Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-043

1985-043Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
April 26, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85-43
Leland E. Rolfs
Counsel
Kansas State Board of Agriculture
109 SW 9th Street
Topeka, Kansas 66612-1280
Re: Waters and Watercourses -- Collection, Storage and
Impounding of Waters -- Construction and Maintenance
of Dams; Donation of Easements; Tax Exemption
Taxation -- Property Exempt From Taxation -- Land
Donated in Connection with Erection or Maintenance of
Dam or Reservoir
Synopsis: K.S.A. 82a-409 permits a landowner who donates an
easement to the state or a governmental subdivision,
such as a watershed district, to receive an exemption
from property taxes levied upon the contiguous
acreage, as provided by K.S.A. 79-201g. That statute
in turn allows an exemption for the contiguous acreage
which is lower than the top of the dam, and applies
for 20 years after the dam is certified by the chief
engineer of the division of water resources of the
department of agriculture. In the case of the land
occupied by the dam and reservoir itself, K.S.A.
79-201a, Second, could result in a complete exemption
for such property if it is exclusively used by the
state or a governmental subdivision. However, such a
determination is administrative in nature and is left
by statute to the State Board of Tax Appeals. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 79-201a, Second; 79-201g; 79-213; .
82a-407; Kan. Const., Art. 11, §1.
Dear Mr. Rolfs:
As counsel for the Kansas State Board of Agriculture, you request
our opinion on a question concerning property tax exemptions for
private property which contains a dam and reservoir constructed
by the state or by a governmental subdivision such as a watershed
district. Specifically, you inquire as follows:
"1. Whether a reduction is assessed valuation granted
for 20 years pursuant to K.S.A. 82a-409 applies to the
land on which the dam is physically located and to the
land on which the dam actually impounds water?
"2. If so, how is the land upon which the dam is
physically located and the land on which the dam
actually impounds water to be valued for tax purposes
after the reduction in assessed valuation expires at the
end of the 20 year period if the holder of the fee title
to that land originally granted the following easement
to a watershed district:
"'For the permanent storage and temporary
detention, either or both, of any waters that
are impounded, stored or detained by the
detention dam to be constructed on (insert
legal description) . . .' (Emphasis
supplied)"
When reductions in assessed valuation were first granted by the
legislature, the statutes used wording such as "piece of land
upon which the reservoir is located" (emphasis added), to
describe the property entitled to the exemption. G.S. 1923
42-601, G.S. 1935 82a-401. In 1941, the legislature enacted
what became K.S.A. 82a-409, which entitled landowners who
donated easements for dams and reservoirs to receive "for 20
years a reduction in the assessed valuation of the entire
contiguous acreage owned by each such landowner." (Emphasis
added.) This language was in effect until 1965, although the
statute was amended in other respects, and was the language under
which many of the current easements were donated. Following the
enactment in 1975 of K.S.A. 79-201g, K.S.A. 82a-409 was amended
to reference that statute, which now contains the specific
limitations on the terms of such exemptions.
K.S.A. 79-201g provides that certain types of property shall be
exempt from all property taxes levied under the laws of Kansas,
including [at subsection (b)]:
"All real property which is contiguous to and
a part of the same tract of land upon which a
dam or reservoir has been constructed and
certified by the chief engineer of the
division of water resources in compliance with
requirements and specifications prescribed by
K.S.A. 82a-405 et seq., and amendments
thereto, the owner of which at the time of
such certification donated to the state or to
any of its agencies or subdivisions land or
easements of right-of-way for such erection or
maintenance of such dam or reservoir in an
amount equal to twice the assessed value of
the land or easements or right-of-way donated.
Such exemption shall be based upon a specific
description of the land donated, excluding any
land the elevation of which is higher than the
top of the dam, as prepared and provided by
the chief engineer and the assessed value
thereof, as determined by the county assessor,
for the year in which the exemption is first
granted.
