Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-113

1983-113Kanag

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

July 27, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83 - 113
Marvin S. Steinert
Commissioner
Savings and Loan Department
503 Kansas Avenue, Room 220
Topeka, Kansas 66603
Re: Corporations -- Savings and Loan Association Code --
Examinations; Acceptance of Examinations Made by
Federal Savings and Loan Insurance Corporation
Synopsis: Pursuant to K.S.A. 17-5612, the savings and loan
commissioner or a deputy commissioner is required
to examine, without prior notice, each savings and
loan association organized under the law of this
state at least once every 18 months. In lieu of
such examinations, the commissioner may accept
examinations made by the Federal Savings and Loan
Insurance Corporation, even though federal examina-
tions may be made only every 20 months. In that
the legislature has expressly permitted the commis-
sioner to adopt the federal report as a substitute
for his own, the 18 month period must be construed
as being directory, rather than mandatory. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 17-5612.
Dear Commissioner Steinert:
On behalf of the Savings and Loan Department, you request
the opinion of this office on a question involving the duty
of your office to examine savings and loan associations or-
ganized under Kansas law. Specifically, you inform us that
K.S.A. 17-5612(a) provides that your office shall examine
the affairs of each such association at least once every 18
months. However, subsection (c) of the same statute provides
that you may accept examinations which the Federal Savings
and Loan Insurance Corporation (FSLIC) makes of the same
institutions. In that the federal examination schedule allows
up to 20 months between audits, you inquire whether your
office can properly discharge its duties by the acceptance
of examinations which may conceivably be made outside the 18
month time frame.
The relevant portions of K.S.A. 17-5612 state as follows:
"(a) The commissioner in person or by one or
more of the deputies of the commissioner, at
times determined by the commissioner or the
board but at least once very eighteen (18)
months, without previous notice, shall visit
and examine into the affairs of every associ-
ation organized under the laws of this state;
"(c) The commissioner is authorized to ex-
pend the moneys in such fund in the adminis-
tration and enforcement of the provisions of
this act and the act to which this act is
amendatory and supplemental. The commissioner
may accept any examination of a savings and
loan association organized under the laws of
the state of Kansas made by a federal home
loan bank or the federal savings and loan in-
surance corporation or may examine such asso-
ciation jointly with the federal home loan
bank or federal savings and loan insurance
corporation. . . ." (Emphasis added.)
Both of these subsections appear in the original Savings and
Loan Code of 1943 (at chapter 133 of the session laws of that
year), with the only substantive change since then being the
time in which examinations done by the commissioner are to be
performed. Now 18 months, initially the requirement called
for annual visits. L. 1942, ch. 133, §165. While a sentence
in the latter subsection initially allowed the commissioner
to charge a percentage of the examination fee whenever he
accepted a federal report "in lieu of" his own, this language
was removed in 1970. L. 1970, ch. 95, §3. However, the gen-
eral grant of authority to accept federal examinations remains.
In view of the obvious fact that 18 months is not the same
as 20, you inquire whether your office can continue to consi-
der the federal examinations (which are made of all savings
and loan associations in Kansas) as acceptable. At the out-
set, we would note that the mere use of the word "shall" in
subsection (a) is not dispositive of the question. Numerous
Kansas decisions have construed statutes containing "shall"
as being directory, rather than mandatory, when the context
requires it. City of Kansas City v. Wyandotte County Commis-
sioners, 213 Kan. 777 (1974), Spalding v. Price, 210 Kan.
337 (1972), Paul v. City of Manhattan, 212 Kan. 381 (1973).
In Paul, the Court stated:
"In determining whether a legislative provi-
sion is mandatory or directory, it is a gen-
eral rule that where strict compliance with
the provision is essential to the preservation
of the rights of parties affected and to the
validity of the proceeding, the provision is
mandatory, but where the provision fixes a
mode of proceeding and a time within which an
official act is to be done, and is intended
to secure order, system and dispatch of the
public business, the provision is directory."
Syl. ¶1.
"Factors which would indicate that a statute
or ordinance is mandatory are: (1) the pre-
sence of negative words requiring that an act
shall be done in no other manner or at no
other time than that designated, or (2) a pro-
vision for a penalty or other consequence of
noncompliance." Syl. ¶2. (Emphasis added.)
In the present situation, there exist no "negative words"
which would conflict with the 20 month time frame employed
by the federal examiners, nor is there any provision for a
penalty or other consequence of noncompliance.
It would accordingly be our opinion that the provision which
calls for an examination every 18 months in subsection (a)
must be read as being discretionary, rather than mandatory.
While it is clearly the intent of the legislature that the
commissioner inspect the institutions under his jurisdiction
on a regular basis, the legislature has also allowed federal
reports to be accepted in lieu of a separate state examina-
tion. In that every savings and loan association subject to
the commissioner's authority is also subject to the FSLIC,
such a pooling of resources and information is eminently
sensible. To require separate examinations because the fed-
eral schedule differs by 2 months from that in subsection (a)
would be an unnecessarily narrow reading of the statute, and
would frustrate, rather than foster, the efficient use of
the state examiners' time.
In conclusion, pursuant to K.S.A. 17-5612, the savings and
loan commissioner or a deputy commissioner is required to
examine, without prior notice, each savings and loan associa-
tion organized under the law of this state at least once
every 18 months. In lieu of such examinations, the commis-
sioner may accept examinations made by the Federal Savings
and Loan Insurance Corporation, even though federal examina-
tions may be made only every 20 months. In that the legisla-
ture has expressly permitted the commissioner to adopt the
federal report as a substitute for his own, the 18 month
period must be construed as being directory, rather than
mandatory.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.