Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-149

1983-149Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

October 3, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 149
The Honorable Mike Meacham
State Representative, Eighty-Third District
1722 Gatewood
Wichita, Kansas 67206
Re: Counties and County Officers -- County Clerks --
Records and Accounts
Synopsis: The duties of the county clerk are statutorily
prescribed and require access to such records
and accounting information as is necessary in
order to carry out such duties. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 10-801, 10-1101, 10-1117, 12-105a, 19-305,
19-306, 19-311, 19-318, 19-507, 19-6a02, 19-6a03.
*
Dear Representative Meacham:
You request our opinion concerning the duties and responsi-
bilities of the Sedgwick County Clerk. In particular, you
inquire whether the clerk, in order to perform her statutory
functions, must be provided access into the county's central
accounting records and computer system through the use of a
terminal outlet.
Upon receiving your request, we requested a statement of
facts and relevant law from the Sedgwick County Counselor.
Regrettably, counsel's efforts proved inadequate regarding
the records or information contained in the computer system
and which records or information are being denied the county
clerk. It is now clear that the questions of law in this
situation are relatively simple and few, while the questions
of fact are complex and numerous. As you know, this office
cannot be a trier of factual questions and resolve disputes
arising from circumstances such as this, where a thorough
understanding of accounting and recording practices of the
county is absolutely necessary. Such factual questions may
best be resolved by negotiation or court action. We are, of
course, pleased to consider and discuss the relevant legal
issues raised by your request.
Generally, the county clerk's duties are statutorily pre-
scribed at K.S.A. 19-301 et seq. These statutes state, in
relevant part, that the county clerk shall "sign all orders
issued by the board [of county commissioners] for the payment
of money," (K.S.A. 19-305, fourth) and "preserve and file all
accounts acted upon by the board, with their action thereon,"
(K.S.A. 19-305, fifth). Additionally, it is the duty of the
clerk "to designate, upon every account . . . the amount so
allowed . . ." (K.S.A. 19-306), to "keep a book in which he
shall keep the receipts and expenditures of his county, and
all accounts of his county with the different county, town-
ship, district, and other officers," (K.S.A. 19-311), and
"to draw orders on the county treasurer . . . for any money
that may have been collected," (K.S.A. 19-318). For a dis-
cussion of the county clerk's duties, see Kansas Attorney
General Opinion No. 82-135. Furthermore, the county clerk
has other statutorily prescribed duties contained in the
Cash Basis Law, K.S.A. 10-1101 et seq., the Uniform Procedure
for Payment of Claims Act, K.S.A. 12-105a et seq., and K.S.A.
10-801 et seq.
The above statutes clearly enumerate the duties of the county
clerk, irrespective of any of the duties of the county con-
troller. However, the Sedgwick County Counselor suggests
that duties of the office of county controller acting pursu-
ant to K.S.A. 19-6a02 and 19-6a03, are duplicitous of certain
duties enjoined upon the county clerk and argues that this
statute implicitly repeals the authority of the county clerk
over such matters. While there may indeed be some duplica-
tion, the laws of this state have long required dual record-
keeping in regard to the financial transactions of counties.
See K.S.A. 19-311 and 19-507, concerning the keeping of finan-
cial records by the county clerk and county treasurer, respec-
tively, both of which laws were enacted originally in 1868.
In addition, the legislature, in amending K.S.A. 10-1117 in
1974, did not change the requirements that the clerk or secre-
tary of each municipality keep detailed records of the muni-
cipality's financial transactions or that "[s]uch clerk or
secretary shall, upon the request of any person, exhibit such
records to such person and any person contracting with the
municipality shall be chargeable with knowledge of what such
records contain." Thus, any person desiring to review finan-
cial records of any municipality, including a county, has the
right to do so by reviewing the records of the clerk or
secretary. The legislature did not mention records maintained
by a county controller.
We discern nothing in the provisions of K.S.A. 19-6a03 or in
the sparse record concerning the enactment of this statute
in 1973 which indicates the legislature intended that a non-
elected county controller was to assume the functions of an
elected county clerk and thereby relieve the county clerk
of duties enjoined upon him or her by state law.
Based upon the above-cited statutory provisions, some of which
were enacted after the statutes concerning a county controller
were adopted, we cannot attribute to the legislature the in-
tent to relieve a county clerk of duties enjoined upon the
clerk by state law, even though the county has appointed a
county controller.
Finally, we return to the issue of whether the county must
provide the county clerk access to the county computer system.
There is no statute requiring such access, however, it can-
not be seriously disputed that no county officer or employee
can substantially interfere in the performance of statutory
duties imposed upon the county clerk. It is a general rule
of law that "fa] public official should not be interfered
with in the performance of his official duties." 67 C.J.S.
Officers §205 (1978). Denial of relevant bookkeeping data
or records necessary to accomplish tasks assigned by law
would be, in our opinion, an unlawful interference with the
performance of the county clerk's duties. In the case of
the county controller, this duty to provide the information
necessary for the county clerk to fulfill statutory respon-
sibilities is also implied in K.S.A. 19-6a03. That statute
requires the controller "Rio initiate and enforce measures
and procedures in cooperation with other officers and depart-
ment heads" regarding efficiency in county government and
"[t]o report to other governmental agencies when and as re-
quired by law or the board of county commissioners."
Whether the legally required information is provided to the
county clerk via computer access or by way of traditional
paperwork has, in our judgment, little significance so long
as the information is available for the clerk to perform sta-
tutory duties.
The remaining practical and factual problem, which, as pre-
viously noted, is beyond the scope of an Attorney General's
opinion, is just which information is necessary to the perform-
ance of statutory duties and how that information can best be
provided. Resolution of such problems are of purely local
interest and importance and may best be solved by local admin-
istrative officers.
Therefore, it is our opinion that duties of the county clerk
are statutorily prescribed and require access to such records
and accounting information as is necessary in order to carry
out such duties.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Matthew W. Boddington
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:MWB:hle

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.