Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-132

1983-132Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

September 9, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 132
Donald 0. Phelps
Consumer Credit Commissioner
535 Kansas Avenue, Suite 1114
Topeka, Kansas 66603
Re: Consumer Credit Code -- Consumer Credit Transac-
tions -- Prohibition on Prepayment Penalties;
Pre-emption as to National Banks
Synopsis: K.S.A. 16a-2-509, contained in the Kansas Consumer
Credit Code, provides that a consumer may prepay
in full the unpaid balance of a consumer credit
transaction at any time without penalty. Such
transactions include both consumer credit sales
[K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 16a-301(10)] and consumer
credit loans IK.S.A. 1982 Supp. 12a-301(13)], with
the prohibition binding on any assignee of either
the seller's or lender's right to payment. While a
regulation of the Comptroller of the Currency
[12 C.F.R. §29.6, as amended in 48 Fed. Reg. 9512,
9513] preempts the application of K.S.A. 16a-2-509
to national banks making adjustable-rate mort-
gage loans, a seller which enters into consumer
credit sales cannot avail itself of the pre-emption
provisions merely because it subsequently assigns
the right to payment to a national bank. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 16a-1-301, K.S.A.
16a-2-509, 16a-3-402, 12 U.S.C. §§371, 3803, 12
C.F.R. §g29.1, 2916, as amended in 48 Fed. Reg.
9512-13, U.S. Const., Art. 6, cl. 2.
Dear Mr. Phelps:
As Consumer Credit Commissioner for the State of Kansas, you
request our opinion on a question involving the impact of a
federal regulation issued by the Comptroller of the Currency
upon the Kansas Consumer Credit Code ("Code"), K.S.A.
16a-1-101 et seq. Specifically, you inquire concerning
K.S.A. 16a-2-509, which prohibits prepayment penalties in
consumer credit transactions, and a recent federal regulation
which pre-empts such state statutes as to national banks
offering or purchasing adjustable-rate mortgage loans.
K.S.A. 16a-2-509 was contained in the original Code, adopted
in Kansas in 1973, and has not been amended since that time.
In full, it states:
"Subject to the provisions on rebate upon pre-
payment (section 16a-2-510), the consumer may
prepay in full the unpaid balance of a consumer
credit transaction at any time without penalty."
The statute refers to consumer credit transactions, which
are defined by K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 16a-1-301(11) to include
both consumer credit sales and consumer credit loans. The
former is defined at subsection (10) of the latter statute
as follows:
"(a) Except as provided in paragraph (b), a
'consumer credit sale' is a sale of goods,
services, or an interest in land in which:
"(i) Credit is granted either by a seller who
regularly engages as a seller in credit trans-
actions of the same kind or pursuant to a
credit card other than a lender credit card,
"(ii) the buyer is a person other than an or-
ganization,
"(iii) the goods, services, or interest in
land are purchased primarily for a personal,
family or household purpose,
"(iv) either the debt is payable in install-
ments or a finance charge is made, and
"(v) with respect to a sale of goods or ser-
vices, the amount financed does not exceed
$25,000."
Consumer loan is defined at subsection (13) thusly:
"(a) Except as provided in paragraph (b), a
'consumer loan' is a loan made by a person
regularly engaged in the business of making
loans in which:
"(i) The debtor is a person other than an or-
ganization;
"(ii) the debt is incurred primarily for a
personal, family or household purpose;
"(iii) either the debt is payable in install-
ments or a finance charge is made; and
"(iv) either the amount financed does not ex-
ceed $25,000 or the debt is secured by an
interest in land."
In the example you cite in your letter involving the sale of
mobile homes, a national bank could become involved under
either of the above statutes, for it could make the consumer
a loan with which to purchase the unit and take a security
interest when the transaction was closed, or purchase from
the dealer the contract which the consumer had previously
signed. The latter scenario would be defined as a consumer
credit sale, for the initial grant of credit is made by the
dealer, who regularly engages in the sale of mobile homes which
it owns, with the bank becoming involved only as an assignee of
the contract of sale. As an assignee, the bank is subject to
the same claims and defenses which the consumer could make
or raise as to the seller. K.S.A. 16a-3-402.
