such persons would include personal
secretaries, executive assistants, etc. One possible such
position in the sheriff's department would be that of
undersheriff. K.S.A. 19-803 states:
"The sheriff of each county shall . . .
appoint some proper person undersheriff of
said county, who shall also be a general
deputy, to hold office during the pleasure
of the sheriff . . . ." (Emphasis added.)
As such, the undersheriff serves at the pleasure of the sheriff
and is thus an unclassified position, but is also a deputy. If
the position of undersheriff is truly unclassified (in that a
removal from office as undersheriff does not place the individual
into the classified deputy position), he would be exempt from the
overtime provisions. However, it is our understanding that the
undersheriff, if removed from office, would retain the classified
position of deputy and is thus truly not an unclassified
employee. Hence, he would not be exempt pursuant to 29 U.S.C.A.
§203(e)(2)(C) and thus it is necessary to look at the provisions
set out in 29 U.S.C.A. §213(a)(1) to determine if the exemptions
for executive,or administrative or professional employees apply.
The regulations that address this latter exemption are contained
at 29 C.F.R. §541.0 et seq. Taking the regulations and reducing
them to their simplest terms, the test to determine whether a
person is employed in an executive capacity (and thus exempt)
requires the employee to: (1) be paid a salary of $250 or more per

week (about $1075 per month); (2) have as a primary duty the
management of the department; and (3) customarily or regularly
direct the work of two or more employees. Employees who are paid
less than $250 per week but not less than $155 per week are
exempt if the following tests are met: (1) their primary duty
consists of management of the department; (2) the employee
supervises two or more employees; (3) the employee has either the
authority to hire and fire subordinates or has his decisions in
this regard given weight by the executive; (4) the employee has
discretionary powers; and (5) the employee devotes no more than
20% of his or her activities to non-exempt work.
In regard to employees who make more than $250 a week, management
as a "primary duty" must be based on all the facts. 29 C.F.R.
§541.103 states that the executive must spend at least 50% of his
or her time in management functions. (This same rule applies to
administrative and professional employees as will be discussed
below.) Examples of such duties include, but are not limited to,
interviewing, selecting and training employees, setting and
adjusting pay rates and hours worked, directing work, evaluating
employee proficiency and efficiency, handling grievances,
handling discipline and providing for the safety of employees and
property. For employees in the $155-$250 pay range, non-exempt
duties would include the same kind of work as subordinate
employees, i.e. clerical duties, cleaning premises, etc. See 29
C.F.R. §§541.99 to .119.
To be exempt as an administrator, an employee must: (1) be paid a
salary of $250 or more per week; (2) have as his or her primary
duty the performance of office or non-manual work directly
related to management policies of his or her employer and
department; and (3) exercise judgment or discretion, as opposed
to following procedure and using skills. For those employees who
earn between $155 and $250 per week, the employee can be
considered exempt if the employee: (1) has a primary duty
consisting of office or non-manual work directly related to
management policies; (2) customarily and regularly exercises
discretion and independent judgment; (3) regularly assists an
executive or administrator; (4) performs work that is specific or
technical which requires special training, experience or knowledge
under general supervision or executes special assignments and
tasks under only general supervision; and (5) devotes no more
than 20% of his or her time to non-exempt activities.
Types of administrative employees would include (but are not
limited to) an executive or administrative assistant, executive
secretary, assistant to department head, or an advisory