"Such exemption shall be applicable to such
property for a period of twenty (20) years
after the original certification of such dam
or reservoir by the chief engineer except that
if the landowner shall apply for such
exemption more than tow (2) years after the
actual completion of the dam or reservoir and
such exemption shall be applicable to such
property for a period of twenty (20) years
after the date of the actual completion of the
dam or reservoir.
"The provisions of this section shall apply to
all taxable years commencing after December
31, 1974." (Emphasis added.)
It is noteworthy that in both the existing statutes which govern
this area (K.S.A. 82a-409 and 79-201g) and in prior statutes
dating back to 1941, the land included in the exemption is
defined as that which is "contiguous" to the land upon which the
reservoir and dam sit. No express mention is made of the land
occupied by the retaining structure or by the water which is
impounded. Rather, a limited tax break is given for a portion of
the entire tract contiguous to the dam and reservoir, with K.S.A.
79-201g restricting the benefits of the reduction to that land
below a prescribed elevation (i.e. below the top of the dam) and
for a specific time period (20 years). After the elapse of that
time, the contiguous land will be fully taxed once again, for
statutes which create an exemption or a reduction in property
taxes are to be strictly construed. National Collegiate Realty
Corp. v. Board of Johnson County Commissioners, 236 Kan. 394
(1984).
You inform us that the language used in most, if not all, of the
easements which landowners have granted to the state and to
governmental subdivisions such as watershed districts allows "the
permanent storage and temporary detention" of water impounded by
the dam. This is the same language which was involved in the
cases of Huser v. Duck Creek Watershed District No. 59, 234
Kan. 1, 5-6 (1983) and Roberts v. Upper Verdigris Watershed
Joint District No. 24, 193 Kan. 151, 152 (1964). These cases
give a wide scope to the easements taken by the watershed
districts, and found that it is the nature of the right given,
rather than the actual or current use, which indicates the legal
extent of the control possessed by the grantee. Therefore, if
a grantor of an easement possessed only a bare legal title, with
a permanent right to maintain the dam and retain water given to
the state or watershed district, a total exemption from taxation
could be proper under Article 11, Section 1 of the Kansas
Constitution and K.S.A. 79-201a, Second. These authorities
allow a complete exemption for property used exclusively by the
state or any political subdivision. Actual ownership is not
required, only the right to exclusive use. Board of Trustees of
Kansas East Conference of United Methodist Church v. Cogswell,
205 Kan. 847, 855 (1970).
Any determination of the exclusive nature of the easement which
was granted to the state or political subdivision would have to
be made on a case-by-case basis. Pursuant to K.S.A. 79-213, the
initial recommendation on an exemption from taxation is made by
the county appraiser, with a final determination made by the
State Board of Tax Appeals. Accordingly, it is impossible for
use to say whether any or all property occupied by a dam and
reservoir constructed pursuant to an easement would be exempt
from taxation under K.S.A. 79-201a, Second. We are therefore
unable to give a definitive answer to either of your questions,
as the result will vary depending on the exclusivity of the use.
Clearly, the land occupied by the dam and reservoir would be
eligible for the limited reduction under K.S.A. 79-201g, should
it be determined that the exclusive use test of K.S.A. 79-201a,
Second, could not be met. Whether the land occupied by a
particular dam and reservoir would be entitled to the full
exemption would hinge on facts which may be determined only
administratively. See Attorney General Opinion No. 82-252.
In conclusion, K.S.A. 82a-409 permits a landowner who donates an
easement to the state or a governmental subdivision, such as a
watershed district, to receive an exemption from property taxes
levied upon the contiguous acreage, as provided by K.S.A.
79-201g. That statute in turn allows an exemption for the
contiguous acreage which is lower than the top of the dam, and
applies for 20 years after the dam is certified by the chief
engineer of the division of water resources of the department of
agriculture. In the case of the land occupied by the dam and
reservoir itself, K.S.A. 79-201a, Second, could result in a
complete exemption for such property if it is exclusively used by
the state or a governmental subdivision. However, such a
determination is administrative in nature and is left by statute
to the State Board of Tax Appeals.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.Southard
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JSS:crw

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.