The federal regulation in question, 12 C.F.R. §29.6, was
published in the Federal Register (Vol. 48, No. 45, p.
9512-13) on March 7, 1983, and provides that:
"Banks offering or purchasing adjustable-rate
mortgage loans may impose fees for prepayments
regardless of any state-law prohibitions of,
or limitations on, such fees, which prohibi-
tions or limitations are expressly preempted.
For the purposes of this Part, prepayments
shall not include: fa] Principal payments
that would fully amortize the loan over the
remaining loan term; or [b] principal payments
in excess of those necessary to retire the
outstanding debt over the remaining loan term
at the then-current interest rate that are
made in accordance with rules governing the
determination of monthly payments contained
in the loan documents." (Emphasis added.)
It is important to note that this pre-emption relates speci-
fically to the offering or purchasing of adjustable-rate
mortgage loans, which term is defined in 12 C.F.R. §29.1
(also published on the same day as the above) to mean "any
loan made to finance or refinance the purchase of and secured
by a lien on a one- to four-family dwelling, including a
condominium unit, cooperative housing unit, or a mobile home,
where such loan is made pursuant to an agreement intended to
enable the lender to adjust the rate of interest form time
to time."
Under the situation you present, we have no doubt in concluding
that, as to consumer credit loans made on for the purchase
of a mobile home, a national bank is no longer subject to
the restrictions contained in K.S.A. 16a-2-509 against pre-
payment penalties. Federal law authorizes the Comptroller
to issue regulations governing adjustable-rate mortgage trans-
actions (12 U.S.C. §3803), with the pre-emptive effect of
such regulations the same as if by statute. Fidelity Federal
Savings and Loan v. de la Cuesta, --- U.S. ---, 73 L.Ed.2d
664 (1982). In that a clear conflict exists between 12 C.F.R.
§29.1 and K.S.A. 16a-2-509, under the Supremacy Clause of
the United States Constitution, Art. 6., cl. 2, the latter
must give way.
It is further our opinion that the same result would occur
if a national bank purchased a consumer sales contract for
the sale of a mobile home from a dealer, and then entered
into an agreement with the consumer whereby prepayment penal-
ties could be assessed. However, a dealer of mobile homes
who sells on credit could not avail itself of the pre-emption
regulation issued by the Comptroller, which deals only with
national, and to some extent, nonfederally chartered, banks.
Accordingly, any contract for sale made by such a dealer
would be covered by the restrictions of K.S.A. 12a-2-509.
While it could be argued that any restrictions on the imposi-
tion of prepayment fees have been pre-empted, the Comptroller's
regulation is limited to the offering or purchasing of loans
with an adjustable-rate feature by banks. Although the dis-
tinction between a consumer sale and a consumer loan is some-
times overlooked, we must construe the regulation as written,
and take the words used therein as having been chosen with a
particular intent in mind. In any event, the extension of this
regulation to a non-financial institution such as a mobile home
dealer would go beyond the scope of the power delegated to
the Comptroller by 12 U.S.C. §§371(a), 3801 et seq., and so
would be ultra vires. Fidelity Federal Savings and Loan
Assn., supra, 73 L.Ed.2d at 679 and following.
In conclusion, K.S.A. 16a-2-509, contained in the Kansas
Consumer Credit Code, provides that a consumer may prepay in
full the unpaid balance of a consumer credit transaction at
any time without penalty. Such transactions include both
consumer credit sales [K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 16a-301(10)] and
consumer credit loans [K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 12a-301(13)], with
the prohibition binding on any assignee of either the seller's
or lender's right to payment. While a regulation of the
Comptroller of the Currency [12 C.F.R. §29.6, as amended in
48 Fed. Reg. 9512, 9513] preempts the application of K.S.A.
16a-2-509 to national banks making adjustable-rate mortgage
loans, a seller which enters into consumer credit sales can-
not avail itself of the pre-emption provisions merely because
it subsequently assigns the right to payment to a national
bank.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
'Jeffrey S. Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.