management specialist. These duties are very diverse and the
duties, not the titles, of the position must be examined.
Non-exempt positions would include filing clerks, secretaries,
etc. See 29 C.F.R. §541.201 to .215.
The professional is the third exemption and will be discussed
herein below, in the context of the department's investigators.
In your letter, you do not indicate the job duties or rate of pay
of the undersheriff. The undersheriff, however, has provided our
office with a brief description of his job duties. He indicates
that he has administrative functions relative to the department
only in the absence of the sheriff and regulates and supervises
the operation of the jail. He also advises that he answers calls
and serves civil process papers. He further indicates that his
rate of pay would place him in the category of employees
receiving in excess of $250 a week. Finally, the undersheriff
estimates, based on a 40-plus hours per week, that his job duties
are 20% administration and 80% general.
Therefore, to determine whether he is exempt from overtime pay, a
two-step process must be used as set out in the regulations
quoted above. Should he receive a salary per week of $250 or
more and spend at least 50% of his time in administrative or
executive functions, he would be exempt. However, based on the
information provided, it does not appear as if the undersheriff
fits within the tests. Therefore he is not exempt from receiving
overtime compensation. However, we recommend that any final
determination be made by the county.
Based upon your representations concerning the remainder of the
sheriff's department employees, none of them, except possibly the
investigator, would appear to meet the administrative or
executive exemptions. As such, under FLSA, each of the
non-exempt employees is entitled to be paid straight time of at
least minimum wage and overtime at one and one-half time for any
hours in excess of 40 hours per week. However, as has been
indicated above, a special rule [29 U.S.C.A. §207(k)] can be
applied to law enforcement officers and firefighters to enable
them to work up to 171 and 212 hours per every 28 days,
respectively. You will note that this represents a substantial
deviation from K.S.A. 44-1201 et seq. K.S.A. 44-1203 sets the
minimum wage at $1.60 per hour, while K.S.A. 44-1204 states that
law enforcement and firefighters must be paid overtime only for
those hours worked in excess of 258 hours in a 28-day period. See
K.S.A. 44-1203(b) and K.S.A. 44-1204(c)(1).

As the Kansas act is not applicable to those employees covered by
the FLSA, we must again look to federal law for the definition of
law enforcement officers and firefighters. In addition, it
should be noted that 29 C.F.R. §553.1(b) requires that an
employer elect to claim the §7(k) exemption before the 171 or 212
hour rule can be applied. However this election need not be
formal. 29 C.F.R. §553.4 reads in pertinent part as follows:
"(a) As used in sections 7(k) and 13(b)(20) of
the Act, the term 'any employee in law
enforcement activities' refers to any employee
(1) who is a uniformed or plainclothed member
of a body of officers and subordinates who are
empowered by statute or local ordinance to
enforce laws designed to maintain public peace
and order and to protect both life and
property from accidental or willful injury,
and to prevent and detect crimes, (2) who has
the power of arrest, and (3) who is presently
undergoing or has undergone or will undergo
on-the-job training and/or a course of
instruction and study which typically includes
physical training, self-defense, firearm
proficiency, criminal and civil law
principles, investigative and law enforcement
techniques, community relations, medical aid
and ethics.
"Employees who meet these tests are considered
to be engaged in law enforcement activities
regardless of their rank, or of their status as
'trainee,' probationary' or 'permanent'
employee, and regardless of their assignment
to duties incidental to the performance of
their law enforcement activities . . ."
Although you have not specifically inquired about firefighters,
29 C.F.R. §553.3 reads in pertinent part:
"(a) As used in section 7(k) and 13(b)(20) of
the Act, the term 'any employee in fire
protection activities' refers to any employee
(1) who is employed by an organized
fire department or fire protection district
and who, pursuant to the extent required by
State statute or local ordinance, has been
trained and has the legal authority and

