Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-142

1983-142Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

September 15, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 142
Mr. Rodney H. Symonds
County Attorney
Lyon County Courthouse
Emporia, Kansas 66801
Re: Crimes and Punishments -- Crimes Against Property --
Giving a Worthless Check
Synopsis: Partial payment of an insufficient funds check is not a
bar to prosecution for the giving of a worthless check
under K.S.A. 21-3707. The crime has been committed
when the worthless check has been made, drawn, issued
or delivered, and subsequent payment only goes to the
question of "intent to defraud." Cited herein: K.S.A. 21-3707.
Dear Mt. Symonds:
You have requested our opinion regarding whether a prosecution pursuant
to K.S.A. 21-3707 is precluded if the insufficient funds check is';
made as payment on an existing account and secondly, whether charges
can be filed if partial payment is made on an insufficient funds_
check prior to the commencement of prosecution.
In response to your question on prosecution of an insufficient funds
check made on an existing account, we must decline to issue an opinion,
on that issue at this time due to a pending criminal prosecution in
Dickinson County District Court. The criminal case of State v. Johnson,82CR218(DistrictCourtofDickinsonCounty),hasbeenappealedto
the Supreme Court of Kansas (Kansas Supreme Court Case No. 55,353,
Opinion filed July 15, 1983). Johnson, supra, raised the issues
of both pre-existing debt and the prima facie intent to defraud
presumption. The Court in Johnson reversed the conviction based
on the instruction used and did not reach the pre-existing debt
issue. We have been informed that the defendant is currently being
retried and therefore we must decline to issue an opinion that will
address an issue presently being litigated. Previously, however, we
issued an opinion on the payment of monthly utility bills with
worthless checks, Opinion 79-16 (a copy of which is attached).
In response to your second question regarding prosecution when partial
payment on an insufficient funds check has been made, it is our opinion
that subsequent payment does not bar prosecution.
It is fundamental that the crime of giving a worthless check is
committed when the check is made, drawn, issued or delivered. K.S.A.
21-3707. State v. Powell, 220 Kan. 168 (1976). Foor v. State, 196
Kan. 618 (1966). Subsequent attempts to pay the check are admissible
to show lack of intent to defraud, but a conviction can still be
upheld as was the case in State v. Marsh, 211 Kan. 585 (1973).
K.S.A. 21-3707(2) provides that it is prima facie evidence of intent
to defraud, if the amount of the check and a maximum service charge
of $3.00 is not paid within seven days after notice has been given.
This seven-day notice is not a prerequisite for prosecution since the
criminal intent can be shown in other ways. State v. Shannon, 194 Kan.
258 (1965). Recovery of the money or property by the payee has no
bearing on whether a crime has been committed. "The fact that the
swindled party is able to recover the money or its equivalent does not
Abate or lessen the crime," Foor, supra, at 620.
In conclusion, partial payment of an insufficient funds check is not
a bar to prosecution for the giving of a worthless check under K.S.A.
21-3707. The crime has been committed when the worthless funds check
has been made, drawn, issued or delivered, and subsequent payment only
goes to the question of whether or not "intent to defraud" is present.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
TimothyG.Madden
Assistant Attorney General
RTS :LILT : TGM:may

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.