Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1984-015

1984-015Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

February 14, 1984
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 84- 15
Morgan Metcalf
Butler County Attorney
Judicial Building
El Dorado, Kansas 67042
Re: Criminal Procedure -- Procedure After Arrest -- Diver-
sion; Imposition of Diversion Costs
Synopsis: K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 22-2909 provides for the content
of diversion agreements which are entered into by a
defendant and a county or district attorney. One pro-
vision which may be included concerns the payment of
restitution, including court costs and diversion costs.
While the term diversion costs is not defined in the
statute, it can be construed to include those specific
expenses actually incurred by personnel of the county
or district attorney's office in drafting and executing
the divtcalfgreement:
Cited herein: K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 8-1567, 22-2909, K.S.A.
60-2003.
Dear Mr. Me/vitcalf:
As County Attorney for Butler County, you request our opinion
as to the scope of the term "diversion costs" in K.S.A. 1983 Supp.
22-2909, which statute provides for a defendant entering a diver-
sion agreement to pay restitution and certain other costs.
K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 22-2209 is a statute contained in the Code of
Criminal Procedure section pertaining to diversion of criminal
defendants. In pertinent part, the statute states:
"(a) A diversion agreement shall provide that if
the defendant fulfills the obligations of the pro-
gram described therein, as determined by the county
or district attorney, the county or district at-
torney shall act to have the criminal charges against
the defendant dismissed with prejudice. The diver-
sion agreement shall include specifically the waiver
of all rights under the law or the constitution
of Kansas or of the United States to a speedy ar-
raignment, preliminary examinations and hearings,
and a speedy trial, and in the case of diversion
under subsection (c) waiver of the right to trial
by jury. The diversion agreement may include,
but is not limited to, provisions concerning pay-
ment of restitution, including court costs and
diversion costs, residence in a specified facility,
maintenance of gainful employment, and participation
in programs offering medical, educational, voca-
tional, social and psychological services, cor-
rective and preventive guidance and other rehabil-
itative services." (Emphasis added.)
You inform us that some county attorneys have employed the term
"diversion costs" to provide for a defendant's payment of money
which is ultimately used for salaries of office personnel and for
office equipment and supplies. While you do not indicate the
amount which is typically charged, you do state that it is in
addition to court costs and, in cases where an offense under K.S.A.
1983 Supp. 8-1567 (driving under the influence) is involved, the
required fine and evaluation assessment.
The diversion statutes do not provide guidance as to what charges
are encompassed by the term diversion costs. However, in that
the phrase is used in the same sentence as the more familiar term
"court costs," it would be helpful to note what types of expenses
are generally included within this term. As set out at K.S.A.
60-2003, court costs include:
"(1) The docket fee as provided for by K.S.A.
60-2001.
(2.) The mileage, fees, and other allowable
expenses of the sheriff or other officer incurred
in the service of process outside of this state
or in effecting any of the provisional remedies
authorized by this chapter.
(3) Publisher's charges in effecting any
publication of notices authorized by law.
(4) Statutory fees and mileage of witnesses
attending court or the taking of depositions
used as evidence.
(5) Reporter's or stenographic charges for
the taking of depositions used as evidence.
(6) Such other charges as are by statute
authorized to be taxed as costs."
Although diverse in origin, each of these charges is specifically
attributable to an item of expense which is incurred during the
course of a judicial proceeding. Applying the same concept to
diversion costs, it is our opinion that a county attorney could
legitimately require a defendant to pay those expenses which stem
from the negotiations leading up to, as well as the final execu-
tion of, a diversion agreement. These could include charges for
evaluations of the defendant by court or county personnel and for
obtaining documents necessary to determine the defendant's eligi-
bility and suitability for diversion.
In our opinion, the term diversion costs does not include general
expenses incurred by the county attorney's office such as salaries
for legal or secretarial staff, office equipment or maintenance,
and overhead costs. For example, we do not believe that a
county attorney could require a defendant to pay a portion of
the attorney's salary (for the number of hours spent in drafting
the diversion agreement) or a secretary's salary (for the time
spent in preparing documents). Court costs do not include charges
for the salary of the judge or court personnel, and in the absence
of any legislative intent we are not prepared to imply a different
meaning for diversion costs. Neither court costs nor diversion
costs should be used as means of raising revenue for day-to-day
operations of the judicial or law enforcement system. This funct-
ion is performed in part by the fines which defendants are assessed
as part of the diversion agreement, and should not be augmented
through the imposition of non-specific "costs."
In conclusion, K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 22-2909 provides for the content
of diversion agreements which are entered into by a defendant
and a county or district attorney. One provision which may be
included concerns the payment of restitution, including court
costs and diversion costs. While the term diversion costs is
not defined in the statute, it can be construed to include those
specific expenses incurred by personnel of the county or district
attorney's office in drafting and executing the diversion agree-
ment.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Jeffrey S. Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:crw

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.