responsibility to engage in the prevention,
control or extinguishment of a fire or any
type and (2) who performs activities which are
required for, and directly concerned with the
prevention, control or extinguishment of
fires, including such incidental
non-firefighting functions as housekeeping,
equipment maintenance, lecturing, attending
community fire drills and inspecting homes and
schools for fire hazards. The term would
include all employees, regardless of their
status as 'trainee,' probationary,' or
'permanent' employee, or of their particular
specialty or job title (e.g., firefighter,
engineer, hose or ladder operator, fire
specialist, fire inspector, lieutenant,
captain, inspector, fire marshal, battalion
chief, deputy chief, or chief), and regardless
of their assignment to support activities . . .
"(c) Not included in the term 'employee in
fire protection activities' are the so-called
'civilian' employees of a fire department,
fire district, or forestry service who engage
in such support activities as those performed
by dispatchers, alarm operators, apparatus and
equipment repair and maintenance workers, camp
cooks, clerks, stenographers, etc."
See 29 C.F.R. §553.3 and 553.8 for provisions relating to
ambulance and other emergency medical technicians. Additionally,
it should be noted that §7(k) employees are subject to the 20%
limitation on the performance of non-exempt work. 29 C.F.R.
§553.5.
We have been advised that the investigator, jailors and
dispatchers have been deputized. If these employees in fact meet
the above criteria, they would be treated as law enforcement
officers regardless of their actual duties. We are advised also
that the matrons are deputized but we are unable to determine if
they have met the third element of the §553.4(a) test (i.e.
specialized course of training.) In any event, using the
definition of law enforcement employee as set out above, and
based upon the information provided by the sheriff's department,
we have no hesitancy in concluding that the undersheriff,

deputies, investigator, dispatchers and jailors are law
enforcement officers and thus are eligible for the limited
exemption under §7(k). All other employees of the department
are subject to the 40-hour rule.
As noted earlier, 29 C.F.R. §553.1 states that criminal
investigative agents may be §13(a)(1) administrative employees.
However, depending upon the requirements imposed upon the deputy
necessary to enable him to become an investigator, the employee
may also be exempt from overtime as a §13(a)(1) professional
employee. To be exempt under this classification, the
professional must: (1) be paid a salary of $250 or more per
week; (2) have as a primary duty work requiring knowledge of an
advance type in a field of science or learning customarily
acquired by a prolonged course of specialized intellectual
instruction and study; and (3) perform work requiring consistent
exercise of discretion and judgment, or work requiring invention,
imagination or talent in a recognized field of artistic endeavor.
Employees earning less than $250 but more than $170 per week must
do: (1)work requiring advanced knowledge; (2) work that is
original or creative in character in a recognized field by
artistic endeavor; (3) work which requires consistent exercise of
discretion and judgment; (4) work which is predominantly
intellectual and varied in character; and (5) no more than 20%
non-exempt work.
Examples of professionals would be accountants, engineers,
chemists, etc. In essence, the test is whether the activity
engaged in requires a special degree and the work must be
intellectual and varied as opposed to routine, manual, physical
or mechanical. See 29 C.F.R. §§541.301-.315. Also, please note
the primary duty test of 50% and the non-exempt work test would
be the same as above. Therefore, to determine whether the
investigator, or any of the other employees in that department,
fit into the §13(a)(1) exemptions, it will be necessary to match
the duties against the test.
As indicated earlier, an employee can be a law enforcement
officer or firefighter and still be able to claim a §7(k),
§13(a)(1) or §13(b)(20) exemption. See 29 C.F.R. §553.1. This
regulation, however, goes on to state that:
"In no event, however, will the election [by
the employer] to take the section 13(a)(1)
exemption for an employee who qualifies for
it, result in excluding that employee from the
count that must be made under §553.1(d) in

determining whether the employer may claim for
its other employees the section 13(b)(20)
exemption." (Emphasis added.)
In other words, the criminal investigator and undersheriff who
otherwise are law enforcement officers and could be 513(a)(1)
exempted employees for purposes of overtime, will still be
included as employees for purposes of the 513(b)(20) exemption
(which exempts those departments which have four or less
employees with fire protection or law enforcement duties.) The
sheriff would not be included because he is not defined as an
employee at all under 53(e)(2). Therefore, based upon your
representations of the composition of the sheriff's department,
we have little hesitancy in concluding that the 513(b)(20)
exemption is not applicable.
Having addressed your main inquiries concerning the status of the
department's various employees, we feel it appropriate to briefly
discuss several additional FLSA provisions.
One of the most frequently-asked questions to this office has
been the issue of standby or "on call" employees. As a general
rule, the determination of whether an employee is "waiting to be
engaged" or "engaged to wait" depends upon the restrictions
placed on the employee's movement by the employer. If the
employee is told to stay by a telephone and wait, he is "engaged
to wait" and is entitled to be paid. If, on the other hand, the
employee is simply told to leave a number where he or she can be
reached or to carry a pager or portable radio and told to stay
within a certain radius of the office (and thus is otherwise able
to make use of his time as he pleases), the employee is "waiting
to be engaged" and is thus not subject to be paid until such time
as he or she is called back on duty. See 29 C.F.R. 55785.14 to
785.17. In addition, if the employer requires employees to come
in prior to the working shift to be briefed or allows the
employee to work (so called "suffered to work") prior to the
working shift, 29 C.F.R. §785.11 requires that the employee be
paid. See also 29 C.F.R. §553.14 and §553.17.
Pursuant to federal law, 29 C.F.R. §785.18 and §553.15 require that
employees must be paid for sleep time and meal time. If the
employee can be completely relieved of job duties for a period of
30 minutes or more for lunch, then the employer does not have to
pay for lunch time. If, however, this period is interruptible or
is less than 30 minutes in length, this is compensable time.
Also, for those employees who are required to work a 24-hour (or

less) shift and are given rest periods, these rest periods are
compensable time as well.
One of the biggest effects of the FLSA on sheriff's duties, as
well as other public employees, is the prohibition of
comprehensive or "comp" time. 29 C.F.R. §553.19 precludes the use
of comp time except on a limited basis. Those employees who are
not subject to the §7(k) exemption must be paid overtime if the
employee works in excess of 40 hours per week. As each work week
stands alone, the hours cannot be averaged together. 29 C.F.R.
§778.104. However, such is not the case with employees on the
§7(k) schedule. If the work period is 28 days, the number of
hours worked each day or week can exceed the scheduled maximum
hours as long as the permissible total is not exceeded.
Employees who must work in excess of the stated hours can be
subject to a forced lay-off or comp time to stay within the
permissible limits. However, the time can only be given in hours
off if the time is taken during the work week in which the
overtime occurred at an hour for hour comp rate. Comp time can
be given at time and one-half if taken within the pay period in
which the overtime occurred. If the comp time is not taken
within that specified time, the employee must be paid in cash by
the next pay period. See 29 C.F.R. §531.27 et seq.
Another common area of interest concerns the use of volunteers or
reserve officers. As set out at 29 C.F.R. §553.11, volunteers are
not considered employees until such time as they are paid more
than a nominal fee. Under the regulations, payments of $2.50 per
call are considered nominal. (Note: In that these regulations
were drafted in 1975, a higher amount may be considered nominal
by 1985 standards.) Any amount paid in excess of the $2.50 may
still be nominal if the money paid is actually reimbursement for
expenses, as opposed to renumeration.
You should also be aware of 29 C.F.R. §553.7 and 29 C.F.R. §785.27
et seq. These regulations state that whenever an employee is
required to attend training classes as part of a job requirement,
such time is compensable. Travel time may also be included. See
29 C.F.R. §785.33 et seq. 29 C.F.R. §553.18 allows employees to
trade time, with these provisions similar to those set out in
K.S.A. 44-1204.
It should be pointed out that the FLSA requires the maintenance
of records for a period of at least three years. See 29 C.F.R.
§516.1 et seq. While departments may currently be maintaining
hourly records, these should be checked against the requirements

set out in 29 C.F.R. §516.1 et seg. 29 C.F.R. §516.2 sets out
the basic reporting requirements and includes such items as name,
address, sex, date of birth, date and time of start of workweek,
regular rate of pay, hours worked each day and each pay period,
total straight and overtime hours and deductions for each
employee, whether exempt or not. See 29.C.F.R. §516.11. 29
C.F.R. §516.4 requires the posting of notices to employees of
the applicability of the FLSA. Furthermore, it is important to
remember 29 C.F.R. §553.9 mandates that whenever an employee is
engaged in joint employment or moonlighting, the compensable time
is "tacked" together if the employee worked for the same employer
in two capacities or performs the same type of work for two
governmental agencies. For example, if a police officer works
for the city as an officer and as a clerk, the hours would be
cumulative; they would not be if he worked as an independent
private security guard or for a different employer, so long as
the employers are truly independent of each other.
Section 16 [16 U.S.C.A. §216] contains the penalty provisions
for non-compliance. Subsection (b) provides an employee private
enforcement rights, and states that for violations of §§6 or 7,
the employee is entitled to the amount of unpaid wages and/or
overtime, and an additional equal amount as liquidated damages
plus attorneys fees. Subsection (c) contains the actions
available to the U.S. Department of Labor. These include
supervision of the payback of wages which would include a waiver
of the employee's subsection (b) rights, plus liquidated damages.
Any private remedies under (b) are suspended whenever the
Department of Labor intervenes, unless the department determines
that said intervention should be dismissed. Subsection (e)
contains criminal sanctions. Section 17 [29 U.S.C.A. §217]
sets forth the injunctive relief available to the department.
Finally, there have been many questions raised concerning the
enforceability date of Garcia. As stated above, Garcia was
decided on February 19, 1985. However, subsequent to the
decision, a motion for reconsideration was filed. The Supreme
Court denied that motion on April 15, 1985. Under Rule 51, a
party has 25 days in which to file a petition for rehearing.
Under Rule 52, a mandate will not lie until a motion for a
rehearing is ruled upon. Accordingly, we are of the opinion that
the effective date of enforceability runs from the date that the
litigation is final, or April 15, 1985, and not from the date the
decision was announced. See United States of America v. Ohio
Power Company, 353 U.S. 98, 1 L.Ed.2d 683, 77 S.Ct. 652 (1957).
Therefore, until such time as the state, county or city
department comes into compliance with federal law, those

employees who have not been paid overtime beyond 40 hours (and
were not otherwise compensated) are entitled to be paid time and
one-half for those hours. As noted, the number of hours which
may be worked prior to payment of overtime is increased if the
employer has elected the §7(k) exemption.
There are many more provisions of the federal law that have not
been mentioned. We have attempted to provide a concise outline
of the major sections. It may may be necessary for you to
consult the regulations for further clarification. Please note
also that since the statutes and regulations on public employees
were drafted in 1974 and 1975 and then stayed by National League,
it is extremely likely that they will be revised in the near
future.
In conclusion, as a result of the decision in Garcia v. San
Antonio Metropolitan Transit Authority, the Dickinson County
sheriff's department is subject to the federal Fair Labor
Standards Act. Department employees who meet the qualifications
of 29 C.F.R. §553.4 are entitled to the exemption from overtime
in 29 U.S.C.A. §207(k) if the employer so elects. As the
department has more than four employees who are law enforcement
officers, it is therefore not eligible for the exemption in 29
U.S.C.A. §213(b)(20). Law enforcement employees who are
subject to §7(k) may work a maximum of 171 hours in a 28 day pay
period. Following April 15, 1985, overtime is required to be
paid to such employees for any hours over this amount.
Very truly Boddington
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF 11ANSAAttachment
Matthew W. Boddingtmnr
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:MKANSAS

Appendix A
Work period (days)
Maximum hours standards Fire protection Law enforcement
28.
212
171
27
204
165
26
197
159
25
189
153
24
182
147
23
174
141
22
167
134
21
159
128
20
151
122
19
144
116
18
136
110
17
129
104
16
121
98
15
114
92
14
106
86
13
98
79
12
91
73
11
83
67
10
76
61
9
68
55
8
61
49
7
53
43
-

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.